‘It’s dangerous to put a number on them’. Media coverage of koalas during the 2019–2020 ‘Black Summer’ bushfires in Australia
Eleanor Stalenberg A , Daniel Lunney B C * and Chris Moon DA
B
C
D
Abstract
The unprecedented scale and severity of the 2019–2020 ‘Black Summer’ bushfires in Australia were an environmental disaster, and koalas became the public face of the fires’ toll on wildlife.
We investigated the media stories on koalas during the fires to identify what was reported, and how the numbers of koalas killed by the fires were sourced and reported.
We searched for media articles published in major Australian print and online news outlets, local sources, press releases and international outlets for the terms ‘koala’, ‘fire’, ‘bushfire’, ‘emergency’, ‘disaster’ and ‘burn’, published between 15 October 2019 and 31 October 2020, and recorded any numbers of koalas given in those reports. This places our methods in a qualitative realm of investigation.
We reviewed 371 media articles on the bushfires and koalas in New South Wales (NSW). Almost half included an estimate of the numbers of koalas killed in NSW. Almost a third stated that koalas are going extinct in NSW, however almost two thirds did not mention that koalas were already in decline from threats other than fire.
We concluded that it was dangerous to put numbers on koalas. Misinformation, half-truths, and neglecting the important role of science and scientists, can erode public trust in the media and in science.
The obsession with numbers has left a legacy that can drown out the more considered narrative of science and lead to distortions of policy and management, as well as distract from other critical attributes of koala conservation.
Keywords: conservation, disaster, evidence, extinction, journalism, media studies, qualitative research, science communication, science in the media, threatened species, wildfire, wildlife rehabilitation.
References
ABC News (2020) Word of the year 2020. Available at https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-11-17/iso-is-the-australian-word-of-the-year-dictionary/12890260 [last accessed 13 January 2023]
Abram NJ, Henley BJ, Sen Gupta A, Lippmann TJR, Clarke H, Dowdy AJ, Sharples JJ, Nolan RH, Zhang T, Wooster MJ, Wurtzel JB, Meissner KJ, Pitman AJ, Ukkola AM, Murphy BP, Tapper NJ, Boer MM (2021) Connections of climate change and variability to large and extreme forest fires in southeast Australia. Communications Earth & Environment 2, 8.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Ampuja M, Koivisto J, Väliverronen E (2014) Strong and weak forms of mediatization theory: a critical review. Nordicom Review 35(s1), 111-124.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Batsakis A, Mountain W (2020) Click through the tragic stories of 119 species still struggling after Black Summer in this interactive (and how to help) (theconversation.com). The Conversation, 14 July 2020. Available at https://theconversation.com/click-through-the-tragic-stories-of-119-species-still-struggling-after-black-summer-in-this-interactive-and-how-to-help-131025
Beale P, Youngentob K, Marsh K (2022) Effects of fire on koalas and their habitat. Report prepared for the Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water, Canberra. Available at https://www.dcceew.gov.au/environment/epbc/publications
Berger R (2015) Now I see it, now I don’t: researcher’s position and reflexivity in qualitative research. Qualitative Research 15(2), 219-234.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Caldwell M, Henry PC (2020) How cultural branding, story-telling, and personification can save the iconic Australian koala. Psychology & Marketing 37, 1781-1789.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Caulfield T, Clark MI, McCormack JP, Rachul C, Field CJ (2014) Representations of the health value of vitamin D supplementation in newspapers: media content analysis. BMJ Open 4(12), e006395.
| Crossref | Google Scholar | PubMed |
Cristescu RH, Gardiner R, Terraube J, McDonald K, Powell D, Levengood AL, Frère CH (2023) Difficulties of assessing the impacts of the 2019–2020 bushfires on koalas. Austral Ecology 48, 12-18.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
DCCEEW (2024) Threatened species. Koalas. Available at https://www.dcceew.gov.au/environment/biodiversity/threatened/species/koalas#:~:text=Koala%20listing%20under%20national%20environmental%20law&text=In%20February%202022%2C%20the%20combined,Act%201999%20(EPBC%20Act). [last accessed 12 August 2024]
Dempster G, Sutherland G, Keogh L (2022) Scientific research in news media: a case study of misrepresentation, sensationalism and harmful recommendations. Journal of Science Communication 21(01), A06.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Dickman CR, Hutchings P, Law B, Lunney D (2022) Raking over the ashes: assessing the impact of fire on native fauna in the aftermath of Australia’s 2019–2020 fires. Australian Zoologist 42, 643-653.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
DPIE (2021a) Fire extent and severity mapping. Annual report for the 2019–20, 2018–19 and 2017–18 fire years. DPIE, Locked Bag 5022, Parramatta NSW 2124. Available at https://www.environment.nsw.gov.au/research-and-publications/publications-search/fire-extent-and-severity-mapping-annual-report-2019-20.
Due C, Thompson K, Every D (2014) ‘An image of hope in a week of despair’: representations of Sam the koala in the Australian mainstream news media. Media International Australia 151, 47-55.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Eagle L, Hay R, Low DR (2018) Competing and conflicting messages via online news media: potential impacts of claims that the Great Barrier Reef is dying. Ocean & Coastal Management 158, 154-163.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
EPA (2021) Fire 2021. NSW State of the Environment. Available at www.soe.epa.nsw.gov.au/all-themes/land/fire-2021
Ettema JS, Glasser TL (1984) On the epistemology of investigative journalism. Communication 8(2), 183-206.
| Google Scholar |
Ewart J, Cook M (2024) Mind the gap, exploring the expectation gap in political leadership in disasters: an Australian case study. Risk, Hazards, & Crisis in Public Policy 1-21.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Fielding K, Lunney D, Rhodes J, Goldingay R, Hetherington S, Brace A, Vass L, Hopkins M, Swankie L, Garofano N, Goulding W, McAlpine C (2023) What predicts community members’ intentions to take action to protect koalas? Pacific Conservation Biology 29(1), 26-37.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Gibson R, Danaher T, Hehir W, Collins L (2020) A remote sensing approach to mapping fire severity in south-eastern Australia using sentinel 2 and random forest. Remote Sensing of Environment 240, 111702.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Haering R, Wilson V, Zhuo A, Stathis P (2020) Towards a more effective model of wildlife care and rehabilitation: a survey of volunteers in New South Wales, Australia. Australian Zoologist 40, 605-627.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Haering R, Wilson V, Zhuo A, Stathis P (2021) A survey of veterinary professionals about their interactions with free-living native animals and the volunteer wildlife rehabilitation sector in New South Wales, Australia. Australian Zoologist 41, 254-282.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Hayden T, Check Hayden E (2018) Science journalism’s unlikely golden age. Frontiers in Communication 2, 24.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Jiang A, Tribe A, Murray P (2019) The development of an improved scat survey method for koalas (Phascolarctos cinereus). Australian Journal of Zoology 67, 125-133.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Kinnick KN, Krugman DM, Cameron GT (1996) Compassion fatigue: communication and burnout toward social problems. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly 73, 687-707.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Kitzinger J (1999) Researching risk and the media. Health, Risk & Society 1, 55-69.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Kocher SD, Toman E, Trainor SF, et al. (2012) How can we span the boundaries between wildland fire science and management in the United States? Journal of Forestry 110, 421-428.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Lane A, Wallis K, Phillips S (2020) A review of the conservation status of New South Wales populations of the Koala (Phascolarctos cinereus) leading up to and including part of the 2019/20 fire event. A report prepared for the International Fund for Animal Welfare (IFAW). Biolink Ecological Consultants, NSW.
Law BS, Gonsalves L, Burgar J, Brassil T, Kerr I, O’Loughlin C (2022) Fire severity and its local extent are key to assessing impacts of Australian mega-fires on koala (Phascolarctos cinereus) density. Global Ecology and Biogeography 31, 714-726.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Legge S, Rumpff L, Woinarski JCZ, Whiterod NS, Ward M, Southwell DG, Scheele BC, Nimmo DG, Lintermans M, Geyle HM, Garnett ST, Hayward-Brown B, Ensbey M, Ehmke G, Ahyong ST, Blackmore CJ, Bower DS, Brizuela-Torres D, Burbidge AH, Burns PA, Butler G, Catullo R, Chapple DG, Dickman CR, Doyle KE, Ferris J, Fisher D, Gallagher R, Gillespie GR, Greenlees MJ, Hohnen R, Hoskin CJ, Hunter D, Jolly C, Kennard M, King A, Kuchinke D, Law B, Lawler I, Lawler S, Loyn R, Lunney D, Lyon J, MacHunter J, Mahony M, Mahony S, McCormack RB, Melville J, Menkhorst P, Michael D, Mitchell N, Mulder E, Newell D, Pearce L, Raadik TA, Rowley JJL, Sitters H, Spencer R, Valavi R, West M, Wilkinson DP, Zukowski S (2022) The conservation impacts of ecological disturbance: time-bound estimates of population loss and recovery for fauna affected by the 2019–2020 Australian megafires. Global Ecology and Biogeography 31, 2085-2104.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Leimbach T, Palmer J (2022) #AustraliaOnFire: hashtag activism and collective affect in the black summer fires. Journal of Australian Studies 46, 496-511.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Levitt HM, Bamberg M, Creswell JW, Frost DM, Josselson R, Suárez-Orozco C (2018) Journal article reporting standards for qualitative primary, qualitative meta-analytic, and mixed methods research in psychology: the APA publications and communications board task force report. American Psychologist 73, 26-46.
| Crossref | Google Scholar | PubMed |
Lunney D, Matthews A (2003) “Throw a koala on the barbie”(Daily Telegraph 15 July 1997): an analysis of wildlife reporting in two daily newspapers. Australian Zoologist 32, 288-297.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Lunney D, Moon C (1988) An ecological view of the history of logging and fire in Mumbulla State Forest on the south coast of New South Wales. In ‘Australia’s ever changing forests. Proceedings of the First National Forest History Symposium’. (Eds K Frawley, N Semple) pp. 23–61. (Australian Defence Forces Academy: Campbell, ACT)
Lunney D, Moon C (2012a) Disasters for wildlife: an analysis of media attention. Australian Zoologist 36, 5-19.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Lunney D, Moon C (2012b) An ecological history of Australia’s Forests and Fauna (1770-2010). In ‘World environmental history’. (Eds M Agnoletti, E Johann, SN Serneri) p. 46. (Eolss Publishers: Oxford, UK) (in ‘Encyclopedia of Life Support Systems (EOLSS)’, developed under the auspices of the UNESCO). Available at http://www.eolss.net
Lunney D, Coburn D, Matthews A, Moon C (2001) Community perceptions of koala populations and their management in Port Stephens and Coffs Harbour Local Government Areas, New South Wales. In ‘The research and management of non-urban koala populations’. (Eds K Lyons, A Melzer, F Carrick, D Lamb) pp. 48–70. (Koala Research Centre of Central Queensland, Central Queensland University: Rockhampton)
Lunney D, Gresser SM, Mahon PS, Matthews A (2004) Post-fire survival and reproduction of rehabilitated and unburnt koalas. Biological Conservation 120, 567-575.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Lunney D, Gresser S, E. O’neill L, Matthews A, Rhodes J (2007) The impact of fire and dogs on Koalas at Port Stephens, New South Wales, using population viability analysis. Pacific Conservation Biology 13, 189-201.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Lunney D, Stalenberg E, Santika T, Rhodes JR (2014) Extinction in Eden: identifying the role of climate change in the decline of the koala in south-eastern NSW. Wildlife Research 41, 22-34.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Lunney D, Predavec M, Sonawane I, Kavanagh R, Barrott-Brown G, Phillips S, Callaghan J, Mitchell D, Parnaby H, Paull DC, Shannon I, Ellis M, Price O, Milledge D (2017) The remaining koalas (Phascolarctos cinereus) of the Pilliga forests, north-west New South Wales: refugial persistence or a population on the road to extinction? Pacific Conservation Biology 23, 277-294.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Lunney D, Purcell B, McLeod S, Grigg G, Pople T, Wolter S (2018) Four decades of research and monitoring the populations of kangaroos in New South Wales: one of the best long-term datasets in Australia. Australian Zoologist 39, 784-800.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Lunney D, Sonawane I, Wheeler R, Tasker E, Ellis M, Predavec M, Fleming M (2020) An ecological reading of the history of the koala population of Warrumbungle National Park. Proceedings of the Linnean Society of New South Wales 142, S132-S154.
| Google Scholar |
Lunney D, Moon C, Sonawane I, Predavec M, Rhodes JR (2022a) A 6-year study of mitigating koala roadkill during an upgrade of the Pacific Highway at Lindsay’s cutting, Coffs Harbour New South Wales. Australian Mammalogy 44, 305-318.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Lunney D, Predavec M, Sonawane I, Moon C, Rhodes JR (2022b) Factors that drive koala roadkill: an analysis across multiple scales in New South Wales, Australia. Australian Mammalogy 44, 328-337.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Lunney D, Cope H, Sonawane I, Haering R (2022c) A state-wide picture of koala rescue and rehabilitation in New South Wales during the 2019-2020 bushfires. Australian Zoologist 42, 243-255.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Lunney D, Cope H, Sonawane I, Stalenberg E, Haering R (2023a) An analysis of the long-term trends in the records of Friends of the Koala in north-east New South Wales: I. Cause and fate of koalas admitted for rehabilitation (1989-2020). Pacific Conservation Biology 29, 177-196.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Lunney D, Cope H, Sonawane I, Stalenberg E, Haering R (2023b) An analysis of the long-term trends in the records of Friends of the Koala in north-east New South Wales: II. Post-release survival. Pacific Conservation Biology 29, 197-222.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Lunney D, Cope H, Griffith J, Orcheg C, Bryant J, Haering R (2023c) Trends in the rescue and fate of koalas in New South Wales (1973-2020), with a focus on disease and trauma. Australian Zoologist
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Maier M, Milde J, Post S, Günther L, Ruhrmann G, Barkela B (2016) Communicating scientific evidence: Scientists’, journalists’ and audiences’ expectations and evaluations regarding the representation of scientific uncertainty. Communications 41, 239-264.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Matthews A, Lunney D, Gresser S, Maitz W (2007) Tree use by koalas (Phascolarctos cinereus) after fire in remnant coastal forest. Wildlife Research 34, 84-93.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Matthews A, Lunney D, Gresser S, Maitz W (2016) Movement patterns of koalas in remnant forest after fire. Australian Mammalogy 38, 91-104.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
McAlpine C, Lunney D, Melzer A, Menkhorst P, Phillips S, Phalen D, Ellis W, Foley W, Baxter G, de Villiers D, Kavanagh R, Adams-Hosking C, Todd C, Whisson D, Molsher R, Walter M, Lawler I, Close R (2015) Conserving koalas: a review of the contrasting regional trends, outlooks and policy challenges. Biological Conservation 192, 226-236.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Moon K, Blackman DA, Adams VM, et al. (2019) Expanding the role of social science in conservation through an engagement with philosophy, methodology, and methods. Methods in Ecology and Evolution 10, 294-302.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Morrison M, Parton K, Hine DW (2018) Increasing belief but issue fatigue: changes in Australian household climate change segments between 2011 and 2016. PLoS ONE 13(6), e0197988.
| Crossref | Google Scholar | PubMed |
Phillips S, Wallis K, Lane A (2021) Quantifying the impacts of bushfire on populations of wild koalas (Phascolarctos cinereus): insights from the 2019/20 fire season. Ecological Management & Restoration 22, 80-88.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Recher HF (2023) Tilting at Windmills II: a review of Australia’s Megafires - Biodiversity Impacts and Lessons from 2019-2020. Australian Zoologist 43(2), 410-418.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Reckless HJ, Murray M, Crowther MS (2017) A review of climatic change as a determinant of the viability of koala populations. Wildlife Research 44, 458-470.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Reich Z, Barnoy A (2023) Justifying the news: the role of evidence in daily reporting. Journalism 24, 22-40.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
RFS (2020) Bush fire bulletin. Volume 42 No. 1/2020. Available at https://www.rfs.nsw.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0007/174823/Bush-Fire-Bulletin-Vol-42-No1.pdf [last accessed 13 January 2023]
Rumpff L, Wintle B, Woinarski J, Legge S, van Leeuwen S (2023) 200 experts dissected the Black Summer bushfires in unprecedented detail. Here are 6 lessons to heed. The Conversation. Available at https://theconversation.com/200-experts-dissected-the-black-summer-bushfires-in-unprecedented-detail-here-are-6-lessons-to-heed-198989
Safford HD, Sawyer SC, Kocher SD, Hiers JK, Cross M (2017) Linking knowledge to action: the role of boundary spanners in translating ecology. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 15, 560-568.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Salas-Zapata WA, Rios-Osorio LA, Trouchon-Osorio AL (2013) Typology of scientific reflections needed for sustainability science development. Sustainability Science 8(4), 607-612.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Shiffman DS, Bittick SJ, Cashion MS, Colla SR, Coristine LE, Derrick DH, Gow EA, Macdonald CC, More O’Ferrall M, Orobko M, Pollom RA, Provencher J, Dulvy NK (2020) Inaccurate and biased global media coverage underlies public misunderstanding of shark conservation threats and solutions. iScience 23, 101205.
| Crossref | Google Scholar | PubMed |
Stalenberg E, Wallis I, Cunningham RB, Allen C, Foley WJ (2014) Nutritional Correlates of Koala Persistence in a Low-Density Population. PLoS One 9(12), e113930.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Thomson TJ (2021) Picturing destruction at home and abroad: a comparative visual analysis of icons and news values during disaster. Media International Australia 181, 197-216.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
van Eeden L, Dickman C (2023) Chapter 12 – Estimating the number of wild animals affected by Australia’s 2019-20 wildfires. In ‘Australia’s megafires – biodiversity impacts and lessons from 2019-2020’. (Eds L Rumpff, S Legge, S van Leeuwen, B Wintle, J Woinarski) pp. 154–166. (CSIRO Publishing: Melbourne, Vic)
van Kerkhoff L (2013) Knowledge governance for sustainable development: a critical analysis of an emerging concept. Challenges in Sustainability 1(2), 82-93.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
van Kerkhoff L, Pilbeam V (2017) Understanding socio-cultural dimensions of environmental decision-making: a knowledge governance approach. Environmental Science & Policy 73, 29-37.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Willis P (2020) How social media can create impact for research. Australian Zoologist 40, 462-467.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Woinarski JCZ, Cripps J, Durkin L, Law B, Legge SM, Macak PV, Nelson J, Runpff L (2023) Impacts of the 2019-20 wildfires on native mammals. In ‘Australia’s megafires: biodiversity impacts and lessons from 2019–2020’. (Eds L Rumpff, SM Legge, S van Leeuwen, BA Wintle, JCZ Woinarski) pp. 211–226. (CSIRO Publishing: Melburne, Vic)