Modelling of breech strike risk and protective efficacy of mulesing in adult Merino sheep
B. J. Horton A B G , R. Corkrey A C , J. Smith D , J. Greeff E and L. J. E. Karlsson FA CRC for Sheep Industry Innovation, Homestead Building, UNE, Armidale, NSW 2350, Australia.
B Tasmanian Institute of Agriculture, Private Bag 1375, Launceston, Tas. 7250, Australia.
C Tasmanian Institute of Agriculture, University of Tasmania, Hobart, Tas. 7005, Australia.
D CSIRO Agriculture, FD McMaster Laboratory, Chiswick, Locked Bag 1, Armidale, NSW 2350, Australia.
E Livestock Industries, Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development, Western Australia, 3 Baron-Hay Court, South Perth, WA 6151, Australia.
F RMB 314, Bridgetown, WA 6255, Australia.
G Corresponding author. Email: brian.horton@utas.edu.au
Animal Production Science 60(8) 1051-1060 https://doi.org/10.1071/AN18488
Submitted: 7 August 2018 Accepted: 14 October 2019 Published: 13 February 2020
Abstract
Context: Mulesing provides a high degree of protection against beech strike, but wool producers need to be able to predict the level of risk of flystrike if they cease mulesing.
Aims: To use data from trials of mulesed and unmulesed sheep to estimate the distribution of adult breech scores (wrinkle, breech cover and dag) from mean flock values, and use those scores to estimate the risk of breech strike in Merino sheep flocks.
Methods: Breech scores and breech strike from flocks with comparable mulesed and unmulesed sheep were examined using logistic functions to relate breech scores in mulesed sheep to those in unmulesed sheep, and to estimate the risk of breech strike in sheep for any given combination of breech scores.
Key results: Functions are given to estimate whole flock adult breech wrinkle and breech cover using combinations of the breech traits that are available. Unmulesed Merino sheep have a 6-fold increased risk of breech strike compared with mulesed sheep under the same conditions. There were increased relative risks of breech strike of 2.0 for each unit increase in dag score, 2.2 for each unit increase in breech wrinkle score and 1.7 for each unit increase in breech cover score. Mulesing reduced each of these risk factors, but had an additional 3.2-fold benefit independent of these factors. Adult breech wrinkle was most reliably estimated from neck wrinkle or from marking breech wrinkle (before mulesing). Breech cover was estimated from face cover, or from marking breech cover. The risk of breech strike if adult sheep were to be left unmulesed in a commercial flock was predicted using a centred log ratio transformation to estimate the distribution of dag scores in the unmulesed sheep, given the actual distribution in the mulesed flock. If the distribution was not known, then the mean dag score of the mulesed sheep could be used to estimate the distribution of dag scores in unmulesed sheep using a 2/3 power function to transform the mean dag score.
Conclusions: A flock of unmulesed sheep would need to lower breech wrinkle, breech cover and dag scores by 0.5 for each score to achieve a comparable level of risk of breech strike in mulesed sheep.
Implications: The use of the model will allow wool producers to selectively breed for sheep with lower risk of breech strike, while continuing to mules the sheep as long as it is necessary to do so. They will be able to estimate what the risk of strike would be if they cease mulesing, due to the proportion of sheep with potentially high wrinkle score, high breech cover or high dag scores at any stage of their breeding program.
Additional keywords: breech wrinkle, breech cover, breeding, dags.
References
Aitchison J (1986) ‘The statistical analysis of compositional data.’ (Chapman & Hall Ltd: London)Australian Wool Innovation (2007) Visual sheep scores. (Australian Wool Innovation and Meat & Livestock Australia. Available at https://www.wool.com/on-farm-research-and-development/sheep-health-welfare-and-productivity/sheep-breeding/visual-sheep-scores/ [Verified 18 July 2019]
Brown DJ, Swan AA, Gill JS (2010) Within- and across-flock genetic relationships for breech flystrike resistance indicator traits. Animal Production Science 50, 1060–1068.
| Within- and across-flock genetic relationships for breech flystrike resistance indicator traits.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Greeff J, Karlsson J (2009a) Incorporating breech strike resistance into your ram selection program: how to use the data effectively, what genetic progress you can expect to make. In ‘Sheep updates 2009. Perth, WA’. (Ed. S White) (Department of Agriculture and Food: Perth, WA)
Greeff JC, Karlsson LJE (2009b) Opportunities to breed for resistance to breech strike in merino sheep in a Mediterranean environment. Proceedings of the Association for the Advancement of Animal Breeding and Genetics 18, 272–278.
Greeff J, Karlsson LJE, Schlink AC, Underwood N, Stanwyck N, Lindon G (2010) Identifying indicator traits that can be used to breed for breech strike resistance. In ‘National R&D technical update. Sydney, June 2010’. (Australian Wool Innovation: Sydney, NSW).
Greeff JC, Karlsson LJE, Schlink AC (2014) Identifying indicator traits for breech strike in Merino sheep in a Mediterranean environment. Animal Production Science 54, 125–140.
| Identifying indicator traits for breech strike in Merino sheep in a Mediterranean environment.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Hansford K (2018) National wool declaration (NWD) update. In ‘Breech flystrike RD&E technical update. Sydney’. (Australian Wool Innovation: Sydney, NSW).
Hatcher S, Preston JWV (2015) Genetic parameters for breech cover, wrinkle and wool coverage scores and their implications for Merino sheep breeding programs and flock management. Small Ruminant Research 130, 36–46.
| Genetic parameters for breech cover, wrinkle and wool coverage scores and their implications for Merino sheep breeding programs and flock management.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Horton B (2013) A method for estimating the economic value of changes in the risk of breech strike. Animal Production Science 53, 1126–1133.
| A method for estimating the economic value of changes in the risk of breech strike.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Horton B, Hogan L (2010) FlyBoss: a web-based flystrike information and decision support system. Animal Production Science 50, 1069–1076.
| FlyBoss: a web-based flystrike information and decision support system.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Horton BJ, Iles L (2007) Dag scores and mean crutching period for mulesed and unmulesed weaners. International Journal of Sheep and Wool Science 55, 48–64.
James PJ (2006) Genetic alternatives to Mulesing and tail docking in sheep: a review. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 46, 1–18.
| Genetic alternatives to Mulesing and tail docking in sheep: a review.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Kahn LP, Johnson IR, Rowe JB, Hogan L, Boshoff J (2017) ASKBILL as a web-based program to enhance sheep well-being and productivity. Animal Production Science 57, 2257–2262.
| ASKBILL as a web-based program to enhance sheep well-being and productivity.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Larsen JWA, Anderson N (2000) The relationship between the rate of intake of trichostrongylid larvae and the occurrence of diarrhoea and breech soiling in adult Merino sheep. Australian Veterinary Journal 78, 112–116.
| The relationship between the rate of intake of trichostrongylid larvae and the occurrence of diarrhoea and breech soiling in adult Merino sheep.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Larsen JWA, Tyrell LD, Anderson N (2012) Prevalence of breech-strike in mulesed, clipped and unmulesed Merino hoggets in south-eastern Australia. Australian Veterinary Journal 90, 158–166.
| Prevalence of breech-strike in mulesed, clipped and unmulesed Merino hoggets in south-eastern Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Lewer RP, Woolaston RR, Howe RR (1995) Studies on Western Australian Merino sheep. III. Genetic and phenotypic parameter estimates for subjectively assessed and objectively measured traits in ewe hoggets. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research 46, 379–388.
| Studies on Western Australian Merino sheep. III. Genetic and phenotypic parameter estimates for subjectively assessed and objectively measured traits in ewe hoggets.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Morley FHW, Johnstone IL (1983) Mules operation – a review of development and adoption. In ‘Sheep blowfly and flystrike in sheep. Proceedings of the Second National Symposium. University of New South Wales’. (Ed. HW Raadsma) pp. 3–24. (Department of Agriculture New South Wales: Sydney, New South Wales)
Phillips CJC (2009) A review of mulesing and other methods to control flystrike (cutaneous myiasis) in sheep. Animal Welfare 18, 113–121.
Reid RND, Jones AL (1976) The effectiveness of mulesing in flystrike control in Corriedale and crossbred sheep in Tasmania. Proceedings of the Australian Society for Animal Production 11, 185–188.
Richards JS, Atkins KD (2010) Will genetics offer a permanent solution to breech strike? Animal Production Science 50, 1053–1059.
| Will genetics offer a permanent solution to breech strike?Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Rubin DB (1976) Inference and missing data (with discussion). Biometrika 63, 581–592.
| Inference and missing data (with discussion).Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Rubin DB (1987) ‘Multiple imputation for nonresponse in surveys.’ (John Wiley & Sons Inc.: New York)
Scholtz AJ, Cloete SWP, van Wyk JB, Misztal I, du Toit E, van der Linde T, Cde K (2010) Genetic (co)variances between wrinkle score and absence of breech strike in mulesed and unmulesed Merino sheep, using a threshold model. Animal Production Science 50, 210–218.
| Genetic (co)variances between wrinkle score and absence of breech strike in mulesed and unmulesed Merino sheep, using a threshold model.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Scobie DR, O’Connell D, Morris CA, Hickey SM (2008) Dag score is negatively correlated with breech bareness score of sheep. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 48, 999–1003.
| Dag score is negatively correlated with breech bareness score of sheep.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Seddon HR (1931) Conditions which predispose sheep to blowfly attack. Agricultural Gazette of New South Wales 42, 581–594.
Smith J (2010) Breeding for breech flystrike resistance – project results update. In ‘National R&D technical update. (Australian Wool Innovation, Sydney, NSW). Available at https://www.wool.com/on-farm-research-and-development/sheep-health-welfare-and-productivity/sheep-health/breech-flystrike/randd-update/ [Verified 22 January 2020]
Smith JL, Brewer HG, Dyall T (2009) Heritability and phenotypic correlations for breech strike and breech strike resistance indicators in Merinos. In ‘Proceedings of the Association for Advancement of Animal Breeding and Genetics. Vol.18 pp. 334–337. (Association for the Advancement of Animal Breeding and Genetics: Roseworthy, South Australia, Australia)
Smith JE, Woodgate RG, Curnow CA, Michael DL (2010) Influence of dag score and breech wrinkle score on the time taken to crutch unmulesed Merino sheep. Animal Production Science 50, 608–610.
| Influence of dag score and breech wrinkle score on the time taken to crutch unmulesed Merino sheep.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Stokes ME, Davis CS, Koch GG (2000) ‘Categorical data analysis using the SAS system.’ 2nd edn. (SAS Institute Inc.: Cary, NC USA)
Tyrell LD, Larsen JWA, Anderson N (2014) Breech-strike on mulesed, clipped and unmulesed Merino ewes and hoggets in south-eastern Australia. Australian Veterinary Journal 92, 348–356.
| Breech-strike on mulesed, clipped and unmulesed Merino ewes and hoggets in south-eastern Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 25156054PubMed |
van den Boogaart KG, Tolosna R, Bren M (2010) ‘Compositions: compositional data analysis, 2010.’ R package ver. 1.10-1. Available at http://CRAN.R-project.org/package=compositions [Verified 22 January 2020]
Wardhaugh KG, Vogt WG, Dallwitz R, Woodburn TL (1989) The incidence of flystrike in relation to sheep susceptibility and the abundance of the blowfly, Lucilia cuprina (Wiedemann) (Diptera: Calliphoridae). General and Applied Entomology 21, 11–16.
Watts JE, Dash KM, Lisle KA (1978) The effect of anthelmintic treatment and other management factors on the incidence of breech strike in Merino sheep. Australian Veterinary Journal 54, 352–355.
| The effect of anthelmintic treatment and other management factors on the incidence of breech strike in Merino sheep.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 708333PubMed |
