Comparison of three carbon determination methods on naturally occurring substrates and the implication for the quantification of ‘soil carbon’
M. K. Conyers A C , G. J. Poile A , A. A. Oates A , D. Waters A and K. Y. Chan A BA EH Graham Centre for Agricultural Innovation (Industry & Investment NSW and Charles Sturt University), PMB, Pine Gully Road, Wagga Wagga, NSW 2650, Australia.
B Industry & Investment NSW, Locked Bag 4, Richmond, NSW 2753, Australia.
C Corresponding author. Email: mark.conyers@industry.nsw.gov.au
Soil Research 49(1) 27-33 https://doi.org/10.1071/SR10103
Submitted: 14 May 2010 Accepted: 17 August 2010 Published: 4 February 2011
Abstract
Accounting for carbon (C) in soil will require a degree of precision sufficient to permit an assessment of any trend through time. Soil can contain many chemically and physically diverse forms of organic and inorganic carbon, some of which might not meet certain definitions of ‘soil carbon’. In an attempt to assess how measurements of these diverse forms of C might vary with analytical method, we measured the C concentration of 26 substrates by three methods commonly used for soil C (Walkley–Black, Heanes, and Leco). The Heanes and Leco methods were essentially equivalent in their capture of organic C, but the Leco method captured almost all of the inorganic C (carbonates, graphite). The Heanes and Walkley–Black methods did not measure carbonates but did measure 92% and 9%, respectively, of the C in graphite. All three of the common soil test procedures measured some proportion of the charcoal and of the other burnt materials. The proportion of common organic substrates (not the carbonates, graphite, or soil) that was C by weight ranged from ~10% to 90% based on the Heanes and Leco data. The proportion of the organic fraction of those same substrates, as measured by loss-on-ignition, that was C by weight ranged from 42% to 100%. The relationship between Walkley–Black C and total C (by Heanes and Leco) showed that Walkley–Black C was a variable proportion of total C for the 26 substrates. Finally, the well-known, apparent artefact in the Cr-acid methods was investigated: dichromate digestion should contain at least 7–10 mg C in the sample or over-recovery of C might be reported. Our observation that common soil C procedures readily measure C in plant roots and shoots, and in burnt stubble, means that there will likely be intra-annual variation in soil C, because avoidance of these fresh residues is difficult. Such apparent intra-annual variation in soil C will make the detection of long-term trends problematic.
Additional keywords: Leco, Heanes, Walkley–Black.
References
Broadbent FE (1953) The soil organic fraction. In ‘Advances in agronomy’. Vol. 5. (Ed. AG Norman) pp. 153–183. (Academic Press: New York)Chan KY (2001) Soil particulate organic carbon under different land use and management. Soil Use and Management 17, 217–221.
| Soil particulate organic carbon under different land use and management.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Chatterjee A, Lal R, Wielopolski L, Martin MZ, Ebinger MH (2009) Evaluation of different soil carbon determination methods. Critical Reviews in Plant Sciences 28, 164–178.
| Evaluation of different soil carbon determination methods.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD1MXktFClsrc%3D&md5=fb285969e0bcab9b8f63626825c770faCAS |
Conyers MK, Scott BJ (1989) The influence of surface incorporated lime on subsurface soil acidity. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 29, 201–207.
| The influence of surface incorporated lime on subsurface soil acidity.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Grewal KS, Buchan GD, Sherlock RR (1991) A comparison of three methods of organic carbon determination in some New Zealand soils. European Journal of Soil Science 42, 251–257.
| A comparison of three methods of organic carbon determination in some New Zealand soils.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DyaK3MXltlCqsbg%3D&md5=679429e6d6c6fa8f2b550af816be75ebCAS |
Heanes DL (1984) Determination of total organic-C in soils by an improved chromic acid digestion and spectrophotometric procedure. Communications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis 15, 1191–1213.
| Determination of total organic-C in soils by an improved chromic acid digestion and spectrophotometric procedure.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DyaL2cXmt12itL8%3D&md5=4566bf15a19c78f945ceda981d9a23eeCAS |
Kerven GL, Menzies NW, Geyer MD (2000) Soil carbon determination by high temperature combustion—a comparison with dichromate oxidation procedures and the influence of charcoal and carbonate carbon on the measured value. Communications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis 31, 1935–1939.
| Soil carbon determination by high temperature combustion—a comparison with dichromate oxidation procedures and the influence of charcoal and carbonate carbon on the measured value.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD3cXmvVGlsLs%3D&md5=8589b681feff75550e936ae9bc5eb266CAS |
Leco (1995) ‘Instrumentation for characterisation of organic/inorganic materials and microstructural analysis.’ Instruction Manual FP-2000 Protein/Nitrogen Analyses, Form No. 200–558, May 1995. (Leco Corporation: St Joseph, MI)
Matthiessen MK, Larney FJ, Selinger LB, Olson AF (2005) Influence of loss-on-ignition temperature and heating time on ash content of compost and manure. Communications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis 36, 2561–2573.
| Influence of loss-on-ignition temperature and heating time on ash content of compost and manure.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD2MXht1agtrfJ&md5=03b2ca980391d26ddf22ead6b56d4ba7CAS |
Nelson DW, Sommers LE (1982) Total carbon, organic carbon, and organic matter. In ‘Methods of soil analysis’. (Eds AL Page, RH Miller, DR Keeney) pp. 539–579. (American Society of Agronomy Inc., Soil Science Society of America Inc.: Madison, WI)
Nelson DW, Sommers LE (1996) Total carbon, organic carbon, and organic matter. In ‘Methods of soil analysis. Part 3: Chemical methods’. (Eds DL Sparks, AL Page, PA Helmke, RH Loeppert, PN Soltanpour, MA Tabatabai, CT Johnston, ME Sumner) pp. 961–1010. (Soil Science Society of America, Inc., American Society of Agronomy, Inc.: Madison, WI)
Papa G, Spagnol M, Tambone F, Pilu R, Scaglia B, Adani F (2010) Micropore surface area of alkali-soluble plant macromolecules (humic acids) drives their decomposition rates in soil. Chemosphere 78, 1036–1041.
| Micropore surface area of alkali-soluble plant macromolecules (humic acids) drives their decomposition rates in soil.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BC3cXhtlWkurg%3D&md5=f8df2f428768cbecb7fd93c10bb3ba0aCAS | 20015535PubMed |
Schulte EE, Hopkins BG (1996) Estimation of soil organic matter by weight loss-on-ignition. In ‘Soil organic matter: analysis and interpretation’. SSSA Special Publication No. 46. (Eds FR Magdoff, MA Tabatabai, EA Hanlon Jr.) pp. 21–31. (Soil Science Society of America: Madison, WI)
Sims JR, Haby VA (1971) Simplified colorimetric determination of soil organic matter. Soil Science 112, 137–141.
| Simplified colorimetric determination of soil organic matter.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DyaE3MXkvFOls70%3D&md5=af875664df71ff51d88290f3ca08b8a3CAS |
Skjemstad JO, Clarke P, Taylor JA, Oades JM, Mcclure SG (1996) The chemistry and nature of protected carbon in soil. Australian Journal of Soil Research 34, 251–271.
| The chemistry and nature of protected carbon in soil.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DyaK28XisV2is74%3D&md5=ea31ffd1e1165728b3c2c777337e8709CAS |
Szava-Kovats R (2009) Re-analysis on the relationship between organic carbon and loss-on-ignition in soil. Communications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis 40, 2712–2724.
| Re-analysis on the relationship between organic carbon and loss-on-ignition in soil.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD1MXhtlCqurnK&md5=1abba1b7a66f2d44947c401a9f98e0e8CAS |
Tabatabai MA, Bremner JM (1991) Automated instruments for determination of total carbon, nitrogen and sulfur in soils by combustion techniques. In ‘Soil analysis: modern instrumental techniques’. 2nd edn (Ed. KA Smith) pp. 261–286. (Marcel Dekker Inc.: New York)
Walinga I, Kithome M, Novozamsky I, Houba VJG, van der Lee JJ (1992) Spectrophotometric determination of organic carbon in soil. Communications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis 23, 1935–1944.
| Spectrophotometric determination of organic carbon in soil.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DyaK3sXmtFOm&md5=2f192400e9a85863bc7ac0a98f5b61f5CAS |
Walkley A (1947) A critical examination of a rapid method for determining organic carbon in soils – effect of variations in digestion conditions and of inorganic soil constituents. Soil Science 63, 251–264.
| A critical examination of a rapid method for determining organic carbon in soils – effect of variations in digestion conditions and of inorganic soil constituents.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DyaH2sXivVWqtQ%3D%3D&md5=3e1746e4cafbd416f56a140ccba29db1CAS |
Walkley A, Black IA (1934) An examination of the Degtjareff method for determining soil organic matter, and a proposed modification of the chromic acid titration method. Soil Science 37, 29–38.
| An examination of the Degtjareff method for determining soil organic matter, and a proposed modification of the chromic acid titration method.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DyaA2cXitlGmug%3D%3D&md5=8f8216c8a32203f6de7c69e24a34e97bCAS |
Zhang M, Li Y, Stoffella PJ (2005) Comparison of analytical methods for organic matter in composts and organic mulches. Communications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis 36, 2587–2599.
| Comparison of analytical methods for organic matter in composts and organic mulches.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:CAS:528:DC%2BD2MXht1agtrfL&md5=08b3bc4f80e3a9a81db07810b9f7d51bCAS |
