Modelling the reduction in enteric methane from voluntary intake versus controlled individual animal intake of lipid or nitrate supplements
David Cottle A C and Richard Eckard B
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations
A School of Environmental and Rural Science, University of New England, NSW 2351, Australia.
B Faculty of Veterinary and Agricultural Sciences, University of Melbourne, VIC 3010, Australia.
C Corresponding author. Email: david.cottle@une.edu.au
Animal Production Science 54(12) 2121-2131 https://doi.org/10.1071/AN14464
Submitted: 1 April 2014 Accepted: 26 July 2014 Published: 29 August 2014
Abstract
In 2011, the Australian government introduced a voluntary carbon offset scheme called the Carbon Farming Initiative (CFI), which provides an incentive mechanism for farmers to earn carbon credits by lowering greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions or sequestering carbon. In Australia, there is now interest in developing offset methods for controlled feeding of lipids or nitrates to livestock, where individual animal daily supplement intake is controlled and recorded. Carbon offset methodologies are being drafted that require the impact of voluntary versus controlled feeding of these supplements on methane mitigation to be modelled. This paper presents modelling results and tests the hypothesis that controlled feeding would result in higher mitigation than would voluntary, uncontrolled feeding. Controlled feeding with all animals either having the same average supplement intake (C1) or having a controlled maximum intake (C2) resulted in higher herd- or flock-scale methane mitigation than did voluntary, uncontrolled feeding (VFI) from the same total amount of supplement fed. The percentage reductions in methane from C1 and C2 feeding patterns versus VFI were relatively greater at higher levels of both lipid and nitrate supplementation. The modelled effect of higher methane production from VFI than from C1 or C2 was larger for nitrate than for lipid supplements. Controlled feeding can be expected to result in a far more even and consistent intake per animal than from VFI. Any supplementation aimed at reducing enteric methane is therefore more effectively administered through some form of controlled feeding. Also, due to the potential toxicity from excess intake of nitrate, controlled supplementation is far less likely to lead to excessive intake and toxicity.
Additional keywords: carbon offset methodologies.
References
Bannink A, Kogut J, Dijkstra J, France J, Kebreab E, Van Vuuren AM, Tamminga S (2006) Estimation of the stoichiometry of volatile fatty acid production in the rumen of lactating cows. Journal of Theoretical Biology 238, 36–51.| Estimation of the stoichiometry of volatile fatty acid production in the rumen of lactating cows.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD2MXht1Oms7jN&md5=45dade30c3d863e7c6b284f978bb5874CAS | 16111711PubMed |
Bannink A, van Schijndel MW, Dijkstra J (2011) A model of enteric fermentation in dairy cows to estimate methane emission for the Dutch National Inventory Report using the IPCC Tier 3 approach. Animal Feed Science and Technology 166–167, 603–618.
| A model of enteric fermentation in dairy cows to estimate methane emission for the Dutch National Inventory Report using the IPCC Tier 3 approach.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Beauchemin KA, Kreuzer M, O’Mara F, McAllister TA (2008) Nutritional management for enteric methane abatement: a review. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 48, 21–27.
| Nutritional management for enteric methane abatement: a review.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD1cXovVGn&md5=26636171128f28fd501de1857924926bCAS |
Benchaar C, Rivest J, Pomar C, Chiquette J (1998) Prediction of methane production from dairy cows using existing mechanistic models and regression equations. Journal of Animal Science 76, 617–627.
Blair GJ, Nicolson AJ (1975) The occurrence of sulphur deficiency in temperate Australia. In ‘Sulphur in Australasian agriculture’. (Ed. KD McLachlan) pp. 127–136. (Sydney University Press: Sydney)
Bowman JG, Sowell BF (1997) Delivery method and supplement consumption by grazing ruminants: a review. Journal of Animal Science 75, 543–550.
Bradley WB, Eppson HF, Beath OA (1940) Livestock poisoning by oat hay and other plants containing nitrate. Wyoming Agricultural Experimental Station Bulletin 241, [cited by Crawford et al. 1966].
Cockwill CL, McAllister TA, Olson ME, Milligan DN, Ralston BJ, Huisma C, Hand RK (2000) Individual intake of mineral and molasses supplements by cows, heifers and calves. Canadian Journal of Animal Science 80, 681–690.
| Individual intake of mineral and molasses supplements by cows, heifers and calves.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD3MXitlCgtro%3D&md5=16917f8c4914e6664df38af3d00603fbCAS |
Comlaw (2011) Carbon credits (Carbon Farming Initiative) Act 2011 – C2011A00101. Available at http://www.comlaw.gov.au/Details/C2011A00101 [Verified 25 June 2014]
Comlaw (2013) Carbon credits (Carbon Farming Initiative) (reducing greenhouse gas emissions by feeding dietary additives to milking cows) methodology determination 2013. Available at http://www.comlaw.gov.au/Details/F2013L01554 [Verified 19 March 2014]
Cottle DJ (2013) The trials and tribulations of estimating the pasture intake of grazing animals. Animal Production Science 53, 1209–1220.
| The trials and tribulations of estimating the pasture intake of grazing animals.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Cottle DJ, Nolan JVN, Wiedemann S (2011) Ruminant enteric methane mitigation: a review. Animal Production Science 51, 491–514.
| Ruminant enteric methane mitigation: a review.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC3MXntVGisLY%3D&md5=5199c518bcbf607cd2261a9a90b2975eCAS |
Crawford RF, Kennedy WK, Davison KL (1966) Factors influencing the toxicity of forages that contain nitrate when fed to cattle. The Cornell Veterinarian 56, 3–17.
DelCurto T, Olson KC, Hess B, Huston E (2000) Optimal supplementation strategies for beef cattle consuming low-quality forages in the Western United States. Journal of Animal Science 77, 1–16.
Department of Environment (2014a) Australian National Greenhouse Accounts. National Inventory Report 2012. Available at http://www.environment.gov.au/node/35779 [Verified 25 June 2014]
Department of Environment (2014b) An overview of the Carbon Farming Initiative. Available at http://www.climatechange.gov.au/reducing-carbon/carbon-farming-initiative/about-cfi [Verified 25 June 2014]
Dijkstra J, Neal HDSC, Beever DE, France J (1992) Simulation of nutrient digestion, absorption and outflow in the rumen: model description. The Journal of Nutrition 122, 2239–2256.
Dixon RM, Smith DR, Porch I, Petherick JC (2001) Effects of experience on voluntary intake of supplements by cattle. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 41, 581–592.
| Effects of experience on voluntary intake of supplements by cattle.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD3MXmvVersrc%3D&md5=9987a1c38e05ff233d6537db30b87c4dCAS |
Dixon RM, White A, Fry P, Petherick JC (2003) Effects of supplement type and previous experience on variability in intake of supplements by heifers. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research 54, 529–540.
| Effects of supplement type and previous experience on variability in intake of supplements by heifers.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Eckard RJ (1990) The relationship between the nitrogen and nitrate content and nitrate toxicity potential of Lolium multiflorum. Journal of the Grassland Society of Southern Africa 7, 174–178.
| The relationship between the nitrogen and nitrate content and nitrate toxicity potential of Lolium multiflorum.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Eckard RJ, Grainger C, de Klein CAM (2010) Options for the abatement of methane and nitrous oxide from ruminant production: a review. Livestock Science 130, 47–56.
| Options for the abatement of methane and nitrous oxide from ruminant production: a review.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Eggington AR, McCosker TH, Arnold CA (1990) Intake of lick block supplements by cattle grazing native monsoonal tallgrass pastures in the Northern Territory. Australian Rangeland Journal 12, 7–13.
| Intake of lick block supplements by cattle grazing native monsoonal tallgrass pastures in the Northern Territory.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Ellis JL, Dijkstra J, Kebreab E, Bannink A, Odongo NE, McBride BW, France J (2008) Aspects of rumen microbiology central to mechanistic modelling of methane production in cattle. The Journal of Agricultural Science 146, 213–233.
| Aspects of rumen microbiology central to mechanistic modelling of methane production in cattle.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD1cXjs12kuro%3D&md5=094e65bd32dcf71ad8fcbedc978d1c52CAS |
Farra PA, Satter LD (1971) Manipulation of the ruminal fermentation. III. Effect of nitrate on ruminal volatile fatty acid production and milk composition. Journal of Dairy Science 54, 1018–1024.
| Manipulation of the ruminal fermentation. III. Effect of nitrate on ruminal volatile fatty acid production and milk composition.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DyaE3MXksVKgur4%3D&md5=00e76480de3774c07a3e1460b1d96dbaCAS |
Forbes JM, Mayes RW (2002) Food choice. In ‘Sheep nutrition’. (Eds M Freer, H Dove) pp. 51–69. (CABI International: Wallingford, UK)
Garces-Yepez P, Kunkle WE, Bates DB, Moore JE, Thatcher WW, Sollenberger LE (1997) Effects of supplemental energy source and amount on forage intake and performance by steers and intake and diet digestibility by sheep. Journal of Animal Science 75, 1918–1925.
Garossino KC, Ralston BJ, McAllister TA, Milligan DN, Royan G, Olson ME (2001) Individual intake and antiparasitic efficacy of free choice mineral and fenbendazole in range calves. Veterinary Parasitology 94, 151–162.
| Individual intake and antiparasitic efficacy of free choice mineral and fenbendazole in range calves.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD3cXoslKnu7k%3D&md5=45b2275dbd8053d5a2c0c94791e1edc4CAS | 11113546PubMed |
Garossino KC, Ralston BJ, Olson ME, McAllister TA, Milligan DN, Genswein BMA (2005) Individual intake and antiparasitic efficacy of free choice mineral containing fenbendazole for grazing steers. Veterinary Parasitology 129, 35–41.
| Individual intake and antiparasitic efficacy of free choice mineral containing fenbendazole for grazing steers.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD2MXivF2jtLw%3D&md5=e759445a1aca3c68cd930ad6a2e44e52CAS | 15817200PubMed |
Goodrich RD, Emerick RJ, Embry LB (1964) Effect of sodium nitrate on the vitamin A nutrition of sheep. Journal of Animal Science 23, 100–104.
Grainger C, Beauchemin KA (2011) Can enteric methane emissions from ruminants be lowered without lowering their production? Animal Feed Science and Technology 166–167, 308–320.
| Can enteric methane emissions from ruminants be lowered without lowering their production?Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Grainger C, Clarke T, Beauchemin KA, McGinn SM, Eckard RJ (2008) Supplementation with whole cottonseed reduces methane emissions and can profitably increase milk production of dairy cows offered a forage and cereal grain diet. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 48, 73–76.
| Supplementation with whole cottonseed reduces methane emissions and can profitably increase milk production of dairy cows offered a forage and cereal grain diet.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD1cXovVKm&md5=4093b5a206133b9cd8ed8e589eddcd2bCAS |
Horn GW, Beck PA, Andrae JG, Paisley SI (2005) Designing supplements for stocker cattle grazing wheat pasture. Journal of Animal Science 83, E69–E78.
Hulshof RBA, Berndt A, Gerrits WJJ, Dijkstra J, van Zijderveld SM, Newbold JR, Perdok HB (2012) Dietary nitrate supplementation reduces methane emission in beef cattle fed sugarcane-based diets. Journal of Animal Science 90, 2317–2323.
| Dietary nitrate supplementation reduces methane emission in beef cattle fed sugarcane-based diets.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC38XhtFehsbjN&md5=96a48ee0214f4fa24c2e164cb62708e8CAS |
Kahn LP (1994) The use of lithium chloride for estimating supplement intake in grazing sheep: estimates of heritability and repeatability. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research 45, 1731–1739.
| The use of lithium chloride for estimating supplement intake in grazing sheep: estimates of heritability and repeatability.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DyaK2MXitlGqtbs%3D&md5=592c138be136a1b9560aab4ae829efa7CAS |
Kemp A, Geurink JH, Haalstra RT, Malestein A (1977) Nitrate poisoning in cattle. 2. Changes in nitrite in rumen fluid and methemoglobin formation in blood after high nitrate intake. Netherlands Journal of Agricultural Science 25, 51–62.
Kincheloe JJ (2004) Variation in supplement intake by grazing beef cows. Master of Science Thesis, Animal and Range Sciences, Montana State University, Bozeman, MT.
Leng RA (2008) The potential of feeding nitrate to reduce enteric methane production in ruminants. A report to the Department of Climate Change. Available at http://www.penambulbooks.com/Downloads/Leng-FinalModified17-9-2008.pdf [Verified 19 March 2014]
Li L, Silveira CI, Nolan JV, Godwin IR, Leng RA, Hegarty RS (2013) Effect of added dietary nitrate and elemental sulfur on wool growth and methane emission of Merino lambs. Animal Production Science 53, 1195–1201.
| Effect of added dietary nitrate and elemental sulfur on wool growth and methane emission of Merino lambs.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC3sXhsFGgsrvO&md5=6de68170013c08aaac3a9c45d6a9ae4eCAS |
Manzano RP, Paterson J, Harbac MM, Lima Filho RO (2012) The effect of season on supplemental mineral intake and behavior by grazing steers. The Professional Animal Scientist 28, 73–81.
Marais JP (1988) Effect of nitrate and its reduction products on the growth and activity of the rumen microbial population. The British Journal of Nutrition 59, 301–313.
| Effect of nitrate and its reduction products on the growth and activity of the rumen microbial population.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DyaL1cXhsV2js7Y%3D&md5=5f130d85ff477ca3cde11b46df9db3b6CAS | 3358930PubMed |
McAllister TA, Newbold CJ (2008) Redirecting rumen fermentation to reduce methanogenesis. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 48, 7–13.
| Redirecting rumen fermentation to reduce methanogenesis.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD1cXovVKh&md5=2cf3f257293eca4b5ea313d16a0d7e84CAS |
McKenzie RA, Rayner AC, Thompson GK, Pidgeon GF, Burren BR (2004) Nitrate-nitrite toxicity in cattle and sheep grazing Dactyloctenium radulans (button grass) in stockyards. Australian Veterinary Journal 82, 630–634.
| Nitrate-nitrite toxicity in cattle and sheep grazing Dactyloctenium radulans (button grass) in stockyards.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:STN:280:DC%2BD2M3kvVenug%3D%3D&md5=341a45077d14d3cdb15f9f8b1d9ee1d0CAS | 15887389PubMed |
Mills JAN, Dijkstra J, Bannink A, Cammell SB, Kebreab E, France J (2001) A mechanistic model of whole-tract digestion and methanogenesis in the lactating dairy cow: model development, evaluation, and application. Journal of Animal Science 79, 1584–1597.
Moate PJ, Williams SRO, Grainger C, Hannah MC, Ponnampalam EN, Eckard RJ (2011) Influence of cold-pressed canola, brewers grains and hominy meal as dietary supplements suitable for reducing enteric methane emissions from lactating dairy cows. Animal Feed Science and Technology 166–167, 254–264.
| Influence of cold-pressed canola, brewers grains and hominy meal as dietary supplements suitable for reducing enteric methane emissions from lactating dairy cows.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
National Academy of Sciences (NAS) (1972) ‘Accumulation of nitrate.’ 106 p (National Academy of Sciences: Washington, DC, USA)
National Inventory Report (2010) Australian National Greenhouse Accounts. National Inventory Report 2010. The Australian Government Submission to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change April 2012. Department of Climate Change and Energy Efficiency, Canberra.
Nolan JV, Hegarty RS, Hegarty J, Godwin IR, Woodgate R (2010) Effects of dietary nitrate on fermentation, methane production and digesta kinetics in sheep. Animal Production 50, 801–806.
| Effects of dietary nitrate on fermentation, methane production and digesta kinetics in sheep.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC3cXhtVyrtbzP&md5=fec0fdf6d058f63b6cb019493a242d75CAS |
O’Hara PJ, Fraser AJ (1975) Nitrate poisoning in cattle grazing crops. New Zealand Veterinary Journal 23, 45–53.
| Nitrate poisoning in cattle grazing crops.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:STN:280:DyaE28%2FjtVKnuw%3D%3D&md5=c7802c19cfa583e865bf353149a89f7bCAS | 1101114PubMed |
Pinder AG, Pittaway E, Morris K, James PE (2009) Nitrite directly vasodilates hypoxic vasculature via nitric oxide-dependent and -independent pathways. British Journal of Pharmacology 157, 1523–1530.
| Nitrite directly vasodilates hypoxic vasculature via nitric oxide-dependent and -independent pathways.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD1MXhsVKmu7jN&md5=0104f78e0f960a3abea667838a23e2afCAS | 19594749PubMed |
Poore M, Green J, Rogers G, Spivey K, Dugan K (2000) Nitrate management in beef cattle. North Carolina College of Agriculture and Life Sciences. Available at http://www.cals.ncsu.edu/an_sci/extension/animal/nutr/nitrate%20management%20in%20beef.pdf [Verified 25 June 2014]
Rimington C, Quin JI (1933) Studies on the photosensitisation of animals in South Africa. II. The presence of a lethal factor in certain members of the plant genus Tribulus. Onderstepoort Journal of Veterinary Science and Animal Industry 1, 469–489.
Sakai K, Hirooka YM, Matsuo I, Eshima K, Shigematsu H, Shimokawa H, Takeshita A (2000) Overexpression of eNOS in NTS causes hypotension and bradycardia in vivo. Hypertension 36, 1023–1028.
| Overexpression of eNOS in NTS causes hypotension and bradycardia in vivo.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD3MXitlSgtw%3D%3D&md5=8d3b17c0b547630e6a490f12041abdeeCAS | 11116119PubMed |
Sowell BF, Bowman JGP, Grings EE, MacNeil MD (2003) Liquid supplement and forage intake by range beef cows. Journal of Animal Science 81, 294–303.
Undersander D, Combs D, Shaver R, Thomas D (2013) Nitrate poisoning in cattle, sheep and goats. Available at http://www.uwex.edu/ces/forage/pubs/nitrate.htm#_ftn1 [Verified 25 June 2014]
Ungerfeld EM, Kohn RA (2006) The role of thermodynamics in the control of ruminal fermentation. In ‘Ruminant physiology: digestion, metabolism and impact of nutrition on gene expression, immunology and stress’. (Eds K Sejrsen, T Hvelplund, MO Nielsen) pp. 55–85. (Wageningen Academic Publishers: Wageningen, The Netherlands)
Van Middelaar CE, Dijkstra J, Berentsen PBM, De Boer IJM (2014) Cost-effectiveness of feeding strategies to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from dairy farming. Journal of Dairy Science 97, 2427–2439.
| Cost-effectiveness of feeding strategies to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from dairy farming.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC2cXhs1Glt7s%3D&md5=f6967071cfd8840edb6fb9e3ec7f4a98CAS | 24485690PubMed |
van Zijderveld SM (2011) Dietary strategies to reduce methane emissions from ruminants 132 pp, PhD Thesis, Wageningen University, Wageningen, The Netherlands. Available at http://edepot.wur.nl/179281 [Verified 25 June 2014]
van Zijderveld SM, Gerrits WJJ, Apajalahti JA, Newbold JR, Dijkstra J, Leng RA, Perdok HB (2010) Nitrate and sulfate: effective alternative hydrogen sinks for mitigation of ruminal methane production in sheep. Journal of Dairy Science 93, 5856–5866.
| Nitrate and sulfate: effective alternative hydrogen sinks for mitigation of ruminal methane production in sheep.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC3MXjs1Kis7Y%3D&md5=2c90a9348249f958588d724bd6912c2aCAS | 21094759PubMed |
van Zijderveld SM, Gerrits WJJ, Dijkstra J, Newbold JR, Hulshof RBA, Perdok HB (2011) Persistency of methane mitigation by dietary nitrate supplementation in dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science 94, 4028–4038.
| Persistency of methane mitigation by dietary nitrate supplementation in dairy cows.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC3MXpsVylur4%3D&md5=b403e5eac8ed8ca1f5a91dddfa81918fCAS | 21787938PubMed |
Weichenthal BA, Embry LB, Emerick RJ, Whetzal FW (1963) Influence of sodium nitrate, vitamin A and protein level, on feedlol performance and vitamin A status of fattening cattle. Journal of Animal Science 22, 979–984.
Whatman S, Godwin IR, Nolan JV (2013) Nitrite toxicity in sheep: hypotension or methaemoglobinaemia. In ‘Recent advances in animal nutrition’. (Ed. P Cronje) (University of New England: Armidale, NSW)
Yaremcio B (1991) Nitrate poisoning and feeding nitrate feeds to livestock. Agdex 400/60-1, Government of Alberta, Agricultural and Rural Development. Available at http://www1.agric.gov.ab.ca/$department/deptdocs.nsf/all/agdex851 [Verified 25 June 2014]
