Comparing acoustic survey data for European bats: do walked transects or automated fixed-point surveys provide more robust data?
Samantha J. Perks A and Anne E. Goodenough
A B
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations
A School of Natural and Social Sciences, Francis Close Hall, University of Gloucestershire, Cheltenham, GL50 4AZ, UK.
B Corresponding author. Email: aegoodenough@glos.ac.uk
Wildlife Research 49(4) 314-323 https://doi.org/10.1071/WR20123
Submitted: 25 July 2020 Accepted: 7 September 2021 Published: 22 December 2021
Abstract
Context: Monitoring schemes provide vital data on the distribution and population dynamics of species. This information can be used to inform conservation management and, especially for legally protected species, ensure legislative compliance in development contexts. For bats, acoustic activity surveys are widely used and often involve (1) deployment of automated fixed-point detectors or (2) using bat detectors on walked or driven transects. Transect surveys are typically performed for 2 h, commencing approximately at sunset; automated fixed-point surveys record continually between sunset and sunrise, often over multiple consecutive nights.
Aims: Despite both walked transects and fixed-point surveys being common methods used to survey bat activity in many parts of the world, often just one technique is used per site. We test the similarity of these two survey methods by comparing acoustic data encompassing 12 species of European bat to determine whether data from different surveys are directly comparable.
Methods: In this study, we use acoustic data covering 2349 survey hours over a 3-year period to investigate the relative effectiveness of walked activity transects and automated fixed-point methods for 12 species of European bats.
Key results: A greater number of bat species were recorded via the fixed-point method. Three species, namely, greater horseshoe (Rhinolophus ferrumequinum), lesser horseshoe (Rhinolophus hipposideros) and Daubenton’s (Myotis daubentonii), were recorded only by using automated detectors, possibly because the survey window encompassed the entire night rather than the period immediately after sunset. However, activity transects recorded a significantly higher mean species richness per hour than fixed-point surveys. When both methods were used at the same sites on the same nights, providing paired data for direct comparison, detection of brown long-eared (Plecotus auratus) and soprano pipistrelle (Pipistrellus pygmaeus) bat activity was significantly higher for transect surveys.
Conclusions and implications: This study demonstrated important differences in the data resulting from different bat survey methods and highlighted the potential for combining acoustic survey types to obtain rigorous and reliable monitoring data for bat populations.
Keywords: activity surveys, anabat, bat surveying, bat detector, echolocation, ultrasonic detection.
References
Alder, D. C., Poore, A., Norrey, J., Newson, S. E., and Marsden, S. J. (2020). Irregular silviculture positively influences multiple bat species in a lowland temperate broadleaf woodland. Forest Ecology and Management 483, 118786.Anderson, M. E., and Racey, P. A. (1991). Feeding behaviour of captive brown long-eared bats, Plecotus auritus. Animal Behaviour 42, 489–493.
| Feeding behaviour of captive brown long-eared bats, Plecotus auritus.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Balmford, A., Green, R. E., and Jenkins, M. (2003). Measuring the changing state of nature. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 18, 326–330.
| Measuring the changing state of nature.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Bambini, L., Blyth, A., Bradford, T., Bristol, R., Burthe, S., Craig, L., Downs, N., Laing, S., Marshall-Ball, L., McGowan, D., and Vel, T. (2006). Another Seychelles endemic close to extinction: the emballonurid bat Coleura seychellensis. Oryx 40, 310–318.
| Another Seychelles endemic close to extinction: the emballonurid bat Coleura seychellensis.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Barlow, K. E., Briggs, P. A., Haysom, K. A., Hutson, A. M., Lechiara, N. L., Racey, P. A., Walsh, A. L., and Langton, S. D. (2015). Citizen science reveals trends in bat populations: the National Bat Monitoring Programme in Great Britain. Biological Conservation 182, 14–26.
| Citizen science reveals trends in bat populations: the National Bat Monitoring Programme in Great Britain.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Bat Conservation International (2021). www.batcon.org/about-bats
Billington, G. (2003a). Radio tracking study of greater horseshoe bats at Caen Valley Bats Site of Special Scientific Interest, 2002. English Nature Research Report No. 495.
Billington, G. (2003b). Radio tracking study of greater horseshoe bats at Chudleigh Caves and Woods Site of Special Scientific Interest, 2002. English Nature Research Report No. 496.
Billington, G. (2004). Radio tracking study of greater horseshoe bats at Buckfastleigh Caves Site of Special Scientific Interest, 2003. English Nature Research Report No. 573.
Bontadina, F., Schofield, H., and Naef-Daenzer, B. (2002). Radio-tracking reveals that lesser horseshoe bats (Rhinolophus hipposideros) forage in woodland. Journal of Zoology 258, 281–290.
| Radio-tracking reveals that lesser horseshoe bats (Rhinolophus hipposideros) forage in woodland.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Braun de Torrez, E. C., Wallrichs, M. A., Ober, H. K., and McCleery, R. A. (2017). Mobile acoustic transects miss rare bat species: implications of survey method and spatio-temporal sampling for monitoring bats. PeerJ 5, e3940.
| Mobile acoustic transects miss rare bat species: implications of survey method and spatio-temporal sampling for monitoring bats.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 29134138PubMed |
Ciechanowski, M., Zając, T., Biłas, A., and Dunajski, R. (2007). Spatiotemporal variation in activity of bat species differing in hunting tactics: effects of weather, moonlight, food abundance, and structural clutter. Canadian Journal of Zoology 85, 1249–1263.
| Spatiotemporal variation in activity of bat species differing in hunting tactics: effects of weather, moonlight, food abundance, and structural clutter.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
CIEEM (2018). Chartered Institute of Ecology and Environmental Management Guidelines for Ecological Impact Assessment in the UK and Ireland. Available at https://cieem.net/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/Combined-EclA-guidelines-2018-compressed.pdf.
Collins, J. (Ed.) (2016). ‘Bat Surveys for Professional Ecologists: Good Practice Guidelines.’ 3rd edn. (The Bat Conservation Trust: London, UK.)
D’Acunto, L. E., Pauli, B. P., Moy, M., Johnson, K., Abu‐Omar, J., and Zollner, P. A. (2018). Timing and technique impact the effectiveness of road‐based, mobile acoustic surveys of bats. Ecology and Evolution 8, 3152–3160.
| Timing and technique impact the effectiveness of road‐based, mobile acoustic surveys of bats.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 29607014PubMed |
Dietz, M., Encarnação, J. A., and Kalko, E. K. (2006). Small scale distribution patterns of female and male Daubentons bats (Myotis daubentonii). Acta Chiropterologica 8, 403–415.
| Small scale distribution patterns of female and male Daubentons bats (Myotis daubentonii).Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Drayson, K., Wood, G., and Thompson, S. (2015). Assessing the quality of the ecological component of English Environmental Statements. Journal of Environmental Management 160, 241–253.
| Assessing the quality of the ecological component of English Environmental Statements.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 26119331PubMed |
Eklöf, J., and Jones, G. (2003). Use of vision in prey detection by brown long-eared bats, Plecotus auritus. Animal Behaviour 66, 949–953.
| Use of vision in prey detection by brown long-eared bats, Plecotus auritus.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Goodenough, A. E., and Hart, A. G. (2017). ‘Applied Ecology: Monitoring, Managing and Conserving.’ (Oxford University Press: Oxford, UK.)
Goodenough, A. E., Deans, L., Whiteley, L., and Pickering, S. (2015). Later is better: optimal timing for walked activity surveys for a European bat guild. Wildlife Biology 21, 323–328.
| Later is better: optimal timing for walked activity surveys for a European bat guild.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Grant, J. D. (1991). Prey location by 12 Australian long-eared bats, Nyctophilus-gouldi and N-geoffroyi. Australian Journal of Zoology 39, 45–56.
| Prey location by 12 Australian long-eared bats, Nyctophilus-gouldi and N-geoffroyi.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Hayes, J. P. (1997). Temporal variation in activity of bats and the design of echolocation-monitoring studies. Journal of Mammalogy 78, 514–524.
| Temporal variation in activity of bats and the design of echolocation-monitoring studies.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Henkens, R. J. H. G., Ottburg, F. G. W. A., van der Sluis, T., and Klok, C. (2014). Biodiversity monitoring in the Kornati Archipelago, Croatia. Available at https://library.wur.nl/WebQuery/wurpubs/fulltext/138332 [verified 3 March 2021].
Hutson, A. M., Mickleburgh, S. P., and Racey, P. A. (2001). ‘Microchiropteran Bats: Global Status Survey and Conservation Action Plan.’ (IUCN: Gland, Switzerland and Cambridge, UK.)
JNCC (2019). UKBI-C8 Mammals of the wider countryside (bats). Available at https://jncc.gov.uk/our-work/ukbi-c8-mammals-of-the-countryside/ [verified 18 October 2019].
Jones, G., Jacobs, D. S., Kunz, T. H., Willig, M. R., and Racey, P. A. (2009). Carpe noctem: the importance of bats as bioindicators. Endangered Species Research 8, 93–115.
| Carpe noctem: the importance of bats as bioindicators.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Lavery, T. H., Leary, T. N., Shaw, C., Tahi, M., Posala, C., and Pierce, R. (2021). Ecology and conservation of bats in Temotu Province, Solomon Islands and Torba Province, Vanuatu. Pacific Conservation Biology 27, 27–38.
| Ecology and conservation of bats in Temotu Province, Solomon Islands and Torba Province, Vanuatu.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Law, B., Anderson, J., and Chidel, M. (1998). A bat survey in State Forests on the south-west slopes region of New South Wales with suggestions of improvements for future surveys. Australian Zoologist 30, 467–479.
| A bat survey in State Forests on the south-west slopes region of New South Wales with suggestions of improvements for future surveys.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Lee, Y. F., Kuo, Y. M., Chang, H. Y., Tsai, C. F., and Baba, S. (2017). Foraging dispersion of Ryukyu flying-foxes and relationships with fig abundance in East-Asian subtropical island forests. BMC Ecology 17, 35.
| Foraging dispersion of Ryukyu flying-foxes and relationships with fig abundance in East-Asian subtropical island forests.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 29137616PubMed |
Lintott, P. R., Barlow, K., Bunnefeld, N., Briggs, P., Gajas Roig, C., and Park, K. J. (2016). Differential responses of cryptic bat species to the urban landscape. Ecology and Evolution 6, 2044–2052.
| Differential responses of cryptic bat species to the urban landscape.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 27066223PubMed |
Milne, D. J., Armstrong, M., Fisher, A., Flores, T., and Pavey, C. R. (2004). A comparison of three survey methods for collecting bat echolocation calls and species-accumulation rates from nightly Anabat recordings. Wildlife Research 31, 57–63.
| A comparison of three survey methods for collecting bat echolocation calls and species-accumulation rates from nightly Anabat recordings.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Milne, D. J., Fisher, A., Rainey, I., and Pavey, C. R. (2005). Temporal patterns of bats in the top end of the Northern Territory, Australia. Journal of Mammalogy 86, 909–920.
| Temporal patterns of bats in the top end of the Northern Territory, Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Mitchell-Jones, A. J. (2004). ‘Bat Mitigation Guidelines.’ (External Relations Team, English Nature.)
Mullin, K. E., Yoh, N., Mitchell, S. L., Basrur, S., Seaman, D. J., Bernard, H., and Struebig, M. J. (2020). Riparian reserves promote insectivorous bat activity in oil palm dominated landscapes. Frontiers in Forests and Global Change 3, 73.
| Riparian reserves promote insectivorous bat activity in oil palm dominated landscapes.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Musila, S., Bogdanowicz, W., Syingi, R., Zuhura, A., Chylarecki, P., and Rydell, J. (2019). No lunar phobia in insectivorous bats in Kenya. Mammalian Biology 95, 77–84.
| No lunar phobia in insectivorous bats in Kenya.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
O’Donnell, C. F. (2000). Conservation status and causes of decline of the threatened New Zealand Long‐tailed Bat Chalinolobus tuberculatus (Chiroptera: Vespertilionidae). Mammal Review 30, 89–106.
| Conservation status and causes of decline of the threatened New Zealand Long‐tailed Bat Chalinolobus tuberculatus (Chiroptera: Vespertilionidae).Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
O’Donnell, C. F., and Sedgeley, J. A. (2001). ‘Guidelines for surveying and monitoring long-tailed bat populations using line transects.’ (New Zealand Department of Conservation: Wellington, New Zealand.)
O’Farrell, M. J., and Gannon, W. L. (1999). A comparison of acoustic versus capture techniques for the inventory of bats. Journal of Mammalogy 80, 24–30.
| A comparison of acoustic versus capture techniques for the inventory of bats.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
O’Shea, T. J., and Johnston, J. J. (2009). Environmental Contaminants and Bats. In ‘Ecological and Behavioral Methods for the Study of Bats’ (Eds T. H. Kunz and S. Parsons.) pp. 500–528. (The John Hopkins University Press: Baltimore, MD, USA.)
O’Shea, T. J., Cryan, P. M., Hayman, D. T., Plowright, R. K., and Streicker, D. G. (2016). Multiple mortality events in bats: a global review. Mammal Review 46, 175–190.
| Multiple mortality events in bats: a global review.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 29755179PubMed |
Perks, S. J., and Goodenough, A. E. (2020). Abiotic and spatiotemporal factors affect activity of European bat species and have implications for detectability for acoustic surveys. Wildlife Biology 2020, 1–8.
| Abiotic and spatiotemporal factors affect activity of European bat species and have implications for detectability for acoustic surveys.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Pottie, S. A., Lane, D. J., Kingston, T., and Lee, B. P. H. (2005). The microchiropteran bat fauna of Singapore. Acta Chiropterologica 7, 237–247.
| The microchiropteran bat fauna of Singapore.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Russ, J. (2012). ‘British Bat Calls: A Guide to Species Identification.’ (Pleagic Publishing: Exeter, UK.)
Russo, D., and Jones, G. (2003). Use of foraging habitats by bats in a Mediterranean area determined by acoustic surveys: conservation implications. Ecography 26, 197–209.
| Use of foraging habitats by bats in a Mediterranean area determined by acoustic surveys: conservation implications.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Russo, D., and Jones, G. (2015). Bats as bioindicators. Mammalian Biology 80, 157–158.
| Bats as bioindicators.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Russo, D., and Voigt, C. C. (2016). The use of automated identification of bat echolocation calls in acoustic monitoring: a cautionary note for a sound analysis. Ecological Indicators 66, 598–602.
| The use of automated identification of bat echolocation calls in acoustic monitoring: a cautionary note for a sound analysis.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Rydell, J., Entwistle, A., and Racey, P. A. (1996). Timing of foraging flights of three species of bats in relation to insect activity and predation risk. Oikos 76, 243–252.
| Timing of foraging flights of three species of bats in relation to insect activity and predation risk.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Scanlon, A. T., and Petit, S. (2008). Effects of site, time, weather and light on urban bat activity and richness: considerations for survey effort. Wildlife Research 35, 821–834.
| Effects of site, time, weather and light on urban bat activity and richness: considerations for survey effort.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Sedlock, J. L., Jose, R. P., Vogt, J. M., Paguntalan, L. M. J., and Cariño, A. B. (2014). A survey of bats in a karst landscape in the central Philippines. Acta Chiropterologica 16, 197–211.
| A survey of bats in a karst landscape in the central Philippines.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Simmons, J. A., Fenton, M. B., and O’Farrell, M. J. (1979). Echolocation and pursuit of prey by bats. Science 203, 16–21.
| Echolocation and pursuit of prey by bats.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 758674PubMed |
Stahlschmidt, P., and Brühl, C. A. (2012). Bats as bioindicators: the need of a standardized method for acoustic bat activity surveys. Methods in Ecology and Evolution 3, 503–508.
| Bats as bioindicators: the need of a standardized method for acoustic bat activity surveys.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Swift, S. M., and Racey, P. A. (1983). Resource partitioning in two species of vespertilionid bats (Chiroptera) occupying the same roost. Journal of Zoology 200, 249–259.
| Resource partitioning in two species of vespertilionid bats (Chiroptera) occupying the same roost.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Taylor, P. J., Monadjem, A., and Nicolaas Steyn, J. (2013). Seasonal patterns of habitat use by insectivorous bats in a subtropical African agro‐ecosystem dominated by macadamia orchards. African Journal of Ecology 51, 552–561.
| Seasonal patterns of habitat use by insectivorous bats in a subtropical African agro‐ecosystem dominated by macadamia orchards.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Tonos, J. M., Pauli, B. P., Zollner, P. A., and Haulton, G. S. (2014). A comparison of the efficiency of mobile and stationary acoustic bat surveys. Proceedings of the Indiana Academy of Sciences 2, 103–111.
Treanor, J. J., Johnson, J. S., Lee, E. H., and Waag, A. G. (2019). Yellowstone Bats: an Important Indicator of Ecosystem Health. Available at https://www.nps.gov/articles/yellowstone-bats-important-indicator-ecosystem-health.htm [verified 3 March 2021].
Treweek, J. (2009). ‘Ecological Impact Assessment.’ (John Wiley & Sons.)
Vaughan, T. A., and Vaughan, R. P. (1986). Seasonality and the behavior of the African yellow-winged bat. Journal of Mammalogy 67, 91–102.
| Seasonality and the behavior of the African yellow-winged bat.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Walsh, A. L., and Harris, S. (1996a). Factors determining the abundance of vespertilionid bats in Britain: geographical, land class and local habitat relationships. Journal of Applied Ecology 33, 519–529.
| Factors determining the abundance of vespertilionid bats in Britain: geographical, land class and local habitat relationships.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Walsh, A. L., and Harris, S. (1996b). Foraging habitat preferences of vespertilionid bats in Britain. Journal of Applied Ecology 33, 508–518.
| Foraging habitat preferences of vespertilionid bats in Britain.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Walsh, A. L., Barclay, R. M., and McCracken, G. F. (2004). Designing bat activity surveys for inventory and monitoring studies at local and regional scales. In ‘Bat echolocation research: tools, techniques and analysis’. (Eds R. M. Brigham, E. K. V. Kalko, G. Jones, S. Parsons, and H. J. G. A. Limpens.) pp. 157–165. (Bat Conservation International: Austin, TX, USA.)
Warren, R. D., and Witter, M. S. (2002). Monitoring trends in bat populations through roost surveys: methods and data from Rhinolophus hipposideros. Biological Conservation 105, 255–261.
| Monitoring trends in bat populations through roost surveys: methods and data from Rhinolophus hipposideros.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Weier, S., Linden, V., and Taylor, P. (2020). Bats versus macadamia crop pests: theme – natural control. Quest 16, 16–17.
Willig, M. R., Presley, S. J., Bloch, C. P., Hice, C. L., Yanoviak, S. P., Díaz, M. M., Chauca, L. A., Pacheco, V., and Weaver, S. C. (2007). Phyllostomid bats of lowland Amazonia: effects of habitat alteration on abundance. Biotropica 39, 737–746.
| Phyllostomid bats of lowland Amazonia: effects of habitat alteration on abundance.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
