The importance of selection and reporting of the sex of experimental animals
Anthony Rowe
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations
CSIRO Science Impact and Policy, PO Box 93, North Ryde, NSW 1670, Australia. Email: Anthony.Rowe@csiro.au
Animal Production Science 59(3) 401-407 https://doi.org/10.1071/AN18032
Submitted: 15 January 2018 Accepted: 24 June 2018 Published: 20 August 2018
Abstract
Biased use of males and females in animal studies or omitting specific details of the sex of animals used in publications limits reproducibility, hampers the pace and likelihood of new discoveries and invites adverse events in ensuing clinical research. Hence unbiased use of males and females in animal studies and specific reporting of animal details are increasingly required by funding bodies and scientific journals worldwide. An analysis to determine how males and females are used in animal studies involving the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO) was undertaken as part of a process to review and further support best practice. In the study 178 publications that contain animal studies and include CSIRO researchers published between January 2014 and December 2016 were analysed for the sex of animals used. The overall sex distribution was males only 26.4% (47/178), females only 15.7% (28/178), males and females 18.0% (32/178) and sex of animals unspecified 39.9% (71/178). Reasons for this distribution include species biology, farming practices and commercial relevance. Although including sex as an experimental variable provides the most information, using both sexes in an animal study requires careful consideration and planning. Furthermore, there are valid biological and experimental reasons why sex distribution in a study may not be balanced. Biological reasons include cases where the severity of disease in a given model differs between males and females, superior husbandry or production traits in one sex and hermaphroditic species that change sex with age. Examples where experiments can only be undertaken in one sex of animal include animal models of female breast cancer, female reproductive traits, male fertility studies and post-castration welfare outcomes. Where there is no biological or experimental reason for using a single sex of animal, future studies should obtain an estimate of sex effect either from the literature or with a pilot study, and experiments should be planned and reported accordingly.
Additional keywords: bias, female, male, reproducibility.
References
Baker D, Lidster K, Sottomayor A, Amor S (2014) Two years later: journals are not yet enforcing the ARRIVE guidelines on reporting standards for pre-clinical animal studies. PLoS Biology 12,| Two years later: journals are not yet enforcing the ARRIVE guidelines on reporting standards for pre-clinical animal studies.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Bara M, Joffe AR (2014) The methodological quality of animal research in critical care: the public face of science. Annals of Intensive Care 4, 26
| The methodological quality of animal research in critical care: the public face of science.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Becker JB, Arnold AP, Berkley KJ, Blaustein JD, Eckel LA, Hampson E, Herman JP, Marts S, Sadee W, Steiner M, Taylor J, Young E (2005) Strategies and methods for research on sex differences in brain and behavior. Endocrinology 146, 1650–1673.
| Strategies and methods for research on sex differences in brain and behavior.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Becker JB, Prendergast BJ, Liang JW (2016) Female rats are not more variable than male rats: a meta-analysis of neuroscience studies. Biology of Sex Differences 7, 34
| Female rats are not more variable than male rats: a meta-analysis of neuroscience studies.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Beery AK, Zucker I (2011) Sex bias in neuroscience and biomedical research. Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews 35, 565–572.
| Sex bias in neuroscience and biomedical research.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Bingham J, Payne J, Harper J, Frazer L, Eastwood S, Wilson S, Lowther S, Lunt R, Warner S, Carr M, Hall RA, Durr PA (2014) Evaluation of a mouse model for the West Nile virus group for the purpose of determining viral pathotypes. The Journal of General Virology 95, 1221–1232.
| Evaluation of a mouse model for the West Nile virus group for the purpose of determining viral pathotypes.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Bolormaa S, Pryce JE, Zhang Y, Reverter A, Barendse W, Hayes BJ, Goddard ME (2015) Non-additive genetic variation in growth, carcass and fertility traits of beef cattle. Genetics, Selection, Evolution. 47, 26
| Non-additive genetic variation in growth, carcass and fertility traits of beef cattle.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Bramhall M, Flórez-Vargas O, Stevens R, Brass A, Cruickshank S (2015) Quality of methods reporting in animal models of colitis. Inflammatory Bowel Diseases 21, 1248–1259.
Cao B, Hutt OE, Zhang Z, Li S, Heazlewood SY, Williams B, Smith JA, Haylock DN, Savage GP, Nilsson SK (2014) Design, synthesis and binding properties of a fluorescent α9β1/α4β1 integrin antagonist and its application as an in vivo probe for bone marrow haemopoietic stem cells. Organic & Biomolecular Chemistry 12, 965–978.
| Design, synthesis and binding properties of a fluorescent α9β1/α4β1 integrin antagonist and its application as an in vivo probe for bone marrow haemopoietic stem cells.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Charmley E, Williams SRO, Moate PJ, Hegarty RS, Herd RM, Oddy VH, Reyenga P, Staunton KM, Anderson A, Hannah MC (2016) A universal equation to predict methane production of forage-fed cattle in Australia. Animal Production Science 56, 169–180.
| A universal equation to predict methane production of forage-fed cattle in Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Clayton JA, Collins FS (2014) NIH to balance sex in cell and animal studies. Nature 509, 282–283.
| NIH to balance sex in cell and animal studies.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Collins FS, Tabak LA (2014) NIH plans to enhance reproducibility. Nature 505, 612–613.
| NIH plans to enhance reproducibility.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Cornelison TL, Clayton JA (2017) Considering sex as a biological variable in biomedical research. Gender and the Genome 1, 89–93.
| Considering sex as a biological variable in biomedical research.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Dove H, Kelman WM (2015) Liveweight gains of young sheep grazing dual-purpose wheat with sodium and magnesium supplied as direct supplement, or with magnesium supplied as fertiliser. Animal Production Science 55, 1217–1229.
| Liveweight gains of young sheep grazing dual-purpose wheat with sodium and magnesium supplied as direct supplement, or with magnesium supplied as fertiliser.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Du S, Itoh N, Askarinam S, Hill H, Arnold AP, Voskuhl RR (2014) XY sex chromosome complement, compared with XX, in the CNS confers greater neurodegeneration during experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 111, 2806–2811.
| XY sex chromosome complement, compared with XX, in the CNS confers greater neurodegeneration during experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Edenborough KM, Lowther S, Laurie K, Yamada M, Long F, Bingham J, Payne J, Harper J, Haining J, Arkinstall R, Gilbertson B, Middleton D, Brown LE (2016) Predicting disease severity and viral spread of H5N1 influenza virus in ferrets in the context of natural exposure routes. Journal of Virology 90, 1888–1897.
| Predicting disease severity and viral spread of H5N1 influenza virus in ferrets in the context of natural exposure routes.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Flórez-Vargas O, Bramhall M, Noyes H, Cruickshank S, Stevens R, Brass A (2014) The quality of methods reporting in parasitology experiments. PLoS One 9,
| The quality of methods reporting in parasitology experiments.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Flórez-Vargas O, Brass A, Karystianis G, Bramhall M, Stevens R, Cruickshank S, Nenadic G (2016) Bias in the reporting of sex and age in biomedical research on mouse models. eLife 5,
| Bias in the reporting of sex and age in biomedical research on mouse models.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Gochfeld M (2017) Sex differences in human and animal toxicology. Toxicologic Pathology 45, 172–189.
| Sex differences in human and animal toxicology.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Groves NJ, Bradford D, Sullivan RKP, Conn K-A, Aljelaify RF, McGrath JJ, Burne THJ (2016) Behavioural effects of adult vitamin D deficiency in BALB/c mice are not associated with proliferation or survival of neurons in the adult hippocampus. PLoS One 11,
| Behavioural effects of adult vitamin D deficiency in BALB/c mice are not associated with proliferation or survival of neurons in the adult hippocampus.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Gulin JEN, Rocco DM, García-Bournissen F (2015) Quality of reporting and adherence to ARRIVE guidelines in animal studies for Chagas Disease preclinical drug research: a systematic review. PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases 9,
| Quality of reporting and adherence to ARRIVE guidelines in animal studies for Chagas Disease preclinical drug research: a systematic review.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Jilka RL (2016) The road to reproducibility in animal research. Journal of Bone and Mineral Research 31, 1317–1319.
| The road to reproducibility in animal research.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Kilkenny C, Parsons N, Kadyszewski E, Festing MFW, Cuthill IC, Fry D, Hutton J, Altman DG (2009) Survey of the quality of experimental design, statistical analysis and reporting of research using animals. PLoS One 4,
| Survey of the quality of experimental design, statistical analysis and reporting of research using animals.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Kilkenny C, Browne WJ, Cuthill IC, Emerson M, Altman DG (2010) Improving bioscience research reporting: the ARRIVE guidelines for reporting animal research. PLoS Biology 8,
| Improving bioscience research reporting: the ARRIVE guidelines for reporting animal research.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Kim AM, Tingen CM, Woodruff TK (2010) Sex bias in trials and treatment must end. Nature 465, 688–689.
| Sex bias in trials and treatment must end.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Klein SL, Schiebinger L, Stefanick ML, Cahill L, Danska J, de Vries GJ, Kibbe MR, McCarthy MM, Mogil JS, Woodruff TK, Zucker I (2015) Opinion: sex inclusion in basic research drives discovery. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 112, 5257–5258.
| Opinion: sex inclusion in basic research drives discovery.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Koch-Henriksen N, Sørensen PS (2010) The changing demographic pattern of multiple sclerosis epidemiology. Lancet Neurology 9, 520–532.
| The changing demographic pattern of multiple sclerosis epidemiology.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Kroon FJ, Hook SE, Jones D, Metcalfe S, Henderson B, Smith R, Warne MSJ, Turner RD, McKeown A, Westcott DA (2015) Altered transcription levels of endocrine associated genes in two fisheries species collected from the Great Barrier Reef catchment and lagoon. Marine Environmental Research 104, 51–61.
| Altered transcription levels of endocrine associated genes in two fisheries species collected from the Great Barrier Reef catchment and lagoon.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Lubieniecki KP, Botwright NA, Taylor RS, Evans BS, Cook MT, Davidson WS (2015) Expression analysis of sex-determining pathway genes during development in male and female Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar). Physiological Genomics 47, 581–587.
| Expression analysis of sex-determining pathway genes during development in male and female Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar).Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Lyons RE, Loan NT, Dierens L, Fortes MRS, Kelly M, McWilliam SS, Li Y, Bunch RJ, Harrison BE, Barendse W, Lehnert SA, Moore SS (2014) Evidence for positive selection of taurine genes within a QTL region on chromosome X associated with testicular size in Australian Brahman cattle. BMC Genetics 15, 6
| Evidence for positive selection of taurine genes within a QTL region on chromosome X associated with testicular size in Australian Brahman cattle.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
McCullough LD, de Vries GJ, Miller VM, Becker JB, Sandberg K, McCarthy MM (2014) NIH initiative to balance sex of animals in preclinical studies: generative questions to guide policy, implementation, and metrics. Biology of Sex Differences 5, 15–15.
| NIH initiative to balance sex of animals in preclinical studies: generative questions to guide policy, implementation, and metrics.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Megat S, Shiers S, Moy JK, Barragan-Iglesias P, Pradhan G, Seal RP, Dussor G, Price TJ (2018) A critical role for dopamine D5 receptors in pain chronicity in male mice. The Journal of Neuroscience 38, 379–397.
| A critical role for dopamine D5 receptors in pain chronicity in male mice.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
National Health and Medical Research Council (2017) Best practice methodology in the use of animals for scientific purposes. Available at https://www.nhmrc.gov.au/guidelines-publications/ea20 [Verified 15 December 2017]
National Institutes of Health (2015) Consideration of sex as a biological variable in NIH-funded research. Available at https://grants.nih.gov/grants/guide/notice-files/NOT-OD-15-102.html [Verified 26 April 2017]
Ovseiko PV, Greenhalgh T, Adam P, Grant J, Hinrichs-Krapels S, Graham KE, Valentine PA, Sued O, Boukhris OF, Al Olaqi NM, Al Rahbi IS, Dowd A-M, Bice S, Heiden TL, Fischer MD, Dopson S, Norton R, Pollitt A, Wooding S, Balling GV, Jakobsen U, Kuhlmann E, Klinge I, Pololi LH, Jagsi R, Smith HL, Etzkowitz H, Nielsen MW, Carrion C, Solans‐Domènech M, Vizcaino E, Naing L, Cheok QHN, Eckelmann B, Simuyemba MC, Msiska T, Declich G, Edmunds LD, Kiparoglou V, Buchan AMJ, Williamson C, Lord GM, Channon KM, Surender R, Buchan AM (2016) A global call for action to include gender in research impact assessment. Health Research Policy and Systems 14, 50
| A global call for action to include gender in research impact assessment.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Petherick JC, Small AH, Reid DJ, Colditz IG, Ferguson DM (2015) Welfare outcomes for 3- and 6-month-old beef calves in a tropical environment castrated surgically or by applying rubber rings. Applied Animal Behaviour Science 171, 47–57.
| Welfare outcomes for 3- and 6-month-old beef calves in a tropical environment castrated surgically or by applying rubber rings.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Picciotto M (2017) Reporting on experimental design and statistical analysis. The Journal of Neuroscience 37, 3737
| Reporting on experimental design and statistical analysis.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Piferrer F, Beaumont A, Falguière J-C, Flajšhans M, Haffray P, Colombo L (2009) Polyploid fish and shellfish: production, biology and applications to aquaculture for performance improvement and genetic containment. Aquaculture 293, 125–156.
| Polyploid fish and shellfish: production, biology and applications to aquaculture for performance improvement and genetic containment.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Porto-Neto LR, Barendse W, Henshall JM, McWilliam SM, Lehnert SA, Reverter A (2015) Genomic correlation: harnessing the benefit of combining two unrelated populations for genomic selection. Genetics, Selection, Evolution. 47, 84
| Genomic correlation: harnessing the benefit of combining two unrelated populations for genomic selection.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Prendergast BJ, Onishi KG, Zucker I (2014) Female mice liberated for inclusion in neuroscience and biomedical research. Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews 40, 1–5.
| Female mice liberated for inclusion in neuroscience and biomedical research.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Rahn EJ, Iannitti T, Donahue RR, Taylor BK (2014) Sex differences in a mouse model of multiple sclerosis: neuropathic pain behavior in females but not males and protection from neurological deficits during proestrus. Biology of Sex Differences 5, 4
| Sex differences in a mouse model of multiple sclerosis: neuropathic pain behavior in females but not males and protection from neurological deficits during proestrus.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Riederer BM (2015) When sex matters in biomedical research. Laboratory Animals 49, 265–266.
| When sex matters in biomedical research.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Ritz SA, Antle DM, Côté J, Deroy K, Fraleigh N, Messing K, Parent L, St-Pierre J, Vaillancourt C, Mergler D (2014) First steps for integrating sex and gender considerations into basic experimental biomedical research. The FASEB Journal 28, 4–13.
| First steps for integrating sex and gender considerations into basic experimental biomedical research.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Sharma S, McDonald I, Miller L, Hinds LA (2014) Parenteral administration of GnRH constructs and adjuvants: Immune responses and effects on reproductive tissues of male mice. Vaccine 32, 5555–5563.
| Parenteral administration of GnRH constructs and adjuvants: Immune responses and effects on reproductive tissues of male mice.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Smarr BL, Grant AD, Zucker I, Prendergast BJ, Kriegsfeld LJ (2017) Sex differences in variability across timescales in BALB/c mice. Biology of Sex Differences 8, 7
| Sex differences in variability across timescales in BALB/c mice.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Smith JA, Birke L, Sadler D (1997) Reporting animal use in scientific papers. Laboratory Animals 31, 312–317.
| Reporting animal use in scientific papers.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Sorge RE, Martin LJ, Isbester KA, Sotocinal SG, Rosen S, Tuttle AH, Wieskopf JS, Acland EL, Dokova A, Kadoura B, Leger P, Mapplebeck JCS, McPhail M, Delaney A, Wigerblad G, Schumann AP, Quinn T, Frasnelli J, Svensson CI, Sternberg WF, Mogil JS (2014) Olfactory exposure to males, including men, causes stress and related analgesia in rodents. Nature Methods 11, 629–632.
| Olfactory exposure to males, including men, causes stress and related analgesia in rodents.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Sorge RE, Mapplebeck JCS, Rosen S, Beggs S, Taves S, Alexander JK, Martin LJ, Austin J-S, Sotocinal SG, Chen D, Yang M, Shi XQ, Huang H, Pillon NJ, Bilan PJ, Tu Y, Klip A, Ji R-R, Zhang J, Salter MW, Mogil JS (2015) Different immune cells mediate mechanical pain hypersensitivity in male and female mice. Nature Neuroscience 18, 1081–1083.
| Different immune cells mediate mechanical pain hypersensitivity in male and female mice.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Ting KHJ, Hill CL, Whittle SL (2015) Quality of reporting of interventional animal studies in rheumatology: a systematic review using the ARRIVE guidelines. International Journal of Rheumatic Diseases 18, 488–494.
| Quality of reporting of interventional animal studies in rheumatology: a systematic review using the ARRIVE guidelines.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Ulrich D, Edwards SL, Su K, White JF, Ramshaw JAM, Jenkin G, Deprest J, Rosamilia A, Werkmeister JA, Gargett CE (2014) Influence of reproductive status on tissue composition and biomechanical properties of ovine vagina. PLoS One 9,
| Influence of reproductive status on tissue composition and biomechanical properties of ovine vagina.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Vaithilingam V, Kollarikova G, Qi M, Larsson R, Lacik I, Formo K, Marchese E, Oberholzer J, Guillemin GJ, Tuch BE (2014) Beneficial effects of coating alginate microcapsules with macromolecular heparin conjugates – in vitro and in vivo study. Tissue Engineering. Part A 20, 324–334.
| Beneficial effects of coating alginate microcapsules with macromolecular heparin conjugates – in vitro and in vivo study.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Voskuhl RR, Gold SM (2012) Sex-related factors in multiple sclerosis susceptibility and progression. Nature Reviews. Neurology 8, 255–263.
| Sex-related factors in multiple sclerosis susceptibility and progression.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Wald C, Wu C (2010) Of mice and women: the bias in animal models. Science 327, 1571
| Of mice and women: the bias in animal models.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Wang T, Gantier MP, Xiang D, Bean AG, Bruce M, Zhou S-F, Khasraw M, Ward A, Wang L, Wei MQ, AlShamaileh H, Chen L, She X, Lin J, Kong L, Shigdar S, Duan W (2015) EpCAM aptamer-mediated survivin silencing sensitized cancer stem cells to doxorubicin in a breast cancer model. Theranostics 5, 1456–1472.
| EpCAM aptamer-mediated survivin silencing sensitized cancer stem cells to doxorubicin in a breast cancer model.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Warner RD, Dunshea FR, Gutzke D, Lau J, Kearney G (2014) Factors influencing the incidence of high rigor temperature in beef carcasses in Australia. Animal Production Science 54, 363–374.
| Factors influencing the incidence of high rigor temperature in beef carcasses in Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Yu Y, Chen J, Li D, Wang L, Wang W, Liu H (2016) Systematic analysis of adverse event reports for sex differences in adverse drug events. Scientific Reports 6, 24955
| Systematic analysis of adverse event reports for sex differences in adverse drug events.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Yue GH, Xia JH, Liu F, Lin G (2012) Evidence for female-biased dispersal in the protandrous hermaphroditic asian seabass, Lates calcarifer. PLoS One 7,
| Evidence for female-biased dispersal in the protandrous hermaphroditic asian seabass, Lates calcarifer.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Zarkasi KZ, Taylor RS, Abell GCJ, Tamplin ML, Glencross BD, Bowman JP (2016) Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar L.) gastrointestinal microbial community dynamics in relation to digesta properties and diet. Microbial Ecology 71, 589–603.
| Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar L.) gastrointestinal microbial community dynamics in relation to digesta properties and diet.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Zucker I, Beery AK (2010) Males still dominate animal studies. Nature 465, 690
| Males still dominate animal studies.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
