Comparing narratives on carnivore management in a dryland ecosystem: a case study of state-backed lethal control
Joshua Taylor
A * , Paula Núñez B , Pablo Gáspero A , Simon Pooley C and Valeria Fernandez-Arhex A
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations
A Grupo de Fauna, Área de Recursos Naturales, Instituto de Investigaciones Forestales y Agropecuarias Bariloche (IFAB; INTA-CONICET), Modesta Victoria 4450, (8400) San Carlos de Bariloche, Río Negro, Argentina.
B Universidad de Los Lagos - Universidad Nacional de Río Negro, Instituto de Investigación en Diversidad Cultural y Procesos de Cambio, CONICET, Mitre 630, San Carlos de Bariloche, Río Negro, Argentina.
C Department of Geography, Birkbeck University of London, London, UK.
* Correspondence to: taylor.joshua@inta.gob.ar
The Rangeland Journal 45(1) 45-52 https://doi.org/10.1071/RJ23005
Submitted: 19 January 2023 Accepted: 21 May 2023 Published: 6 June 2023
© 2023 The Author(s) (or their employer(s)). Published by CSIRO Publishing on behalf of the Australian Rangeland Society.
Abstract
Lethal control of native carnivores as a principal management strategy can have unforseen ecological consequences and is often of questionable efficacy. Using as a case study a region where the lethal control of native puma and culpeo foxes has been incentivised via legislation for over 50 years, we examined how this policy has affected institutional narratives in the region. We conducted four key informant interviews with members of relevant institutions to establish their perspectives on carnivore management. We also examined the informational basis for the current legislative approach to predation, and identified topics for discussion surrounding legislation and its formation for decision-makers in the province. We identified a duality where two branches of gove rnment have contradictory policies regarding livestock production and carnivore management. All institutions involved in predation management in rural landscapes produced narratives supporting sustainable development, and suggested, in varying degrees, that alternatives to lethal control would be positive. Interviewees stated that modification of the existing laws require livestock producers to demand a change from policy-makers, who generally view carnivores poorly. Furthermore, there is evidence that discussions surrounding management strategies suffer from cultural bias, with rural inhabitants finding themselves marginalised from the decision-making process. We identified a need for empathy regarding the adverse situation of rural inhabitants facing the impacts of predation, and an appreciation of the role that carnivores play within their environments, so as to change the negative discourse surrounding human–carnivore interactions.
Keywords: carnivores, interviews, lethal control, livestock, management, marginalisation, policy, predator control, semiarid zones.
References
2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development (2015a) ‘Transforming Our World: The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development.’ (United Nations) Available at https://sdgs.un.org/goals/goal2 [accessed 9 June 2022]2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development (2015b) ‘Transforming Our World: The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development.’ (United Nations) Available at https://sdgs.un.org/goals/goal12 [accessed 9 June 2022]
2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development (2015c) ‘Transforming Our World: The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development.’ (United Nations) Available at https://sdgs.un.org/goals/goal15 [accessed 9 June 2022]
Amit, R, Gordillo-Chávez, EJ, and Bone, R (2013). Jaguar and puma attacks on livestock in Costa Rica. Human–Wildlife Interactions 7, 77–84.
Baker, PJ, Boitani, L, Harris, S, et al. (2008). Terrestrial carnivores and human food production: impact and management. Mammal Review 38, 123–166.
| Terrestrial carnivores and human food production: impact and management.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Bandieri S, Favaroy O, Morinelli M (1993) ‘Historia de Neuquén.’ (Plus Ultra Press: Buenos Aires, Argentina) [In Spanish]
Bergstrom, BJ (2017). Carnivore conservation: shifting the paradigm from control to coexistence. Journal of Mammalogy 98, 1–6.
| Carnivore conservation: shifting the paradigm from control to coexistence.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Blossey, B, and Hare, D (2022). Myths, Wishful Thinking, and Accountability in Predator Conservation and Management in the United States. Frontiers in Conservation Science 3, .
| Myths, Wishful Thinking, and Accountability in Predator Conservation and Management in the United States.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Bond, J (2014). A holistic approach to natural resource conflict: the case of Laikipia County, Kenya. Journal of Rural Studies 34, 117–127.
| A holistic approach to natural resource conflict: the case of Laikipia County, Kenya.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Consejo Nacional de Coordinación de Políticas Sociales (2020) ‘Segundo Informe Voluntario Nacional de la Argentina 2020.’ 1st edn. (Ciudad Autónoma de Buenos Aires) [In Spanish]
Coronato F (2010) El rol de la ganadería ovina en las construcción del territorio de la Patagonia. Thesis, Institute des Sciens et Industries du Vivant et de I’ Environnement, AgroParisTech, Université Paris-Saclay, France. [In Spanish]
Dickman, AJ, Macdonald, EA, and Macdonald, DW (2011). A review of financial instruments to pay for predator conservation and encourage human–carnivore coexistence. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 108, 13937–13944.
| A review of financial instruments to pay for predator conservation and encourage human–carnivore coexistence.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Dickman, AJ, Hazzah, L, Carbone, C, et al. (2014). Carnivores, culture and ‘contagious conflict’: multiple factors influence perceived problems with carnivores in Tanzania’s Ruaha landscape. Biological Conservation 178, 19–27.
| Carnivores, culture and ‘contagious conflict’: multiple factors influence perceived problems with carnivores in Tanzania’s Ruaha landscape.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Durant, SM, Pettorelli, N, Bashir, S, et al. (2012). Forgotten biodiversity in desert ecosystems. Science 336, 1379–1380.
| Forgotten biodiversity in desert ecosystems.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Easdale, MH, and Domptail, SE (2014). Fate can be changed! Arid rangelands in a globalizing world: a complementary co-evolutionary perspective on the current ‘desert syndrome’. Journal of Arid Environments 100–101, 52–62.
| Fate can be changed! Arid rangelands in a globalizing world: a complementary co-evolutionary perspective on the current ‘desert syndrome’.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Easdale, MH, Aguiar, MR, Román, M, et al. (2009). Comparación socio-económica de dos regiones biofísicas: los sistemas ganaderos de la provincia de Río Negro, Argentina. Cuadernos de Desarrollo Rural 6, 173–198.
Easdale, MH, Sacchero, D, Vigna, M, et al. (2014). Assessing the magnitude of impact of volcanic ash deposits on Merino wool production and fibre traits in the context of a drought in North-West Patagonia, Argentina. The Rangeland Journal 36, 143–149.
| Assessing the magnitude of impact of volcanic ash deposits on Merino wool production and fibre traits in the context of a drought in North-West Patagonia, Argentina.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Eklund, A, Johansson, M, Flykt, A, et al. (2020). Drivers of intervention use to protect domestic animals from large carnivore attacks. Human Dimensions of Wildlife 25, 339–354.
| Drivers of intervention use to protect domestic animals from large carnivore attacks.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Fernandez-Arhex V, Easdale MH, Castillo D, et al. (2016) ‘Manejo Integrado de depredadores en sistemas ganaderos en Patagonia.’ (Ediciones INTA) [In Spanish]
Funes, MC, Novaro, AJ, Monsalvo, OB, et al. (2006). El Manejo de Zorros en la Argentina: Compatibilizando las Interacciones entre la ganaderia y la caza comercial y la Conservación. Manejo de Fauna Silvestre en la Argentina. Programas de Uso Sustentable , 151–166.
Gaitán, JJ, Bran, DE, Oliva, GE, et al. (2017). Aridity and overgrazing have convergent effects on ecosystem structure and functioning in Patagonian rangelands. Land Degradation & Development 29, 210–218.
| Aridity and overgrazing have convergent effects on ecosystem structure and functioning in Patagonian rangelands.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Gáspero, PG, Easdale, MH, Pereira, JA, et al. (2018). Human–carnivore interaction in a context of socio-productive crisis: assessing smallholder strategies for reducing predation in North-west Patagonia, Argentina. Journal of Arid Environments 150, 92–98.
| Human–carnivore interaction in a context of socio-productive crisis: assessing smallholder strategies for reducing predation in North-west Patagonia, Argentina.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Guerisoli, MM, Luengos Vidal, E, Franchini, M, et al. (2017). Characterization of puma–livestock conflicts in rangelands of central Argentina. Royal Society Open Science 4, 170852.
| Characterization of puma–livestock conflicts in rangelands of central Argentina.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Guerisoli, MM, Luengos Vidal, E, Caruso, N, et al. (2020). Puma–livestock conflicts in the Americas: a review of the evidence. Mammal Review 51, 228–246.
| Puma–livestock conflicts in the Americas: a review of the evidence.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Gusset, M, Maddock, AH, Gunther, GJ, et al. (2008). Conflicting human interests over the re-introduction of endangered wild dogs in South Africa. Biodiversity and Conservation 17, 83–101.
| Conflicting human interests over the re-introduction of endangered wild dogs in South Africa.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Holling, CS, and Meffe, GK (1996). Command and control and the pathology of natural resource management. Conservation Biology 10, 328–337.
| Command and control and the pathology of natural resource management.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Huang R (2016) RQDA: R-based Qualitative Data Analysis. R package version 0.2-8. http://rqda.r-forge.r-project.org/
INDEC (2021) Censo Nacional Agropecuario 2018: resultados definitivos. 1a ed. - Ciudad Autónoma de Buenos Aires: Instituto Nacional de Estadística y Censos - INDEC, 2021. https://www.indec.gob.ar/ftp/cuadros/economia/cna2018_resultados_definitivos.pdf [accessed 21 January 2022] [In Spanish]
Inskip, C, and Zimmermann, A (2009). Human–felid conflict: a review of patterns and priorities worldwide. Oryx 43, 18–34.
| Human–felid conflict: a review of patterns and priorities worldwide.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
International Livestock Research Institute (2002) ‘Livestock: a pathway out of poverty. ILRI’s strategy to 2010. 24 pp. (ILRI: Nairobi, Kenya)
IUCN (2022) ‘Human–wildlife conflict.’ Issues Brief by IUCN. (IUCN)
Lichtenstein, G, and Carmanchahi, P D (2012). Guanaco management by pastoralists in the Southern Andes. Pastoralism: Research, Policy and Practice 2, 16.
| Guanaco management by pastoralists in the Southern Andes.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Llanos, R, Andrade, A, and Alejandro, T (2019). Puma and livestock in central Patagonia (Argentina): from ranchers’ perceptions to predator management. Human Dimensions of Wildlife 25, 1–16.
| Puma and livestock in central Patagonia (Argentina): from ranchers’ perceptions to predator management.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Lovan WR, Murray M, Shaffer R (Eds) (2017) ‘Participatory governance: planning, conflict mediation and public decision-making in civil society.’ (Routledge)
Lucherini M (2016) Lycalopex culpaeus. The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species 2016: e.T6929A85324366.
| Crossref | [accessed 13 July 2022]
Macon D, Baldwin R, Lile D, et al. (2018). Livestock Protection Tools for California Ranchers.
| Crossref |, Retrieved from https://escholarship.org/uc/item/1dh2z0d5
Manfredo, MJ, Bruskotter, JT, Teel, TL, et al. (2017). Why social values cannot be changed for the sake of conservation. Conservation Biology 31, 772–780.
| Why social values cannot be changed for the sake of conservation.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Marchini S (2014) Who’s in conflict with whom? Human dimensions of the conflicts involving wildlife. In ‘Applied ecology and human dimensions in biological conservation’. (Eds LM Verdade, MC Lyra-Jorge, CI Piña) pp. 189–209. (Springer: Berlin, Germany)
Márquez, C, Vargas, JM, Villafuerte, R, et al. (2013). Understanding the propensity of wild predators to illegal poison baiting. Animal Conservation 16, 118–129.
| Understanding the propensity of wild predators to illegal poison baiting.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
McKeon, GM, Stone, GS, Syktus, JI, et al. (2009). Climate change impacts on northern Australian rangeland livestock carrying capacity: a review of issues. The Rangeland Journal 31, 1–29.
| Climate change impacts on northern Australian rangeland livestock carrying capacity: a review of issues.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Middleton, N, Stringer L, Goudie A, et al. (2011) ‘The forgotten billion: MDG achievement in the drylands.’ (United Nations Development Programme: New York, NY, USA)
Miller, JRB, Stoner, KJ, Cejtin, MR, et al. (2016). Effectiveness of contemporary techniques for reducing livestock depredations by large carnivores. Wildlife Society Bulletin 40, 806–815.
| Effectiveness of contemporary techniques for reducing livestock depredations by large carnivores.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Mottet, A, Teillard, F, Boettcher, P, et al. (2018). Review: domestic herbivores and food security: current contribution, trends and challenges for a sustainable development. Animal 12, s188–s198.
| Review: domestic herbivores and food security: current contribution, trends and challenges for a sustainable development.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Nicholson, SK, Marneweck, DG, Lindsey, PA, et al. (2020). A 20-year review of the status and distribution of African wild dogs (Lycaon pictus) in South Africa. African Journal of Wildlife Research 50, 8–19.
| A 20-year review of the status and distribution of African wild dogs (Lycaon pictus) in South Africa.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Nielsen C, Thompson D, Kelly M, et al. (2015) Puma concolor (errata version published in 2016). The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species 2015: e.T18868A97216466.
| Crossref | [accessed 13 July 2022]
Novaro, AJ (1995). Sustainability of harvest of culpeo foxes in Patagonia. Oryx 29, 18–22.
| Sustainability of harvest of culpeo foxes in Patagonia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Núñez PG (2016) ‘Sombras del desarrollo: La Patagonia de la energía y la formación de la Provincia de Río Negro’ (UNRN-IIDYPCA: San Carlos de Bariloche, Argentina) [In Spanish]
Ohrens, O, Treves, A, and Bonacic, C (2016). Relationship between rural depopulation and puma–human conflict in the high Andes of Chile. Environmental Conservation 43, 24–33.
| Relationship between rural depopulation and puma–human conflict in the high Andes of Chile.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Oliva G, Gaitán J, Ferrante D (2016) Humans cause deserts: evidence of irreversible changes in Argentinian Patagonia rangelands. In ‘The end of desertification?’. Springer Earth System Sciences. (Eds R Behnke, M Mortimore) (Springer: Berlin, Germany)
| Crossref |
Paruelo, JM (2005) Cuánto se han desertificado las estepas patagónicas? Evidencias a partir de la memoria del sistema. In ‘La heterogeneidad de la vegetación de los agroecosistemas–Un homenaje a Rolando JC León’. (Eds M Oesterheld, MR Aguiar, CM Ghersa, JM Paruelo) pp. 303-319. (Editorial Facultad de Agronomía, Universidad de Bs. As., Argentina) [In Spanish]
Pascual, U, Adams, WM, Díaz, S, et al. (2021). Biodiversity and the challenge of pluralism. Nature Sustainability 4, 567–572.
| Biodiversity and the challenge of pluralism.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Plaza, PI, and Lambertucci, SA (2020). Ecology and conservation of a rare species: what do we know and what may we do to preserve Andean condors? Biological Conservation 251, 108782.
| Ecology and conservation of a rare species: what do we know and what may we do to preserve Andean condors?Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Pooley, S, Barua, M, Beinart, W, et al. (2017). An interdisciplinary review of current and future approaches to improving human–predator relations. Conservation Biology 31, 513–523.
| An interdisciplinary review of current and future approaches to improving human–predator relations.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Redpath, SM, Young, J, Evely, A, et al. (2013). Understanding and managing conservation conflicts. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 28, 100–109.
| Understanding and managing conservation conflicts.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Redpath, SM, Linnell, JDC, Festa-Bianchet, M, et al. (2017). Don’t forget to look down: collaborative approaches to predator conservation. Biological Reviews 92, 2157–2163.
| Don’t forget to look down: collaborative approaches to predator conservation.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Saldaña J (2013) ‘The coding manual for qualitative researchers.’ 3rd edn. 303 pp. (SAGE Publications: London, UK)
Scarnecchia, DL (1990). Concepts of carrying capacity and substitution ratios: a systems viewpoint. Journal of Range Management 43, 553–555.
| Concepts of carrying capacity and substitution ratios: a systems viewpoint.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Secretaria de Recursos Naturales y Desarrollo Sustentable (1998) Convenio sobre diversidad biológica – Informe de Argentina. pp. 1–61. https://www.cbd.int/doc/world/ar/ar-nr-01-es.pdf [accessed 13 July 2022] [In Spanish]
Smith, ME, Linnell, JDC, Odden, J, and Swenson, JE (2000). Review of methods to reduce livestock depradation: I. Guardian animals. Acta Agriculturae Scandinavica, Section A: Animal Science 50, 279–290.
| Review of methods to reduce livestock depradation: I. Guardian animals.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
(2016). Código de Ética para la investigación, la investigación-acción y la colaboración etnocientífica en América Latina. Revista Etnobiología 14, 1–34.
Stafford Smith, M (2008). The ‘desert syndrome’: causally-linked factors that characterise outback Australia. The Rangeland Journal 30, 3–14.
| The ‘desert syndrome’: causally-linked factors that characterise outback Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Thomas, DR (2006). A general inductive approach for analyzing qualitative evaluation data. American Journal of Evaluation 27, 237–246.
| A general inductive approach for analyzing qualitative evaluation data.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
van Eeden, LM, Crowther, MS, Dickman, CR, et al. (2018). Managing conflict between large carnivores and livestock. Conservation Biology 32, 26–34.
| Managing conflict between large carnivores and livestock.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
van Eeden, L, Dickman, C, Crowther, M, and Newsome, T (2020a). A theory of change for promoting coexistence between dingoes and livestock production. Conservation Science and Practice 3, .
| A theory of change for promoting coexistence between dingoes and livestock production.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
van Eeden, LM, Slagle, K, Newsome, TM, et al. (2020b). Exploring nationality and social identity to explain attitudes toward conservation actions in the United States and Australia. Conservation Biology 34, 1165–1175.
| Exploring nationality and social identity to explain attitudes toward conservation actions in the United States and Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Villagra, ES, Pelliza, A, Willems, P, et al. (2013). What do domestic livestock eat in northern Patagonian rangelands? Animal Production Science 53, 360–367.
| What do domestic livestock eat in northern Patagonian rangelands?Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Zimmermann A, Baker N, Inskip C, et al. (2009) Contemporary views of human–carnivore conflicts on wild rangelands. In ‘Wild rangelands: conserving wildlife while maintaining livestock in semi-arid ecosystems’. 1st edn. (Eds JT du Toit, R Kock, JC Deutsch) pp. 129–151. (Blackwell Publishing: New Jersey, USA) https://doi.org/ 10.1002/9781444317091.ch6
