‘The border problems of science and philosophy’: Ilse Rosenthal-Schneider and post-World War 2 science in Australian academia and society
Daniela K. Helbig A * and Maureen A. O’Malley A *
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations
A School of History and Philosophy of Science, The University of Sydney, Carslaw Building, Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia.
* Correspondence to: daniela.helbig@sydney.edu.au
Historical Records of Australian Science 33(2) 147-159 https://doi.org/10.1071/HR22005
Published: 19 July 2022
© 2022 The Author(s) (or their employer(s)). Published by CSIRO Publishing on behalf of the Australian Academy of Science. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License (CC BY-NC-ND)
Abstract
Ilse Rosenthal-Schneider (1891–1990), a refugee immigrant to Australia in 1938, was a student of Nobel Prize-winning physicists, Einstein, Planck, and von Laue. She combined a background in physics, especially relativity theory, with a philosophical focus on the nature and possibilities of knowledge. As well as working at the University of Sydney to teach science students how to recognise philosophical issues in their subjects, she drove a major outreach programme to regional towns in New South Wales, where she was fêted by her audiences as a highly accomplished science communicator. Her best-known book, published in 1980, examined her interactions with Einstein, Planck, and von Laue by expanding on how all of them understood the relationship between science and philosophy. Rosenthal-Schneider never achieved a great deal of recognition, due in part to the limited opportunities for women of her era, but also due to her insistence on bridging disciplines and engaging in a scientific and philosophical dialogue beyond academia. We will show how Rosenthal-Schneider explored the borderlands of science and philosophy throughout her life, as she argued for the relevance of philosophical questions to practising scientists and non-academic publics in Australia.
Keywords: Einstein, history and philosophy of science, interdisciplinarity, modern physics, Planck, post-WW2 science, refugees in Australia, von Laue, women in STEM.
References
Allen, N. (1994) Achievement in science: the careers of two Australian women chemists, Historical Records of Australian Science, 10, 129–141.| Achievement in science: the careers of two Australian women chemistsCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Allen, N. (1996) A pioneer of paediatric gastroenterology: the career of an Australian woman scientist, Historical Records of Australian Science, 11, 35–50.
| A pioneer of paediatric gastroenterology: the career of an Australian woman scientistCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Anderson, W. (2022) History and philosophy of science takes form, Studies in History and Philosophy of Science, 93, 175–182.
| History and philosophy of science takes formCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 35525133PubMed |
Anonymous (1939) Coming events: Extension Board, Honi Soit, 11(5), 2.
Anonymous (1941) Reality and scientific ‘truth’, Honi Soit, 13(24), 3.
Anonymous (1943a) Tonight’s School of Arts lecture, Daily Advertiser, 2 July, p. 2.
Anonymous (1943b) Mental adjustment: part in reconstruction: address by Dr. Rosenthal-Schneider, Daily Advertiser, 3 July, p. 6.
Anonymous (1943c) Science and reality: lecture at Wagga by Dr. Ilse Rosenthal-Schneider, Daily Advertiser, 1 October, p. 3.
Anonymous (1943d) Better way of life: philosophic base for reconstruction, Newcastle Morning Herald and Miners’ Advocate, 28 May, p. 2.
Anonymous (1943e) Cessnock Rotary Club: ‘The need for a philosophic basis for post-war reconstruction’: Interesting address, Cessnock Eagle and South Maitland Recorder, 28 May, p. 5.
Anonymous (1944a) School of Arts Lecture, Daily Advertiser, 28 October, p. 4.
Anonymous (1944b) Rotarians hear ‘quite unusual address’, Border Morning Mail, 31 October, p. 6.
Anonymous (1944c) AASW meets: science history discussed, Honi Soit, 16(13), 1.
Anonymous (1945) GNUS: history of science, Honi Soit, 17(19), 8.
Anonymous (1946) ‘The Atomic Age’: notable address at Rotary Club, Muswellbrook Chronicle, 31 May, p. 1.
Anonymous (1947a) Science and war: lecture at Wagga, Daily Advertiser, 12 April, p. 2.
Anonymous (1947b) Notes by ‘Dianthus’: distinguished visitors, Daily Advertiser, 16 April, p. 6.
Anonymous (1948) Personal, Scone Advocate, 3 September, 1–3.
Anonymous (1950) ‘Yuletide’ toast, Singleton Argus, 22 December, p. 4.
Anonymous (1965) Sydney University Extension Board: Scientific German 1965: Ilse Rosenthal-Schneider, Ph.D, tutor, Honi Soit, 38(2), 6.
Anonymous (1991) Rare books for Library, Uniken: The University of NSW, 360, 3 May, 11.
Ash, M. G. and Söllner, A. (1996) ‘Introduction: forced migration and scientific change after 1933’, in Forced Migration and Scientific Change: Émigré German-Speaking Scientists and Scholars After 1933, eds M. G. Ash and A. Söllner, Cambridge, UK, pp. 1–19.
Campbell, K. S. W., and Jell, J. S. (1998) Dorothy Hill 1907–1997, Historical Records of Australian Science, 12, 205–228.
| Dorothy Hill 1907–1997Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Carey, J. (2001a) Engendering scientific pursuits: Australian women and science, 1880–1960, Limina, 7, 10–25.
Carey, J. (2001b) No place for a woman? Intersections of class, modernity and colonialism in the gendering of Australian Science, 1885–1940, Lilith, 10, 153–172.
Colley, L. (2018) For better or for worse: fifty years since the removal of the marriage bar in the Australian Public Service, Australian Journal of Politics and History, 64, 227–240.
| For better or for worse: fifty years since the removal of the marriage bar in the Australian Public ServiceCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
CSIRO (1950) Chairman’s letter to Ruby Payne-Scott. National Archives of Australia, A8520, PH/PAY/002.
Deery, P. (2000) Scientific freedom and post-war politics: Australia, 1945–1955, Historical Records of Australian Science, 13, 1–18.
| Scientific freedom and post-war politics: Australia, 1945–1955Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Denz, C. and Vogt, A. (2005) ‘Ilse Rosenthal-Schneider—eine Frau interpretiert Albert Einstein [Ilse Rosenthal-Schneider: a woman interprets Albert Einstein]’, in Einstein’s Kolleginnen—Physikerinnen gestern und heute [Einstein’s (Female) Colleagues: Physicists Yesterday and Today], eds C. Denz and A. Vogt, Bielefeld, pp. 10–13.
Dyason, D. (1977) After thirty years history and philosophy of science in Australia 1946–1976, Critical Studies in Education, 19, 45–74.
Elkana, Y. (1982) ‘The myth of simplicity’, in Albert Einstein, Historical and Cultural Perspectives: the Centennial Symposium in Jerusalem, eds G. Holton and Y. Elkana, pp. 205–251.
Giere, R. N. (1996) ‘From Wissenschaftliche Philosophie to philosophy of science’, in Origins of Logical Empiricism, eds R. N. Giere and A. W. Richardson, Minnesota, MN, pp. 335–354.
Glaros, M. (2012) ‘Sometimes a little injustice must be suffered for the public good’: How the National Security (Aliens Control) Regulations 1939 (Cth) affected the lives of German, Italian, Japanese and Australian born women living in Australia during the Second World War', unpublished PhD thesis, University of Western Sydney.
Glorfeld, J. (2020) Rachel Makinson and the science of wool, Cosmos, 24 July, https://cosmosmagazine.com/science/physics/rachel-makinson-and-the-science-of-wool/
Goss, W. M. (2013) Making Waves: the Story of Ruby Payne-Scott: Australian Pioneer Radio Astronomer, Springer.
Grimshaw, P. and Francis, R. (2014) ‘Academic women and research leadership in twentieth-century Australia’, in Diversity in Leadership: Australian Women, Past and Present, eds J. Damousi, K. Rubenstein, and M. Tomsic, Canberra, pp. 207–236.
Hendry, J. (1982) Review: Reality and Scientific Truth. Discussions with Einstein, von Laue, and Planck by I. Rosenthal-Schneider and T. Braun, British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 33, 329–331.
Hentschel, K. (1992) Einstein’s attitude towards experiments: testing relativity theory 1907–1927, Studies in History and Philosophy of Science, 23, 593–624.
| Einstein’s attitude towards experiments: testing relativity theory 1907–1927Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Holton, G. (1968) Mach, Einstein, and the search for reality, Daedalus, 97, 636–673.
Hooker, C. (2004) Irresistible Forces: Australian Women in Science, Melbourne.
Horne, J. (2016) The “knowledge front”, women, war and peace, History of Education Review, 45, 151–167.
| The “knowledge front”, women, war and peaceCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Horton, P., Chow, W. S., and Barrett, C. (2019) Joan Mary Anderson 1932–2015, Historical Records of Australian Science, 30, 19–31.
| Joan Mary Anderson 1932–2015Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Howard, D. (1994) ‘Einstein, Kant, and the origins of logical empiricism’, in Logic, Language, and the Structure of Scientific Theories: Proceedings of the Carnap-Reichenbach Centennial, University of Konstanz, 21–24 May 1991, eds W. Salmon and G. Wolters, PA, pp. 45–105.
Kelly, F. (ed.) (1993a) On the Edge of Discovery, Melbourne.
Kelly, F. (1993b) ‘Learning and teaching science: women making careers 1890-1920’, in On the Edge of Discovery, ed. F. Kelly, Melbourne, pp. 35–75.
Kettler, D. and Lauer, G. (2005) Exile, Science, and Bildung: the Contested Legacies of German Émigré Intellectuals, NY.
Kunze, S. (2015) The Friedmann-Brauns: chocolate cake and the story of a family, Archives and Manuscripts at the Bodleian Library Blog, http://blogs.bodleian.ox.ac.uk/archivesandmanuscripts/2015/02/19/braun/
Lowenthal, G. C. (1985) Letter to the editor, Australian Physicist, 22, 51.
Maroske, S. (1993) ‘“The whole great continent as a present”: nineteenth-century Australian women workers in science’, in On the Edge of Discovery, ed. F. Kelly, Melbourne, pp. 13–34.
Mazón, P. M. (2003) Gender and the Modern Research University: the Admission of Women to German Higher Education, 1865–1914, Stanford.
McEwin, E. (2018) Nancy Atkinson, bacteriologist, winemaker and writer, Australian Journal of Biography and History, 1, 59–77.
| Nancy Atkinson, bacteriologist, winemaker and writerCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
McLachlan, E. M., and Hirst, G. D. S. (2013) Mollie Elizabeth Holman 1930–2010, Historical Records of Australian Science, 24, 242–250.
| Mollie Elizabeth Holman 1930–2010Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Moyal, A. (1993) Invisible participants: women in science in Australia, 1830–1950, Prometheus, 11, 175–187.
| Invisible participants: women in science in Australia, 1830–1950Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Newman, M. F., and Wall, G. E. (1975) Hanna Neumann, Records of Australian Academy of Science, 3, 57–87.
| Hanna NeumannCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Orthia, L. A. (2016) ‘Laudably communicating to the world’: science in Sydney’s public culture, 1788–1821, Historical Records of Australian Science, 27, 1–12.
| ‘Laudably communicating to the world’: science in Sydney’s public culture, 1788–1821Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Palmquist, S. (2010) The Kantian grounding of Einstein’s worldview: (I) the early influence of Kant’s system of perspectives, Polish Journal of Philosophy, 4, 45–64.
| The Kantian grounding of Einstein’s worldview: (I) the early influence of Kant’s system of perspectivesCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Pickles, K. (2001) Colonial counterparts: the first academic women in Anglo-Canada, New Zealand and Australia, Women’s History Review, 10, 273–298.
| Colonial counterparts: the first academic women in Anglo-Canada, New Zealand and AustraliaCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Pittard, A. J. (2013) Nancy Fanny Millis 1922–2012, Historical Records of Australian Science, 24, 283–293.
| Nancy Fanny Millis 1922–2012Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Pomata, G. (2013) Amateurs by choice: women and the pursuit of independent scholarship in 20th century historical writing, Centaurus, 55, 196–219.
| Amateurs by choice: women and the pursuit of independent scholarship in 20th century historical writingCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Reichenbach, H. (1949) ‘The philosophical significance of the theory of relativity’, in Albert Einstein: Philosopher-Scientist, ed P. A. Schilpp, vol. 1, Evanston, IL, pp. 287–311.
Reichenberger, A. (2020) ‘Zwei Fundstücke zu Henri Poincaré’, in Siegener Beiträge zur Geschichte und Philosophie der Mathematik, band 13, eds R. Krömer and G. Nickel, Siegen, pp. 127–154.
Rosenthal-Schneider, I. (1945) The scientist’s interference with the things he studies, Australian Journal of Science, 7, 166–169.
| 21006457PubMed |
Rosenthal-Schneider, I. (1946) The laws of nature in light of modern physics and biology, Australian Journal of Science, 8, 120–123.
| 20991703PubMed |
Rosenthal-Schneider, I. (1947) The interpretation of scientific evidence, Australian Journal of Science, 9, 161–166.
| 20250895PubMed |
Rosenthal-Schneider, I. (1948a) Review: Geschichte der Physik by Max v. Laue, Isis, 38, 258–260.
Rosenthal-Schneider, I. (1948b) Obituary: Max Planck, Australian Journal of Science, 10, 105–106.
Rosenthal-Schneider, I. (1949a) Review: Wissenschaftliche Selbstbiographie by Max Planck, Isis, 40, 67–69.
Rosenthal-Schneider, I. (1949b) ‘Presuppositions and anticipations in Einstein’s physics’, in Albert Einstein: Philosopher-Scientist, ed. P. A. Schilpp, vol. 1, pp. 129–146.
Rosenthal-Schneider, I. (1950) Review: Vorträge der aus Anlass seines 300: Geburtstages in Hamburg abgehaltenen wissenschaftlichen Tagung zu Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, Isis, 41, 310–313.
Rosenthal-Schneider, I. (1952) Limits in modern physics and their epistemological implications, Australian Journal of Science, 15, 77–80.
Rosenthal-Schneider, I. (1954) Einstein, at 75, is still seeking eternal truths, Sydney Morning Herald, 13 March, p. 2.
Rosenthal-Schneider, I. (1955) Albert Einstein: 14 March 1879 – 18 April 1955, Australian Journal of Science, 18, 15–20.
Rosenthal-Schneider, I. (1960) Obituary notice: Max von Laue, Australian Journal of Science, 23, 42–43.
Rosenthal-Schneider, I. (1980a) ‘Reminiscences of Einstein’, in Some Strangeness in the Proportions: a Centennial Symposium to Celebrate the Achievements of Albert Einstein, ed. H. Woolf, pp. 521–523.
Rosenthal-Schneider, I. (1980b) Reality and Scientific Truth: Discussions with Einstein, von Laue, and Planck, Detroit.
Sarton, G., and Diller, A. (1946) Notes and correspondence: history of science in Australia (from a letter to the editor by Dr. Ilse Rosenthal-Schneider, Sydney, July 24, 1945), Isis, 36, 130–134.
Schilpp, P. A. (ed) (1949) Albert Einstein: Philosopher-Scientist, 2 vols, Evanston, IL.
Schneider, I. (1914) ‘Raum, Zeit und ihre Relativität bei Poincaré’, in Herrn Geheimrat Professor Dr. phil. et H. LL. D. Alois Riehl zum siebzigsten Geburtstag, eds K. Lewin and A. Riehl, Berlin, pp. 91–130.
Schneider, I. (1921) Das Raum-Zeit-Problem bei Kant und Einstein, Heidelberg.
Sharma, M. D. (2005) The changing status of women physicists in Australia, AIP Conference Proceedings, 795, 89–90.
Sheridan, T., and Stretton, P. (2004) Mandarins, ministers and the bar on married women, Journal of Industrial Relations, 46, 84–101.
| Mandarins, ministers and the bar on married womenCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Smith, B. (2014) Ann Janet Woolcock 1937–2001, Historical Records of Australian Science, 25, 313–336.
| Ann Janet Woolcock 1937–2001Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Smith, D. (1983) Einstein’s pupil reflects on a lifetime of science, National Times, 30 January–5 February, pp. 11–12.
Staley, R. (2005) On the co-creation of classical and modern physics, Isis, 96, 530–558.
| 16536154PubMed |
Stevenson, T. (2014) Making visible the first women in astronomy in Australia: the measurers and computers employed for the astrographic catalogue, Publications of the Astronomical Society of Australia, 31, e018.
| Making visible the first women in astronomy in Australia: the measurers and computers employed for the astrographic catalogueCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Turnbull, M. J. (2000) Safe Haven: Records of Jewish Experience in Australia, Kingston, ACT.
Turner, S. (2007) ‘Invincible but mostly invisible: Australian women’s contribution to geology and palaeontology’, in The Role of Women in the History of Geology, eds C. V. Burek and B. Higgs, London, pp. 165–201.
Turtle, A. M. (1987) History and Philosophy of Science at the University of Sydney: a case study in non-innovation, Historical Records of Australian Science, 7, 27–37.
| History and Philosophy of Science at the University of Sydney: a case study in non-innovationCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Upstill, G., Spurling, T. H., and Healy, T. J. (2021) CSIR and Australian industry: 1926–49, Historical Records of Australian Science, 32, 52–66.
| CSIR and Australian industry: 1926–49Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Way, A. (2021) Natural selection and the ‘antiquity of man’: intellectual impacts in the Australian colonies, Studies in History and Philosophy of Science, 90, 308–320.
| Natural selection and the ‘antiquity of man’: intellectual impacts in the Australian coloniesCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 34798591PubMed |
Wright, S. W., Hallegraeff, G. M., and Mantoura, R. F. C. (2016) Shirley Winifred Jeffrey 1930–2014, Historical Records of Australian Science, 27, 81–91.
| Shirley Winifred Jeffrey 1930–2014Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
