Catering for the needs of fauna in fire management: science or just wishful thinking?
Michael F. Clarke
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations
Department of Zoology, La Trobe University, Bundoora, Vic. 3086, Australia. Email: m.clarke@latrobe.edu.au
Wildlife Research 35(5) 385-394 https://doi.org/10.1071/WR07137
Submitted: 10 September 2007 Accepted: 8 April 2008 Published: 19 August 2008
Abstract
Ecological fire management in Australia is often built on an assumption that meeting the needs of plant species will automatically meet the needs of animal species. However, the scarcity of ecological data on the needs of fauna in relation to fire undermines the confidence managers should place in current popular frameworks for planning ecological burning. Such frameworks are built almost entirely around the goal of maintaining plant community diversity. They provide little guidance to managers regarding the characteristics of desirable ‘mosaics’ (e.g. patch size, connectivity or composition of age-since-burnt classes) or the timing of fires in relation to faunal population trends linked to other cycles (e.g. El Niño events). Claims by agencies of adopting an adaptive management approach (‘learning by doing’) to cope with a dearth of knowledge are credible only if monitoring and evaluation are carried out and future actions are modified in light of new evidence. Much monitoring of fauna is of such a small scale and short duration that the statistical likelihood of detecting a positive or negative effect of the management regime is minute. Such shortcomings will only be overcome through broad-scale and/or long-term studies of fauna. The funding for such research is unlikely to be forthcoming if fire ecologists and land managers convey the impression that the current data are adequate for the implementation of the current planning frameworks.
Acknowledgements
My deliberations on the issue of managing fire for wildlife have benefited from fruitful discussions with David Baker-Gabb, Andrew Bennett, Kate Callister, David Cheal, Rohan Clarke, Geoff Cary, Ray Damon, Matt Edmunds, Gordon Friend, Peter Green, Brian Malone, David Keith, Greg Jenkins, John Morgan, Neil Murray, Ros St Clair, Kevin Tolhurst, and Neville Walsh, as well as all members of the Mallee Fire and Biodiversity Project Team. I am particularly grateful to Andrew Bennett, David Cheal, Camilla Myers and three anonymous referees for their insightful criticisms of this ms. Nevertheless, the views presented above are personal conclusions, and should in no way be deduced to necessarily represent the views of those named.
References
Abbott I. (2003). Aboriginal fire regimes in south-west Western Australia: evidence from historical documents. In ‘Fire in Ecosystems of South-west Western Australia: Impacts and Management’. (Eds I. Abbott and N. Burrows.) pp. 119–146. (Backhuys Publishers: Leiden.)
Andersen, A. N. , Cook, G. D. , Corbett, L. K. , Douglas, M. M. , Eager, R. W. , Russell-Smith, J. , Setterfield, S. A. , Williams, R. J. , and Woinarski, J. C. Z. (2005). Fire frequency and biodiversity conservation in Australian tropical savanna: implications from the Kapalga fire experiment. Austral Ecology 30, 155–167.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Benshemesh J. (1990). Management of the malleefowl with regard to fire. In ‘The Mallee Lands: a Conservation Perspective’. (Eds J. C. Noble, P. J. Joss and G. K. Jones.) pp. 206–211. (CSIRO: Melbourne.)
Benson, J. S. , and Redpath, P. A. (1997). The nature of pre-European native vegetation in Australia: a critique of Ryan, D. G., Ryan, J. R. and Starr B. J. (1995). Australian Landscape: observations of explorers and early settlers. Cunninghamia 5, 285–328.
Bradstock R. A., and Cohn J. S. (2002). Fire regimes and biodiversity in semi-arid mallee ecosystems. In ‘Flammable Australia: the Fire Regimes and Biodiversity of a Continent’. (Eds R. A. Bradstock, J. E. Williams and M. A. Gill.) pp. 238–258. (Cambridge University Press: Cambridge.)
Bradstock, R. A. , Bedward, M. , Gill, A. M. , and Cohn, J. S. (2005). Which mosaic? A landscape ecological approach for evaluating interactions between fire regimes, habitat and animals. Wildlife Research 32, 409–423.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Burbidge A. H. (2003). Birds and fire in the Mediterranean climate of south-west Western Australia. In ‘Fire in Ecosystems of south-west Western Australia: Impacts and Management’. (Eds I. Abbott and N. Burrows.) pp. 321–348. (Backhuys Publishers: Leiden.)
Burgman M. A., and Lindenmayer D. B. (1998). ‘Conservation Biology for the Australian Environment.’ (Surrey Beatty: Sydney.)
Busby, J. R. (1986). A bioclimatic analysis of Nothofagus cunninghamii (Hook.) Oerst. in southeastern Australia. Austral Ecology 11, 1–7.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Caughley J. (1985). Effect of fire on the reptile fauna of mallee. In ‘Biology of Australasian Frogs and Reptiles’. (Eds G. Grigg, R. Shine and H. Ehmann.) pp. 31–34. (Surrey Beatty: Sydney.)
Chandler, L. G. (1973). In the wake of a bushfire. Wildlife in Australia 10, 140–141.
Cheal D. (2004). consideration of Victoria’s proposals for ecological burning, using mallee heathlands as a case study. In ‘Proceedings of Bushfire 2004: Earth, Wind and Fire, Fusing the Elements Conference’. pp. 1–9. (Department of Environment and Heritage: Adelaide.)
Christensen P. E., and Kimber P. C. (1975). Effects of prescribed burning on the flora and fauna of south-west Australian forests. In ‘Managing Terrestrial Ecosystems’. (Eds J. Kikkawa and H. A.Nix.) pp. 85–106. (The Ecological Society of Australia: Brisbane.)
Cockburn, A. , Braithwaite, R. W. , and Lee, A. K. (1981). The response of heath rat, Pseudomys shortridgei, to pyric succession: a temporally dynamic life-history strategy. Journal of Animal Ecology 50, 649–666.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Courtenay J., and Friend T. (2004). Gilbert’s potoroo (Potorous gilbertii) recovery plan July 2003 – June 2008. Department of Conservation and Land Management Western Australia, Wanneroo.
Department of Sustainability and Environment (2006). Code of practice for fire management on public land. Victorian Government Department of Sustainability and Environment, Melbourne.
Department of Sustainability and Environment (2007). Mildura District fire protection plan. Victorian Government Department of Sustainability and Environment, Melbourne.
Department of the Environment and Water Resources (2007). ‘Australia’s Native Vegetation: A Summary of Australia’s Major Vegetation Groups, 2007.’ (Australian Government: Canberra.)
Dostine, P. L. , Johnson, G. C. , Franklin, D. C. , and Hempel, C. (2001). Seasonal use of savanna landscapes by the Gouldian finch Erythrura gouldiae, and co-existing finches in the Yinberrie Hills area, Northern Territory. Wildlife Research 28, 445–458.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Fire Ecology Working Group (2002). Analysis of disturbance by fire on public land in Victoria. Department of Natural Resources and Environment, Melbourne.
Fire Ecology Working Group (2004). Guidelines and procedures for ecological burning on public land in Victoria 2004. Department of Sustainability and Environment, Melbourne.
Fox, B. J. (1982). Fire and mammalian secondary succession in an Australian coastal heath. Ecology 63, 1332–1341.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Friend G. R. (1996). Fire ecology of invertebrates – implications for nature conservation, fire management and future research. In ‘Fire and Biodiversity - The Effects and Effectiveness of Fire Management’. pp. 155–161. (Department of the Environment, Sport and Tourism: Canberra.)
Gibbons P. and Lindenmayer D.B. (1997). Conserving hollow-dependent fauna in timber-production forests. NSW National Parks and Wildlife Service, Sydney.
Gill, A.M. (1975). Fire and the Australian flora. Australian Forestry , 4–25.
Gill A. M. (1981). Adaptive responses of Australian vascular plant species to fires. In ‘Fire and the Australian Biota’. (Eds A. M. Gill, R. H. Groves and I. R. Noble.) (Australian Academy of Science: Canberra.)
Gill A. M. (1999). Biodiversity and bushfires: an Australia-wide perspective on plant-species changes after a fire event. In ‘Australia’s Biodiversity – Responses to Fire: Plants, Birds and Invertebrates’. (Eds A. M. Gill, J. C. Z. Woinarski and A. York.) pp. 9–54. (Department of the Environment and Heritage: Canberra.)
Gill, A. M. , and McCarthy, M. A. (1998). Intervals between prescribed fires in Australia: what intrinsic variation should apply? Biological Conservation 85, 161–169.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Gill A. M., Bradstock R. A., and Williams J. E. (2002). Fire regimes and biodiversity: legacy and vision. In ‘Flammable Australia: the Fire Regimes and Biodiversity of a Continent’. (Eds R. A. Bradstock, J. E. Williams and A. M. Gill.) pp. 429–446. (Cambridge University Press: Cambridge.)
Good R. (1981). Adaptations of Australian plants to fires. In ‘Bushfires: Their Effect on Australian Life and Landscape’. (Ed. P. Stanbury.) pp. 48–59. (The Macleay Museum: Sydney.)
Good R. B. (1996). Fuel dynamics, preplan and future research needs. In ‘Fire and Biodiversity – The Effects and Effectiveness of Fire Management’. pp. 253–266. (Department of the Environment, Sport and Tourism: Canberra.)
Griffiths, A. D. , and Christian, K. A. (1996). The effects of fire on the frillneck lizard (Chlamydosaurus kingii) in northern Australia. Australian Journal of Ecology 21, 386–398.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Keith D. A., Williams J. E., and Woinarski J. C. Z. (2002). Fire management and biodiversity conservation: key approaches and principles. In ‘Flammable Australia: the Fire Regimes and Biodiversity of a Continent’. (Eds R. A. Bradstock, J. E. Williams and M. A. Gill.) pp. 401–425. (Cambridge University Press: Cambridge.)
Kenny B., Sutherland E.F., Tasker E., and Bradstock R. (2004). Guidelines for ecologically sustainable fire management. NSW biodiversity strategy. Biodiversity Research and Management Division (Bushfire Research), NSW National Parks and Wildlife Service, Sydney.
Koch P. (2005). Factors influencing food availability for the endangered south-eastern red-tailed black cockatoo Calyptorhynchus banksii graptogyne in remnant stringybark woodland, and implications for management. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Adelaide.
Lambeck, R. J. (1997). Focal species: a multi-species umbrella for nature conservation. Conservation Biology 11, 849–856.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Mackey B., Lindenmayer D. B., Gill M., McCarthy M., and Lindesay J. (2002). ‘Wildlife, Fire and Future Climate: A Forest Ecosystem Analysis.’ (CSIRO Publishing: Melbourne.)
Mackowski C. M. (1984). The ontogeny of hollows in blackbutt, Eucalyptus pilularis and its relevance to the management of forests for possums, gliders and timber. In ‘Possums and Gliders’. (Eds A. P. Smith and I. D. Hume.) pp. 517–525. (Surrey Beatty: Sydney.)
Masters, P. (1993). The effects of fire-driven succession and rainfall on small mammals in spinifex grassland at Uluru National Park, Northern Territory. Wildlife Research 20, 803–813.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
McCarthy G. J., Tolhurst K. G., and Chatto K. (1999). Overall fuel hazard guide. (Department of Natural Resources and Environment, Melbourne.)
Meredith, C. W. , Gilmore, A. M. , and Isles, A. C. (1984). The ground parrot (Pezoporus wallicus Kerr) in south-eastern Australia: a fire-adapted species? Australian Journal of Ecology 9, 367–389.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Nield C. (2006). Fire mosaics: the influence of variations in fire severity on initial post-fire biotic responses after the 2005 wildfire at Wilsons Promontory. B.Sc.(Honours) Thesis, Department of Botany, La Trobe University.
Noble, I. R. , and Slatyer, R. O. (1980). The use of vital attributes to predict successional changes in plant communities subject to recurrent disturbances. Vegetatio 43, 5–21.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
O’Brien T. P. (1989). The impact of severe frost. In ‘Mediterranean Landscapes in Australia Mallee Ecosystems and their Management’. (Eds J. C. Noble and R. A. Bradstock.) pp. 181–188. (CSIRO: Melbourne).
Parr, C. L. , and Andersen, A. N. (2006). Patch mosaic burning for biodiversity conservation: a critique of the pyrodiversity paradigm. Conservation Biology 20, 1610–1619.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | PubMed |
Quinn G.P. and Keough M.J. (2002). ‘Experimental Design and Data Analysis for Biologists.’ (Cambridge University Press: Cambridge.)
Radford, J. Q. , and Bennett, A. F. (2007). The relative importance of landscape properties for woodland birds in agricultural environments. Journal of Applied Ecology 44, 737–747.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Tolhurst K. G., and Friend G. R. (2001). An objective basis for ecological fire management. In ‘Bushfire 2001 Proceedings of the Joint Bushfire/FRFANZ Conference’. pp. 220–228. (New Zealand Forest Research Institute Ltd: Rotorua.)
Ward, M. J. , and Paton, D. C. (2004). Responses to fire of slender-billed thornbills, Acanthiza iredalei hedleyi in Ngarkat Conservation Park, South Australia. I. Densities, group sizes, distribution and management issues. Emu 104, 157–167.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Whelan R. J. (1995). ‘The Ecology of Fire.’ (Cambridge University Press: Cambridge.)
Whelan R. J., Rodgerson L., Dickman C. R., and Sutherland E. F. (2002). Critical life cycles of plants and animals: developing a process-based understanding of population changes in fire-prone landscapes. In ‘Flammable Australia: the Fire Regimes and Biodiversity of a Continent’. (Eds R. A. Bradstock, J. E. Williams and A. M. Gill.) pp. 94–124. (Cambridge University Press: Cambridge.)
Williams, R. J. , Whelan, R. J. , and Gill, A. M. (1994). Fire and environmental heterogeneity in southern temperate forest ecosystems: implications for management. Australian Journal of Botany 42, 125–137.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Willson A. (1999). Tarawi Nature Reserve fire management plan. NSW National Parks and Wildlife Service, Sydney.
Woinarski J. C. Z. (1999). Fire and Australian birds: a review. In ‘Australia’s Biodiversity: Responses to Fire’. (Eds A. M. Gill, J. C. Z. Woinarski and A. York.) pp. 55–111. (Department of Environment and Heritage: Canberra.)
Woinarski J. C. Z. (2005). Living with fire – birds in northern Australia. In ‘Fire and Birds: Fire Management for Biodiversity’. (Eds P. Olsen and M. Weston.) pp. 7–9. (Supplement to Wingspan 15.) (Birds Australia: Melbourne.)
Woinarski, J. C. Z. , Brock, C. , Fisher, A. , Milne, D. , and Oliver, B. (1999). Response of birds and reptiles to fire regimes on pastoral land in the Victoria River District, Northern Territory. The Rangeland Journal 21, 24–38.
| Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Wouters M. A. (1993). Developing fire management planning in Victoria: a case study from the Grampians. Department of Conservation and Natural Resources, Melbourne.
York A. (1999). Long-term effects of repeated prescribed burning on forest invertebrates: management implications for the conservation of biodiversity. In ‘Australia’s Biodiversity: Responses to Fire’. (Eds A. M. Gill, J. C. Z. Woinarski and A. York.) pp. 181–266. (Department of Environment and Heritage: Canberra.)
