Register      Login
Soil Research Soil Research Society
Soil, land care and environmental research
Shopping Cart: ( empty )
You are here: Home > Journals > SR > SR07232
RESEARCH ARTICLE
Contents Vol 46(8)

Small-scale, high-intensity rainfall simulation under-estimates natural runoff P concentrations from pastures on hill-slopes

W. J. Dougherty A B F , D. M. Nash C , J. W. Cox D , D. J. Chittleborough A and N. K. Fleming E
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations

A Soil and Land Systems, School of Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of Adelaide, SA 5005, Australia.

B Current address: New South Wales Department of Primary Industries, Locked Bag 4, Richmond, NSW 2753, Australia.

C Department of Primary Industries and eWater CRC, RMB 2460, Ellinbank, Vic. 3820, Australia.

D CSIRO Land and Water and eWater CRC, PMB 2, Glen Osmond, SA 5064, Australia.

E South Australian Research and Development Institute and eWater CRC, GPO Box 397, Adelaide, SA 5001, Australia.

F Corresponding author. Email: warwick.dougherty@dpi.nsw.gov.au

Australian Journal of Soil Research 46(8) 694-702 https://doi.org/10.1071/SR07232
Submitted: 20 December 2007  Accepted: 27 August 2008   Published: 2 December 2008

Abstract

Rainfall simulation is a widely used technique for studying the processes, and quantifying the mobilisation, of phosphorus (P) from soil/pasture systems into surface runoff. There are conflicting reports in the literature of the effects of rainfall simulation on runoff P concentrations and forms of P compared to those under natural rainfall runoff conditions. Furthermore, there is a dearth of information on how rainfall simulation studies relate to hill-slope and landscape scale processes and measures. In this study we compare P mobilisation by examining P forms and concentrations in runoff from small-scale, high-intensity (SH, 1.5 m2, 80 mm/h) rainfall simulation and large-scale, low-intensity (LL, 1250 m2, 8 mm/h) simulations that have previously been shown to approximate natural runoff on hill-slopes. We also examined the effect of soil P status on this comparison. The SH methodology resulted in lower (average 56%) runoff P concentrations than those measured under the LL methodology. The interaction method × soil P status was highly significant (P < 0.001). There was no significant effect of method (SH v. LL) and soil P status on P forms (%).The hydrological characteristics were very different between the 2 methods, runoff rates being c. 42 and 3 mm/h for the SH and LL methods, respectively. We hypothesise that the lower runoff P concentrations from the SH method are the result of a combination of (i) the P mobilisation being a rate-limited process, and (ii) the relatively high runoff rates and short runoff path-lengths of the SH method allowing for relatively incomplete attainment of equilibrium between P in the soil/pasture system and runoff. We conclude that small-scale, high-intensity rainfall simulation provides a useful tool for studying treatment effects and processes of mobilisation in pastures, but concentration and load data should not be inferred for natural conditions at larger scales without a clear understanding of the effects of the rainfall simulation methodology on the results for the system being studied.

Additional keywords: scale, rainfall simulation, modelling, phosphorus, runoff, mobilisation.


References


Ahuja LR (1982) Release of a soluble chemical from soil to runoff. Transactions of the American Society of Agricultural Engineers 25, 948–960.
|  CAS |
(verified 6 Nov. 2008).

APHA (1995) Phosphorus sample preparation. In ‘Standard methods for the examination of water and wastewater’. (Eds AD Eaton, LS Clesceri, AE Greenberg) pp. 109–110. (American Public Health Association, American Water Works Association, Water Environment Federation: Washington, DC)

Burchett RJE (1996) Assessment of the potential for runoff and leaching of phosphate fertiliser applied to dairy pasture. BSc(Hons) Thesis, University of Sydney, NSW, Australia.

Clemmens AJ, Bos MG, Replogle JA (1984) Portable RBC flumes for furrows and earthen channels. Transactions of the American Society of Agricultural Engineers 27, 1016–1021. open url image1

Cornish PS, Hallissey R, Hollinger E (2002) Is a rainfall simulator useful for estimating phosphorus runoff from pastures – a question of scale-dependency? Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 42, 953–959.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | open url image1

Davies PJ, Cox JW, Fleming NK, Dougherty WJ, Nash DM, Hutson JL (2006) Predicting runoff and phosphorus loads from variable source areas: a terrain-based spatial modelling approach. Journal of Spatial Hydrology 6, 82–104. open url image1

Doody D, Moles R, Tunney H, Kurz I, Bourke D, Daly K, O’Regan B (2006) Impact of flow path length and flow rate on phosphorus loss in simulated overland flow from a humic gleysol grassland soil. The Science of the Total Environment 372, 247–255.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | CAS | PubMed | open url image1

Dougherty WJ (2006) The mobilisation of soil P in surface runoff from intensively managed pastures in South-east Australia. PhD Dissertation, University of Adelaide, SA, Australia. http://thesis.library.adelaide.edu.au/uploads/approved/adt-SUA20061214.113622/public/02whole.pdf. (Verified: 22 July 2008)

Dougherty WJ, Fleming NK, Cox JW, Chittleborough DJ (2004) Phosphorus transfer in surface runoff from intensive pasture systems at various scales: A review. Journal of Environmental Quality 33, 1973–1988.
|  CAS | PubMed |
open url image1

Dougherty WJ, Nash DM, Chittleborough DJ, Cox JW, Fleming NK (2006) Stratification, forms and mobility of phosphorus in the topsoil of a Chromosol used for dairying. Australian Journal of Soil Research 44, 277–284.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | CAS | open url image1

Dougherty WJ, Nicholls PJ, Milham PJ, Havilah EJ, Lawrie RA (2008) Phosphorus fertilizer and grazing management effects on phosphorus in runoff from dairy pastures. Journal of Environmental Quality 37, 417–428.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | CAS | PubMed | open url image1

Gourley CJP , Melland AR , Waller RA , Awty IM , Smith AP , Peverill KI , Hannah MC (2007) ‘Making better fertilizer decisions for grazed pastures in Australia.’ (Victorian Department of Primary Industries: Ellinbank, Vic.)

Hart MR, Quin BF, Nguyen ML (2004) Phosphorus runoff from agricultural land and direct fertilizer effects: A review. Journal of Environmental Quality 33, 1954–1972.
|  CAS | PubMed |
open url image1

Havilah E , Warren H , Granzin B , Dougherty W , Nicholls P , Lawrie R , Milham P , Chan KY , Davies L (2005) Optimising phosphorus fertiliser use on dairy farms, New South Wales. NSW Department of Primary Industries, Camden, NSW.

Humphry JB, Daniel TC, Edwards DR, Sharpley AN (2002) A portable rainfall simulator for plot-scale runoff studies. Applied Engineering in Agriculture 18, 199–204. open url image1

Isbell RF (1997) ‘The Australian Soil Classification.’ (CSIRO Publishing: Collingwood, Vic.)

Kleinman PJA, Sharpley AN, Veith TL, Maguire RO, Vadas PA (2004) Evaluation of phosphorus transport in surface runoff from packed soil boxes. Journal of Environmental Quality 33, 1413–1423.
|  CAS | PubMed |
open url image1

Kleinman PJA, Srinivasan MS, Dell CJ, Schmidt JP, Sharpley AN, Bryant RB (2006) Role of rainfall intensity and hydrology in nutrient transport via surface runoff. Journal of Environmental Quality 35, 1248–1259.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | CAS | PubMed | open url image1

Kuo S (1996) Phosphorus. In ‘Methods of soil analysis: chemical methods’. (Ed. DL Sparks) pp. 891–893. (Soil Science Society of America: Madison, WI)

Loch RJ, Donnollan TE (1983) Field rainfall simulator studies on two clay soils of the Darling Downs, Queensland. I The effects of plot length and tillage orientation on erosion processes and runoff erosion rates. Australian Journal of Soil Research 21, 33–46.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | open url image1

Loch RJ, Robotham BG, Zeller L, Masterman N, Orange DN, Bridge BJ, Sheridan G, Bourke JJ (2001) A multipurpose rainfall simulator for field infiltration and erosion studies. Australian Journal of Soil Research 39, 599–610.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | open url image1

McDowell RW, Monaghan RM, Morton J (2003) Soil phosphorus concentrations to minimise potential P loss to surface waters in Southland. New Zealand Journal of Agricultural Research 46, 239–253. open url image1

McDowell RW, Sharpley AN (2003) Uptake and release of phosphorus from overland flow in a stream environment. Journal of Environmental Quality 32, 937–948.
|  CAS | PubMed |
open url image1

Meyer LD (1965) Simulation of rainfall for soil erosion research. Transactions of the American Society of Agricultural Engineers , 63–65. open url image1

Murphy J, Riley JP (1962) A modified single solution method for the determination of phosphate in natural waters. Analytica Chimica Acta 27, 31–36.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | CAS | open url image1

Nash D, Clemow L, Hannah M, Barlow K, Gangaiya P (2005) Modelling phosphorus exports from rain-fed and irrigated pastures in southern Australia. Australian Journal of Soil Research 43, 745–755.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | CAS | open url image1

Nash D, Murdoch C (1997) Phosphorus in runoff from a fertile dairy pasture. Australian Journal of Soil Research 35, 419–429.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | open url image1

Nash DM , Halliwell D , Cox J (2002) Hydrological mobilization of pollutants at the field/slope scale. In ‘Agriculture, hydrology and water quality’. (Eds PM Haygarth, SC Jarvis) pp. 225–242. (CABI Publishing: UK)

Nash DM, Halliwell DJ (1999) Fertilisers and phosphorus loss from productive grazing systems. Australian Journal of Soil Research 37, 403–429.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | open url image1

Pilgrim DH (1987) ‘Australian rainfall and runoff: a guide to flood estimation.’ (Australian Institution of Engineers: Canberra, ACT)

Pote DH, Daniel TC, Nichols DJ, Sharpley AN, Moore PA, Miller DM, Edwards DR (1999) Relationship between phosphorus levels in three Ultisols and phosphorus concentrations in runoff. Journal of Environmental Quality 28, 170–175.
|  CAS |
open url image1

Pote DH, Daniel TC, Sharpley AN, Moore PA, Edwards AC, Nichols DJ (1996) Relating extractable soil phosphorus to phosphorus losses in runoff. Soil Science Society of America Journal 60, 855–859.
|  CAS |
open url image1

Sharpley AN (1980) The effect of storm interval on the transport of soluble phosphorus in runoff. Journal of Environmental Quality 9, 575–578.
|  CAS |
open url image1

Sharpley AN (1985) Depth of surface soil-runoff interaction as affected by rainfall, soil slope, and management. Soil Science Society of America Journal 49, 1010–1015. open url image1

Sharpley AN (1995) Dependence of runoff phosphorus on extractable soil phosphorus. Journal of Environmental Quality 24, 920–926.
|  CAS |
open url image1

Sharpley AN, Ahuja LR, Menzel RG (1981) The release of soil phosphorus to runoff in relation to the kinetics of desorption. Journal of Environmental Quality 10, 386–391. open url image1

Sharpley AN, Kleinman P (2003) Effect of rainfall simulator and plot scale on overland flow and phosphorus transport. Journal of Environmental Quality 32, 2172–2179.
|  CAS | PubMed |
open url image1

Sharpley AN , Krogstad T , Kleinman PJ , Haggard B , Shigaki F , Saporito LS (2007) Managing natural processes in drainage ditches for nonpoint source phosphorus control. (Special section: Drainage ditches). In ‘Journal of Soil and Water Conservation (Ankeny)’. pp. 62, 64, 197–206. (Soil and Water Conservation Society: Ankeny)

Soil Survey Staff (1999) ‘Soil taxonomy: A basic system of classification for making and interpreting soil surveys.’ (U.S. Government Printing Office: Washington, DC)

Srinivasan MS, Kleinman PJA, Sharpley AN, Buob T, Gburek WJ (2007) Hydrology of small field plots used to study phosphorus runoff under simulated rainfall. Journal of Environmental Quality 36, 1833–1842.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | CAS | PubMed | open url image1

Srinivasan MS, Wittman MA, Hamlett JM, Gburek WJ (2000) Surface and subsurface sensors to record variable runoff generation areas. Transactions of the American Society of Agricultural Engineers 43, 651–660. open url image1

Tao S, Lin B, Liu XH, Cao J (2000) Release kinetics of water soluble organic carbon (WSOC) from river sediment and wetland soil. Water, Air, and Soil Pollution 118, 407–418.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | CAS | open url image1

Torbert HA, Daniel TC, Lemunyon JL, Jones RM (2002) Relationship of soil test phosphorus and sampling depth to runoff phosphorus in calcareous and non-calcareous soils. Journal of Environmental Quality 31, 1380–1387.
|  CAS | PubMed |
open url image1

Vadas PA, Kleinman PJA, Sharpley AN, Turner BL (2005) Relating soil phosphorus to dissolved phosphorus in runoff: A single extraction coefficient for water quality modeling. Journal of Environmental Quality 34, 572–580.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | CAS | PubMed | open url image1

Valsaraj KT, Verma S, Sojitra I, Reible DD, Thibodeaux LJ (1996) Diffusive transport of organic colloids from sediment beds. Journal of Environmental Engineering 122, 722–729.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | CAS | open url image1