Altered vegetation structure from mechanical thinning treatments changed wildfire behaviour in the wildland–urban interface on the 2011 Wallow Fire, Arizona, USA
Morris C. Johnson A C and Maureen C. Kennedy B
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations
A USDA Forest Service, Pacific Northwest Research Station, 400 N 34th Street Suite 201, Seattle, WA 98103, USA.
B University of Washington, Box 358436, Tacoma, WA 98402, USA.
C Corresponding author. Email: mcjohnson@fs.fed.us
International Journal of Wildland Fire 28(3) 216-229 https://doi.org/10.1071/WF18062
Submitted: 24 April 2018 Accepted: 11 December 2018 Published: 19 February 2019
Abstract
Fuel reduction treatments are designed to meet multiple management objectives, resulting in unique vegetation structures that do not conform to standard classifications and vary considerably over space and time. We evaluated how different post-treatment vegetation structures relate to patterns in wildfire severity. To reconstruct both untreated and treated pre-fire forest structure, we used post-fire stand data measured at three different fuel treatment units burned by the 2011 Wallow Fire (Arizona). We describe (1) how forest structure differs among the treatment units, both in the untreated forest and within the treated area; and (2) how those differences in forest structure explain variability in burn severity. We show that the retention of smaller trees (ladder fuels) for wildlife cover relates significantly to higher severity within one treatment unit. Further variability in within-treatment severity is explained by the severity of the wildfire in the untreated forest as the fire approached the treated area. The untreated forest structure and species composition constrain post-treatment structure and composition, which was related to within-treatment structure and post-fire composition and structure. The study design presented in this paper suggests that evaluations of fuel treatment effectiveness can move beyond simple classifications of treatment type and fire behaviour.
Additional keywords: bole char, crown scorch, fire severity, fuel treatment effectiveness.
References
Abella SR (2008) Managing Gambel oak in south-western ponderosa pine forests: the status of our knowledge. USDA Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, General Technical Report RMRS-218. (Fort Collins, CO, USA)Abella SR, Fulé PZ (2008) Fire effects on Gambel oak in south-western ponderosa pine–oak forests. USDA Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, Research Note RMRS-RN-34. (Fort Collins, CO, USA)
Agee JK (1996) The influence of forest structure on fire behavior. In ‘Proceedings of the 17th annual forest vegetation management conference’, 16–18 January 1996, Redding, CA. pp. 52–68. (University of California, Agriculture and Natural Resources: Berkely, CA)
Agee JK, Skinner CN (2005) Basic principles of forest fuel reduction treatments. Forest Ecology and Management 211, 83–96.
| Basic principles of forest fuel reduction treatments.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Agee JK, Bahro B, Finney MA, Omi PN, Sapsis DB, Skinner CN, van Wagtendonk JW, Weatherspoon CP (2000) The use of shaded fuelbreaks in landscape fire management. Forest Ecology and Management 127, 55–66.
| The use of shaded fuelbreaks in landscape fire management.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Alexander ME, Cruz MG (2012) Interdependencies between flame length and fireline intensity in predicting crown fire initiation and crown scorch height. International Journal of Wildland Fire 21, 95–113.
| Interdependencies between flame length and fireline intensity in predicting crown fire initiation and crown scorch height.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Bostwick P, Menakis J, Sexton T (2011) How fuel treatments saved homes from the 2011 Wallow Fire. Available at https://www.fs.usda.gov/Internet/FSE_DOCUMENTS/stelprdb5318765.pdf [Verified 28 January 2019]
Brown JK (1974) Handbook for inventorying downed woody material. USDA Forest Service, Intermountain Forest and Range Experiment Station, General Technical Report GTR-INT-16. (Ogden, UT, USA)
Cain MD (1984) Height of stem-bark char underestimates flame length in prescribed burns. Fire Management Notes 45, 17–21.
Covington WW, Everett RL, Steele R, Irwin LL, Daer TA, Auclair AND (1994) Historical and anticipated changes in forest ecosystems of the inland west of the United States. Journal of Sustainable Forestry 2, 13–63.
| Historical and anticipated changes in forest ecosystems of the inland west of the United States.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Eidenshink J, Schwind B, Brewer K, Zhu Z, Quayle B, Howard S (2007) A project for monitoring trends in burn severity. Fire Ecology 3, 3–21.
| A project for monitoring trends in burn severity.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Fortin MJ, Jacquez GM (2000) Randomization tests and spatially autocorrelated data. Bulletin of the Ecological Society of America 81, 201–206.
Fortin MJ, Payette S (2002) How to test the significance of the relation between spatially autocorrelated data at the landscape scale: a case study using fire and forest maps. Ecoscience 9, 213–218.
| How to test the significance of the relation between spatially autocorrelated data at the landscape scale: a case study using fire and forest maps.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Fowler JF, Sieg CH (2004) Post-fire mortality of ponderosa pine and Douglas-fir: a review of methods to predict tree death. USDA Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, General Technical Report RMRS-RM-132. (Fort Collins, CO, USA)
Fulé PZ, Crouse JE, Roccaforte JP, Kalies EL (2012) Do thinning and/or burning treatments in western USA ponderosa or Jeffrey pine-dominated forests help restore natural fire behavior? Forest Ecology and Management 269, 68–81.
| Do thinning and/or burning treatments in western USA ponderosa or Jeffrey pine-dominated forests help restore natural fire behavior?Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Graham RT, McCaffrey S, Jain TB (2004) Science basis for changing forest structure to modify wildfire behavior and severity. USDA Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, General Technical Report RMRS-120. (Fort Collins, CO, USA)
Haines DA (1988) A lower atmospheric severity index for wildland fire. National Weather Digest 13, 23–27.
Harper KT, Wagstaff FJ, Kunzler LM (1985) Biology and management of Gambel oak vegetative type: a literature review. USDA Forest Service, Intermountain Forest and Range Experiment Station, General Technical Report INT-179. (Ogden, UT, USA)
Harrington MG (1985) The effects of spring, summer and fall burning on Gambel oak in south-western ponderosa pine stand. Forest Science 31, 156–163.
Hessburg PF, Agee JK, Franklin JF (2005) Dry forests and wildland fires of the inland Northwest USA: contrasting the landscape ecology of the pre-settlement modern eras. Forest Ecology and Management 211, 117–139.
| Dry forests and wildland fires of the inland Northwest USA: contrasting the landscape ecology of the pre-settlement modern eras.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Hood SM, Bentz BJ (2007) Predicting post-fire Douglas-fir beetle attacks and tree mortality in the northern Rocky Mountains. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 37, 1058–1069.
| Predicting post-fire Douglas-fir beetle attacks and tree mortality in the northern Rocky Mountains.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Hood SM, Smith SL, Cluck D (2007) Delayed tree mortality following fire in northern California. USDA Forest Service, Pacific Southwest Research Station, Research Paper PSW-GTR-203. (Albany, CA, USA)
Johnson MC, Kennedy MC, Peterson DL (2011) Simulating fuel treatment effects in dry forest of the western United States: testing the principles of a fire-safe forest. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 41, 1018–1030.
| Simulating fuel treatment effects in dry forest of the western United States: testing the principles of a fire-safe forest.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Kalies EL, Yocom Kent LL (2016) Tamm Review: are fuel treatments effective at achieving ecological and social objectives? A systematic review. Forest Ecology and Management 375, 84–95.
| Tamm Review: are fuel treatments effective at achieving ecological and social objectives? A systematic review.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Keen FP (1955) The rate of natural falling of beetle-killed ponderosa pine snags. Journal of Forestry 53, 720–723.
Kennedy MC, Johnson MC (2014) Fuel treatment prescriptions alter spatial patterns of fire severity around the wildland–urban interface during the Wallow Fire, Arizona, USA. Forest Ecology and Management 318, 122–132.
| Fuel treatment prescriptions alter spatial patterns of fire severity around the wildland–urban interface during the Wallow Fire, Arizona, USA.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Kennedy MC, Prichard SJ (2017) Choose your neighborhood wisely: implications of subsampling and autocorrelation structure in simultaneous autoregression models for landscape ecology. Landscape Ecology 32, 945–952.
| Choose your neighborhood wisely: implications of subsampling and autocorrelation structure in simultaneous autoregression models for landscape ecology.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Kolden CA, Smith AMS, Abatzoglou JT (2015) Limitations and utilisation of Monitoring Trends in Burn Severity products for assessing wildfire severity in the USA. International Journal of Wildland Fire 24, 1023–1028.
| Limitations and utilisation of Monitoring Trends in Burn Severity products for assessing wildfire severity in the USA.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
LaCroix JJ, Li Q, Ryu S-R, Zheng D, Chen J (2013) Simulating fire spread with landscape edge fuel scenarios. In ‘Remote sensing and modeling applications to wildland fires’. (Eds JJ Qu, WT Sommers, R Yang, A Riebau) pp. 267–279. (Springer-Verlag: Heidelberg, Germany).
Laing L, Ambos N, Subirge T, McDonald C, Nelson C, Robbie W (1989) Terrestrial ecosystems survey of the Apache–Sitgreaves National Forest. Internal report, USDA Forest Service, Southwestern Region. (Fort Collins, CO, USA)
Lehmkuhl JF, Kennedy MC, Ford ED, Singleton PH, Gaines WL, Lind RL (2007) Seeing the forest for the fuels: integrating ecological values and fuels management. Forest Ecology and Management 246, 73–80.
| Seeing the forest for the fuels: integrating ecological values and fuels management.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
McHugh C, Kolb TE (2003) Ponderosa pine mortality following fire in northern Arizona. International Journal of Wildland Fire 12, 7–22.
| Ponderosa pine mortality following fire in northern Arizona.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Mell WE, Manzello SL, Maranghides A, Butry D, Rehm DB (2010) The wildland–urban interface fire problem: current approaches and research needs. International Journal of Wildland Fire 19, 238–251.
| The wildland–urban interface fire problem: current approaches and research needs.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Methven IR (1973) Fire succession and community structure in a red and white pine stand. Canadian Forestry Service, Petawawa Forest Experiment Station, Information Report PS-X-43. (Chalk River, ON, Canada)
Neary DG, Zieroth EJ (2007) Forest bioenergy system to reduce the hazard of wildfires: White Mountains, Arizona. Biomass and Bioenergy 31, 638–645.
| Forest bioenergy system to reduce the hazard of wildfires: White Mountains, Arizona.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Ottmar RD, Burns MF, Hall JN, Hanson AD (1993) CONSUME: users guide. USDA Forest Service, Pacific Northwest Research Station, General Technical Report, GTR-PNW-403. (Portland, OR, USA)
Peterson DL, Johnson MC, Agee JK, Jain TB, McKenzie D, Reinhardt ED (2005) Forest structure and fire hazard in dry forests of the Western United States. USDA Forest Service, Pacific Northwest Research Station, General Technical Report GTR-PNW-628. (Portland, OR, USA)
Pollet J, Omi PN (2002) Effect of thinning and prescribed burning on crown fire severity in ponderosa pine forests. International Journal of Wildland Fire 11, 1–10.
| Effect of thinning and prescribed burning on crown fire severity in ponderosa pine forests.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Prichard SJ, Kennedy MC (2012) Fuel treatment effects on tree mortality following wildfire in dry mixed-conifer forests, Washington State, USA. International Journal of Wildland Fire 21, 1004–1013.
| Fuel treatment effects on tree mortality following wildfire in dry mixed-conifer forests, Washington State, USA.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Prichard SJ, Kennedy MC (2014) Fuel treatments and landform modify landscape patterns of burn severity in an extreme fire event. Ecological Applications 24, 571–590.
| Fuel treatments and landform modify landscape patterns of burn severity in an extreme fire event.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 24834742PubMed |
R Core Team (2013) R: a language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing. (Vienna, Austria). Available at http://www.R-project.org/ [Verified 28 January 2019]
Raymond CL, Peterson DL (2005) Fuel treatments alter the effects of wildfire in a mixed-evergreen forest, Oregon, USA. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 35, 2981–2995.
| Fuel treatments alter the effects of wildfire in a mixed-evergreen forest, Oregon, USA.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Rebain SA (2010) The Fire and Fuels Extension to the Forest Vegetation Simulator: updated model documentation (revised September 2010). USDA Forest Service, Forest Management Service Center, Internal Report. (Fort Collins, CO, USA)
Regelbrugge JC, Conard SG (1993) Modelling tree mortality following wildfire in Pinus ponderosa forests in the central Sierra Nevada of California. International Journal of Wildland Fire 3, 139–143.
| Modelling tree mortality following wildfire in Pinus ponderosa forests in the central Sierra Nevada of California.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Reinhardt ED, Keane RE, Calkin DE, Cohen JD (2008) Objectives and considerations for wildland fuel treatment in forested ecosystems of the interior western United States. Forest Ecology and Management 256, 1997–2006.
| Objectives and considerations for wildland fuel treatment in forested ecosystems of the interior western United States.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Ritchie MW, Skinner CN, Hamilton TA (2007) Probability of tree survival after wildfire in an interior pine forest of northern California: effects of thinning and prescribed fire. Forest Ecology and Management 247, 200–208.
| Probability of tree survival after wildfire in an interior pine forest of northern California: effects of thinning and prescribed fire.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Roccaforte JP, Huffman DW, Fulé PZ, Covington WW, Chancellor WW, Stoddard MT, Crouse JE (2015) Forest structure and fuels dynamics following ponderosa pine restoration treatments, White Mountains, Arizona, USA. Forest Ecology and Management 337, 174–185.
| Forest structure and fuels dynamics following ponderosa pine restoration treatments, White Mountains, Arizona, USA.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Roccaforte JP, Sánchez Meador A, Waltz AEM, Gaylord ML, Stoddard MT, Huffman DW (2018) Delayed tree mortality, bark beetle activity, and regeneration dynamics five years following the Wallow Fire, Arizona, USA: Assessing trajectories towards resiliency. Forest Ecology and Management 428, 20–26.
| Delayed tree mortality, bark beetle activity, and regeneration dynamics five years following the Wallow Fire, Arizona, USA: Assessing trajectories towards resiliency.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Ryan KC, Amman GD (1996) Bark beetle activity and delayed tree mortality in the Greater Yellowstone Area following the 1988 fires. In ‘Ecological implications of fire in Greater Yellowstone proceedings’. (Eds R E Keane, KC Ryan, SW Running) pp. 151–158. (International Association Wildland Fire: Fairland, WA)
Safford HD, Schmidt DA, Carlson CH (2009) Effects of fuel treatments on fire severity in an area of wildland–urban interface, Angora Fire, Lake Tahoe Basin, California. Forest Ecology and Management 258, 773–787.
| Effects of fuel treatments on fire severity in an area of wildland–urban interface, Angora Fire, Lake Tahoe Basin, California.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Schmidt DA, Taylor AH, Skinner CN (2008) The influence of fuels treatment and landscape arrangement on simulated fire behaviour, Southern Cascade range, California. Forest Ecology and Management 255, 3170–3184.
Shindler B (2002) Citizens in the fuel-reduction equation: problems and prospects for public forest managers. In ‘Fire in Oregon’s forests: risks, effects, and treatment options’. (Ed. SA Fitzgerald) pp. 139–147. (Oregon State University Press: Corvallis, OR, USA)
Sieg CH, McMillin JD, Fowler JF, Allen KK, Negron JF, Wadleigh LL, Anhold JA, Gibson KE (2006) Best predictors for post-fire mortality of ponderosa pine trees in the Intermountain West. Forest Science 52, 718–728.
Sitko S, Hurteau S (2010) ‘Evaluating the impacts of forest treatments: the first five years of the White Mountain Stewardship Project.’ (The Nature Conservancy: Phoenix, AZ, USA)
Springer JD, Huffman DW, Stoddard MT, Sánchez Meador AJ, Waltz AEM (2018) Plant community dynamics following hazardous fuel treatments and mega-wildfire in a warm dry mixed-conifer forest of the USA. Forest Ecology and Management 429, 278–286.
| Plant community dynamics following hazardous fuel treatments and mega-wildfire in a warm dry mixed-conifer forest of the USA.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Stephens SL, Moghaddas JJ (2005a) Experimental fuel treatment impacts on forest structure, potential fire behavior, and predicted tree mortality in a California mixed conifer forest. Forest Ecology and Management 215, 21–36.
| Experimental fuel treatment impacts on forest structure, potential fire behavior, and predicted tree mortality in a California mixed conifer forest.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Stephens SL, Moghaddas JJ (2005b) Fuel treatment effects on snags and coarse woody debris in a Sierra Nevada mixed-conifer forest. Forest Ecology and Management 214, 53–64.
| Fuel treatment effects on snags and coarse woody debris in a Sierra Nevada mixed-conifer forest.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Stephens SL, Moghaddas JJ, Edminster C, Fiedler CE, Haase S, Harrington M, Keeley JE, Knapp EE (2009a) Fire treatment effects on vegetation structure, fuels, and potential fire severity in western US forests. Ecological Applications 19, 305–320.
| Fire treatment effects on vegetation structure, fuels, and potential fire severity in western US forests.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 19323192PubMed |
Stephens SL, Moghaddas JJ, Hartsough BR, Moghaddas EEY, Clinton NE (2009b) Fuel treatment effects on stand-level carbon pools, treatment-related emissions, and fire risk in a Sierra Nevada mixed-conifer forest. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 39, 1538–1547.
| Fuel treatment effects on stand-level carbon pools, treatment-related emissions, and fire risk in a Sierra Nevada mixed-conifer forest.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Stevens JT, Safford HD, Latimer AM (2014) Wildfire-contingent effects of fuel treatments can promote ecological resilience in seasonally dry conifer forests. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 44, 843–854.
| Wildfire-contingent effects of fuel treatments can promote ecological resilience in seasonally dry conifer forests.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
US Department of the Interior National Park Service (2003) ‘Fire monitoring handbook.’ (Fire Management Program Center, National Interagency Fire Center: Boise, ID, USA)
Vaillant N, Noonan-Wright EK, Reiner AL, Ewell CM, Benjamin BMA, Fites-Kaufman JA, Dailey SN (2015) Fuel accumulation and forest structure change following hazardous fuel reduction treatments throughout California. International Journal of Wildland Fire 24, 361–371.
| Fuel accumulation and forest structure change following hazardous fuel reduction treatments throughout California.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Waltz AEM, Stoddard MT, Kalies EL, Springer JD, Huffman DW, Sánchez Meador A (2014) Effectiveness of fuel reduction treatments: assessing metrics of forest resiliency and wildfire severity after the Wallow Fire, AZ. Forest Ecology and Management 334, 43–52.
| Effectiveness of fuel reduction treatments: assessing metrics of forest resiliency and wildfire severity after the Wallow Fire, AZ.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Wimberly MC, Cochrane AD, Baer AD, Pabst K (2009) Assessing fuel treatment effectiveness using satellite imagery and spatial statistics. Ecological Applications 19, 1377–1384.
| Assessing fuel treatment effectiveness using satellite imagery and spatial statistics.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 19769087PubMed |
Ziegler JP, Hoffman C, Battaglia M, Mell W (2017) Spatially explicit measurements of forest structure and fire behavior following restoration treatments in dry forests. Forest Ecology and Management 386, 1–12.
| Spatially explicit measurements of forest structure and fire behavior following restoration treatments in dry forests.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
