Evaluating the concentration addition approach for describing expected toxicity of a ternary metal mixture (Ni, Cu, Cd) using metal speciation and response surface regression
Yamini Gopalapillai A B and Beverley Hale A
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations
A School of Environmental Sciences, University of Guelph, Guelph, ON, N1G 2W1, Canada.
B Corresponding author. Email: ygopalap@uoguelph.ca
Environmental Chemistry 13(3) 447-456 https://doi.org/10.1071/EN15124
Submitted: 16 June 2015 Accepted: 31 July 2015 Published: 8 October 2015
Environmental context. Environmental quality guidelines are often based on an ‘additive’ approach using single metal toxicity values. We evaluated the ‘additive’ approach by testing it on three priority pollutant metals (Ni, Cu, Cd), and found that the toxicity of the metal mixture was less than additive when dose was expressed as total metal concentration, but it was additive when dose was expressed as bioavailable metal. We suggest that for metal mixtures, a more realistic indicator of risk is provided by calculations based on the bioavailable form of metals.
Abstract. Aquatic environments containing elevated metal concentrations, such as natural waters receiving mining effluents, are often a mixture of metals because mineral deposits are commonly an association of multiple metals. Water quality guidelines for protection of aquatic life are not designed for multiple toxicants but are overwhelmingly based on dose–response studies of a single toxicant and assuming additivity. Resolving the uncertainty in risk assessment for metal mixtures in waters surrounding Canada’s many current and legacy extractive mining sites is a high priority for both government and base metal mining companies. Our study evaluated the ‘concentration addition’ approach to predicting the chronic toxicity of a ternary metal mixture (Ni, Cu, Cd) to Lemna minor (a free-floating macrophyte used in biomonitoring of mining effluents) using either total metal concentration as dose or free-ion activity. The aim was to fill several data gaps in mixture toxicity studies, such as: inclusion of water chemistry to calculate metal speciation, test species other than the commonly studied rainbow trout and cladocerans, and test mixture effects on chronic toxicity. Results indicate that toxicity of Ni, Cu plus Cd to L. minor was less than additive (overestimated toxicity) when expressed as total metal concentration but was additive when expressed as free ion (the bioavailable form). We suggest that applying single-element quality guidelines ‘additively’ for plants is likely to overestimate risk to the ecosystem from metal mixtures, and that the use of a concentration addition approach based on the bioavailable form of metals provides a more realistic indicator of risk.
References
[1] E. Van Genderen, W. Adams, R. Dwyer, E. Garman, J. Gorsuch, Modeling and interpreting biological effects of mixtures in the environment: introduction to the Metal Mixture Modeling Evaluation project. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 2015, 34, 721.| Modeling and interpreting biological effects of mixtures in the environment: introduction to the Metal Mixture Modeling Evaluation project.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC2MXltFSksLc%3D&md5=b051db33ae20c12a284ce8205ca832f7CAS | 25809105PubMed |
[2] WHO OECD ILSI/HESI International Workshop on Risk Assessment of Combined Exposures to Multiple Chemicals 2011 (OECD: Paris, France). Available at http://search.oecd.org/officialdocuments/displaydocumentpdf/?cote=env/jm/mono(2011)10&doclanguage=en [Verified 2 September 2015].
[3] Toxicity and Assessment of Chemical Mixtures 2012 (Scientific Committee on Health and Environmental Risks, Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety, Scientific Committee on Emerging and Newly Identified Health Risks). Available at http://ec.europa.eu/health/scientific_committees/environmental_risks/docs/scher_o_155.pdf [Verified 2 September 2015].
[4] M. G. Vijver, W. J. G. M. Peijnenburg, G. R. De Snoo, Toxicological mixture models are based on inadequate assumptions. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2010, 44, 4841.
| Toxicological mixture models are based on inadequate assumptions.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC3cXnvFGntro%3D&md5=d3256bf392fea3660f7f8cdb89609f39CAS | 20583826PubMed |
[5] V. Gregorio, N. Chèvre, M. Junghans, Critical issues in using the common mixture toxicity models concentration addition or response addition on species sensitivity distributions: a theoretical approach. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 2013, 32, 2387.
| Critical issues in using the common mixture toxicity models concentration addition or response addition on species sensitivity distributions: a theoretical approach.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC3sXhtlOku73E&md5=19cab898f4e1df749bce1ef119fbb179CAS | 23804417PubMed |
[6] L. S. Balistrieri, C. A. Mebane, Predicting the toxicity of metal mixtures. Sci. Total Environ. 2014, 466–467, 788.
| Predicting the toxicity of metal mixtures.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 23973545PubMed |
[7] P. Marschner, H. Marschner, Marschner’s Mineral Nutrition of Higher Plants 2012 (Academic Press: Waltham, MA, USA).
[8] A. Kortenkamp, T. Backhaus, M. Faust, State of the Art Report on Mixture Toxicity 2009 (University of London: Brussels, Belgium).
[9] K. J. Farley, J. S. Meyer, L. S. Balistrieri, K. A. C. De Schamphelaere, Y. Iwasaki, C. R. Janssen, M. Kamo, S. Lofts, C. A. Mebane, W. Naito, A. C. Ryan, R. C. Santore, E. Tipping, Metal Mixture Modeling Evaluation project: 2. Comparison of four modeling approaches. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 2015, 34, 741.
| Metal Mixture Modeling Evaluation project: 2. Comparison of four modeling approaches.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC2MXltFSksLg%3D&md5=561fde674c71283691b48d5a6bb3b019CAS | 25418584PubMed |
[10] L. S. Balistrieri, C. A. Mebane, T. S. Schmidt, W. B. Keller, Expanding metal mixture toxicity models to natural stream and lake invertebrate communities. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. SETAC 2015, 34, 761.
| Expanding metal mixture toxicity models to natural stream and lake invertebrate communities.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC2MXltFSksLk%3D&md5=6f1289399cadac74500a4f26a06cb7faCAS |
[11] J. S. Meyer, K. J. Farley, E. R. Garman, Metal mixtures modeling evaluation project: 1. background. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 2015, 34, 726.
| Metal mixtures modeling evaluation project: 1. background.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC2MXltFSkt7w%3D&md5=94941e087dbe0160e7acd712e5c5dff1CAS | 25353683PubMed |
[12] Y. Iwasaki, M. Kamo, W. Naito, Testing an application of a biotic ligand model to predict acute toxicity of metal mixtures to rainbow trout. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 2015, 34, 754.
| Testing an application of a biotic ligand model to predict acute toxicity of metal mixtures to rainbow trout.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC2MXltFSktr4%3D&md5=c510395667b3f8440afb2752349e2ef9CAS | 25323464PubMed |
[13] R. C. Santore, A. C. Ryan, Development and application of a multimetal multibiotic ligand model for assessing aquatic toxicity of metal mixtures. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 2015, 34, 777.
| Development and application of a multimetal multibiotic ligand model for assessing aquatic toxicity of metal mixtures.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC2MXltFSktr0%3D&md5=6d05882ae8f41b2ea3c2393c9ed9b37cCAS | 25556972PubMed |
[14] E. Tipping, S. Lofts, Testing WHAM-FTox with laboratory toxicity data for mixtures of metals (Cu, Zn, Cd, Ag, Pb). Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 2015, 34, 788.
| Testing WHAM-FTox with laboratory toxicity data for mixtures of metals (Cu, Zn, Cd, Ag, Pb).Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC2MXltFSksLs%3D&md5=a2856b734cc1fe90ff8cc8c60e923612CAS | 25318827PubMed |
[15] J. S. Meyer, J. F. Ranville, M. Pontasch, J. W. Gorsuch, W. J. Adams, Acute toxicity of binary and ternary mixtures of Cd, Cu, and Zn to Daphnia magna. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 2015, 34, 799.
| Acute toxicity of binary and ternary mixtures of Cd, Cu, and Zn to Daphnia magna.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC2MXltFSksbg%3D&md5=01d0424101c2f8464cec2db1261c989fCAS | 25336231PubMed |
[16] R. B. Naddy, A. S. Cohen, W. A. Stubblefield, The interactive toxicity of cadmium, copper, and zinc to Ceriodaphnia dubia and rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss). Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 2015, 34, 809.
| The interactive toxicity of cadmium, copper, and zinc to Ceriodaphnia dubia and rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss).Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC2MXltFSksbs%3D&md5=e255dde771d62b6dad135c9cbd955125CAS | 25641563PubMed |
[17] Y. Iwasaki, S. F. Brinkman, Application of a generalized linear mixed model to analyze mixture toxicity: survival of brown trout affected by copper and zinc. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 2015, 34, 816.
| Application of a generalized linear mixed model to analyze mixture toxicity: survival of brown trout affected by copper and zinc.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC2MXltFSkt78%3D&md5=bc48b1950aed0da51de9a0a03c61d210CAS | 25524054PubMed |
[18] K. J. Farley, J. S. Meyer, Metal Mixture Modeling Evaluation project: 3. Lessons learned and steps forward. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 2015, 34, 821.
| Metal Mixture Modeling Evaluation project: 3. Lessons learned and steps forward.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC2MXltFSktrw%3D&md5=ef86880b3ea943865e83c235ab819e57CAS | 25475765PubMed |
[19] D. G. Heijerick, C. R. Janssen, W. M. D. Coen, The combined effects of hardness, pH, and dissolved organic carbon on the chronic toxicity of Zn to D. magna: development of a surface response model. Arch. Environ. Contam. Toxicol. 2003, 44, 210.
| The combined effects of hardness, pH, and dissolved organic carbon on the chronic toxicity of Zn to D. magna: development of a surface response model.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD3sXjsF2ntQ%3D%3D&md5=02c51fac18a48d6c9c2929e5d1abfce1CAS | 12520393PubMed |
[20] F. De Laender, C. R. Janssen, K. A. C. De Schamphelaere, Non-simultaneous ecotoxicity testing of single chemicals and their mixture results in erroneous conclusions about the joint action of the mixture. Chemosphere 2009, 76, 428.
| Non-simultaneous ecotoxicity testing of single chemicals and their mixture results in erroneous conclusions about the joint action of the mixture.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD1MXmtl2rtbc%3D&md5=8d6430a2008d982fb28e2a1b253186e7CAS | 19375150PubMed |
[21] Metal Mining Effluent Regulations 2002 (Justice Laws: Ottawa, ON, Canada) Available at http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/regulations/sor-2002-222/index.html [Verified 2 September 2015].
[22] H. B. Xue, S. Jansen, A. Prasch, L. Sigg, Nickel speciation and complexation kinetics freshwater by ligand exchange and DPCSV. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2001, 35, 539.
| Nickel speciation and complexation kinetics freshwater by ligand exchange and DPCSV.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD3MXntw%3D%3D&md5=554496e78a94db00835e36f9c1d08f0cCAS | 11351726PubMed |
[23] Biological Test Method: Test for Measuring the Inhibition of Growth Using the Freshwater Macrophyte, Lemna minor 2007 (Environment Canada, Environmental Technology Centre: Ottawa, ON, Canada).
[24] Y. Gopalapillai, B. Vigneault, B. Hale, Effect of pH and environmental ligands on accumulation and toxicity of Ni2+ to Lemna minor. Environ. Chem. 2012, 9, 547.
| Effect of pH and environmental ligands on accumulation and toxicity of Ni2+ to Lemna minor.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC38XhvVOqu7vP&md5=f88ea1c78e0961ad194ad4f1c7e554f3CAS |
[25] Y. Gopalapillai, B. Hale, B. Vigneault, Effect of major cations (Ca 2+, Mg 2+, Na +, K +) and anions (SO42–, Cl–, NO3–) on Ni accumulation and toxicity in aquatic plant (Lemna minor L.): implications for Ni risk assessment. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 2013, 32, 810.
| Effect of major cations (Ca 2+, Mg 2+, Na +, K +) and anions (SO42–, Cl–, NO3–) on Ni accumulation and toxicity in aquatic plant (Lemna minor L.): implications for Ni risk assessment.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC3sXkslSlt7k%3D&md5=135fc3df9642d76e3e79fde2fa9d0afbCAS | 23297250PubMed |
[26] Y. Gopalapillai, B. Vigneault, B. A. Hale, Root length of aquatic plant, Lemna minor L., as an optimal toxicity endpoint for biomonitoring of mining effluents. Integr. Environ. Assess. Manag. 2014, 10, 493.
| Root length of aquatic plant, Lemna minor L., as an optimal toxicity endpoint for biomonitoring of mining effluents.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 25045146PubMed |
[27] Windermere Humic Aqueous Model 7 2011 (Centre for Ecology & Hydrology: Lancaster, UK).
[28] L. Van Laer, E. Smolders, F. Degryse, C. Janssen, K. A. C. De Schamphelaere, Speciation of nickel in surface waters measured with the Donnan membrane technique. Anal. Chim. Acta 2006, 578, 195.
| Speciation of nickel in surface waters measured with the Donnan membrane technique.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD28XhtVSitrjJ&md5=602c11ad220cdbf600a304875e1b1102CAS | 17723712PubMed |
[29] T. Cheng, K. De Schamphelaere, S. Lofts, C. Janssen, H. E. Allen, Measurement and computation of zinc binding to natural dissolved organic matter in European surface waters. Anal. Chim. Acta 2005, 542, 230.
| Measurement and computation of zinc binding to natural dissolved organic matter in European surface waters.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD2MXltFGnsLo%3D&md5=317a183118aa1f38dd419ed27d28298fCAS |
[30] N. M. E. Deleebeeck, K. A. C. De Schamphelaere, C. R. Janssen, A bioavailability model predicting the toxicity of nickel to rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) and fathead minnow (Pimephales promelas) in synthetic and natural waters. Ecotoxicol. Environ. Saf. 2007, 67, 1.
| A bioavailability model predicting the toxicity of nickel to rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) and fathead minnow (Pimephales promelas) in synthetic and natural waters.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD2sXjvFGnurs%3D&md5=749e2d75226b5bae3c51cf24537657d3CAS |
[31] R. M. Smith, A. E. Martell, R. J. Motekaitis, NIST Critically Selected Stability Constants of Metal Complexes Database, Version 8.0 for Windows 2004 (National Institute of Standards and Technology: Gaithersburg, MD, USA).
[32] P. M. C. Antunes, M. L. Scornaienchi, H. D. Roshon, Copper toxicity to Lemna minor modelled using humic acid as a surrogate for the plant root. Chemosphere 2012, 88, 389.
| Copper toxicity to Lemna minor modelled using humic acid as a surrogate for the plant root.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC38XktFGis70%3D&md5=9253b0e691d8bb766dde583ad53b095eCAS |
[33] Comprehensive Environmental Toxicity Information System (CETIS) 2009 (Tidepool Scientific Software: McKinleyville, CA, USA).
[34] J. B. Belden, R. J. Gilliom, M. J. Lydy, How well can we predict the toxicity of pesticide mixtures to aquatic life? Integr. Environ. Assess. Manag. 2007, 3, 364.
| How well can we predict the toxicity of pesticide mixtures to aquatic life?Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD2sXpt1altbk%3D&md5=4a00fc28b0caac1d4563c9de9f19ebbfCAS | 17695109PubMed |
[35] M. J. Jonker, C. Svendsen, J. J. M. Bedaux, M. Bongers, J. E. Kammenga, Significance testing of synergistic/antagonistic, dose level-dependent, or dose ratio-dependent effects in mixture dose–response analysis. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 2005, 24, 2701.
| Significance testing of synergistic/antagonistic, dose level-dependent, or dose ratio-dependent effects in mixture dose–response analysis.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD2MXhtVKqt7fM&md5=481e4e910f971dfd3ecdeef1d2e52e9eCAS | 16268173PubMed |
[36] K. A. C. De Schamphelaere, C. R. Janssen, A biotic ligand model predicting acute copper toxicity for Daphnia magna: the effects of calcium, magnesium, sodium, potassium, and pH. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2002, 36, 48.
| A biotic ligand model predicting acute copper toxicity for Daphnia magna: the effects of calcium, magnesium, sodium, potassium, and pH.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD3MXoslSgtbY%3D&md5=b67781f0a03709537485c89a9c57b09cCAS |
[37] K. A. C. De Schamphelaere, C. R. Janssen, Development and field validation of a biotic ligand model predicting chronic copper toxicity to Daphnia magna. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 2004, 23, 1365.
| Development and field validation of a biotic ligand model predicting chronic copper toxicity to Daphnia magna.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD2cXks1ylsL0%3D&md5=a4992e0c97e350e65527ec04108f10b3CAS |
[38] K. A. C. De Schamphelaere, F. M. Vasconcelos, D. G. Heijerick, F. M. G. Tack, K. Delbeke, H. E. Allen, H. E. Allen, C. R. Janssen, Development and field validation of a predictive copper toxicity model for the green alga Pseudokirchneriella subcapitata. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 2003, 22, 2454.
| Development and field validation of a predictive copper toxicity model for the green alga Pseudokirchneriella subcapitata.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD3sXnslKis7s%3D&md5=7be75941ebc66c6c5a883339a85602bdCAS |
[39] N. Cedergreen, H. Sorensen, C. Svendsen, Can the joint effect of ternary mixtures be predicted from binary mixture toxicity results? Sci. Total Environ. 2012, 427–428, 229.
| Can the joint effect of ternary mixtures be predicted from binary mixture toxicity results?Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 22542295PubMed |
[40] N. M. Franklin, J. L. Stauber, R. P. Lim, P. Petocz, Toxicity of metal mixtures to a tropical freshwater alga (Chlorella sp.): the effect of interactions between copper, cadmium, and zinc on metal cell binding and uptake. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. SETAC 2002, 21, 2412.
| Toxicity of metal mixtures to a tropical freshwater alga (Chlorella sp.): the effect of interactions between copper, cadmium, and zinc on metal cell binding and uptake.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD38XotVGntrk%3D&md5=4b94cd1e6bc2066418f4c6b8ba0c7b4fCAS |
[41] M. G. Vijver, E. G. Elliott, W. J. G. M. Peijnenburg, G. R. de Snoo, Response predictions for organisms water-exposed to metal mixtures: a meta-analysis. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. SETAC 2011, 30, 1482.
| Response predictions for organisms water-exposed to metal mixtures: a meta-analysis.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC3MXmt1ygs7Y%3D&md5=28d2cee984af045799756886a459ba67CAS |
[42] I. Komjarova, R. Blust, Multimetal interactions between Cd, Cu, Ni, Pb, and Zn uptake from water in the zebrafish Danio rerio. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2009, 43, 7225.
| Multimetal interactions between Cd, Cu, Ni, Pb, and Zn uptake from water in the zebrafish Danio rerio.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD1MXntFygsro%3D&md5=11147664f28d167733a9765851eff590CAS | 19848126PubMed |
[43] M. Kamo, T. Nagai, An application of the biotic ligand model to predict the toxic effects of metal mixtures. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. SETAC 2008, 27, 1479.
| An application of the biotic ligand model to predict the toxic effects of metal mixtures.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD1cXnsl2ju7g%3D&md5=8b8c152d5143a3976254b16cda10d1a3CAS |
[44] J. S. Meyer, R. C. Santore, J. P. Bobbitt, L. D. DeBrey, C. J. Boese, P. R. Paquin, H. E. Allen, H. L. Bergman, D. M. DiToro, Binding of nickel and copper to fish gills predicts toxicity when water hardness varies, but free-ion activity does not. Environ. Sci. Technol. 1999, 33, 913.
| Binding of nickel and copper to fish gills predicts toxicity when water hardness varies, but free-ion activity does not.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DyaK1MXnsF2luw%3D%3D&md5=c112274487be3f1208cca5000f752cd8CAS |
[45] W. P. Norwood, U. Borgmann, D. G. Dixon, A. Wallace, Effects of metal mixtures on aquatic biota: a review of observations and methods. Hum. Ecol. Risk Assess. Int. J. 2003, 9, 795.
| Effects of metal mixtures on aquatic biota: a review of observations and methods.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD3sXmtF2mtrg%3D&md5=ce4cff4138a38d23cf0c8c692b70ecabCAS |
