Does establishing lucerne under a cover crop increase farm financial risk?
T. L. Nordblom A D , T. R. Hutchings A , R. C. Hayes A B , G. D. Li A B and J. D. Finlayson CA Graham Centre for Agricultural Innovation (an alliance between Charles Sturt University and NSW Department of Primary Industries), Albert Pugsley Place, Wagga Wagga, NSW 2650, Australia.
B NSW Department of Primary Industries, Wagga Wagga Agricultural Institute, Pine Gully Road, Wagga Wagga, NSW 2650, Australia.
C John Finlayson Research Limited, Whangarei, New Zealand.
D Corresponding author. Email: tnordblom@csu.edu.au
Crop and Pasture Science 68(12) 1149-1157 https://doi.org/10.1071/CP16379
Submitted: 14 October 2016 Accepted: 15 October 2017 Published: 29 November 2017
Journal compilation © CSIRO 2017 Open Access CC BY-NC-ND
Abstract
Rainfed farms in south-eastern Australia often combine annual cropping and perennial pasture phases with grazing sheep enterprises. Such diversity serves in managing diseases, pests and plant nutrition while stabilising income in the face of wide, uncorrelated variations in international commodity prices and local weather over time. We use an actuarial accounting approach to capture the above contexts to render financial risk profiles in the form of distributions of decadal cash balances for a representative 1000-ha farm at Coolamon (34°50ʹS, 147°12ʹE) in New South Wales, Australia. For the soil and weather conditions at this location we pose the question of which approach is better when establishing the perennial pasture lucerne (Medicago sativa L.): sowing with the final crop of the cropping phase, or sowing alone following the final crop? It is less expensive to sow lucerne with the final crop, which can provide useful income from the sale of grain, but this practice can reduce pasture quantity and quality in poorer years. Although many years of field research have confirmed that sowing lucerne alone is the most reliable way to establish a pasture in this area, and years of extension messages to this effect have gone out to farmers, they often persist in sowing lucerne with their final cereal crops. For this region, counting all costs, we show that sowing lucerne alone can reduce farm financial risk (i.e. probability of negative decadal cash balances) at stocking rates >10 dry sheep equivalents (DSE)/ha, compared with the practice of sowing lucerne with a cover crop. Establishing lucerne alone allows the farmer the option to profitably run higher stocking rates for higher median decadal cash margins without additional financial risk. At low stocking rates (i.e. 5 DSE/ha), there appears to be no financial advantage of either establishment approach. We consider the level of equity, background farm debt and overhead costs to demonstrate how these also affect risk-profile positions of the two sowing options. For a farm that is deeply in debt, we cannot suggest either approach to establishing lucerne will lead to substantially better financial outcomes.
Additional keywords: alfalfa, dryland cropping, economics, farming systems, pasture simulation, risk management, sowing time.
References
Armstrong DP, Tarrant KA, Ho CKM, Malcolm LR, Wales WJ (2010) Evaluating development options for a rain-fed dairy farm in Gippsland. Animal Production Science 50, 363–370.| Evaluating development options for a rain-fed dairy farm in Gippsland.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
AWI (2011) Lifetimewool: more lambs, better wool, healthy ewes. Australian Wool Innovation, Sheep CRC. Available at: www.lifetimewool.com.au/Tools/NSWfeedtable.aspx
Behrendt K, Cacho O, Scott JM, Jones R (2006) Methodology for assessing optimal rates of pasture improvement in the high rainfall temperate pasture zone. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 46, 845–849.
| Methodology for assessing optimal rates of pasture improvement in the high rainfall temperate pasture zone.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Behrendt K, Cacho O, Scott JM, Jones R (2013) Optimising pasture and grazing management decisions on the Cicerone Project farmlets over variable time horizons. Animal Production Science 53, 796–805.
| Optimising pasture and grazing management decisions on the Cicerone Project farmlets over variable time horizons.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Cregan PD (1985) Managing the seedling for establishment. In ‘Pasture renovation. Proceedings Grasslands Society of Victoria 26th Annual Conference’. Melbourne, Vic. pp. 41–46. (Grasslands Society of Victoria)
Dear BS (1989) Establishment of subterranean clover under direct drilled cereal crops. In ‘Agronomy in a Mediterranean Environment. Proceedings 5th Australian Agronomy Conference’. Perth, W. Aust. (Australian Society of Agronomy) Available at: www.regional.org.au/au/asa/1989/contributed/pasture/p-03.htm
Donnelly JR, Freer M, Salmon L, Moore AD, Simpson RJ, Dove H, Bolger TP (2002) Evolution of the GRAZPLAN decision support tools and adoption by the grazing industry in temperate Australia. Agricultural Systems 74, 115–139.
| Evolution of the GRAZPLAN decision support tools and adoption by the grazing industry in temperate Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
French RJ, Schultz JE (1984) Water-use efficiency of wheat in a Mediterranean type environment. II. Some limitations to efficiency. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research 35, 765–775.
| Water-use efficiency of wheat in a Mediterranean type environment. II. Some limitations to efficiency.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Hardaker JB, Lien G, Anderson JR, Huirne RBM (2015) ‘Coping with risk in agriculture.’ Applied Decision Analysis. 3rd edn (CABI: Wallingford, UK)
Hutchings TR (2013) Managing financial risk on dryland farms in SE Australia. PhD Thesis, Charles Sturt University, Wagga Wagga, NSW, Australia. Available at: http://purl.umn.edu/204434
Hutchings TR, Nordblom T, Hayes R, Li GD (2014) Financial risk modelling with long-run weather and price variations: Effects of pasture options on the financial performance of a representative dryland farm at Coolamon, NSW, comparing results of average-year linear programming and sequential multivariate analysis (SMA). Future Farm Industries CRC Technical Report No. 14—Economic analysis. Available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=2495186
Hutchings T, Nordblom T, Hayes R, Li GD, Finlayson J (2016) A framework for modelling financial risk in Southern Australia: the intensive farming (IF) model. In ‘60th Annual Conference of the Australian Agricultural & Resource Economics Society’. (Contributed paper) 2–5 February 2016. Canberra, ACT. Available at: http://purl.umn.edu/235333
Li GD, Hayes RC, McCormick JI, Gardner MJ, Sandral GA, Dear BS (2014) Time of sowing and the presence of a cover-crop determine the productivity and persistence of perennial pastures in mixed farming systems. Crop & Pasture Science 65, 988–1001.
| Time of sowing and the presence of a cover-crop determine the productivity and persistence of perennial pastures in mixed farming systems.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Lien G, Hardaker JB, van Asseldonk MAPM, Richardson JW (2011) Risk programming analysis with imperfect information. Annals of Operations Research 190, 311–323.
| Risk programming analysis with imperfect information.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Llewellyn RS, Robertson MJ, Hayes RC, Ferris D, Descheemaeker K, Revell C (2014) Developing the role of perennial forages for crop–livestock farms: a strategic multi-disciplinary approach. Crop & Pasture Science 65, 945–955.
| Developing the role of perennial forages for crop–livestock farms: a strategic multi-disciplinary approach.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Malcolm LR, Makeham JP, Wright V (2005) ‘The farming game, agricultural management and marketing.’ 2nd edn (Cambridge University Press: Melbourne)
McCormick J, Li G, Hayes R, Casburn G, Gardner M, Sandral G, Peoples M, Swan T (2012a) A survey of farmer practice on the establishment, duration and production of pastures in the mixed farming zone of southern New South Wales. In ‘Capturing opportunities and overcoming obstacles in Australian agronomy. Proceedings 16th Australian Agronomy Conference’. 14–18 October 2012. Armidale, NSW. (Ed. I Yunusa) (Australian Society of Agronomy) Available at: www.regional.org.au/au/asa/2012/pastures/8077_mccormickji.htm
McCormick J, Hayes R, Li G, Nordblom T, Casburn G, Hutchings T, Moore AD, Zurcher E, Peoples M, Swan T (2012b) To under-sow or not? A decision support tool to determine the most profitable method of pasture establishment. In ‘Capturing opportunities and overcoming obstacles in Australian agronomy. Proceedings 16th Australian Agronomy Conference’. 14–18 October 2012. Armidale, NSW. (Ed. I Yunusa) (Australian Society of Agronomy) Available at: www.regional.org.au/au/asa/2012/pastures/8079_mccormickji.htm
McCormick JI, Hayes RC, Li GD, Norton MR (2014) A review of pasture establishment by under-sowing with special reference to the mixed farming zone of south-eastern Australia. Crop & Pasture Science 65, 956–972.
| A review of pasture establishment by under-sowing with special reference to the mixed farming zone of south-eastern Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
McDonald W, Orchard P (2017) Using DSEs and carrying capacities to compare sheep enterprises. NSW Department of Primary Industries. Available at: www.dpi.nsw.gov.au/agriculture/budgets/livestock/sheep-gross-margins-october-2015/background/dse
Moodie AWS (1936) Sowing lucerne with wheat. Light seedings for grazing stands in restricted rainfall areas. The Agricultural Gazette of New South Wales 47, 419–423.
Moore AD (2014) The case for and against perennial forages in the Australian sheep–wheat zone: modelling livestock production, business risk and environmental interactions. Animal Production Science 54, 2029–2041.
| The case for and against perennial forages in the Australian sheep–wheat zone: modelling livestock production, business risk and environmental interactions.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Nordblom TL, Hutchings TR, Hayes RC, Li GD (2015) A framework for modelling whole-farm financial risk. In ‘59th AARES Annual Conference’. (Selected paper) Rotorua, New Zealand, 10–13 February 2015. Available at: http://purl.umn.edu/202581
Nordblom TL, Hutchings TR, Li GD, Hayes RC, Finlayson JD (2016) Financial risk analysis of lucerne pasture establishment: under-sowing vs direct sowing. In ‘60th AARES Annual Conference’. (Contributed paper) Canberra, ACT, 2–5 February 2016. Available at: http://purl.umn.edu/235420
Nuthall PL (2011) ‘Farm business management: analysis of farming systems.’ (CAB International: Wallingford, UK)
Oliver YM, Robertson MJ, Stone PJ, Whitbread A (2009) Improving estimates of water-limited yield of wheat by accounting for soil type and within-season rainfall. Crop & Pasture Science 60, 1137–1146.
| Improving estimates of water-limited yield of wheat by accounting for soil type and within-season rainfall.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Rodriguez D, deVoil P, Power B, Cox H, Crimp S, Meinke H (2011) The intrinsic plasticity of farm businesses and their resilience to change. An Australian example. Field Crops Research 124, 157–170.
| The intrinsic plasticity of farm businesses and their resilience to change. An Australian example.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Scott JF, Lodge GM, McCormick LH (2000) Economics of increasing the persistence of sown pastures: costs, stocking rate and cash flow. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 40, 313–323.
| Economics of increasing the persistence of sown pastures: costs, stocking rate and cash flow.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Scott JF, Cacho OJ, Scott JM (2013) Economic risk analysis of different livestock management systems. Animal Production Science 53, 788–795.
| Economic risk analysis of different livestock management systems.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Sinnett A, Ho CKM, Malcolm B (2017) Expanding a dairy business affects business and financial risk. Animal Production Science 57, 2167–2174.
| Expanding a dairy business affects business and financial risk.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Smith JAC, Argyle DB (1964) Establishing wheatbelt pastures—don’t use a cover-crop. Journal of Agriculture Western Australia 5, 134–140.
Swan AD, Peoples MB, Hayes RC, Li GD, Casburn GR, McCormick JI, Dear BS (2014) Farmer experience with perennial pastures in the mixed farming areas of southern New South Wales: on-farm participatory research investigating pasture establishment with cover-cropping. Crop & Pasture Science 65, 973–987.
| Farmer experience with perennial pastures in the mixed farming areas of southern New South Wales: on-farm participatory research investigating pasture establishment with cover-cropping.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Trapnell L, Malcolm B (2014) Expected benefits on and off farm from including lucerne (Medicago sativa) in crop rotations on the Broken Plains of north-eastern Victoria. Australian Farm Business Management (AFBM) Journal 11, 19–40.
