Comparison of three Australian Merino strains for wool and body traits. II. Estimates of between-stud genetic parameters

Abstract

Data from two-tooth rams and ewes representing seven Australian Merino studs were analysed to provide estimates of between-stud genetic variances and between-stud genetic correlations for 20 wool and body traits. The estimates were used to compare two methods of choosing foundation animals for a new stud: selection within one stud or selection within each of several studs. Where only one trait was considered in selection, and provided that accurate estimates of stud mean breeding values were available, selection from a single stud was superior, although there were some differences between traits in the degree of superiority. Where more than one trait was considered the conclusion depended on the relative magnitudes and signs of the between and within-stud genetic and phenotypic correlations. In the particular case of selection for high clean fleece weight and fine fibre diameter, a strong unfavourable between-stud genetic correlation shifted the emphasis more toward selection from several studs, but selection from a single stud was still superior when accurate estimates of stud mean breeding values for clean fleece weight were available. When response to subsequent selection, as well as immediate gain in choice of founders, was considered, the conclusions were reversed. For a single trait, selection from several studs was always superior in the long term (three or more generations), and also in the short term when accurate estimates of stud mean breeding values were not available.