Perennial ryegrass breeding and the scaling issue: a review of system experiments investigating milk production and profit differences among cultivars
Stacey J. Hendriks A , Daniel J. Donaghy A D , Lydia M. Cranston A , Grant R. Edwards B and David F. Chapman C
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations
A Institute of Veterinary, Animal and Biomedical Sciences, Massey University, Private Bag 11222, Palmerston North, New Zealand.
B Faculty of Agriculture and Life Sciences, Lincoln University, PO Box 85084 Lincoln, New Zealand.
C DairyNZ, PO Box 160, Lincoln University, Lincoln, New Zealand.
D Corresponding author. Email: d.j.donaghy@massey.ac.nz
Animal Production Science 57(7) 1289-1296 https://doi.org/10.1071/AN16524
Submitted: 1 August 2016 Accepted: 3 February 2017 Published: 11 May 2017
Abstract
Results of studies designed to determine whether or not differences measured among perennial ryegrass cultivars in small-plot studies translate into differences in milk production and profit in dairy whole-system studies were reviewed. Only three experiments were identified that met the criteria for fully self-contained systems repeated over multiple years required to account for annual feed supply–demand balance, its interaction with animal intake and production, and the influence of inter-annual climate variability on these processes. Collectively, these studies provide evidence of improvement in animal production, associated with genetic gains from ryegrass breeding, albeit through shifts in factors such as heading date (as it affects herbage quality and grazing efficiency) and host plant by endophyte interactions, rather than through gains in dry-matter yield. The latter remains unresolved, despite substantial evidence for gains from small-plot trials of dry-matter yield increases in the order of 0.5% per annum. These studies also highlighted the number of factors that have to be taken into account in the design and conduct of such studies, including gaining clarity about the size of the differences that can be expected and ensuring sufficient statistical power. Implementing objective management rules that allow cultivars to express their potential and capture differences through the grazing animal will ensure sufficient measurement intensity to enable differences (if observed) in milk production and profit to be explained. This should guard against confounding factors such as the differential effects of insect pests on plant performance, and consequent changes in pasture botanical composition mediated by ryegrass endophyte strains. Despite these difficulties, more experiments of this type are required to quantify and, ultimately, increase the value being delivered by ryegrass breeding to pasture-based dairy production systems in temperate regions. Therefore, there is a need for whole-system studies to be undertaken to provide valuable new information and give farmers the confidence to invest in the use of new cultivars.
Additional keywords: forage indexing systems, Lolium, pasture-based dairying, whole-system studies.
References
Beard KT (1987) Efficiency of index selection for dairy cattle using economic weights for major milk constituents. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research 38, 273–284.Bluett SJ, Thom ER, Clark DA, Macdonald KA, Minnee EMK (2005) Effects of perennial ryegrass infected with either AR1 or wild endophyte on dairy production in the Waikato. New Zealand Journal of Agricultural Research 48, 197–212.
| Effects of perennial ryegrass infected with either AR1 or wild endophyte on dairy production in the Waikato.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Castle ME, Watson JN (1971) A comparison between a diploid and a tetraploid ryegrass for milk production. Journal of Agricultural Science Cambridge 77, 69–76.
| A comparison between a diploid and a tetraploid ryegrass for milk production.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Chapman DF, Bryant JR, McMillan WH, Khaembah EN (2012) Economic values for evaluating pasture plant traits. Proceedings of the New Zealand Grassland Association 73, 209–215.
Chapman DF, Edwards GR, Stewart AV, McEvoy M, O’Donovan M, Waghorn GC (2015) Valuing forages for genetic selection: what traits should we focus on? Animal Production Science 55, 869–882.
| Valuing forages for genetic selection: what traits should we focus on?Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Chapman DF, Bryant JR, Olayemi ME, Edwards GR, Thorrold BS, McMillan WH, Kerr GA, Judson G, Cookson T, Moorhead A, Norriss M (2016) An economically based evaluation index for perennial and short-term ryegrasses in New Zealand dairy farm systems. Grass and Forage Science 72, 1–21.
| An economically based evaluation index for perennial and short-term ryegrasses in New Zealand dairy farm systems.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Chaves B, De Vliegher A, Van Waes J, Carlier L, Marynissen B (2009) Change in agronomic performance of Lolium perenne and Lolium multiflorum varieties in the past 40 years based on data from Belgian VCU trials. Plant Breeding 128, 680–690.
| Change in agronomic performance of Lolium perenne and Lolium multiflorum varieties in the past 40 years based on data from Belgian VCU trials.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Clark DA (2010) Contribution of farmlet scale research in New Zealand and Australia to improved dairy farming systems. In ‘Proceedings of the 4th Australasian dairy science symposium’. (Eds GR Edwards, RH Bryant) pp. 112–124. (Caxton Press: Christchurch, New Zealand)
Crush JR, Woodward SL, Eerens JPJ, Macdonald KA (2006) Growth and milksolids production in pastures of older and more recent ryegrass and white clover cultivars under dairy grazing. New Zealand Journal of Agricultural Research 49, 119–135.
| Growth and milksolids production in pastures of older and more recent ryegrass and white clover cultivars under dairy grazing.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Cunningham PJ, Blumenthal MJ, Anderson MW, Prakash KS, Leonforte A (1994) Perennial ryegrass improvement in Australia. New Zealand Journal of Agricultural Research 37, 295–310.
| Perennial ryegrass improvement in Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Davies DA, Fothergill M, Morgan CT (1992) Assessment of contrasting perennial ryegrasses, with and without clover, under continuous sheep stocking in the uplands. 4. Animal performance in years 4–6. Grass and Forage Science 47, 249–258.
| Assessment of contrasting perennial ryegrasses, with and without clover, under continuous sheep stocking in the uplands. 4. Animal performance in years 4–6.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Davies DA, Fothergill M, Morgan CT (1993) Assessment of contrasting perennial ryegrasses, with and without white clover, under continuous sheep stocking in the uplands. 5. Herbage production, quality and intake in years 4–6. Grass and Forage Science 48, 213–222.
| Assessment of contrasting perennial ryegrasses, with and without white clover, under continuous sheep stocking in the uplands. 5. Herbage production, quality and intake in years 4–6.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Easton HS, Baird DB, Cameron NE, Kerr GA, Norriss MG, Stewart AV (2001) Perennial ryegrass cultivars: herbage yield in multi-site lot trials. Proceedings of the New Zealand Grasslands Association 63, 183–188.
Eerens JPJ, Crush JR, Woodward SL, Macdonald KA, Carter WA (2001) Milksolids production from different combinations of perennial ryegrass and white clover cultivars: I Trial design and pasture performance. Proceedings of the New Zealand Grasslands Association 63, 91–96.
Ferris A, Malcolm LR (1999) Sense and nonsense in dairy farm management economic analysis. In ‘Proceedings of the 43rd annual conference of the Australian Agricultural and Resource Economics Society’, January 1999, Christchurch, New Zealand.
Gowen N, O’Donovan M, Casey I, Rath M, Delaby L, Stakelum G (2003) The effect of grass cultivars differing in heading date and ploidy on the performance and dry matter intake of spring calving dairy cows at pasture. Animal Research 52, 321–336.
| The effect of grass cultivars differing in heading date and ploidy on the performance and dry matter intake of spring calving dairy cows at pasture.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD3sXot1Cms7k%3D&md5=865dcbf6cf5dd429b3a35719724b9226CAS |
Gregorini P, Beukes PC, Romera AJ, Levy G, Hanigan MD (2013) A model of diurnal grazing patterns and herbage intake of a grazing cow, MINDY: model description. Ecological Modelling 270, 11–29.
| A model of diurnal grazing patterns and herbage intake of a grazing cow, MINDY: model description.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Grogan D, Gilliland TJ (2011) A review of perennial ryegrass evaluation in Ireland. Irish Journal of Agricultural and Food Research 50, 65–81.
Harmer M, Stewart AV, Woodfield DR (2016) Perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne) genetic gain in Australia and New Zealand. Journal of New Zealand Grasslands 78, (In press).
Kelly S, Smith E, Brazendale R (2011) Pasture renewal in the Waikato and Bay of Plenty regions: an overview of farmer practice, experience and attitudes. Grassland Research and Practice Series 15, 21–24.
Lee JM, Matthew C, Thom ER, Chapman DF (2012) Perennial ryegrass breeding in New Zealand: a dairy industry perspective. Crop & Pasture Science 63, 107–127.
| Perennial ryegrass breeding in New Zealand: a dairy industry perspective.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Ludemann CI, Eckard RJ, Cullen BR, Jacobs JL, Malcolm B, Smith KF (2015) Higher energy concentration traits in perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne L.) may increase profitability and improve energy conversion on dairy farms. Agricultural Systems 137, 89–100.
| Higher energy concentration traits in perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne L.) may increase profitability and improve energy conversion on dairy farms.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Macdonald KA, Penno JW (1998) Management decision rules to optimise milksolids production on dairy farms. Proceedings of the New Zealand Society of Animal Production 58, 132–135.
Macdonald KA, Glassey CB, Rawnsley RP (2010) The emergence, development and effectiveness of decision rules for pasture based dairy systems. In ‘Proceedings of the 4th Australasian dairy science symposium’. pp. 199–209. (Caxton Press: Christchurch, New Zealand)
McCallum DA, Thomson NA (1994) The effect of different perennial ryegrass cultivars on dairy animal performance. Proceedings of the New Zealand Society of Animal Production 54, 87–90.
McDonagh J, O’Donovan M, McEvoy M, Gilliland TJ (2017) Genetic gain in perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne L.) varieties 1973 to 2013. Euphytica 212, 187–199.
| Genetic gain in perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne L.) varieties 1973 to 2013.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
McEvoy M, O’Donovan M, Shalloo L (2011) Development and application of an economic ranking index for perennial ryegrass cultivars. Journal of Dairy Science 94, 1627–1639.
| Development and application of an economic ranking index for perennial ryegrass cultivars.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC3MXmvFeitLg%3D&md5=8becfe928356e3dc3e915db921c07235CAS |
Moss RA, Fraser TJ, Daly MJ, Knight TL, Carson DG (2000) The effect of pasture species on pasture and animal performances in irrigated systems. Proceedings of the New Zealand Grasslands Association 62, 59–66.
Munro J, Davies D, Evans W, Scurlock R (1992) Animal production evaluation of herbage varieties. 1. Comparison of Aurora with Frances, Talbot and Melle perennial ryegrasses when grown alone and with clover. Grass and Forage Science 47, 259–273.
| Animal production evaluation of herbage varieties. 1. Comparison of Aurora with Frances, Talbot and Melle perennial ryegrasses when grown alone and with clover.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Nicol A, Bryant RH, Ridgeway M, Edwards GR (2010) Liveweight gain per head and per ha throughout the year of lambs grazing conventional pastures and those that switch from grass to clover. Proceedings of the New Zealand Grasslands Association 72, 211–216.
O’Donovan M, Delaby L (2005) A comparison of perennial ryegrass cultivars differing in heading date and grass ploidy with spring calving dairy cows grazed at two different stocking rates. Animal Research 54, 337–350.
| A comparison of perennial ryegrass cultivars differing in heading date and grass ploidy with spring calving dairy cows grazed at two different stocking rates.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD28XhsVI%3D&md5=da1a5b3d9441b2330c3d2152ceccbc5dCAS |
O’Donovan M, Lewis E, O’Kiely P (2011) Requirements of future grass-based ruminant production systems in Ireland. Irish Journal of Agricultural and Food Research 50, 1–21.
Reed KFM (1994) Improved grass cultivars increase milk and meat production: a review. New Zealand Journal of Agricultural Research 37, 277–286.
| Improved grass cultivars increase milk and meat production: a review.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Sampoux J-P, Baudouin P, Bayle B, Beguier V, Bourdon P, Chosson J-F, Deneufbourg F, Galbrun C, Ghesquiere M, Noel D, Pietraszek W, Tharel B, Viguie A (2011) Breeding perennial grasses for forage use: an experimental assessment of trait changes in diploid perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne L.) cultivars released in the last four decades. Field Crops Research 123, 117–129.
| Breeding perennial grasses for forage use: an experimental assessment of trait changes in diploid perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne L.) cultivars released in the last four decades.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Stewart AV (2006) Genetic origins of perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne) for New Zealand pastures. In ‘Breeding for success: diversity in action. Proceedings of the 13th Australasian plant breeding conference’. (Ed. CF Mercer) pp. 11–20. (New Zealand Grassland Association: Christchurch, New Zealand)
Thom ER, Popay AJ, Hume DE, Fletcher LR (2012) Evaluating the performance of endophytes in farm systems to improve farmer outcomes: a review. Crop & Pasture Science 63, 927–943.
| Evaluating the performance of endophytes in farm systems to improve farmer outcomes: a review.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Westwood CT, Norriss MG (2000) Performance of dairy cows grazing two perennial ryegrass cultivars. Proceedings of the New Zealand Society of Animal Production 60, 247–252.
Widdup KH, Barrett BA (2011) Achieving persistence and productivity in white clover. In ‘Pasture persistence symposium’. Grassland research and practice series no. 15. (Ed. CF Mercer) pp. 173–180. (New Zealand Grassland Association: Dunedin, New Zealand)
Wilkins PW, Humphreys MO (2003) Progress in breeding perennial forage grasses for temperate agriculture. The Journal of Agricultural Science 140, 129–150.
| Progress in breeding perennial forage grasses for temperate agriculture.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD3sXktVejsbc%3D&md5=3730a5480555090a8e5ebf8d4e7f85ddCAS |
Wims CM, McEvoy M, Delaby L, Boland TM, O’Donovan M (2013) Effect of perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne L.) cultivars on the milk yield of grazing dairy cows. Animal 7, 410–421.
| Effect of perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne L.) cultivars on the milk yield of grazing dairy cows.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:STN:280:DC%2BC3s%2FitlSqtA%3D%3D&md5=4d7c184ecb9308bbc349e0de4a3f04e8CAS |
