Assessing the profitability of native pasture grazing systems: a stochastic whole-farm modelling approach
Martin R. Amidy A D , Karl Behrendt B and Warwick B. Badgery C
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations
A Fenner School of Environment and Society, Australian National University, Acton, ACT 2601, Australia.
B Graham Centre for Agricultural Innovation (Charles Sturt University and NSW Department of Primary Industries), Charles Sturt University, Orange, NSW 2800, Australia.
C NSW Department of Primary Industries, Orange Agricultural Institute, 1447 Forest Road, Orange, NSW 2800, Australia.
D Corresponding author. Email: martin.amidy@anu.edu.au
Animal Production Science 57(9) 1859-1868 https://doi.org/10.1071/AN16678
Submitted: 18 October 2016 Accepted: 6 June 2017 Published: 28 July 2017
Abstract
Grazing enterprises on the Central Tablelands of New South Wales employ a range of different strategies to manage temperate native grassland pastures common in the high rainfall zone of southern Australia. This paper uses a stochastic whole-farm simulation modelling approach to assess the impact of grazing system and stocking rate (SR) on the long-term profitability of a representative case-study enterprise. In particular, the impact of infrastructure costs, debt and downside risk, on whole-farm performance are examined over a 10-year planning horizon. In total, 12 different strategies were modelled under both price and climate risk, with a matrix of three paddock systems (1-paddock, 4-paddock and 20-paddock rotations) and four stocking rates (SR of 3, 4.2, 5.3 and 7 ewes/ha). Profitability was primarily driven by SR. In general, higher SR increased total farm output and annual profits under favourable conditions, although they were also associated with higher costs and greater downside risk in poor seasons, which in turn was magnified by the compounding effect of accumulating debt over time. When SR increased above 4.2 ewes/ha, it had a negative impact on lamb sale weights, resulting in lower prices due to lambs not meeting the ≥40-kg liveweight specification. Although this was offset by increased whole-farm production volumes at 5.3 ewes/ha, declines in profitability occurred at 7 ewes/ha as a result of significant increases in supplement feeding costs, and lambs not meeting sale weight specifications. The analytical scale of the analysis also had an impact on the relative profitability between alternative treatments. When assessed using a partial measure of economic analysis (gross margin per ha), there was little difference between paddock system treatments at the same SR. When the cost of additional fencing and water infrastructure were accounted for at the whole-farm analytical scale, the 20 paddock system was markedly less profitable than the 1- and 4-paddock rotations. This highlights the need for assessing production systems at an appropriate analytical and temporal scale to better understand the relationship between the key drivers of long-term profitability and risk. Overall there were relatively small differences in whole-farm performance between the four best performing strategies in this study. Given the trade-offs between profitability, downside risk, ground cover and feedbase sustainability, the lower risk 1- and 4-paddock systems with a SR of 4.2 ewes/ha are proposed as being optimal.
Additional keywords: financial analysis, price risk, stocking rate.
References
ABARES (2012) ‘Australian commodity statistics 2012.’ (Australian Bureau of Agricultural and Resource Economics and Sciences: Canberra)ABARES (2014) ‘Australian farm survey results 2011–12 to 2013–14.’ (Australian Bureau of Agricultural and Resource Economics and Sciences: Canberra)
Allan CJ, Mason WK, Reeve IJ, Hooper S (2003) Evaluation of the impact of SGS on livestock producers and their practices. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 43, 1031–1040.
| Evaluation of the impact of SGS on livestock producers and their practices.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Armstrong DP, Tarrant KA, Ho CKM, Malcolm M, Wales WJ (2010) Evaluating development options for a rain-fed dairy farm in Gippsland. Animal Production Science 50, 363–370.
| Evaluating development options for a rain-fed dairy farm in Gippsland.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
AWEX (2012) Weekly MPG indicators, Australian Wool Exchange, various issues. (Australian Wool Exchange)
Badgery WB, Cranney P, Millar GD, Mitchell D, Behrendt K (2012) Intensive rotational grazing can improve profitability and environmental outcomes. In ‘Proceedings of the 27th annual conference of the Grassland Society of NSW, Wagga Wagga’. (Eds C Harris, G Lodge, C Waters) pp. 85–91. (The Grassland Society of NSW: Orange)
Badgery WB, Mitchell D, Millar GD, Broadfoot K, Michalk DL, Cranney P, Brown W (2017a) Designing a grazing-system experiment for variable native pastures and flexible lamb-production systems. Animal Production Science 57, 1785–1798.
| Designing a grazing-system experiment for variable native pastures and flexible lamb-production systems.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Badgery WB, Millar GD, Broadfoot K, Michalk DL, Cranney P, Mitchell D, van de Ven R (2017b) Increased production and cover in a variable native pasture following intensive grazing management. Animal Production Science 57, 1812–1823.
| Increased production and cover in a variable native pasture following intensive grazing management.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Badgery WB, Millar GD, Michalk DL, Cranney P, Broadfoot K (2017c) The intensity of grazing management influences lamb production from native grassland. Animal Production Science 57, 1837–1848.
| The intensity of grazing management influences lamb production from native grassland.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Behrendt K (2014) Price risk exposure of Australian Merinos – is it in the bloodline? Animal Production Science 54, 1317–1322.
| Price risk exposure of Australian Merinos – is it in the bloodline?Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Behrendt K, Eppleston J (2011) Threats, realises and opportunities of grassland farming in the central Tablelands. In ‘Proceedings of the 26th annual conference of the Grassland Society of NSW’, Bathurst. (Eds G Lodge, W Wheatley, J Scott) pp. 12–22. (The Grassland Society of NSW: Orange)
Behrendt K, Cacho O, Scott JM, Jones R (2013a) Optimising pasture and grazing management decisions on the Cicerone Project farmlets over variable time horizons. Animal Production Science 53, 796–805.
| Optimising pasture and grazing management decisions on the Cicerone Project farmlets over variable time horizons.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Behrendt K, Malcolm B, Jackson T (2013b) Beef business management. In ‘Beef cattle production and trade’. (Eds DJ Cottle, L Kahn) pp. 493–514. (CSIRO Publishing: Melbourne)
Behrendt K, Scott JM, Mackay DF, Murison R (2013c) Comparing the climate experienced during the Cicerone farmlet experiment against the climatic record. Animal Production Science 53, 658–669.
| Comparing the climate experienced during the Cicerone farmlet experiment against the climatic record.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Behrendt K, Scott JM, Cacho O, Jones R (2013d) Simulating the impact of fertiliser strategies and price on the economics of developing and managing the Cicerone Project farmlets under climatic uncertainty. Animal Production Science 53, 806–816.
| Simulating the impact of fertiliser strategies and price on the economics of developing and managing the Cicerone Project farmlets under climatic uncertainty.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Behrendt K, Cacho O, Scott JM, Jones R (2016) Using seasonal stochastic dynamic programming to identify optimal management decisions that achieve maximum economic sustainable yields from grasslands under climate risk. Agricultural Systems 145, 13–23.
| Using seasonal stochastic dynamic programming to identify optimal management decisions that achieve maximum economic sustainable yields from grasslands under climate risk.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Broadfoot KM, Badgery WB, Millar GD (2017) Post-experimental modelling of grazing systems to improve profit and environmental outcomes using AusFarm. Animal Production Science 57, 1849–1858.
| Post-experimental modelling of grazing systems to improve profit and environmental outcomes using AusFarm.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Carroll M (2003) Farm performance from a wealth creation perspective. In ‘ABARE – Outlook 2003: gateway to rural and regional business, 4–5 March, Canberra. (Australian Bureau of Agricultural and Resource Economics)
Cottle D, Eckard R, Bray S, Sullivan M (2016) An evaluation of carbon offset supplementation options for beef production in systems on coastal speargrass in central Queensland, Australia. Animal Production Science 56, 385–392.
| An evaluation of carbon offset supplementation options for beef production in systems on coastal speargrass in central Queensland, Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC28Xis1amu7w%3D&md5=644bc22a2efa6694299c6d70015431f3CAS |
Counsell DJ (2002) Review of the sale performance of individual wool clips against regional Australian Wool Exchange micron price guides. Wool Technology and Sheep Breeding 50, 208–214.
CSIRO (2007) ‘AusFarm.’ (CSIRO Plant Industry: Canberra)
Dowling PM, Kemp DR, Ball PD, Langford CM, Michalk DL, Millar GD, Simpson PC, Thompson RP (2005) Effect of continuous and time-control grazing on grassland components in south-eastern Australia. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 45, 369–382.
| Effect of continuous and time-control grazing on grassland components in south-eastern Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Garden DL, Dowling PM, Eddy DA, Nicol HI (2000a) A survey of farms on the Central, Southern and Monaro Tablelands of New South Wales: management practices, farmer knowledge of native grasses, and extent of native grass areas. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 40, 1081–1088.
| A survey of farms on the Central, Southern and Monaro Tablelands of New South Wales: management practices, farmer knowledge of native grasses, and extent of native grass areas.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Garden DL, Lodge GM, Friend DA, Dowling PM, Orchard BA (2000b) Effect of grazing management on botanical composition of native grass-based pastures in temperate south-east Australia. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 40, 225–245.
| Effect of grazing management on botanical composition of native grass-based pastures in temperate south-east Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Hatcher S, Eppleston J, Graham RP, McDonald J, Schlunke S, Watt B, Thornberry KJ (2008) Higher weaning weight improves postweaning growth and survival in young Merino sheep. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 48, 966–973.
| Higher weaning weight improves postweaning growth and survival in young Merino sheep.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Heard J, Malcolm B, Jackson T, Tocker J, Graham P, White A (2013) Whole farm analysis versus activity gross margin analysis: a sheep farm example. AFBM Journal 10, 16–29.
Hufton C, Griffith G, Mullen J, Farrell T (2009) The influence of weight and fat on lamb prices, revisited. Australasian Agribusiness Review 17, 47–77.
Jeffrey SJ, Carter JO, Moodie KM, Beswick AR (2001) Using spatial interpolation to construct a comprehensive archive of Australian climate. Environmental Modelling & Software 16, 309–330.
| Using spatial interpolation to construct a comprehensive archive of Australian climate.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Kemp DR, King WM, Gilmour AR, Lodge GM, Murphy SR, Quigley PE, Sanford P, Andrew MH (2003) SGS Biodiversity Theme: impact of plant biodiversity on the productivity and stability of grazing systems across southern Australia. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 43, 961–975.
| SGS Biodiversity Theme: impact of plant biodiversity on the productivity and stability of grazing systems across southern Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Lodge GM, Johnson IR (2008) Agricultural drought analysis for temperate Australia using a biophysical pasture model. 1. Identifying and characterising drought periods. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research 59, 1049–1060.
| Agricultural drought analysis for temperate Australia using a biophysical pasture model. 1. Identifying and characterising drought periods.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Luck GW, Race D, Black R (2011) ‘Demographic change in Australia’s rural landscapes: implication for society and the environment.’ 1st edn. Springer Landscape Series Vol. 12. (Springer and CSIRO Publishing: Melbourne)
Malcolm B (2011) Financing matters. AFBM Journal 8, 11–18.
Malcolm B, Makeham J, Wright V (2005) ‘The farming game – agricultural management and marketing.’ 2nd edn. (Cambridge University Press: Melbourne)
McIvor J (2013) ‘HRM and cell grazing: a review of the evidence base.’ (Meat & Livestock Australia: Sydney)
MLA (2015) MLA Market Information Statistic Database. Meat and Livestock Australia. Available at http://statistics.mla.com.au/Report/List [Verified 1 December 2015]
Michalk DL, Dowling PM, Kemp DR, King WM, Packer IJ, Holst PJ, Jones RE, Priest SM, Millar GD, Brisbane S, Stanley DF (2003) Sustainable grazing systems for the Central Tablelands, New South Wales. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 43, 861–874.
| Sustainable grazing systems for the Central Tablelands, New South Wales.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Millar GD, Jones RE, Michalk DL, Brady S (2009) An exploratory tool for analysis of forage and livestock production options. Animal Production Science 49, 788–796.
| An exploratory tool for analysis of forage and livestock production options.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Monjardino M, McBeath T, Ouzman J, Llewellyn R, Jones B (2015) Farmer risk-aversion limits closure of yield and profit gaps: A study of nitrogen management in the southern Australian wheatbelt. Agricultural Systems 137, 108–118.
| Farmer risk-aversion limits closure of yield and profit gaps: A study of nitrogen management in the southern Australian wheatbelt.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Murison R, Scott JM (2013) Statistical methodologies for drawing causal inference from a replicated farmlet experiment conducted by the Cicerone Project. Animal Production Science 53, 643–648.
| Statistical methodologies for drawing causal inference from a replicated farmlet experiment conducted by the Cicerone Project.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
NSW Department of Primary Industries (2011) ‘Merino ewes (20 micron) – terminal rams: farm enterprise budget series – April 2011.’ (Industry and Investment NSW: Orange)
Nuthall PL (2011) ‘Farm business management: analysis of farming systems.’ (CABI Publishing: Wallingford, Oxfordshire)
Palisade (2016) ‘@Risk: risk analysis and simulation add-in for Microsoft Excel™ version 7.5.0.’ (Palisade Corporation: Ithaca, NY)
Payne R, Murray D, Harding S, Baird D, Soutar D (2013) ‘Introduction to GenStat® for Windows™.’ 16th edn. (VSN International: Hemel Hempstead, Hertfordshire)
Robertson SM, Southwell AF, Friend MA (2014) Modelling the risk of different joining times and lamb sale policies. Animal Production Science 54, 1694–1698.
| Modelling the risk of different joining times and lamb sale policies.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Rockafellar RT, Uryasev S (2002) Conditional value-at-risk for general loss distributions. Journal of Banking & Finance 26, 1443–1471.
| Conditional value-at-risk for general loss distributions.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Scott JM, Gaden CA, Edwards C, Paull DR, Marchant R, Hoad J, Sutherland H, Coventry T, Dutton P (2013) Selection of experimental treatments, methods used and evolution of management guidelines for comparing and measuring three grazed farmlet systems. Animal Production Science 53, 628–684.
| Selection of experimental treatments, methods used and evolution of management guidelines for comparing and measuring three grazed farmlet systems.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Slack-Smith A, Griffith G, Thompson J (2009) The cost of non-compliance to beef market specification. Australasian Agribusiness Review 17, 178–190.
Szegö G (2005) Measures of risk. European Journal of Operational Research 163, 5–19.
| Measures of risk.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Virgona JM, Avery AL, Graham JF, Orchard BA (2000) Effect of grazing management on phalaris herbage mass and persistence in summer-dry environments. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 40, 171–184.
| Effect of grazing management on phalaris herbage mass and persistence in summer-dry environments.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Warn LK, Frame HR, McLarty GR (2002) Effects of grazing method and soil fertility on stocking rate and wool production. Wool Technology and Sheep Breeding 50, 510–517.
Young JM, Thompson AN, Kennedy AJ (2010) Bioeconomic modelling to identify the relative importance of a range of critical control points for prime lamb production systems in south-west Victoria. Animal Production Science 50, 748–756.
| Bioeconomic modelling to identify the relative importance of a range of critical control points for prime lamb production systems in south-west Victoria.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
