Whither the paradigm shift? Large wildland fires and the wildfire paradox offer opportunities for a new paradigm of ecological fire management
Timothy Ingalsbee
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations
Firefighters United for Safety, Ethics, and Ecology (FUSEE), 2852 Willamette number 125, Eugene, OR 97405, USA. Email: fire@efn.org
International Journal of Wildland Fire 26(7) 557-561 https://doi.org/10.1071/WF17062
Submitted: 27 July 2016 Accepted: 11 May 2017 Published: 5 July 2017
Abstract
The growing frequency of large wildland fires has raised awareness of the ‘wildfire paradox’ and the ‘firefighting trap’ that are both rooted in the fire exclusion paradigm. However, a paradigm shift has been unfolding in the wildland fire community that seeks to restore fire ecology processes across broad landscapes. This would involve managing rather than aggressively suppressing large fires. Examples of recent fire science publications demonstrating ‘new paradigm’ thinking or critical questioning of ‘old paradigm’ assumptions are offered as evidence of this shift in thinking. However, integration of fire ecology science is lagging in fire-related policies and legislation, media representations of wildland fires, and conventional management responses to most wildland fires. Sociocultural, political and economic factors are functioning as barriers to change in fire management policies and practices. However, the growing risks, costs and impacts of large wildland fires will continue to highlight the crisis of the dominant fire exclusion paradigm. The general inability to prevent and effectively suppress large wildland fires may be the means to break through these institutional and societal barriers and propel efforts to shift philosophy and practice to a new paradigm of ecological fire management.
References
Baker W (2015) Are higher-severity fires burning at much higher rates recently than historically in dry-forest landscapes of the western USA? PLoS One 10, e0136147| Are higher-severity fires burning at much higher rates recently than historically in dry-forest landscapes of the western USA?Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Busenberg G (2004) Wildfire management in the US: the evolution of a policy failure. The Review of Policy Research 21, 145–156.
| Wildfire management in the US: the evolution of a policy failure.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Calkin DE, Finney MA, Ager AA, Thompson MP, Gebert KM (2011) Progress towards and barriers to implementation of a risk framework for US federal wildland fire policy and decision making. Forest Policy and Economics 13, 378–389.
| Progress towards and barriers to implementation of a risk framework for US federal wildland fire policy and decision making.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Calkin DE, Cohen JD, Finney MA, Thompson MP (2014a) How risk management can prevent future wildfire disasters in the wildland–urban interface. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 111, 746–751.
| How risk management can prevent future wildfire disasters in the wildland–urban interface.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC2cXotFCgug%3D%3D&md5=56740c5da6008f4603800941c53a4666CAS |
Calkin DE, Stonesifer CS, Thompson MP, McHugh CW (2014b) Large airtanker use and outcomes in suppressing wildland fires in the United States. International Journal of Wildland Fire 23, 259–271.
| Large airtanker use and outcomes in suppressing wildland fires in the United States.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Calkin DE, Thompson MP, Finney MA (2015) Negative consequences of positive feedbacks in US wildfire management. Forest Ecosystems 2, 1–10.
Canton-Thompson J, Gebert K, Thompson B, Jones G, Calkin D, Donovan G (2008) External human factors in incident management team decision-making and their effect on large fire suppression expenditures. Journal of Forestry 106, 416–424.
Cohen JD (2008) The wildland–urban interface fire problem: a consequence of the fire exclusion paradigm. Forest History Today 20–26.
Collins RD, de Neufville R, Claro J, Oliveira T, Pacheco AP (2013) Forest fire management to avoid unintended consequences: a case study of Portugal using system dynamics. Journal of Environmental Management 130, 1–9.
| Forest fire management to avoid unintended consequences: a case study of Portugal using system dynamics.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Davis JB, Martin RE (Eds) (1987) Proceedings of the symposium on wildland fire 2000. USDA Forest Service, Pacific Southwest Forest and Range Experimental Research Station, General Technical Report PSW-101. (Berkeley, CA, USA)
DellaSala DA, Hanson CT (Eds) (2015) ‘The Ecological Importance of Mixed-Severity Fires: Nature’s Phoenix.’ (Elsevier Academic Press: Burlington, VT, USA)
Donovan GH (2005) An alternative incentive structure for wildfire management on National Forest land. Forest Science 51, 387–395.
Donovan GH, Brown TC (2007) Be careful what you wish for: the legacy of Smokey Bear. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 5, 73–79.
| Be careful what you wish for: the legacy of Smokey Bear.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Donovan GH, Brown TC (2008) Estimating the avoided fuel-treatment costs of wildfire. Western Journal of Applied Forestry 23, 197–201.
Donovan GH, Prestemon JP, Gebert KM (2011) The effect of newspaper coverage and political pressure on wildfire suppression costs. Society & Natural Resources 24, 785–798.
| The effect of newspaper coverage and political pressure on wildfire suppression costs.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Dunn CJ, Bailey JD (2016) Tree mortality and structural change following mixed-severity fire in Pseudotsuga forests of Oregon’s western Cascades, USA. Forest Ecology and Management 365, 107–118.
| Tree mortality and structural change following mixed-severity fire in Pseudotsuga forests of Oregon’s western Cascades, USA.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Finney MA, Grenfell IC, McHugh CW (2009) Modeling containment of large wildfires using generalized linear mixed-model analysis. Forest Science 55, 249–255.
Fischer AP, Spies TA, Steelman TA, Moseley C, Johnson BR, Bailey JD, Ager AA, Bourgeron P, Charnley S, Collins BM, Kline JD, Leahy JE, Littell JS, Millington JDA, Nielsen-Pincus M, Olsen CS, Paveglio TB, Roos CI, Steen-Adams MM, Stevens FR, Vukomanovic J, White EM, Bowman DMJS (2016) Wildfire risk as a socioecological pathology. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 14, 276–284.
| Wildfire risk as a socioecological pathology.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Gebert KM, Black AE (2012) Effect of suppression strategies on federal wildland fire expenditures. Journal of Forestry 110, 65–73.
| Effect of suppression strategies on federal wildland fire expenditures.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Houtman RM, Montgomery CA, Gagnon AR, Calkin DE, Dietterich TG, McGregor S, Crowley M (2013) Allowing a wildfire to burn: estimating the effect on future fire suppression costs. International Journal of Wildland Fire 22, 871–882.
| Allowing a wildfire to burn: estimating the effect on future fire suppression costs.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Hudson M (2011) ‘Fire Management in the American West: Forest Politics and the Rise of Megafires.’ (University of Colorado Press: Boulder, CO, USA)
Hutto RL, Keane RE, Sherriff RL, Rota CT, Eby LA, Saab VA (2016) Toward a more ecological informed view of severe forest fires. Ecosphere 7, 1–13.
| Toward a more ecological informed view of severe forest fires.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Ingalsbee T (2006) The war on wildfire: firefighting and the militarization of forest fire management. In ‘The Wildfire Reader: a Century of Failed Forest Policy’. (Ed. G Wuerthner) pp. 262–282. (Island Press: Sausalito, CA, USA)
Ingalsbee T (2015) Ecological fire use for ecological fire management: managing large wildfires by design. In ‘Proceedings of the Large Wildland Fires Conference’, 19–23 May 2014, Missoula, MT, USA. (Eds RE Keane, M Jolly, R Parsons, K Riley) USDA Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, Proceedings RMRS-P-73, pp. 120–127. (Fort Collins, CO, USA)
Ingalsbee T, Raja U (2015) The rising costs of wildfire suppression and the case for ecological fire use. In ‘The Ecological Importance of Mixed-Severity Fires: Nature’s Phoenix’. (Eds DA DellaSala, CT Hanson) pp. 348–371. (Elsevier Academic Press: Amsterdam, Netherlands)
Jensen SE, McPherson GR (2008) ‘Living with Fire: Fire Ecology and Policy for the Twenty-First Century.’ (University of California Press: Berkeley, CA, USA)
Kuhn TS (1996) ‘The Structure of Scientific Revolutions’, 3rd edn. (University of Chicago Press: Chicago, IL, USA)
Littell JS, McKenzie D, Peterson DL, Westerling AL (2009) Climate and wildfire area burned in western US ecoprovinces, 1916–2003. Ecological Applications 19, 1003–1021.
| Climate and wildfire area burned in western US ecoprovinces, 1916–2003.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Moritz MA, Batllori E, Bradstock RA, Gill AM, Handmer J, Hessburg PF, Leonard J, McCaffrey S, Odion DC, Schoennagel T, Syphard AD (2014) Learning to coexist with wildfire. Nature 515, 58–66.
| Learning to coexist with wildfire.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC2cXitFanu77P&md5=ce36b298954e3e2e3ed54dc193decb5cCAS |
Nelson TC (1979) Fire management policy in the national forests: a new era. Journal of Forestry 77, 723–725.
North M, Collins B, Stephens S (2012) Using fire to increase the scale, benefits, and future maintenance of fuels treatments. Journal of Forestry 110, 392–401.
| Using fire to increase the scale, benefits, and future maintenance of fuels treatments.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Odion DC, Hanson CT, Arsenault AA, Baker WL, DellaSala DA, Hutto RL, Klenner W, Moritz MA, Sherriff RL, Veblen TT, Williams MA (2014) Examining historical and current mixed-severity fire regimes in ponderosa pine and mixed-conifer forest of western North America. PLoS One 9, e87852
| Examining historical and current mixed-severity fire regimes in ponderosa pine and mixed-conifer forest of western North America.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Olson RL, Bengston DN, DeVaney LA, Thompson TAC (2015) Wildland fire management futures: insights from a foresight panel. USDA Forest Service, Northern Research Station, General Technical Report GTR-NRS-152. (Newtown Square, PA, USA)
Paveglio T, Norton T, Carroll MS (2011) Fanning the flames? Media coverage during wildfire events and its relation to broader societal understandings of the hazard. Human Ecology Review 18, 41–52.
Peterson DL, Millar CI, Joyce LA, Furniss MJ, Halofsky JE, Neilson RP, Morelli TL (2011) Responding to climate change in national forests: a guidebook for developing adaptation options. USDA Forest Service Pacific Northwest Research Station, General Technical Report PNW-GTR-855. (Portland, OR, USA)
Pyne SJ (1982) ‘Fire in America: a Cultural History of Wildland and Rural Fire.’ (University of Washington Press: Seattle, WA, USA)
Pyne SJ (2015) ‘Between Two Fires: a Fire History of Contemporary America.’ (University of Arizona Press: Tucson, AZ, USA)
Rothman HK (2007) ‘Blazing heritage: a history of wildland fire in the National Parks.’ (Oxford University Press: Oxford, NY, USA)
Short KC (2015) Sources and implications of bias and uncertainty in a century of US wildfire activity. International Journal of Wildland Fire 24, 883–891.
Snider G, Daugherty PJ, Wood D (2006) Irrationality of continued fire suppression: an avoided cost analysis of fire hazard reduction treatments versus no treatment. Journal of Forestry 104, 431–437.
Spies TA, White EM, Kline JD, Fischer AP, Ager AA, Bailey J, Bolte J, Koch J, Platt E, Olsen CS, Jacobs D, Shindler B, Steen-Adams MM, Hammer R (2014) Examining fire-prone forest landscapes as coupled human and natural systems. Ecology and Society 19, art9
| Examining fire-prone forest landscapes as coupled human and natural systems.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Steelman TA (2016) US wildfire governance as social-ecological problem. Ecology and Society 21, art3
| US wildfire governance as social-ecological problem.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Steelman TA, Burke CA (2007) Is wildfire policy in the United States sustainable? Journal of Forestry 105, 67–72.
Steelman TA, McCaffrey SM (2011) What is limiting more flexible fire management – public or agency pressure? Journal of Forestry 109, 454–461.
Stephens SL, Ruth LW (2005) Federal forest-fire policy in the United States. Ecological Applications 15, 532–542.
| Federal forest-fire policy in the United States.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Stephens SL, Sugihara NG (2006) Fire management and policy since European settlement. In ‘Fire in California’s Ecosystems’. (Eds NG Sugihara, JW van Wagtendonk, KE Shaffer, J Fites-Kauffman, AE Thode) pp. 431–443. (University of California Press: Berkeley, CA, USA)
Stonesifer CS, Thompson MP, Calkin DE (2015) Characterizing large airtanker use in United States fire management. In ‘Proceedings of the Large Wildland Fires Conference’, 19–23 May 2014, Missoula, MT, USA. (Eds RE Keane, M Jolly, R Parsons, K Riley) USDA Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, Proceedings RMRS-P-73, pp. 314–316. (Fort Collins, CO, USA)
Stonesifer CS, Calkin DE, Thompson MP, Stockmann KD (2016) Fighting fire in the heat of the day: an analysis of operational and environmental conditions of use for large airtankers in United States fire suppression. International Journal of Wildland Fire 25, 520–533.
| Fighting fire in the heat of the day: an analysis of operational and environmental conditions of use for large airtankers in United States fire suppression.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Thompson MP (2014) Social, institutional, and psychological factors affecting wildfire incident decision making. Society & Natural Resources 27, 636–644.
| Social, institutional, and psychological factors affecting wildfire incident decision making.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Thompson MP, Calkin DE, Herynk J, McHugh CW, Short KC (2013) Airtankers and wildfire management in the US Forest Service: examining data availability and exploring usage and cost trends. International Journal of Wildland Fire 22, 223–233.
| Airtankers and wildfire management in the US Forest Service: examining data availability and exploring usage and cost trends.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Thompson MP, Dunn C, Calkin DE (2015) Wildfires: systemic change required. Science 350, 920
| Wildfires: systemic change required.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC2MXhvFKrtb%2FK&md5=760caba0101e170194fa3e7bfeb0664fCAS |
USDA Forest Service (2016) Aerial firefighting use and effectiveness study. Available at https://www.fs.fed.us/managing-land/fire/aviation/afue [Verified 22 May 2017]
Venn TJ, Calkin DE (2011) Accommodating non-market values in evaluation of wildfire management in the United States: challenges and opportunities. International Journal of Wildland Fire 20, 327–339.
| Accommodating non-market values in evaluation of wildfire management in the United States: challenges and opportunities.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
