Register      Login
Crop and Pasture Science Crop and Pasture Science Society
Plant sciences, sustainable farming systems and food quality
Shopping Cart: ( empty )
You are here: Home > Journals > CP > AR05051
RESEARCH ARTICLE
Contents Vol 57(2)

Learning from the historical failure of farm management models to aid management practice. Part 1. The rise and demise of theoretical models of farm economics

R. L. McCown A D , L. E. Brennan B and K. A. Parton C
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations

A CSIRO Sustainable Ecosystems, Agricultural Production Systems Research Unit (APSRU), Toowoomba, Qld 4350, Australia.

B CSIRO Sustainable Ecosystems, Queensland Bioscience Precinct, St. Lucia, Qld 4067, Australia.

C Faculty of Science and Agriculture, Charles Sturt University, Orange, NSW 2800, Australia.

D Corresponding author. Email: Bob.McCown@csiro.au

Australian Journal of Agricultural Research 57(2) 143-156 https://doi.org/10.1071/AR05051
Submitted: 18 February 2005  Accepted: 7 September 2005   Published: 24 February 2006

Abstract

A potential source of lessons for agricultural modellers aspiring to influence farm decision making is the historical experience of agricultural economists in the field, variously termed ‘Farm Management Research’ or ‘Farm Management’. Although the histories of Farm Management in the USA and in Australia differ significantly, in both cases the field was originally characterised by pragmatic on-farm research by agricultural scientists and later taken over by agricultural economists committed to theory-based economic analysis to enable rational planning and decision making. But in both countries, it became painfully evident to reflective participants that model-based Farm Management was not proving relevant to practical managers of farms. An insightful few went further to conclude not just that theoretical models of practice had not been relevant but that they could not be relevant, and since the late 1970s, the field has been in crisis.

In this series of 2 papers, we seek insights that might explain this extraordinary ‘market’ failure of models that generate theoretical best practice as a basis for intervention. As an ‘experiment’, the history of Farm Management is enriched by the discontinuity between 2 ‘eras’ characterised by 2 contrasting intervention approaches, an ‘early’ interactive and pragmatic era and a ‘late’ academic and theoretical era. In this first paper, after a brief history of the early pragmatic era and the ‘take-over’ by economic theorists, we analyse the ‘crisis of relevance’ that led to demise, relying heavily on the remarkable intellectual journey of John Dillon, the first Professor of Farm Management in Australia who turned from being elder economic theoretician to pioneer philosopher of pragmatic Farming Systems Research.

The significant turn to Farming Systems Research by disillusioned Farm Management economists in the 1980s was preceded by a turn to another systems approach 2 decades earlier, that of agricultural systems modelling. Learning from the autecology of these significant systems efforts to influence the management of farms is the aim of the second paper in this series.


References


Agrawal, RC ,  and  Heady, EO (1972). ‘Operations research methods for agricultural decisions.’ (Iowa State University Press: Ames, IA)

Anderson, JR , Dillon, JL ,  and  Hardaker, JB (1977). ‘Agricultural decision analysis.’ (Iowa State University Press: Ames, IA)

Anon., (2000). ‘History of the organization of work.’ (Encyclopaedia Britannica, Inc.: Chicago, IL)

Carberry PS, Hochman Z, McCown RL, Dalgliesh NP, Foale MA, Poulton PL, Hargreaves JNG, Hargreaves DMG, Cawthray S, Hillcoat N, Robertson MJ (2002) The FARMSCAPE approach to decision support: Farmers’, advisers’, researchers’ monitoring, simulation, communication, and performance evaluation. Agricultural Systems 74, 141–177.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | open url image1

Case, HCM ,  and  Williams, DB (1957). ‘Fifty years of Farm Management.’ (University of Illinois Press: Urbana, IL)

Cyert, RM ,  and  March, JG (1963). ‘A behavioral theory of the Firm.’ (Prentice-Hall: Englewood Cliffs, NJ)

Day RH (1964) Review of a ‘Behavioural Theory of the Firm’ by Cyert and March. Econometrica 32, 461–464. open url image1

Day RH (1971) Rational choice and economic behavior. Theory and Decision 1, 229–251.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | open url image1

Dillon JL (1965) Farm Management in Australia as an academic discipline. Review of Marketing and Agricultural Economics 33, 175–189. open url image1

Dillon JL (1979) An evaluation of the state of affairs in Farm Management. South African Journal of Agricultural Economics 1, 7–13. open url image1

Dorfman R (1953) Mathematical or linear programming: a non-mathematical exposition. The American Economic Review 43, 797–825. open url image1

Dreyfus, HL (1994). ‘What computers still can’t do: a critique of artificial reason.’ (MIT Press: Cambridge, MA)

Heady, EO (1952). ‘Economics of agricultural production and resource use.’ (Prentice Hall: Englewood Cliffs, NJ)

Johnson GL (1963) Stress on production economics. Australian Journal of Agricultural Economics 7, 12–26. open url image1

King M, McAulay L (1991) Barriers to adopting management expert systems: case studies of management accounting applications which failed. Expert Systems 8, 139–147. open url image1

Longworth J, Menz KM (1980) Activity analysis: bridging the gap between production economic theory and practical farm management. Review of Marketing and Agricultural Economics 48, 7–20. open url image1

Malcolm LR (1990) Fifty years of farm management in Australia: survey and review. Review of Marketing and Agricultural Economics 58, 24–55. open url image1

Malcolm L (2000) Farm management economic analysis: A few disciplines, a few perspectives, a few figurings, a few futures. Paper presented at the 44th Annual Conference of the Australian Agricultural and Resource Economics Society, University of Sydney, 23–25 Jan. 2000.


Maxwell JA, Randall A (1989) Ecological economic modelling in a pluralistic, participatory society. Ecological Economics 1, 233–249.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | open url image1

McCown RL (2002a) Changing systems for supporting farmers’ decisions: problems, paradigms, and prospects. Agricultural Systems 74, 179–220.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | open url image1

McCown RL (2002b) Locating agricultural Decision Support Systems in the problematic history and socio-technical complexity of ‘models for management’. Agricultural Systems 74, 11–25.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | open url image1

Moore, WE (1970). ‘The professions: role and rules.’ (Russell Sage Foundation: New York)

Musgrave WF (1976) Problems of change in Australian agricultural economics. Australian Journal of Agricultural Economics 1, 133–143. open url image1

Pannell DJ (1996) Lessons from a decade of whole-farm modelling in Western Australia. Review of Agricultural Economics 18, 373–383. open url image1

Pannell DJ, Malcolm L, Kingswell RS (2000) Are we risking too much? Perspectives on risk in farm modelling. Agricultural Economics 23, 69–78. open url image1

Powell, JM (1973). ‘Yeomen and Bureaucrats, The Victorian Crown Lands Commission 1878–79.’ (Oxford University Press: Melbourne, Vic.)

Rae, AN (1994). ‘Agricultural management economics: activity analysis and decision-making.’ (CAB International Publications: Wallingford, UK)

Rosenhead, J (1989). ‘Rational analysis for a problematic world.’ (John Wiley & Sons: Chichester, UK)

Schon, DA (1983). ‘The reflective practitioner: how professionals think in action.’ (Basic Books: New York)

Schultz TW (1939) Theory of the Firm and Farm Management research. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 21, 570–586. open url image1

Sorensen JT, Kristensen ES (1992) Systemic modelling: A research methodology in livestock farming. ‘Global appraisal of livestock farming systems and study on their organisational levels: concept, methodology and results’. Proceedings of a Symposium organised by the INRA-SAD and the DIRAD-IEMVT, 7–10 July 1990, Toulouse, France. (Ed.  A Gibon , B Matheron ) (Commission of European Communities: Brussels, Belgium)


Spillman WJ (1902) Systems of farm management in the United States. 1902, pp.363.

Taylor, HC ,  and  Taylor, AD (1952). ‘The story of agricultural economics in the United States 1840–1932.’ (Iowa State College Press: Ames, IA)

Taylor, J (1994). ‘Fashioning farmers: ideology, agricultural knowledge and the Manitoba Farm Movement 1890–1925.’ (Canadian Plains Research Centre: University of Regina, Saskatchewan)

Vollmer, HM ,  and  Mills, DM (1966). ‘Professionalization.’ (Prentice-Hall: Englewood Cliffs, NJ)

Wilcox, WW , Johnson, SE ,  and  Warren, SW (1943). ‘Farm Management research 1940–41.’ Committee on Social and Economic Research in Agriculture. (Social Science Research Council: New York)