G. P. Darnell-Smith and the introduction of copper carbonate ‘dry pickling’ of wheat seed
G. M. Murray
A *
A
Abstract
George Percy Darnell-Smith (1868–1942) was the second plant pathologist appointed to the New South Wales Department of Agriculture. Although he founded the Microbiology Branch (later Plant Pathology Branch) and wrote articles on many plant diseases, his noteworthy contribution was developing the ‘dry pickle’ treatment for common bunt of wheat during the 1910s. Darnell-Smith built on the knowledge gained over the previous 150 years on this disease. Common bunt was the first disease—plant, animal or human—whose cause and disease cycle were found. Mathieu Tillet pioneered scientific study of plant disease with his work on bunt in the 1750s. His microscopic examination showed that minute spores infected wheat seedlings leading to bunt developing in place of wheat seeds. His field experiments found that ‘pickling’ seed with copper solutions and other toxic chemicals prevented the disease. Farmers and researchers refined these wet treatments but they remained tedious to use and reduced seed germination and seedling emergence. Darnell-Smith developed an improved treatment with copper carbonate dust that gave effective control of both seed- and soil-borne inoculum. He patented a simple machine for on-farm use. His treatment had advantages over the wet pickles, being much simpler to apply and not affecting seed germination. After confirmation in the United States of America in the early 1920s, the treatment was rapidly adopted there and in other countries where by 1930 it had reduced bunt from a common disease to one rarely seen. Darnell-Smith said that he chose to work with copper carbonate based on studies by F. C. Clark in the United States of America. However, the German scientist Carl von Tubeuf had described its effectiveness as a dry powder against bunt in 1902. Darnell-Smith lectured in England before moving to Australia so it is possible that he knew of this work. Perhaps the considerable anti-German feeling in Australia during World War I dissuaded Darnell-Smith from acknowledging von Tubeuf.
Keywords: Australian wheat farming, common bunt, copper carbonate, phytopathology, plant disease aetiology, seed treatment, Tilletia laevis, Tilletia tritici.
References
Andrews, J. A. (1987) The bread wheat races of bunt represented in the Australian bunt collection, Euphytica, 36, 577-580.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Andrews, J. A., and Ballinger, D. J. (1987) Potential for bunt resistant wheats, Australasian Plant Pathology, 16, 52-53.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Ballinger, D. J., and Gould, G. J. (1989) Occurrence of spores of Tilletia laevis and T. tritici in wheat deliveries in western Victoria, Australasian Plant Pathology, 18, 6-7.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Blanchard, F. C. (1957) Nathan A. Cobb, botanist and zoologist, a pioneer scientist in Australia, Asa Gray Bulletin, 3, 205-272.
| Google Scholar |
Buttress, F. A., and Dennis, R. W. G. (1947) The early history of cereal seed treatment in England, Agricultural History, 21, 93-103.
| Google Scholar |
Clark, J. F. (1902) On the toxic properties of some copper compounds with special reference to Bordeaux mixture, Botanical Gazette, 33, 26-48.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Cobb, N. A. (1891) Smut, Agricultural Gazette of New South Wales, 2(11), 672-677.
| Google Scholar |
Cobb, N. A. (1896) The hot-air treatment of bunt or stinking smut, Agricultural Gazette of New South Wales, 7(2), 82-83.
| Google Scholar |
Darnell-Smith, G. P. (1915a) The use of copper carbonate as a fungicide, Agricultural Gazette of New South Wales, 26(3), 242-243.
| Google Scholar |
Darnell-Smith, G. P. (1915b) Fungicide experiments, 1914, Agricultural Gazette of New South Wales, 26(6), 494-495.
| Google Scholar |
Darnell-Smith, G. P. (1917) The prevention of bunt: experiments with various fungicides, Agricultural Gazette of New South Wales, 28(3), 185-189.
| Google Scholar |
Darnell-Smith, G. P. (1919) A dry method of treating wheat seed for bunt, Agricultural Gazette of New South Wales, 30(10), 685-692.
| Google Scholar |
Darnell-Smith, G. P. (1923) Dry copper carbonate as a preventative of ‘bunt’ in wheat, Pan-Pacific Congress Record of Proceedings, 1, 136-142.
| Google Scholar |
Farrer, W. (1900) Some experiments in dealing with bunt or the stinking smut of wheat, Agricultural Gazette of New South Wales, 11(5), 335-344.
| Google Scholar |
Farrer, W. (1903) Bunt experiments of 1901, Agricultural Gazette of New South Wales, 14(3), 206-216.
| Google Scholar |
Farrer, W. (1905) The effect, in actual farm practice, of treatment with bluestone on the germination of wheat, Agricultural Gazette of New South Wales, 16(12), 1246-1247.
| Google Scholar |
Farrer, W., and Sutton, G. L. (1905) The effects of some solutions of formalin and bluestone, which are in common use, on the germination of wheat-seeds, Agricultural Gazette of New South Wales, 16(12), 1248-1255.
| Google Scholar |
Fish, S. (1970) The history of plant pathology in Australia, Annual Review of Phytopathology, 8, 13-36.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Kuiper, J. (1965) Failure of hexachlorobenzene to control common bunt of wheat, Nature, 206, 1219-1220.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Kuiper, J. (1981) 'Darnell-Smith, George Percy (1868–1942)' in ‘Australian Dictionary of Biography’, National Centre of Biography, Australian National University, https://adb.anu.edu.au/biography/darnell-smith-george-percy-5886/text10017, published first in hardcopy 1981, viewed 27 May 2023.
Mackie, W. W., and Briggs, F. N. (1923) Fungicidal dusts for the control of bunt, California Agricultural Experiment Station Bulletin, 364, 533-572.
| Google Scholar |
Murray, G. M. (1989) Jan Kuiper, Ing.Agr, 1924–1989, Australasian Plant Pathology, 18, 77.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Murray, G. M., and Brennan, J. P. (2009) Estimating disease losses to the Australian wheat industry, Australasian Plant Pathology, 38, 558-570.
| Google Scholar |
Tillet, M. (1755) Dissertation on the Cause of the Corruption and Smutting of the Kernels of Wheat in the Head, and on the Means of Preventing these Untoward Circumstances, Bordeaux, English translation by H. B. Humphrey (1937), Phytopathological Classics, 5, 1-191.
| Google Scholar |
von Tubeuf, C. F. (1902) Studien über die Brandkrankheiten des Getreides und ihre Bekämpfung, Arbeiten aus der Biologischen Abtheiling für Land- und Forstwirthschaft am Kaiserlichen Gesundheitsamte, 2, 179-260, 437–467 [In German].
| Google Scholar |
