Reflections on the concept, conduct and findings of the producer-led Cicerone Project
T. Coventry A , H. Sutherland B , M. Waters C , P. Dutton D , B. Gream E , R. Croft F , E. Hall G , D. R. Paull H , C. Edwards I , R. Marchant J , P. Smith K , J. M. Scott L N , C. Gaden M and J. Hoad L
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations
A ‘Bailey Park’, Armidale, NSW, 2350, Australia.
B ‘Deeargee’, Uralla, NSW 2358, Australia.
C ‘Riverton’, Armidale, NSW 2350, Australia.
D ‘Wyanga’, Uralla, NSW 2358, Australia.
E Quambaloo Pastoral Company, Armidale, NSW 2350, Australia.
F ‘Dunvegan’, Uralla, NSW 2358, Australia.
G 111 Margaret Street, Launceston, Tas. 7250, Australia.
H CSIRO Livestock Industries, Armidale, NSW 2350, Australia.
I NSW Department of Primary Industries, Armidale, NSW 2350, Australia.
J Formerly, NSW Department of Primary Industries, Armidale, NSW 2350, Australia.
K NSW TAFE, Armidale, NSW 2350, Australia.
L School of Environmental and Rural Science, University of New England, Armidale, NSW 2351, Australia.
M ‘Beaumont’, Invergowrie, NSW 2350, Australia.
N Corresponding author. Email: dr.jimscott@gmail.com
Animal Production Science 53(8) 856-868 https://doi.org/10.1071/AN12292
Submitted: 18 August 2012 Accepted: 6 November 2012 Published: 10 July 2013
Journal Compilation © CSIRO Publishing 2013 Open Access CC BY-NC-ND
Abstract
The Cicerone Project began as a producer-led partnership that sought, over a period of 8 years, to enhance the profitability and sustainability of livestock enterprises by improving the connection between those producers, research and extension. Following a detailed survey, the research and extension needs of livestock producers were identified and several applied investigations were conducted to meet those needs and delivered through a range of extension activities. This final paper of the Cicerone Special Issue reflects on the entire Project from a wide array of perspectives, including livestock producers, researchers, extension specialists and staff employed by the Project, all of whom are authors of this paper.
A notable early successful outcome of the Project was the improved precision of footrot diagnosis, which has been of value to the entire sheep industry, and that flowed from a field investigation of benign and virulent footrot combined with detailed genetic investigations, which led to an improved testing regime.
This paper also reflects on the findings of an unreplicated agricultural ecosystem research trial, which measured the impact of pasture renovation, increased soil fertility and grazing management on the profitability and sustainability of three different 53-ha farmlets. Valuable findings from this whole-farmlet trial included the need for a high quality feed supply for increasing stocking rate and animal liveweights; the ability and utility of satellite imagery to detect changes in pasture growth, composition and recent grazing pressure; the value of short grazing and long rest periods for controlling Barber’s pole worms of sheep; the impact of increased stocking rates on whole-farm profitability and risk; methods of optimising decisions relating to pasture renovation, fertiliser applications and grazing management; and an integrated analysis of all key measured components of the farmlet management systems. Collectively, these findings were powerful as they were demonstrated at a scale credible to livestock producers using the ‘compare – measure – learn – adopt’ approach, which was the key philosophy adopted by the Cicerone Project.
By comparing and measuring different whole-farm systems, and by ensuring that producers had ownership of the trial process, the Project successfully delivered objective findings that producers trusted and which increased our understanding of important drivers of complex grazing enterprises under variable climatic conditions. Some of these drivers included: the influence of soil phosphorus on botanical composition and subsequent livestock production, the role of pasture renovation and soil fertility on herbage supply, herbage quality and stocking rate, and the improved gastrointestinal nematode control delivered by intensive rotational grazing.
The beneficiaries of the Project included the 180 farmer members who participated in some 61 field days and workshops; the research and extension collaborators including four postgraduates who completed their research investigations in conjunction with the Project; and some 500 undergraduate and 300 technical students who benefited from coming to understand the applied field comparisons of the three whole-farmlet systems. Having livestock producers play a significant leadership role led to valuable outcomes achieved with research collaborators; this should encourage the development of other learning partnerships which aim to explore complex farming system issues.
References
Andrew MH, Lodge GM, Mason WK, Price RJ (2003) The Sustainable Grazing Systems National Experiment. 2. Scientific outcomes and effectiveness of the research and development processes. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 43, 993–1013.| The Sustainable Grazing Systems National Experiment. 2. Scientific outcomes and effectiveness of the research and development processes.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Bamberry G, Dunn T, Lamont A (1997) ‘A pilot study on the relationship between farmer education and good farm management.’ (Rural Industries Research & Development Corporation: Canberra, ACT). Available at https://rirdc.infoservices.com.au/items/97-030 [Verified 8 January 8 2013]
Behrendt K, Cacho O, Scott JM, Jones R (2006) Methodology for assessing optimal rates of pasture improvement in the high rainfall temperate pasture zone. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 46, 845–849.
| Methodology for assessing optimal rates of pasture improvement in the high rainfall temperate pasture zone.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Behrendt K, Cacho O, Scott JM, Jones R (2013a) Optimising pasture and grazing management decisions on the Cicerone Project farmlets over variable time horizons. Animal Production Science 53, 796–805.
| Optimising pasture and grazing management decisions on the Cicerone Project farmlets over variable time horizons.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Behrendt K, Scott JM, Cacho O, Jones R (2013b) Simulating the impact of fertiliser strategies and prices on the economics of developing and managing the Cicerone Project farmlets under climatic uncertainty. Animal Production Science 53, 806–816.
| Simulating the impact of fertiliser strategies and prices on the economics of developing and managing the Cicerone Project farmlets under climatic uncertainty.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Behrendt K, Scott JM, Mackay DF, Murison R (2013c) Comparing the climate experienced during the Cicerone farmlet experiment against the climatic record. Animal Production Science 53, 658–669.
| Comparing the climate experienced during the Cicerone farmlet experiment against the climatic record.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Bouma J, de Vos JA, Sonneveld MPW, Heuvelink GBM, Stoorvogel JJ (2008) The role of scientists in multiscale land use analysis: lessons learned from Dutch communities of practice. In ‘Advances in Agronomy’, Vol. 97. (Ed. LS Donald) pp. 175–237. (Academic Press)
Brien FD, Jaensch KS, Grimson RJ, Kemper KE, Smith DH, Hebart ML, Ramsay AMM (2005) Selection demonstration flocks – what have we learnt? In ‘Proceedings of the 16th Association for the Advancement of Animal Breeding and Genetics conference’. Noosa Lakes, Queensland 16. pp. 322–325. (AAABG: Moorooka, Qld). Available at http://www.aaabg.org/livestocklibrary/2005/322brien.pdf [Verified 7 December 2012]
Bywater AC (1990) Exploitation of the systems approach in technical design of agricultural enterprises. In ‘Systems theory applied to agriculture and the food chain’. (Eds J Jones, P Street) pp. 61–88. (Elsevier Applied Science: London)
Carberry PS (2001) Are science rigour and industry relevance both achievable in participatory action research? In ‘10th Australian agronomy conference’. Hobart, Tasmania. (Eds B Rowe, M Donatelli, N Mendham) (Australian Society of Agronomy: Hobart) Available at http://regional.org.au/au/asa/2001/plenary/5/carberry.htm?print=1 [Verified 7 December 2012]
Cawood M (2004) Working with Nature on Lana. In ‘The Land’. July 26, 2004.
Cheetham BF, Tanjung LR, Sutherland M, Druitt J, Green G, McFarlane J, Bailey GD, Seaman JT, Katz ME (2006) Improved diagnosis of virulent ovine footrot using the intA gene. Veterinary Microbiology 116, 166–174.
| Improved diagnosis of virulent ovine footrot using the intA gene.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD28XnsFyntb0%3D&md5=7956d6022cd25bc6713eb8dd716b779eCAS | 16716540PubMed |
Chen W, Blair G, Scott J, Lefroy R (1999) Nitrogen and sulfur dynamics of contrasting grazed pastures. Australian Journal of Agricultural Research 50, 1381–1392.
| Nitrogen and sulfur dynamics of contrasting grazed pastures.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Clark DA (2010) Contribution of farmlet scale research in New Zealand and Australia to improved dairy farming systems. In ‘Proceedings of the 4th Australasian dairy science symposium’. Lincoln University, Christchurch, New Zealand. (Eds GR Edwards, RH Bryant) pp. 112–124. (Caxton Press: Christchurch, New Zealand) Available at http://www.sciquest.org.nz/node/69343 [Verified 7 December 2012]
Colvin AF, Walkden-Brown SW, Knox MR, Scott JM (2008) Intensive rotational grazing assists control of gastrointestinal nematodosis of sheep in a cool temperate environment with summer-dominant rainfall. Veterinary Parasitology 153, 108–120.
| Intensive rotational grazing assists control of gastrointestinal nematodosis of sheep in a cool temperate environment with summer-dominant rainfall.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:STN:280:DC%2BD1c3ivVSisA%3D%3D&md5=fa1fe9efa94c6be0d4f342455e6e43b7CAS | 18339483PubMed |
Cottle D, Gaden CA, Hoad J, Lance D, Smith J, Scott JM (2013) The effects of pasture inputs and intensive rotational grazing on superfine wool production, quality and income. Animal Production Science 53, 750–764.
| The effects of pasture inputs and intensive rotational grazing on superfine wool production, quality and income.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Earl J, Jones C (1996) The need for a new approach to grazing management – is cell grazing the answer? The Rangeland Journal 18, 327–350.
| The need for a new approach to grazing management – is cell grazing the answer?Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Edwards C, Gaden C, Marchant R, Coventry T, Dutton P, Scott JM (2013) Delivering extension and adult learning outcomes from the Cicerone Project by ‘comparing, measuring, learning and adopting’. Animal Production Science 53, 827–840.
| Delivering extension and adult learning outcomes from the Cicerone Project by ‘comparing, measuring, learning and adopting’.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Forté-Gardner O, Young FL, Dillman DA, Carroll MS (2004) Increasing the effectiveness of technology transfer for conservation cropping systems through research and field design. Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems 19, 199–209.
| Increasing the effectiveness of technology transfer for conservation cropping systems through research and field design.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Gaden CA, Cheetham BF, Hall E, Green G, Katz ME (2013) Producer-initiated field research leads to a new diagnostic test for footrot. Animal Production Science 53, 610–617.
| Producer-initiated field research leads to a new diagnostic test for footrot.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Guppy CN, Edwards C, Blair GJ, Scott JM (2013) Whole-farm management of soil nutrients drives productive grazing systems: the Cicerone farmlet experiment confirms earlier research. Animal Production Science 53, 649–657.
| Whole-farm management of soil nutrients drives productive grazing systems: the Cicerone farmlet experiment confirms earlier research.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Hinch GN, Hoad J, Lollback M, Hatcher S, Marchant R, Colvin A, Scott JM, Mackay D (2013a) Livestock weights in response to three whole-farmlet management systems. Animal Production Science 53, 727–739.
| Livestock weights in response to three whole-farmlet management systems.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Hinch GN, Lollback M, Hatcher S, Hoad J, Marchant R, Mackay DF, Scott JM (2013b) Effects of three whole-farmlet management systems on Merino ewe fat scores and reproduction. Animal Production Science 53, 740–749.
| Effects of three whole-farmlet management systems on Merino ewe fat scores and reproduction.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Hutchinson KJ (1997) Grazing systems. In ‘CSIRO Armidale: fifty years of pastoral research, 1947–1997’. (Ed. JL Wheeler) pp. 35–66. (CSIRO Division of Animal Production: Armidale, NSW)
Ison RL, Russell DB (Eds) (2000) ‘Agricultural extension and rural development: breaking out of traditions.’ (Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK)
Jones RM, Jones RJ, McDonald CK (1995) Some advantages of long-term grazing trials, with particular reference to changes in botanical composition. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 35, 1029–1038.
| Some advantages of long-term grazing trials, with particular reference to changes in botanical composition.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Kaine G, Doyle B, Sutherland H, Scott JM (2013) Surveying the management practices and research needs of graziers in the New England region of New South Wales. Animal Production Science 53, 602–609.
| Surveying the management practices and research needs of graziers in the New England region of New South Wales.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Kemp DR, Michalk DL, Virgona JM (2000) Towards more sustainable pastures: lessons learnt. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 40, 343–356.
| Towards more sustainable pastures: lessons learnt.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Keys MJ, Orchard PW (2000) The Prime Pasture Program – using marketing concepts to achieve technology transfer. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 40, 541–546.
| The Prime Pasture Program – using marketing concepts to achieve technology transfer.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Lodge GM, Orchard BA (2000) Effects of grazing management on Sirosa phalaris herbage mass and persistence in a predominantly summer rainfall environment. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 40, 155–169.
| Effects of grazing management on Sirosa phalaris herbage mass and persistence in a predominantly summer rainfall environment.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Mason WK, Lamb K, Russell B (2003) The Sustainable Grazing Systems Program: new solutions for livestock producers. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 43, 663–672.
| The Sustainable Grazing Systems Program: new solutions for livestock producers.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
McClymont GL (1970) The perpetual pentogram: evolution, ecology, economics, ethics and education. In ‘Proceedings of the Ecological Society of Australia’ 5, 169–182.
McCosker T (2000) Cell grazing – the first 10 years in Australia. Tropical Grasslands 34, 207–218.
McKinney G (1974) Management of lucerne for sheep grazing on the Southern Tablelands of New South Wales. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 14, 726–734.
| Management of lucerne for sheep grazing on the Southern Tablelands of New South Wales.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
McLeod MK, MacLeod DA, Daniel H (2006) The effect of degradation of phalaris plus white clover pasture on soil water regimes of a Brown Chromosol on the Northern Tablelands of NSW, Australia. Agricultural Water Management 82, 318–342.
| The effect of degradation of phalaris plus white clover pasture on soil water regimes of a Brown Chromosol on the Northern Tablelands of NSW, Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Moore RM, Barrie N, Kipps EH (1946) ‘Continuous and rotational grazing by Merino sheep. 1. A study of the production of a sown pasture in the Australian Capital Territory under three systems of grazing management.’ (CSIR: Melbourne)
Murison R, Scott JM (2013) Statistical methodologies for drawing causal inference from an unreplicated farmlet experiment conducted by the Cicerone Project. Animal Production Science 53, 643–648.
| Statistical methodologies for drawing causal inference from an unreplicated farmlet experiment conducted by the Cicerone Project.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
O’Keeffe M (1992) ‘A qualitative project into the adoption of pasture research and the potential for GrazFeed.’ (Monash University: Melbourne)
Paine M, Weatherly J, Crawford A, Champion A (2002) Farmlets as learning platforms: a national approach to farming systems research, development and extension in the Australian dairy sector. In ‘Proceedings of the fifth international Farming System Association – European symposium’. Florence, Italy. pp. 730–740. (Dip. di Economia Agraria e delle Risorce Territoriali, Facolta di Agraria, Universita degli Studi di Firenze: Florence, Italy).
Reid N, Reid J, Hoad J, Green S, Chamberlain G, Scott JM (2013) Five-year survival and growth of farm forestry plantings of native trees and radiata pine in pasture affected by position in the landscape. Animal Production Science 53, 817–826.
| Five-year survival and growth of farm forestry plantings of native trees and radiata pine in pasture affected by position in the landscape.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Saul GR (2005) Summing up: Cicerone – A “Mexican’s” perspective. In ‘The Cicerone farms: under the microscope’. Armidale, NSW. (Ed. JM Scott) pp. 83–88. (The Cicerone Project Inc. and Centre for Sustainable Farming Systems, University of New England: Armidale)
Saul GR, Chapman DF (2002) Grazing methods, productivity and sustainability for sheep and beef pastures in temperate Australia. Wool Technology and Sheep Breeding 50, 449–464.
Schlegel ML, Wachenheim CJ, Benson ME, Black JR, Moline WJ, Ritchie HD, Schwab GD, Rust SR (2000) Grazing methods and stocking rates for direct-seeded alfalfa pastures: I. Plant productivity and animal performance. Journal of Animal Science 78, 2192–2201.
Scott JF, Cacho OJ, Scott JM (2013a) Economic risk analysis of livestock management system options. Animal Production Science 53, 788–795.
| Economic risk analysis of livestock management system options.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Scott JF, Scott JM, Cacho OJ (2013b) Whole-farm returns show true profitability of three different livestock management systems. Animal Production Science 53, 780–787.
| Whole-farm returns show true profitability of three different livestock management systems.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Scott JM (2003) Internet ‘Information Dashboard’ for tracking sustainability of whole-farm systems. In ‘1st Australian farming systems conference’. Toowoomba. (Ed. B Robinson) (Australian Farming Systems Association: Toowoomba, Qld)
Scott JM (2009) A network of fact farms is needed to provide credible evidence of sustainable and profitable farming systems. In ‘Farming Systems Design: an international symposium on methodologies for integrated analysis of farm production systems’. Monterey, California, USA. (Ed. J Hatfield) pp. 257–258. (American Society of Agronomy: Madison, WI). Available at http://www.iemss.org/farmsys09/uploads/2009_FSD_Proceedings.pdf [Verified 7 December 2012]
Scott JM, Hutchinson KJ, King K, Chen W, McLeod M, Blair GJ, White A, Wilkinson D, Lefroy RDB, Cresswell H, Daniel H, Harris C, MacLeod DA, Blair N, Chamberlain G (2000) Quantifying the sustainability of grazed pastures on the Northern Tablelands of New South Wales. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 40, 257–265.
| Quantifying the sustainability of grazed pastures on the Northern Tablelands of New South Wales.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Scott JM, Behrendt K, Colvin A, Scott F, Shakhane LM, Guppy C, Hoad J, Gaden CA, Edwards C, Hinch GN, Cacho OJ, Donald GE, Cottle D, Coventry T, Williams G, Mackay DF (2013c) Integrated overview of results from a farmlet experiment which compared the effects of pasture inputs and grazing management on profitability and sustainability. Animal Production Science 53, 841–855.
| Integrated overview of results from a farmlet experiment which compared the effects of pasture inputs and grazing management on profitability and sustainability.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Scott JM, Gaden CA, Edwards C, Paull DR, Marchant R, Hoad J, Sutherland H, Coventry T, Dutton P (2013d) Selection of experimental treatments, methods used and evolution of management guidelines for comparing and measuring three grazed farmlet systems. Animal Production Science 53, 628–642.
| Selection of experimental treatments, methods used and evolution of management guidelines for comparing and measuring three grazed farmlet systems.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Scott JM, Munro M, Rollings N, Browne W, Vickery PJ, Macgregor C, Donald GE, Sutherland H (2013e) Planning for whole-farm systems research at a credible scale: subdividing land into farmlets with equivalent initial conditions. Animal Production Science 53, 618–627.
| Planning for whole-farm systems research at a credible scale: subdividing land into farmlets with equivalent initial conditions.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Shakhane LM, Mulcahy C, Scott JM, Hinch GN, Donald GE, Mackay DF (2013a) Pasture herbage mass, quality and growth in response to three whole-farmlet management systems. Animal Production Science 53, 685–698.
| Pasture herbage mass, quality and growth in response to three whole-farmlet management systems.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Shakhane LM, Scott JM, Murison R, Mulcahy C, Hinch GN, Morrow A, Mackay DF (2013b) Changes in botanical composition on three farmlets subjected to different pasture and grazing management strategies. Animal Production Science 53, 670–684.
| Changes in botanical composition on three farmlets subjected to different pasture and grazing management strategies.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Southcott W, Bindon B (1996) Links with CSIRO in establishing rural science. In ‘Rural science: philosophy and application’. (Ed. JS Ryan) pp. 66–89. (School of Rural Science, University of New England: Armidale)
Southcott W, Le Jambre L, Watson D (1997) Animal health and production. In ‘CSIRO Armidale: fifty years of pastoral research, 1947–1997’. (Ed. JL Wheeler) pp. 67–85. (CSIRO Division of Animal Production: Armidale, NSW)
Spedding CRW, Brockington NR (1976) Guest editorial: the study of ecosystems. Agro-ecosystems 2, 165–172.
| Guest editorial: the study of ecosystems.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Sutherland H, Scott JM, Gray GD, Woolaston RR (2013) Creating the Cicerone Project: seeking closer engagement between livestock producers, research and extension. Animal Production Science 53, 593–601.
| Creating the Cicerone Project: seeking closer engagement between livestock producers, research and extension.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Trompf J, Sale PWG (2006) The productivity, environmental and social benefits of increasing producer participation in extension. In ‘Practice change for sustainable communities: exploring footprints, pathways and possibilities. Proceedings of APEN international conference, 6–8 March 2006, Beechworth, Vic. (Eds RJ Petheram, RC Johnson) (The Regional Institute Ltd: Gosford, NSW). Available at http://regional.org.au/au/apen/2006/refereed/1/2954_trompfjp.htm [Verified 7 December 2012]
Walkden-Brown SW, Colvin AF, Hall E, Knox MR, Mackay DF, Scott JM (2013) Grazing systems and worm control in sheep: a long-term case study involving three management systems with analysis of factors influencing faecal worm egg count. Animal Production Science 53, 765–779.
| Grazing systems and worm control in sheep: a long-term case study involving three management systems with analysis of factors influencing faecal worm egg count.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Walker B (1988) Autecology, synecology, climate and livestock as agents of rangeland dynamics. The Rangeland Journal 10, 69–75.
| Autecology, synecology, climate and livestock as agents of rangeland dynamics.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Waller RA, Sale PWG, Saul GR, Kearney GA (2001) Tactical versus continuous stocking in perennial ryegrass-subterranean clover pastures grazed by sheep in south-western Victoria – 1. Stocking rates and herbage production. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 41, 1099–1108.
| Tactical versus continuous stocking in perennial ryegrass-subterranean clover pastures grazed by sheep in south-western Victoria – 1. Stocking rates and herbage production.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
