The next frontier for recovering endangered huemul (Hippocamelus bisulcus): how to avoid recurrent misdiagnoses of health status and risks
Werner T. Flueck A B C F and Jo Anne M. Smith-Flueck D E
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations
A National Council of Scientific and Technological Research (CONICET), Rivadavia 1917, 1033 Buenos Aires, Argentina.
B Argentine National Park Administration, Bariloche, Argentina.
C Swiss Tropical and Public Health Institute, University Basel, Socinstrasse 57, 4051 Basel, Switzerland.
D Laboratorio de Teriogenología ‘Dr Héctor H. Morello’, Facultad de Ciencias Agrarias, Universidad Nacional del Comahue, Cinco Saltos, Argentina.
E DeerLab, Rolando 699, 8400 Bariloche, Argentina.
F Corresponding author. Email: wtf@deerlab.org
Animal Production Science 60(10) 1271-1282 https://doi.org/10.1071/AN18688
Submitted: 8 November 2018 Accepted: 17 September 2019 Published: 6 May 2020
Abstract
Context: The currently remaining 350–500 huemuls in Argentina are not recovering. We evaluated live huemuls, along with animals that died soon after confinement, or those that had died recently. Although information on the health status is highly valuable, repeated misdiagnoses of the health status indicate a need for other strategies.
Aims: . Discrepancies between clinical and postmortem diagnoses are critical for improving subsequent management decisions.
Methods: Initial clinical interpretations and risk assessments were reinterpreted on the basis of necropsies and other data.
Results: Two debilitated huemul individuals examined by veterinarians died soon afterwards, supposedly one being intoxicated and one being without lesions. Necropsies showed osteopathology and fluorosis (fluorine concentrations of 2209 and 2979 mg/kg). Another male was tied up, with authorities and veterinarians arriving the next day. After being sedated, and judged healthy, the animal was translocated. Because there was no reversal, this animal died 22 h post-capture. Exhumation showed severe osteopathology. Elsewhere, huemuls were considered adequate in selenium because values below the detection limit were excluded. However, when all values were included, 75% of the animals were selenium-deficient; this population had numerous cases of osteopathology. Recently, specialists went to Torres del Paine Park suspecting caseous lymphadenitis, reporting of which has been obligatory since 1937. However, many cases documented in 1999–2007 have not elicited responses since that time by health professionals. Selenium deficiency negatively affects antibody responses against caseous lymphadenitis. One province had denied huemul capture (2012 and 2013) on recommendation of scientific advisors. Because of the right for transparency, it was found out in 2016 that authorities had requested advice from only one veterinarian who assessed that darting was too risky. Another 2016 project proposed to dart the first huemul in Argentina. Two weeks earlier, that same team was called to rescue a tied-up huemul; the team opted not to involve a laboratory with drugs and radios that was only 1 h away. This huemul died and was left in the woods. Finally, the first huemul enclosure in Argentina was proposed (1995), but the permission was denied. Again, in 2000, the first huemul centre with private funding secured for 30 years was proposed. However, the Regional Delegation for Patagonian National Parks prevented aerial surveys, and advised not to provide a permit for the centre.
Conclusions: Future assessments should consider osteopathology. Risk assessments should be transparent and based on assessment by multiple qualified professionals.
Implications: Clinical misdiagnoses may reduce life expectancy, in contrast to taking individuals to enclosures, which would also allow valuable reintroductions. Not permitting captures, censusses and enclosures has resulted in unwarranted delays in conservation progress.
Additional keywords: breeding centre, conservation biology, pathology, recovery.
References
Administración de Parques Nacionales Argentina (APN) (2016a) DRP: captura de huemules para su seguimiento por telemetría – programa Conservación del Huemul APN. (Ed. E Ramilo) Report CUDAP TRI-PNA:0000671/2016. APN, Buenos Aires, Argentina.Administración de Parques Nacionales Argentina (APN) (2016b) ‘En la senda del huemul.’ Available at www.parquesnacionales.gob.ar/2016/04/en-la-senda-del-huemul [Verified 4 April 2016]
Aitken ID (2007) ‘Diseases of sheep.’ 4th edn. (John Wiley & Sons: Chichester, UK)
Barbato LC (2016) Denuncia sobre muerte de huemul. In ‘Resolución PD 126/2016, Administración de Parques Nacionales’. (Eds Oficina de sumarios e investigaciones administrativas) pp. 1–382. (Administración de Parques Nacionales: Buenos Aires, Argentina)
Berner ES, Graber ML (2008) Overconfidence as a cause of diagnostic error in medicine. The American Journal of Medicine 121, S2–S23.
| Overconfidence as a cause of diagnostic error in medicine.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 18440350PubMed |
Braverman I (2014) Conservation without nature: the trouble with in situ versus ex situ conservation. Geoforum 51, 47–57.
| Conservation without nature: the trouble with in situ versus ex situ conservation.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Cerda J, Llanos A, Vidal F (2011) Surgical amputation of foreleg in South Andean deer (huemul, Hippocamelus bisulcus) in Coyhaique, Chile. Animal Production Science 51, li–liv.
Chang Reissig E, Quiroga A, Massone A, Gimeno E, Pastore H, Ramilo E, Izquierdo M, Corvalán F, Lizardo V, Ielpi C, Uzal FA (2015) Posible intoxicación por Astragalus sp. en un huemul Hippocamelus bisulcus. In ‘IX seminario Argentino Fundación Charles Louis Davis and VII reunión del Forum Permanente en Enseñanza de Patología Veterinaria’. (Universidad Católica de Salta: Salta, Argentina) Available at www.conicet.gob.ar/new_scp/detalle.php?keywords=&id=32614& [Verified January 2020]
Che-Castaldo JP, Grow SA, Faust LJ (2018) Evaluating the contribution of North American zoos and aquariums to endangered species recovery. Scientific Reports 8, 9789.
Chehebar C (2016) Participación de personal de la Delegación Regional Patagonia en el intento de rescate y liberación de un ejemplar de huemul en la localidad El Manso, Provincia de Río Negro. In ‘Denuncia sobre muerte de huemul, Resolución PD 126/2016, Administración de Parques Nacionales’. (Ed. LC Barbato) pp. 60–64. (Administración de Parques Nacionales: Buenos Aires, Argentina)
Chihuailaf RH, Stevenson VB, Saucedo C, Corti P (2014) Blood mineral concentrations in the endangered huemul deer (Hippocamelus bisulcus) from Chilean Patagonia. Journal of Wildlife Diseases 50, 146–149.
| Blood mineral concentrations in the endangered huemul deer (Hippocamelus bisulcus) from Chilean Patagonia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 24171561PubMed |
Choubisa AL (2015) Industrial fluorosis in domestic goats (Capra hircus), Rajasthan, India. Fluoride 48, 105–112.
CONAF (2018) ‘CONAF preocupada por posible presencia de enfermedad en huemules de Torres del Paine.’ Available at www.conaf.cl [Verified 26 April 2018]
Croskerry P (2003) The importance of cognitive errors in diagnosis and strategies to minimize them. Academic Medicine 78, 775–780.
| The importance of cognitive errors in diagnosis and strategies to minimize them.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 12915363PubMed |
Davis JW, Anderson RC (1971) ‘Parasitic diseases of wild mammals.’ 1st edn. (Iowa State University Press: Ames, IA, USA)
Davis JW, Karstad LH, Trainer DO (1981) ‘Infectious diseases of wild mammals.’ 2nd edn. (Iowa State University Press: Ames, IA, USA)
de los Reyes Recabarren R (2015) ‘Hippocamelus bisulcus: equivocaciones desde el inicio. El Divisadero.’ Available at www.eldivisadero.cl [Verified January 2020]
DelGiudice GD, Mangipane BA, Sampson BA, Kochanny CO (2001) Chemical immobilization, body temperature, and post-release mortality of white-tailed deer captured by clover trap and net-gun. Wildlife Society Bulletin 29, 1147–1157.
Dunlop Young T (1934) Caseous lymphadenitis; pseudo-tuberculosis of sheep; cheesy broncho-pneumonia. Veterinary Journal 90, 407–409.
Escobar Ruíz EM, Gizejewski Z, Hoby S, Flueck WT, Smith-Flueck JM (2017) El valor de los centros de conservación para la supervivencia del huemul. Chapter 12. In ‘El Huemul de Aysén y otros rincones’. (Eds A Iriarte, DS Donoso, B Segura, M Tirado) pp. 198–215. (Ediciones Secretaría Regional Ministerial de Agricultura de la Región de Aysén y Flora & Fauna Chile Ltd: Aysen, Chile)
Flueck WT (2013) Effects of fluoride intoxication on teeth of livestock due to a recent volcanic eruption in Patagonia, Argentina. Online Journal of Veterinary Research 17, 167–176.
Flueck WT (2015) Osteopathology and selenium deficiency co-occurring in a population of endangered Patagonian huemul (Hippocamelus bisulcus). BMC Research Notes 8, 330
| Osteopathology and selenium deficiency co-occurring in a population of endangered Patagonian huemul (Hippocamelus bisulcus).Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 26233940PubMed |
Flueck WT (2016a) The impact of recent volcanic ash depositions on herbivores in Patagonia: a review. The Rangeland Journal 38, 27–34.
| The impact of recent volcanic ash depositions on herbivores in Patagonia: a review.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Flueck WT (2016b) Extended chronology of the Cordón Caulle volcanic eruption beyond 2011 reveals toxic impacts. Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences 16, 2351–2355.
| Extended chronology of the Cordón Caulle volcanic eruption beyond 2011 reveals toxic impacts.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Flueck WT (2018) Elusive cranial lesions severely afflicting young endangered Patagonian huemul deer: a case report. BMC Research Notes 11, 638
| Elusive cranial lesions severely afflicting young endangered Patagonian huemul deer: a case report.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 30176912PubMed |
Flueck WT, Smith-Flueck JM (2006) Predicaments of endangered huemul deer, Hippocamelus bisulcus, in Argentina: a review. European Journal of Wildlife Research 52, 69–80.
| Predicaments of endangered huemul deer, Hippocamelus bisulcus, in Argentina: a review.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Flueck WT, Smith-Flueck JM (2008) Age-independent osteopathology in skeletons of a south American cervid, the Patagonian huemul (Hippocamelus bisulcus). Journal of Wildlife Diseases 44, 636–648.
| Age-independent osteopathology in skeletons of a south American cervid, the Patagonian huemul (Hippocamelus bisulcus).Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 18689649PubMed |
Flueck WT, Smith-Flueck JM (2011) Recent advances in the nutritional ecology of the Patagonian huemul: implications for recovery. Animal Production Science 51, 311–326.
| Recent advances in the nutritional ecology of the Patagonian huemul: implications for recovery.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Flueck WT, Smith-Flueck JM (2013) Severe dental fluorosis in juvenile deer linked to a recent volcanic eruption in Patagonia. Journal of Wildlife Diseases 49, 355–366.
| Severe dental fluorosis in juvenile deer linked to a recent volcanic eruption in Patagonia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 23568911PubMed |
Flueck WT, Smith-Flueck JM (2017) Troubling disease syndrome in endangered live Patagonian huemul deer (Hippocamelus bisulcus) from the Protected Park Shoonem: unusually high prevalence of osteopathology. BMC Research Notes 10, 739
| Troubling disease syndrome in endangered live Patagonian huemul deer (Hippocamelus bisulcus) from the Protected Park Shoonem: unusually high prevalence of osteopathology.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 29246255PubMed |
Flueck WT, Smith-Flueck JM (2018) Radio marking the first group of endangered Patagonian huemul deer in Argentina. Journal of Neotropical Mammalogy 25, 461–465.
| Radio marking the first group of endangered Patagonian huemul deer in Argentina.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Flueck WT, Smith-Flueck JM, Mionczynski J, Mincher BJ (2012) The implications of selenium deficiency for wild herbivore conservation, a review. European Journal of Wildlife Research 58, 761–780.
| The implications of selenium deficiency for wild herbivore conservation, a review.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Flueck WT, Smith-Flueck JM, Mincher BJ, Winkel LHE (2014a) An alternative interpretation of plasma selenium data from endangered Patagonian huemul deer (Hippocamelus bisulcus). Journal of Wildlife Diseases 50, 1003–1004.
| An alternative interpretation of plasma selenium data from endangered Patagonian huemul deer (Hippocamelus bisulcus).Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 25121403PubMed |
Flueck WT, Smith-Flueck JM, Mincher BJ, Winkel LHE (2014b) Soil selenium levels corroborate direct evidence of selenium deficiency in endangered Patagonian huemul deer (Hippocamelus bisulcus). In ‘Proceedings of the 8th international deer biology congress’. (Eds J Ma, M Zhang, R Halbrook, B Liu, W Zhang) pp. 52–53. (Northeast Forestry University: Harbin, China)
Graber ML (2013) The incidence of diagnostic error in medicine. BMJ Quality & Safety 22, ii21–ii27.
| The incidence of diagnostic error in medicine.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Grandjean P, Landrigan PJ (2014) Neurobehavioral effects of developmental toxicity. Lancet Neurology 13, 330–338.
| Neurobehavioral effects of developmental toxicity.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 24556010PubMed |
Guineo O, Guineo Garay R, Garay G (2008) ‘Conociendo al huemul de Torres del Paine.’ (La Prensa Austral: Punta Arenas, Chile)
Hebert DM, Cowan IM (1971) White muscle disease in the mountain goat. The Journal of Wildlife Management 35, 752–756.
| White muscle disease in the mountain goat.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
IUCN (1987) ‘The IUCN policy statement on captive breeding. No. IUCN-PP-001.’ (IUCN: Gland, Switzerland)
IUCN (2001) ‘IUCN red list categories, version 3.1.’ (IUCN Species Survival Commission: Gland, Switzerland)
IUCN (2002) ‘IUCN technical guidelines on the management of ex-situ populations for conservation.’ (IUCN: Gland, Switzerland)
Izquierdo VM, Flueck WT, Smith-Flueck JM, Bauer G (2018) Fluorosis confirmed in an endangered Patagonian huemul deer population resulting from a 2008 volcanic eruption. In ‘9th international deer biology congress’. (Estes Park, CO, USA)
Jones TC, Hunt RD, King NW (1997) ‘Veterinary pathology.’ 6th edn. (Williams & Wilkins: Baltimore, MD, USA)
Kock MD, Jessup DA, Clark RK, Franti CE, Weaver RA (1987) Capture methods in five subspecies of free-ranging Bighorn sheep: an evaluation of drop-net, drive-net, chemical immobilization and the net-gun. Journal of Wildlife Diseases 23, 634–640.
| Capture methods in five subspecies of free-ranging Bighorn sheep: an evaluation of drop-net, drive-net, chemical immobilization and the net-gun.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 3682090PubMed |
Larsen HJ, Moksnes K, Overnes G (1988) Influence of selenium on antibody production in sheep. Research in Veterinary Science 45, 4–10.
| Influence of selenium on antibody production in sheep.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 3222551PubMed |
Lizurume JL (1995) ‘Centro de rehabilitacion y cria de huemul.’ Nota 328 de 30 Ago. (Ministerio de Gobierno, Trabajo y Justicia: Rawson, Provincia de Chubut, Argentina)
Lopez Alfonsin MA (2019) La protección del huemul como monumento natural, una asignatura pendiente de decisión politica. Revista Iberoamericana de Derecho Ambiental y Recursos Naturales 34,
Lopez Alfonsin MA, Sol Bucetto M (2019) Endangered species and mechanisms for the recovery and conservation of biodiversity: a study on the viability of mechanisms and bureaucratic obstacles. LEX 17, 297–324.
| Endangered species and mechanisms for the recovery and conservation of biodiversity: a study on the viability of mechanisms and bureaucratic obstacles.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Martinez A, Robles C, Gimeno E (2014) Intoxicación por garbancillo o yerba loca. Presencia 62, 5–8.
Matamoros R, Contreras PA, Wittwer F, Mayorga MI (2003) Hypothyroidism in ruminants. Archivos de Medicina Veterinaria 35, 1–11.
Matos AC, Dias AP, Morais M, Figueira L, Martins MH, Matos M, Pinto ML, Coelho AC (2015) Granuloma coinfection with Mycobacterium bovis, Mycobacterium avium subsp. paratuberculosis, and Corynebacterium pseudotuberculosis in five hunted red deer (Cervus elaphus) in Portugal. Journal of Wildlife Diseases 51, 793–794.
| Granuloma coinfection with Mycobacterium bovis, Mycobacterium avium subsp. paratuberculosis, and Corynebacterium pseudotuberculosis in five hunted red deer (Cervus elaphus) in Portugal.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 25932668PubMed |
Morales N, Aldridge D, Bahamonde A, Cerda J, Araya C, Muñoz R, Saldías ME, Lecocq C, Fresno M, Abalos P, Retamal P (2017) Corynebacterium pseudotuberculosis infection in Patagonian Huemul (Hippocamelus bisulcus). Journal of Wildlife Diseases 53, 621–624.
| Corynebacterium pseudotuberculosis infection in Patagonian Huemul (Hippocamelus bisulcus).Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 28323562PubMed |
Pepin M, Paton MW (2010) Caseous lymphadenitis in sheep and goats. Chapter 86. In ‘Infectious and parasitic diseases of livestock’. (Eds PC Lefevre, J Blancou, R Chermette, G Uilenberg) pp. 1151–1163. (Lavoisier: Cachan Cedex, France)
Pilarczyk B, Tomza-Marciniak A, Pilarczyk R, Bkowska M, Gaik M, Wilk M, Kuba J (2013) Relationship between serum Se concentration in dogs and incidence of some disease conditions. Central European Journal of Biology 8, 527–533.
Ramilo E (2001) Cria en cautiverio del huemul, consideraciones generals: Delegación Regional Patagonia, Administración de Parques Nacionales, Argentina. In ‘Expediente Proyecto de censos poblacionales de huemul en el invierno en la provincia de Chubut’. (Ed. Direccion de Fauna y Flora Silvestres) pp. 17–19. (Escribania General de Gobierno: Rawson, Provincia de Chubut, Argentina)
Robles CA, Saber C, Jefrey M (2000) Intoxicación por Astragalus pehuenches (locoismo) en ovinos Merino de la Patagonia Argentina. Revista de Medicina Veterinaria 81, 380–384.
Salwasser H, Jessup D (1978) A methodology for performing necropsies and data analysis on road-killed deer. California Department of Fish and Game internal report. California Department of Fish and Game, Sacramento, CA, USA.
Singh A, Nocerino J (2002) Robust estimation of mean and variance using environmental data sets with below detection limit observations. Chemometrics and Intelligent Laboratory Systems 60, 69–86.
| Robust estimation of mean and variance using environmental data sets with below detection limit observations.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Smith-Flueck JM (2000) The Current Situation of the Patagonian huemul. Chapter 4. In ‘The Patagonian huemul: a mysterious deer on the brink of extinction’. (Eds NI Díaz, JM Smith-Flueck) pp. 67–146. (LOLA: Buenos Aires, Argentina)
Smith-Flueck JM, Díaz NI, Flueck WT (2004) Cría de huemules en cautiverio: las perspectivas actuales considerando las experiencias historicas. Chapter. In ‘Cría en cautividad de fauna Chilena’. (Eds A Iriarte, C Tala, B Gonzalez, B Zapata, G Gonzalez, M Maino) pp. 457–470. (Servicio Agrícola y Ganadero – Parque Metropolitano, Zoológico Nacional, Universidad de Chile: Santiago, Chile)
Stegelmeier BL, James LF, Gardner DR, Panter KE, Lee ST, Ralphs MH, Pfister JA, Spraker TR (2005) Locoweed (Oxytropis sericea): induced lesions in mule deer (Odocoileus hemionus). Veterinary Pathology 42, 566–578.
| Locoweed (Oxytropis sericea): induced lesions in mule deer (Odocoileus hemionus).Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 16145203PubMed |
Sutherland WJ (2000) ‘The conservation handbook: research, management and policy.’ (Blackwell Science: Berlin, Germany)
Texera WA (1974) Algunos aspectos de la biología del huemul (Hippocamelus bisulcus) (Mammalia: Artiodactyla, Cervidae) en cautividad. Anales del Instituto de la Patagonia, Punta Arenas (Chile) 5, 155–188.
Ulemale AH, Kulkarni MD, Yadav GB, Samant SR, Komatwar SJ, Khanvilkar AV (2010) Fluorosis in cattle. Veterinary World 3, 526–527.
Valli VEO, Kiupel M, Bienzle D, Wood D (2016) Hematopoietic system. Chapter 2. In ‘Jubb, Kennedy & Palmer’s pathology of domestic animals, vol. 3’. (Ed. M Grant Maxie) pp. 102–268. (Saunders Elsevier: Philadelphia, PA, USA)
Vidal F, Arias E, Garrido F, Parra Y, Espinoza J (2018) Experimental reintroduction of South Andean huemul and guanaco in the Huilo Huilo Chilean Private Reserve, Chile. In ‘Global reintroduction perspectives: case studies from around the globe’. (Ed. PS Soorae) pp. 125–129. (IUCN/SSC Reintroduction Specialist Group: Gland, Switzerland)
Vinci MC (2016) Observaciones sobre el proyecto ‘Huemul en peligro: propuesta de un manejo adaptativo’. Assessment report by M Uhart to the Director of Wildlife, Nota SAyDS No. 588/2016. Secretaria de Ambiente y Desarrollo Sustentable, Viedma, Rio Negro, Argentina.
Walters CJ, Holling CS (1990) Large-scale management experiments and learning by doing. Ecology 71, 2060–2068.
| Large-scale management experiments and learning by doing.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Wernery U, Kinne J (2016) Caseous lymphadenitis (pseudotuberculosis) in camelids: a review. Austin Journal of Veterinary Science & Animal Husbandry 3, 1022
Wobeser GA, Spraker TR (1980) Post-mortem examination. In ‘Wildlife management techniques manual’. (Ed. SD Schemnitz) pp. 89–98. (The Wildlife Society: Washington, DC, USA)
