A comparison of indexing methods to evaluate quality of horticultural soils. Part II. Sensitivity of soil microbiological indicators
Romina Romaniuk A E , Lidia Giuffré A , Alejandro Costantini A B , Norberto Bartoloni C and Paolo Nannipieri D
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations
A Edafología, Facultad de Agronomía, Universidad de Buenos Aires. Av. San Martín 4453. 1417 Buenos Aires, Argentina.
B Instituto de Suelos, INTA, Nicolas Repetto y de los Reseros s/n (1686), Hurlingham Provincia de Buenos Aires, Argentina.
C Departamento de Métodos Cuantitativos Aplicados, Facultad de Agronomía, Universidad de Buenos Aires. Av. San Martin 4453. 1417. Buenos Aires, Argentina.
D Department of Soil Science and Plant Nutrition, University of Firenze, Italy.
E Corresponding author: Email: romaniuk@agro.uba.ar
Soil Research 52(4) 409-418 https://doi.org/10.1071/SR12273
Submitted: 19 May 2012 Accepted: 4 January 2014 Published: 22 April 2014
Abstract
Soil is a non-renewable natural resource, considered as the basis for food production. Changes in soil properties may indicate potentially beneficial or degradative effects of a given management practice, so it is important to select the most sensitive soil properties to act as quality indicators. This research evaluated different approaches to selecting soil quality indicators in the construction of soil quality indices (SQIs). The sensitivity of integrative SQIs, constructed by considering diverse chemical, physical, and biological properties, was compared with biological SQIs, using only biochemical and microbiological indicators, to assess soil quality in an intensive horticultural production system under short- and long-term organic and conventional management. The results provided by the SQIs showed that plots under organic management had increase soil quality compared with the conventionally managed plots, independent of the number of years under production. The SQIs integrated by physical, chemical and biological indicators were more sensitive than indices composed only of biological indicators, as they did not reflect the physical properties of the studied plots. The organic amendments had a great influence on the microbial community; therefore, microbiological indices could not provide reliable information on soil quality in production systems with high inputs of organic materials.
Additional keywords: catabolic response profiles, phospholipid fatty acid profiles.
References
Anderson TH, Domsh KH (1990) Application of eco-physiological quotients (qCO2 and qD) on microbial biomass from soils of different cropping histories. Soil Biology & Biochemistry 22, 251–255.| Application of eco-physiological quotients (qCO2 and qD) on microbial biomass from soils of different cropping histories.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Andrews SS, Karlen DL, Mitchell JP (2002a) A comparison of soil quality indexing methods for vegetable production systems in Northern California. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 90, 25–45.
| A comparison of soil quality indexing methods for vegetable production systems in Northern California.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Andrews SS, Mitchell JP, Manicinelli R, Karlen DJ, Hartz TK, Horwath WR, Pettygrove GS, Scow KM, Munk DS (2002b) On-farm assessment of soil quality in California’s Central Valley. Agronomy Journal 94, 12–23.
| On-farm assessment of soil quality in California’s Central Valley.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Bending GD, Putland C, Rayns F (2000) Changes in microbial community metabolism and labile organic matter fractions as early indicators of the impact of management on soil biological quality. Biology and Fertility of Soils 31, 78–84.
| Changes in microbial community metabolism and labile organic matter fractions as early indicators of the impact of management on soil biological quality.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD3cXhvF2muro%3D&md5=d8b8b7e673de30db93e062280ec98667CAS |
Bindraban PS, Stoorvogel JJ, Jansen DM, Viaming J, Groot JJR (2000) Land quality indicators for sustainable land management: proposed method for yield gap and soil nutrient balance. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 81, 103–112.
| Land quality indicators for sustainable land management: proposed method for yield gap and soil nutrient balance.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Blake GR (1965) Bulk density. In ‘Methods of soil analysis. Part I. Physical and mineralogical properties, including statistics of measurement and sampling’. (Ed. CA Black) pp. 374–395. (American Society of Agronomy: Madison, WI, USA)
Bouyoucos GJ (1927) The hydrometer as a new method for the mechanical analysis of soils. Soil Science 23, 343–354.
| The hydrometer as a new method for the mechanical analysis of soils.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DyaB1cXisFWh&md5=63c954b87c4f23aaa03eea6ddd79295eCAS |
Bray RH, Kurtz LT (1945) Determination of total, organic and available forms of phosphorus in soils. Soil Science 59, 39–46.
| Determination of total, organic and available forms of phosphorus in soils.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DyaH2MXht1GjtA%3D%3D&md5=b052c29dfd27b772b60c31ef42d81381CAS |
Bremner JM, Mulvaney CS (1982) Total nitrogen. In ‘Methods of soil analysis. Part 2’. (Ed. AL Page) pp. 595–624. (American Society of Agronomy: Madison, WI, USA)
Cambardella CA, Elliott ET (1992) Particulate soil organic-matter across a grassland cultivation sequence. Soil Science Society of America Journal 56, 777–783.
| Particulate soil organic-matter across a grassland cultivation sequence.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Chaer GM, Myrold DD, Bottomley PJ (2009) A soil quality index based on the equilibrium between soil organic matter and biochemical properties of undisturbed coniferous forest soils of the Pacific Northwest. Soil Biology & Biochemistry 41, 822–830.
| A soil quality index based on the equilibrium between soil organic matter and biochemical properties of undisturbed coniferous forest soils of the Pacific Northwest.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD1MXjsFags70%3D&md5=9b14b3ad73ccd486caf2f7a9dba62020CAS |
De Leenheer L, De Boodt M (1958) Determination of aggregate stability by the change in mean weight diameter. In ‘Proceedings International Symposium of Soil Structure’. Gent. Vol. 24. pp. 290–300. (Med. Landbouw)
Degens BP, Harris JA (1997) Development of a physiological approach to measuring the catabolic diversity of soil microbial communities. Soil Biology & Biochemistry 29, 1309–1320.
| Development of a physiological approach to measuring the catabolic diversity of soil microbial communities.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DyaK2sXmtVeltLw%3D&md5=0f438fbd785dc47b534d430a5ca34dceCAS |
Ditzler CA, Tugel AJ (2002) Soil quality field tools: experiences of USDA-NRCS Soil Quality Institute. Agronomy Journal 94, 33–38.
| Soil quality field tools: experiences of USDA-NRCS Soil Quality Institute.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Doran JW, Parkin TB (1994) Defining and assessing soil quality. In ‘Defining soil quality for a sustainable environment’. (Eds JW Doran, DC Coleman, DE Bezdicek, BA Stewart) pp. 3–21. (Soil Science Society of America: Madison, WI, USA)
Doran JW, Zeiss MR (2000) Soil health and sustainability: managing the biotic component of soil quality. Applied Soil Ecology 15, 3–11.
| Soil health and sustainability: managing the biotic component of soil quality.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Drinkwater LE, Letourneau DK, Workneh F, van Bruggen AHC, Shennan C (1995) Fundamental differences between conventional and organic tomato agroecosystems in California. Ecological Applications 5, 1098–1112.
| Fundamental differences between conventional and organic tomato agroecosystems in California.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Dumanski J, Pieri C (2000) Land quality indicators: research plan. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 81, 93–102.
| Land quality indicators: research plan.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Ellert BH, Bettany JR (1995) Calculation of organic matter and nutrients stored in soils under contrasting management regimes. Canadian Journal of Soil Science 75, 529–538.
| Calculation of organic matter and nutrients stored in soils under contrasting management regimes.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DyaK28XhslKlsbo%3D&md5=43a28bf9353d1e5c6ddc668a299f7e38CAS |
Ferreras L, Gomez E, Toresani S, Firpo I, Rotondo R (2006) Effect of organic amendments on some physical, chemical and biological properties in a horticultural soil. Bioresource Technology 97, 635–640.
| Effect of organic amendments on some physical, chemical and biological properties in a horticultural soil.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD2MXht12jur3N&md5=80b2a722796693ff59016ef2ca8fb520CAS | 15905087PubMed |
Ge T, Nie S, Wu J, Shen J, Xiao H, Tong CH, Huang D, Hong Y, Iwasaki K (2011) Chemical properties, microbial biomass, and activity differ between soils of organic and conventional horticultural systems under greenhouse and open field management: a case study. Journal of Soils and Sediments 11, 25–36.
| Chemical properties, microbial biomass, and activity differ between soils of organic and conventional horticultural systems under greenhouse and open field management: a case study.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC3cXhs1ajtLfL&md5=bafa48de675c4d0a2a80b737813a7dacCAS |
Golchin A, Asgari H (2008) Land use effect on soil quality indicators in north-eastern Iran. Australian Journal of Soil Research 46, 27–36.
| Land use effect on soil quality indicators in north-eastern Iran.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD1cXhs1WmsLs%3D&md5=2a11e0470c7cd4a3bae52c29d9b0bd68CAS |
González M, Gomez E, Comese R, Quesada M, Conti M (2010) Influence of organic amendments on soil quality potential indicators in an urban horticultural system. Bioresource Technology 101, 8897–8901.
| Influence of organic amendments on soil quality potential indicators in an urban horticultural system.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 20630748PubMed |
Govaerts B, Sayre KD, Deckers J (2006) A minimum data set for soil quality assessment of wheat and maize cropping in the highland of Mexico. Soil & Tillage Research 87, 163–174.
Harris JA (2003) Measurements of the soil microbial community for estimating the success of restoration. European Journal of Soil Science 54, 801–808.
| Measurements of the soil microbial community for estimating the success of restoration.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Haynes RJ (2005) Labile organic matter fractions as a central component of the quality of agricultural soils: an overview. Advances in Agronomy 85, 221–268.
| Labile organic matter fractions as a central component of the quality of agricultural soils: an overview.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD2MXksFKqt7g%3D&md5=26fd87d78d487aa06af2c54ec9b53d9dCAS |
Herrick JE, Brown JR, Tugel AJ, Shaver PL, Havstad KM (2002) Application of soil quality to monitoring and management: Paradigms from rangeland ecology. Agronomy Journal 94, 3–11.
InfoStat (2007) ‘InfoStat, versión 1.1. Manual del usuario.’ Primera Edición. Grupo InfoStat, FCA, Universidad Nacional de Córdoba. (Editorial Brujas: Córdoba, Argentina)
Islam AKMS, Edwards DG, Asher CJ (1980) pH optima for crop growth results of a flowing solution culture experiment with six species. Plant and Soil 54, 339–357.
| pH optima for crop growth results of a flowing solution culture experiment with six species.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Izquierdo I, Caravaca F, Alguacil MM, Hernandez G, Roldán A (2005) Use of microbiological indicators for evaluating success in soil restoration after revegetation of a mining area under subtropical conditions. Applied Soil Ecology 30, 3–10.
| Use of microbiological indicators for evaluating success in soil restoration after revegetation of a mining area under subtropical conditions.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Jenkinson DS, Powlson DS (1976) The effects of biocide treatments on metabolism in soil. A method for measuring soil biomass. Soil Biology & Biochemistry 8, 209–213.
| The effects of biocide treatments on metabolism in soil. A method for measuring soil biomass.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DyaE28Xkslens7c%3D&md5=cd591a7c27f6c902b18967d7486d926dCAS |
Karlen DL, Mausback MJ, Doran JW, Cline RG, Harris RF, Schuman GE (1997) Soil quality: a concept, definition and framework for evaluation. Soil Science Society of America Journal 61, 4–10.
| Soil quality: a concept, definition and framework for evaluation.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DyaK2sXhtlSitLc%3D&md5=1040aec445e0fb99328ff2242ff7a7dbCAS |
Karlen DL, Gardner JC, Rosek MJ (1998) A soil quality framework for evaluating the impact of CRP. Journal of Production Agriculture 11, 56–60.
Kemper WD, Rosenau RC (1986) Aggregate stability and size distribution. In ‘Methods of soil analysis. Part 1’. 2nd edn (Ed. A Klute) pp. 425–442. (ASA, SSSA: Madison, WI, USA)
Klute A (1965) Laboratory measurement of hydraulic conductivity of saturated soil. In ‘Methods of soil analysis. Part I. Physical and mineralogical proprieties, including statistics of measurement and sampling’. (Ed. CA Black) pp. 210–221. (ASA: Madison, WI, USA)
Larson WE, Pierce FJ (1994) The dynamic of soil quality as a measure of sustainable management. In ‘Defining soil quality for a sustainable environment’. SSSA Special Publication No. 35. (Eds JW Doran, DC Coleman, DE Bezdicek, BA Stewart). pp. 53–72. (Soil Science Society of America: Madison, WI, USA)
Liu B, Tu C, Hu S, Gumpeterz M, Beagle Ristaino J (2007) Effect of organic, sustainable and conventional management strategies in grower fields on physical, chemical, and biological factors and the incidence of southern blight. Applied Soil Ecology 37, 202–214.
| Effect of organic, sustainable and conventional management strategies in grower fields on physical, chemical, and biological factors and the incidence of southern blight.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
McCool DK, Pannkuk CD, Kennedy AC, Fletcher PS (2008) Effects of burn/low-till on erosion and soil quality. Soil & Tillage Research 101, 2–9.
| Effects of burn/low-till on erosion and soil quality.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
McGrath D, Zhang CS (2003) Spatial distribution of soil organic carbon concentrations in grassland of Ireland. Applied Geochemistry 18, 1629–1639.
| Spatial distribution of soil organic carbon concentrations in grassland of Ireland.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD3sXltF2jt7k%3D&md5=4cb2b72844623381694f83be5c7999e7CAS |
Melero S, Porras JCR, Herencia JF, Madejon E (2006) Chemical and biochemical properties in a silty loam soil under conventional and organic management. Soil & Tillage Research 90, 162–170.
| Chemical and biochemical properties in a silty loam soil under conventional and organic management.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Monokrousos N, Papatheodoru EM, Diamantopoulus JD, Stamou GP (2006) Soil quality variables in organically and conventionally cultivated field sites. 2006. Soil Biology & Biochemistry 38, 1282–1289.
| Soil quality variables in organically and conventionally cultivated field sites. 2006.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD28XksVOns70%3D&md5=96a1a7e0944b2b5ef4bca211741b04f1CAS |
Nelson DW, Sommers E (1982) Total carbon, organic carbon, and organic matter. In ‘Methods of soil analysis. Part 2’. 2nd edn Agronomy Monograph No. 9. (Ed. AL Page) pp. 539–579. (ASA: Madison, WI, USA)
Noellemeyer E, Frank F, Alvarez C, Morazzo G, Quiroga A (2008) Carbon contents and aggregation related to soil physical and biological properties under a land-use sequence in the semiarid region of central Argentina. Soil & Tillage Research 99, 179–190.
| Carbon contents and aggregation related to soil physical and biological properties under a land-use sequence in the semiarid region of central Argentina.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Pulleman M, Jongmans A, Marinissen J, Bouma J (2003) Effects of organic versus conventional arable farming on soil structure and organic matter dynamics in a marine loam in the Netherlands. Soil Use and Management 19, 157–165.
| Effects of organic versus conventional arable farming on soil structure and organic matter dynamics in a marine loam in the Netherlands.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Raiesi F (2006) Carbon and N mineralization as affected by soil cultivation and crop residue in a calcareous wetland ecosystem in Central Iran. Agriculture, Ecosystem & Environment 112, 13–20.
Romaniuk R, Giuffré L, Costantini A, Nannipieri P (2011a) Assessment of soil microbial diversity measurements as indicators of soil functioning in organic and conventional horticulture systems. Ecological Indicators 11, 1345–1353.
| Assessment of soil microbial diversity measurements as indicators of soil functioning in organic and conventional horticulture systems.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC3MXlvVCjtLY%3D&md5=1ff95af01b80a57b4b7b72ec405d1da6CAS |
Romaniuk R, Giuffré L, Costantini A, Bartoloni N, Nannipieri P (2011b) A comparison of indexing methods to evaluate soil quality: the role of soil microbiological properties. Soil Research 49, 733–741.
| A comparison of indexing methods to evaluate soil quality: the role of soil microbiological properties.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Schutter ME, Dick RP (2000) Comparison of fatty acid methyl ester (FAME) methods for characterizing microbial communities. Soil Science Society of America Journal 64, 1659–1668.
| Comparison of fatty acid methyl ester (FAME) methods for characterizing microbial communities.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD3cXntlGmu78%3D&md5=bcd82cd48ae58a315911b2ec15cc6021CAS |
Shepherd MA, Harrison R, Webb J (2002) Managing soil organic matter implications for soil structure on organic farms. Soil Use and Management 18, 284–292.
| Managing soil organic matter implications for soil structure on organic farms.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Soil Survey Staff (1999) ‘Soil taxonomy: A basic system of soil classification for making and interpreting soil surveys.’ 2nd edn. USDA Handbook 436. (Natural Resources Conservation Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture)
Sparling G, Schipper LA, Yeates GW, Aislabie J, Vojvodic-Vukovic M, Ryburn J, Di HJ, Hewitt AE (2008) Soil characteristics, belowground diversity and rates of simazine mineralization of a New Zeland Gley Soil in a chronosequence under horticultural use. Biology and Fertility of Soils 44, 633–640.
| Soil characteristics, belowground diversity and rates of simazine mineralization of a New Zeland Gley Soil in a chronosequence under horticultural use.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
van Diepeningen AD, de Vos OJ, Korthals GW, Van Bruggen AHC (2006) Effects of organic versus conventional management on chemical and biological parameters on agricultural soils. Applied Soil Ecology 31, 120–135.
| Effects of organic versus conventional management on chemical and biological parameters on agricultural soils.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Vance ED, Brookes PC, Jenkinson DS (1987) An extraction method for measuring soil microbial biomass C. Soil Biology & Biochemistry 19, 703–707.
| An extraction method for measuring soil microbial biomass C.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DyaL1cXjs1KqsA%3D%3D&md5=619d5036dacd709b54824b460cae8c88CAS |
Wander MM, Bollero GA (1999) Soil quality assessment of tillage impacts in Illinois. Soil Science Society of America Journal 63, 961–971.
| Soil quality assessment of tillage impacts in Illinois.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DyaK1MXmsFCnsL4%3D&md5=3adf54e4f8f9b5b36ddc447431d3ff65CAS |
Zhang B, Zhang Y, Chen D, White RE, Li Y (2004) A quantitative evaluation system of soil productivity for intensive agriculture in China. Geoderma 123, 319–331.
