Missing shots: has the possibility of shooting wolves been lacking for 20 years in France’s livestock protection measures?
M. Meuret
A , C.-H. Moulin B , O. Bonnet C , L. Garde C , M.-O. Nozières-Petit A and N. Lescureux D E
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations
A University Montpellier, INRAE, SELMET, 34000, Montpellier, France.
B University Montpellier, L’Institut Agro Montpellier SupAgro, SELMET, 34000, Montpellier, France.
C CERPAM, 04100, Manosque, France.
D CEFE, CNRS, Univ. Montpellier, EPHE, IRD, Univ. Paul Valéry Montpellier 3, 34000, Montpellier, France.
E Corresponding author. Email: nicolas.lescureux@cefe.cnrs.fr
The Rangeland Journal - https://doi.org/10.1071/RJ20046
Submitted: 27 May 2020 Accepted: 6 November 2020 Published online: 20 January 2021
Journal Compilation © Australian Rangeland Society 2021 Open Access CC BY-NC-ND
Abstract
Wolves were exterminated in France in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Therefore, livestock breeders and herders were unprepared when wolves arrived from Italy in 1993, the year after France committed to the European Union (EU) to protect wolves. Today, ~580 wolves, whose numbers are growing exponentially, are present in over one-third of France. During the last 10 years, livestock deaths from wolves have grown linearly from 3215 in 2009 to 12 451 in 2019, despite France implementing extensive damage protection measures since 2004, including reinforced human presence, livestock guard dogs, secured pasture fencing and electrified night pens. The failure to prevent damage is clear. Wolves enter mosaic landscapes where grazing livestock are abundant and easy prey. Wolves are intelligent and opportunistic. As a strictly protected species, it seems they no longer associate livestock with humans and humans with danger. Half of the successful attacks now occur during the day, notwithstanding the presence of dogs and humans. Considering the high costs of unsatisfactory protection, France recently modified its wolf management policy. In addition to non-lethal means of protection, breeders that have suffered several attacks by wolves are now permitted, by derogation to the law, to defensively shoot wolves. Based upon evidence from other countries, we suggest re-establishing a reciprocal relationship with wolves. Breeders and herders should be allowed to shoot wolves to defend their herds against wolf attacks, not after several successful predation events. Defence shooting would also upgrade the efficiency of non-lethal means, as warning signals for wolves to respect. Rather than passive coexistence, we need to embrace a dynamic and ever-evolving process of coadaptation between humans and wolves, relying on the adaptive capacities of both.
Keywords: adaptive management, damage prevention, defensive shooting, grey wolf, livestock, non-lethal, predation, public policies, wolf.
References
Allen, B. L., Allen, L. R., Andrén, H., Ballard, G., Boitani, L., Engeman, R. M., Fleming, P. J. S., Ford, A. T., Haswell, P. M., Kowalczyk, R., Linnell, J. D. C., Mech, L. D., and Parker, D. M. (2017). Can we save large carnivores without losing large carnivore science? Food Webs 12, 64–75.| Can we save large carnivores without losing large carnivore science?Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Appleby, R., Smith, B., and Jones, D. (2013). Observations of a free-ranging adult female dingo (Canis dingo) and littermates’ responses to the death of a pup. Behavioural Processes 96, 42–46.
| Observations of a free-ranging adult female dingo (Canis dingo) and littermates’ responses to the death of a pup.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 23500482PubMed |
Audrain-Demey, G. (2016). Le loup: de la protection des troupeaux à la régulation de l’espèce. Revue Juridique de l’Environnement 41, 234–252.
Bacha, S., Bataille, J.-F., and Garde, L. (2007). Indemnisation des pertes et évaluation des coûts réels. In: ‘Loup – Elevage: s’ouvrir à la complexité’. Actes du séminaire des 15 et 16 juin 2006. (Ed. L. Garde.) pp. 150–161. (CERPAM: Manosque, France.)
Bangs, E., Jimenez, M., Niemeyer, C., Fontaine, J., Collinge, M., Krsichke, R., Handegard, L., Shivik, J., Sime, C., Nadeau, S., Mack, C., Asher, V., and Stone, S. (2006). Non-lethal and lethal tools to manage wolf-livestock conflict in the Northwestern United States. In: ‘Proceedings 22nd Vertebrate Pest Conference’. (Eds R. M. Timm and J. M. O’Brien.) pp. 7–16. (University of California: Davis, CA, USA.)
Barnes, M., and Hibbard, W. (2016). Strategic grazing management using low-stress herding and night penning for animal impact. Stockmanship Journal 5, 57–71.
Boitani, L. (2000). Action Plan for the Conservation of the Wolves (Canis lupus) in Europe. Council of Europe, Convention on the Conservation of European Wildlife and Natural Habitats (Bern Convention), Report No. 113, Strasbourg, France.
Boitani, L., Phillips, M., and Jhala, Y. (2018). Canis lupus. The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species 2018: e.T3746A119623865. Available at: https://www.iucnredlist.org/species/3746/119623865 (accessed 17 August 2019)
Bradley, E. H., Robinson, H. S., Bangs, E. E., Kunkel, K., Jimenez, M. D., Gude, J. A., and Grimm, T. (2015). Effects of wolf removal on livestock depredation recurrence and wolf recovery in Montana, Idaho, and Wyoming. Journal of Wild Management 79, 1337–1346.
| Effects of wolf removal on livestock depredation recurrence and wolf recovery in Montana, Idaho, and Wyoming.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Breitenmoser, U. (1998). Large predators in the Alps: the fall and rise of man’s competitors. Biological Conservation 83, 279–289.
| Large predators in the Alps: the fall and rise of man’s competitors.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Candy, F., Débit, S., and Garde, L. (2019). Chiens de protection: quand les éleveurs forgent les savoirs dans les Alpes. Rapport enquête CERPAM, FAI-Isère, ADEM-Drôme, SEA-Savoie, SEA-Haute-Savoie, Manosque, 162.
Ciucci, P., and Boitani, L. (1998). Wolf and dog depredation on livestock in central Italy. Wildlife Society Bulletin 26, 504–514.
de Beaufort, F. G. (1988). Écologie historique du loup, Canis lupus L. 1758, en France. Thèse d’État, Université de Rennes I, 4 vol.
de Rugy, F., and Guillaume, D. 2019. Communiqué de presse – Loups: l’État mobilisé pour concilier les activités d’élevage et la préservation de l’espèce. Ministère de la Transition Écologique et Solidaire, Ministère de l’Agriculture et de l’Alimentation, Paris.
DeCesare, N. J., Wilson, S. M., Bradley, E. H., Gude, J. A., Inman, R. M., Lance, N. J., Laudon, K., Nelson, A. A., Ross, M. S., and Smucker, T. D. (2018). Wolf-livestock conflict and the effects of wolf management. The Journal of Wildlife Management 82, 711–722.
| Wolf-livestock conflict and the effects of wolf management.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Dobremez, L., Bray, F., and Borg, D. (2016). Principaux résultats de l’Enquête Pastorale 2012/2014 dans le massif des Alpes. IRSTEA, CERPAM, Réseau Pastoral Rhône-Alpes, ADEM, FAI, SEA 73, SEA 74, Suaci Montagn’Alpes.
Doré, A. (2015). Attention aux loups! L’ambivalence de la menace et de sa mesure. Ethnologie Francaise 45, 45–54.
| Attention aux loups! L’ambivalence de la menace et de sa mesure.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
DREAL Auvergne Rhône-Alpes (2018). 2018–2023 National Action Plan on the Wolf and Stock-Rearing Activities. Available at: http://www.auvergne-rhone-alpes.developpement-durable.gouv.fr/IMG/pdf/nap_wolf_and_stock-rearing_activities_2018-2023.pdf (accessed 17 August 2019)
DREAL Auvergne Rhône-Alpes (2019a). Dommages sur les troupeaux domestiques (loup). Available at: http://www.auvergne-rhone-alpes.developpement-durable.gouv.fr/IMG/pdf/nap_wolf_and_stock-rearing_activities_2018-2023.pdf (accessed 17 August 2019)
DREAL Auvergne Rhône-Alpes (2019b). N° spécial Bilan 2018. Info-Loup 25, 1.
DREAL Auvergne Rhône-Alpes (2019c). Dispositif réglementaire dérogatoire (loup). Available at: http://www.auvergne-rhone-alpes.developpement-durable.gouv.fr/dispositif-reglementaire-derogatoire-r4522.html (accessed 17 August 2019)
Dumez, R., Arpin, I., Hubert, A., Legrand, M., Lescureux, N., Manceron, V., Morizot, B., and Mounet, C. (2017). Expertise scientifique collective sur les aspects sociologiques, culturels et ethnologiques de la présence du loup en France. Expertise pour le Ministère de l’Environnement, de l’Énergie et de la Mer, Muséum national d’Histoire naturelle, Paris.
Eklund, A., López-Bao, J. V., Tourani, M., Chapron, G., and Frank, J. (2017). Limited evidence on the effectiveness of interventions to reduce livestock predation by large carnivores. Scientific Reports 7, 2097.
| Limited evidence on the effectiveness of interventions to reduce livestock predation by large carnivores.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 28522834PubMed |
Espuno, N., Lequette, B., Poulle, M.-L., Migot, P., and Lebreton, J.-D. (2004). Heterogeneous response to preventive sheep husbandry during wolf recolonization of the French Alps. Wildlife Society Bulletin 32, 1195–1208.
| Heterogeneous response to preventive sheep husbandry during wolf recolonization of the French Alps.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
EU Council (1992). Council Directive 92/43/EEC of 21 May 1992 on the Conservation of Natural Habitats and of Wild Fauna and Flora. Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dir/1992/43/oj (accessed 17 August 2019)
Fritts, S. H., Stephenson, R. O., Hayes, R. D., and Boitani, L. (2003). Wolves and humans. In: ‘Wolves: Behavior, Ecology, and Conservation’. (Eds L. D. Mech and L. Boitani.) pp. 289–316. (The University of Chicago Press: Chicago, IL, USA.)
Galaverni, M., Caniglia, R., Fabbri, E., Milanesi, P., and Randi, E. (2015). One, no one, or one hundred thousand: how many wolves are there currently in Italy? Mammal Research 61, 13–24.
| One, no one, or one hundred thousand: how many wolves are there currently in Italy?Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Garde, L. (1997). Loup et pastoralisme: la prédation et la protection des troupeaux dans la perspective de la présence du loup en Région Provence Alpes Côte d’Azur. Convention d’étude avec le Ministère de l’Environnement n° 48/96 du 30 août 1996.
Garde, L. coord. (2012). Protection des troupeaux contre la prédation. Techniques pastorales, CERPAM, OIER Suamme, Adem, DDT(M) 04–05–06–38–73, Idele, Co-eds CERPAM-Cardère, 213–273.
Garde, L., and Meuret, M. (2017). Quand les loups franchissent la lisière: expériences d’éleveurs, chasseurs et autres résidents de Seyne-les-Alpes confrontés aux loups. Rapp. enquête. CERPAM Manosque & INRA UMR Selmet Montpellier.
Garde, L., Bacha, S., Bataille, J.-F., and Gouty, A.-L. (2007). Les éleveurs résidents en zone à loups: perceptions et stratégies. In: ‘Loup – Elevage: s’ouvrir à la complexité’. Actes du séminaire des 15 et 16 juin 2006. (Ed. L. Garde.) pp. 180–190. (CERPAM: Manosque, France.)
Gonçalves, A., and Biro, D. (2018). Comparative thanatology, an integrative approach: exploring sensory/cognitive aspects of death recognition in vertebrates and invertebrates. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological Sciences 373, 20170263.
| Comparative thanatology, an integrative approach: exploring sensory/cognitive aspects of death recognition in vertebrates and invertebrates.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 30012749PubMed |
Grente, O., Duchamp, C., Drouet-Hoguet, N., Bauduin, S., Opitz, T., Chamaillé-James, S., and Gimenez, O. (2020). Tirs dérogatoires de loups en France: état des connaissances et des enjeux pour la gestion des attaques aux troupeaux. Faune sauvage 327, 16–21.
Harper, E. K., Paul, W. J., Mech, L. D., and Weisberg, S. (2008). Effectiveness of lethal, directed wolf-depredation control in Minnesota. Journal of Wildlife Management 72, 778–784.
| Effectiveness of lethal, directed wolf-depredation control in Minnesota.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Hindrikson, M., Remm, J., Pilot, M., Godinho, R., Vik Stronen, A., Baltrunaite, L., Czarnomska, S. D., Leonard, J. A., Randi, E., Nowak, C., Akesson, M., Lopez-Bao, J. V., Alvares, F., Llaneza, L., Echegaray, J., Vila, C., Ozolins, J., Rungis, D., Aspi, J., Paule, L., Skrbinsek, T., and Saarma, U. (2016). Wolf population genetics in Europe: a systematic review, meta-analysis and suggestions for conservation and management. Biological Reviews of the Cambridge Philosophical Society 92, 1601–1629.
| Wolf population genetics in Europe: a systematic review, meta-analysis and suggestions for conservation and management.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 27682639PubMed |
Idele (2019). Ovins 2019 – Production Lait et Viande. http://idele.fr/no_cache/recherche/publication/idelesolr/recommends/chiffres-cles-ovins-2019.html
Iliopoulos, Y., Sgardelis, S., Koutis, V., and Savaris, D. (2009). Wolf depredation on livestock in Central Greece. Acta Theriologica 54, 11–22.
| Wolf depredation on livestock in Central Greece.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Johnson, F. A., Eaton, M. J., Williams, J. H., Jensen, G. H., and Madsen, J. (2015). Training conservation practitioners to be better decision makers. Sustainability 7, 8354–8373.
| Training conservation practitioners to be better decision makers.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Khorozyan, I., and Waltert, M. (2019). A framework of most effective practices in protecting human assets from predators. Human Dimensions of Wildlife 24, 380–394.
| A framework of most effective practices in protecting human assets from predators.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Kompaniyets, L., and Evans, M. A. (2017). Modelling the relationship between wolf control and cattle depredation. PLoS One 12, e0187264.
| Modelling the relationship between wolf control and cattle depredation.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 29084261PubMed |
Lescureux, N. (2006). Towards the necessity of a new interactive approach integrating ethnology, ecology and ethology in the study of the relationship between Kirghiz stockbreeders and wolves. Social Sciences Information. Information Sur les Sciences Sociales 45, 463–478.
| Towards the necessity of a new interactive approach integrating ethnology, ecology and ethology in the study of the relationship between Kirghiz stockbreeders and wolves.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Lescureux, N. (2007). Maintenir la réciprocité pour mieux coexister? Ethnographie du récit Kirghiz des relations dynamiques entre les Hommes et les loups. Thèse de doctorat du Muséum National d’Histoire Naturelle, Paris, France.
Lescureux, N., and Linnell, J. D. C. (2013). The effect of rapid social changes during post-communist transition on perceptions of the human - wolf relationships in Macedonia and Kyrgyzstan. Pastoralism 3, 4.
| The effect of rapid social changes during post-communist transition on perceptions of the human - wolf relationships in Macedonia and Kyrgyzstan.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Lescureux, N., and Linnell, J. D. C. (2014). Warring brothers: The complex interactions between wolves (Canis lupus) and dogs (Canis familiaris) in a conservation context. Biological Conservation 171, 232–245.
| Warring brothers: The complex interactions between wolves (Canis lupus) and dogs (Canis familiaris) in a conservation context.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Lescureux, N., Garde, L., and Meuret, M. (2018). Considering wolves as active agents to understand stakeholders’ perceptions and develop management strategies. In: ‘Large Carnivore Conservation and Management: Human Dimensions and Governance’. (Coord. T. Hovardas.) pp. 147–167. (Routledge: Oxon, UK.)
Linnell, J. D. C., Andersen, R., Andersone, Z., Balciauskas, L., Blanco, J. C., Boitani, L., Brainerd, S., Breitenmoser, U., Kojola, I., Liberg, O., Løe, J., Okarma, H., Pedersen, H. C., Promberger, C., Sand, H., Solberg, E. J., Valdmann, H., and Wabakken, P. (2002). The fear of wolves: a review of wolf attacks on humans. NINA, Trondheim. Oppdragsmelding 731, 1–65.
MAA-DGPE (2018). Mesures de protection des troupeaux contre la prédation. Ministère de l’Agriculture et de l’Alimentation, Instruction technique DGPE/SDPE/2018–124, NOR AGRT1804283J, 18–23.
Mech, L. D. (1995). The challenge and opportunity of recovering wolf populations. Conservation Biology 9, 270–278.
| The challenge and opportunity of recovering wolf populations.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Mech, L. D. (2012). Is science in danger of sanctifying the wolf? Biological Conservation 150, 143–149.
| Is science in danger of sanctifying the wolf?Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Mech, L. D. (2017). Where can wolves live and how can we live with them? Biological Conservation 210, 310–317.
| Where can wolves live and how can we live with them?Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Mech, L. D., and Boitani, L. (2003). ‘Wolves: Behavior, Ecology, and Conservation.’ (The University of Chicago Press: Chicago, IL, USA.)
Meuret, M., and Provenza, F. D. (2015a). When art and science meet: integrating knowledge of French herders with science of foraging behavior. Rangeland Ecology and Management 68, 1–17.
| When art and science meet: integrating knowledge of French herders with science of foraging behavior.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Meuret, M., and Provenza, F. D. (2015b). How French shepherds create meal sequences to stimulate intake and optimise use of forage diversity on rangeland. Animal Production Science 55, 309–318.
| How French shepherds create meal sequences to stimulate intake and optimise use of forage diversity on rangeland.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Moriceau, J.-M. (2007). Histoire du méchant loup: 3000 attaques sur l’homme en France (XVe-XXe siècle). Fayard, Paris, France.
OFB (2020). Bilan du suivi hivernal de la population de loups / Hiver 2019/2020. Bulletin d’information du Réseau Loup-Lynx, Juillet 2020.
Ogada, M. O., Woodroffe, R., Oguge, N. O., and Frank, L. G. (2003). Limiting depredation by African carnivores: the role of livestock husbandry. Conservation Biology 17, 1521–1530.
| Limiting depredation by African carnivores: the role of livestock husbandry.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
ONCFS (2017). Répartition géographique du loup: mise à jour en 2017 et harmonisation méthodologique. Bulletin loup du réseau loup-lynx 36, 13–15.
Oriol-Cotterill, A., Valeix, M., Frank, L. G., Riginos, C., and Macdonald, D. W. (2015). Landscapes of Coexistence for terrestrial carnivores: the ecological consequences of being downgraded from ultimate to penultimate predator by humans. Oikos 124, 1263–1273.
| Landscapes of Coexistence for terrestrial carnivores: the ecological consequences of being downgraded from ultimate to penultimate predator by humans.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Peillon, A., and Carbone, G. (1993). Bienvenue aux loups. Terre Sauvage 73, 23–42.
Peterson, R. O., and Ciucci, P. (2003). The wolf as a carnivore. In: ‘Wolves: Behavior, Ecology, and Conservation’. (Eds L. D. Mech and L. Boitani.) pp. 104–130. (The University of Chicago Press: Chicago, IL, USA.)
Poudyal, N., Baral, N., and Asah, S. T. (2016). Wolf lethal control and livestock depredations: counter-evidence from respecified models. PLoS One 11, e0148743.
| Wolf lethal control and livestock depredations: counter-evidence from respecified models.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 26866592PubMed |
Poulle, M.-L., Carles, L., and Lequette, B. (1997). Significance of ungulates in the diet of recently settled wolves in the Mercantour moutains (Southeastern France). Revue d’Écologie 52, 357–368.
Poulle, M.-L., Lequette, B., and Dahier, T. (1999). La recolonisation des Alpes françaises par le loup de 1992 à 1998. Bull. Mensuel ONCFS 242, 4–13.
R Core Team (2018). R: A language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria. https://www.R-project.org/.
Salvatori, V., and Mertens, A. D. (2012). Damage prevention methods in Europe: experiences from LIFE nature projects. Hystrix, the Italian Journal of Mammalogy 23, 73–79.
Silhol, A., Bataille, J.-F., Dureau, R., Garde, L., and Niez, T. (2007). Evaluation du schéma de protection des troupeaux en alpage: coût, travail, impact. In: ‘Loup – Elevage: s’ouvrir à la complexité’. Actes du séminaire des 15 et 16 juin 2006. (Ed. L. Garde.) pp. 166–178. (CERPAM: Manosque, France.)
Statistical Service of the French Ministry of Agriculture (2020). Agreste, agricultural statistics. https://agreste.agriculture.gouv.fr/agreste-web/disaron/G_2002/detail/ (accessed 12 November 2020).
Stépanoff, C. (2018). Les hommes préhistoriques n’ont jamais été modernes. L’Homme 227–228, 123–152.
| Les hommes préhistoriques n’ont jamais été modernes.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Treves, A., Krofel, M., and McManus, J. (2016). Predator control should not be a shot in the dark. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 14, 380–388.
| Predator control should not be a shot in the dark.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
van Bommel, L., and Johnson, C. N. (2014). Where do livestock guardian dogs go? Movement patterns of free-ranging maremma sheepdogs. PLoS One 9, e111444.
| Where do livestock guardian dogs go? Movement patterns of free-ranging maremma sheepdogs.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 25353319PubMed |
Vasconcellos, A. d-S., Virányi, Z., Range, F., Ades, C., Scheidegger, J. K., Möstl, E., and Kotrschal, K. (2016). Training reduces stress in Human-socialised wolves to the same degree as in dogs. PLoS One 11, e0162389.
| Training reduces stress in Human-socialised wolves to the same degree as in dogs.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Vincent, M. (2014). Shepherding practices in the Alps convulsed by the return of wolves as a protected species. In: ‘The Art and Science of Shepherding: Tapping the Wisdom of French Herders’. (Eds M. Meuret and F. D. Provenza.) pp. 263–289. (Acres USA: Austin, TX, USA.)
Wam, H. K., Dokk, J. G., and Hjeljord, O. (2004). Reduced wolf attacks on sheep in Ostfold, Norway, using electric fencing. Carnivore Damage Prevention News July 2004, 12–13.
Wielgus, R. B., and Peebles, K. A. (2014). Effects of wolf mortality on livestock depredations. PLoS One 9, e113505.
| Effects of wolf mortality on livestock depredations.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 25470821PubMed |
Williams, B. K., and Brown, E. D. (2014). Adaptive management: from more talk to real action. Environmental Management 53, 465–479.
| Adaptive management: from more talk to real action.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 24271618PubMed |
Zahl-Thanem, A., Burton, R. J. F., Blekesaune, A., Haugen, M. S., and Rønningen, K. (2020). The impact of wolves on psychological distress among farmers in Norway. Journal of Rural Studies 78, 1–11.
| The impact of wolves on psychological distress among farmers in Norway.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
