Social-identity dynamics in rural communities: a motive for resistance to change
Saleena Ham
A *
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations
A Rural Economies Centre of Excellence, University of Southern Queensland, Toowoomba, Queensland, Australia.
* Correspondence to: saleena.ham@usq.edu.au
The Rangeland Journal - https://doi.org/10.1071/RJ22023
Submitted: 2 April 2022 Accepted: 29 September 2022 Published online: 25 October 2022
© 2022 The Author(s) (or their employer(s)). Published by CSIRO Publishing on behalf of the Australian Rangeland Society.
Abstract
This research found that rural social resistance to change and newcomers can be explained in part by the influence of social-set membership. Eighty-nine interviews were conducted in two Australian inland rural communities with population <2000 and analysed with a recognised cultural dynamics framework. This found attachment to local social identity, social hierarchy and cultural norms that represented social power. Established residents defended the status quo when valued facets of social identity were perceived to be threatened, resisting efforts to introduce change. Persons representing a challenge to established local identity norms could be socially undermined and censured to preserve the power of dominant social sets, defending their preferred narratives and norms. Understanding social identity influences can explain rural communities’ tendency to conservatism, why newcomers and new ideas are often derided, ignored or attacked. It can explain the motives for negative social capital and suggests social identity as a factor in small town newcomer business failure, and resistance to new knowledge transfer and practice adoption. Welcome and induction to local social codes is critical to newcomer integration. Outsiders and newcomers may meet discretely with like-minded or similar persons to safely fulfil social needs or influence as a social minority, providing support to their own unique group. Where residents cannot find inclusion, they may disengage. Understanding social identity can provide insights for community leaders, development practitioners, extension officers and newcomers struggling to serve and innovate in rural and rangelands communities.
Keywords: change, community, exclusion, inclusion, knowledge transfer, rural, social identity, social influences, social power.
References
Abrams, D, and Hogg, MA (2004). Metatheory: lessons from social identity research. Personality and Scoial Psychology Review 8, 98–106.| Metatheory: lessons from social identity research.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Abrams D, Hogg MA (2010) Social identity and self-categorization. In ‘The SAGE handbook of prejudice, stereotyping and discrimination’. (Eds JF Dovidio, P Glick, M Hewstone, VM Esses) pp. 179–193. (SAGE Publications)
Alston M (2005) Social exclusion in rural Australia. In ‘Sustainability and change in rural Australia’. (Eds C Cocklin, J Dibden) (University of New South Wales: Sydney, NSW, Australia)
Alter, AL, Aronson, J, Darley, JM, Rodriguez, C, and Ruble, DN (2010). Rising to the threat: Reducing stereotype threat by reframing the threat as a challenge. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 46, 166–171.
| Rising to the threat: Reducing stereotype threat by reframing the threat as a challenge.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Argent, NM, Smailes, PJ, and Griffin, T (2005). Tracing the density impulse in rural settlement systems: a quantitative analysis of the factors underlying rural population density across South-Eastern Australia, 1981–2001. Population and Environment 27, 151–190.
| Tracing the density impulse in rural settlement systems: a quantitative analysis of the factors underlying rural population density across South-Eastern Australia, 1981–2001.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Australian Bureau of Statistics (2016) Australian Census 2016 – Demographics and Education. Available at https://www.abs.gov.au/websitebs/censushome.nsf/home/2016
Bauer, TN, Perrot, S, Liden, RC, and Erdogan, B (2019). Understanding the consequences of newcomer proactive behaviours: the moderating contextual role of servant leadership. Journal of Vocational Behavior 112, 356–368.
| Understanding the consequences of newcomer proactive behaviours: the moderating contextual role of servant leadership.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Bryson, L, and Mowbray, M (2005). More spray on solution: community, social capital and evidence based policy. Australian Journal of Social Issues 40, 91–106.
| More spray on solution: community, social capital and evidence based policy.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Burris, CT, and Jackson, LM (2000). Social identity and the true believer: responses to threatened self‐stereotypes among the intrinsically religious. British Journal of Social Psychology 39, 257–278.
| Social identity and the true believer: responses to threatened self‐stereotypes among the intrinsically religious.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Cikara, M, Botvinik, MM, and Fiske, ST (2011). Us versus them: social identity shapes neural responses to intergroup competition and harm. Psychological Science 22, 306–313.
| Us versus them: social identity shapes neural responses to intergroup competition and harm.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Clarkson, JJ, Tormala, ZL, Rucker, DD, and Dugan, RG (2013). The malleable influence of social consensus on attitude certainty. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 49, 1019–1022.
| The malleable influence of social consensus on attitude certainty.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Clarkson, J, Smith, E, Tormala, ZL, and Dugan, RG (2017). Group identification as a means of attitude restoration. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 68, 139–145.
| Group identification as a means of attitude restoration.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Combs, G, and Freedman, J (2012). Narrative poststructuralism and Social Justice: Current Practices in Narrative Therapy. The Counselling Psychologist 40, 1033–1060.
| Narrative poststructuralism and Social Justice: Current Practices in Narrative Therapy.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Cuervo, H, and Cook, J (2019). Formations of belonging in Australia: the role of nostalgia in experiences of time and place. Population, Space and Place 25, e2214.
Devine-Wright, P (2009). Rethinking NIMBYism: the role of place attachment and place identity in explaining place-protective action. Jounrnal of Community & Applied Social Psychology 19, 421–441.
| Rethinking NIMBYism: the role of place attachment and place identity in explaining place-protective action.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Ellemers N, Spears R, Doosje B (1999) Commitment and strategic responses to social context. In ‘Social identity: context, commitment, content’. (Eds N Ellemers, R Spears, B Doosje) pp. 127–146. (Blackwell Science: Oxford, UK)
Fairclough N (1992) ‘Discourse and social change.’ (Blackwell Publishers: Cambridge, UK)
Fairclough N, Wodak R (1997) Critical discourse analysis. In ‘Introduction to discourse analysis’. (Ed. TA Van Dijk) pp. 258–284. (Sage: London, UK)
Fritsche, I, Eva, J, Catherina, A, Magdalena, B, Johannes, K, Anna-Marie, M, and Marlene, S (2013). The power of we: evidence for group-based control. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 49, 19–32.
| The power of we: evidence for group-based control.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Gaertner SL, Dovidio JF (2000) ‘Reducing intergroup bias: the common ingroup identity model.’ (Psychology Press: Philadelphia, PA, USA)
Garbutt, R (2009). Social inclusion and local practices of belonging. Cosmopolitan Civil Societies 1, 84–108.
| Social inclusion and local practices of belonging.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Greenaway, KH, Louis, WR, Hornsey, MJ, and Jones, JM (2014). Perceived control qualifies the effects of threat on prejudice. British Journal of Social Pscychology 53, 422–442.
| Perceived control qualifies the effects of threat on prejudice.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Hogg MA (2005) All animals are equal but some animals are more equal than others: social identity and marginal membership. In ‘The social outcast: ostracism, social exclusion, rejection, and bullying’. (Eds KD Williams, JP Forgas, W Von Hippel) pp. 201–212. (Psychology Press)
Hogg MA (2012) Social identity and the group context of trust: Managing risk and building trust through belonging. In ‘Trust in Cooperative Risk Management: uncertainty and scepticism in the public mind’. (Eds M Siegrist, TC Earle, H Gutscher) pp. 51–72. (Routledge)
| Crossref |
Hogg, MA (2018). Self‐uncertainty, leadership preference, and communication of social identity. Atlantic Journal of Communication 26, 111–121.
| Self‐uncertainty, leadership preference, and communication of social identity.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Hogg, MA, and Reid, SA (2006). Social identity, self-categorization, and the communication of group norms. Communication Theory 16, 7–30.
| Social identity, self-categorization, and the communication of group norms.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Hogg, MA, and Rinella, MJ (2018). Social identities and shared realities. Current Opinion in Psychology 23, 6–10.
| Social identities and shared realities.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Holmes JH (1981) Settlement systems in sparsely populated regions: the United States and Australia. In ‘Settlement systems in sparsely populated regions’. (Eds RE Lonsdale, JH Holmes) pp. 70–104. (Pergamon: New York, NY, USA)
Holmes JH (1987) Population. In ‘Australia: a geography’. (Ed. DN Jeans) pp. 24–48. (Sydney University Press: Sydney, NSW, Australia)
Hornsey, MJ (2008). Social identity theory and self-categorization theory: a historical review. Social and Persoality Psychology Compass 2, 204–222.
| Social identity theory and self-categorization theory: a historical review.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Hornsey, MJ, and Jetten, J (2003). Not being what you claim to be: impostors as sources of group threat. European Journal of Social Psychology 33, 639–657.
| Not being what you claim to be: impostors as sources of group threat.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Jenkins R (2004) ‘Social identity.’ (Routledge: London, UK)
Jokisaari M, Nurmi J‐E (2012) Getting the right connections? The consequences and antecedent of social networks in newcomer socialization. In ‘The Oxford handbook of organizational socialization’. (Ed. CR Wanberg) pp. 78–96. (Oxford University Press) Available at https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2012‐17778‐005
Kashima, Y, Bratanova, B, and Peters, K (2018). Social transmission and shared reality in cultural dynamics. Current Opinion in Psychology 23, 15–19.
| Social transmission and shared reality in cultural dynamics.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Kenyon P, Black A (2001) Small town renewal: overview and case studies. (Rural Industries Research and Development Corporation: Canberra, ACT) Available at https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED458055.pdf
Korte, RF (2009). How newcomers learn the social norms of an organisation: a case study of the socialisation of newly hired engineers. Human Resource Development Quarterly 20, 285–305.
| How newcomers learn the social norms of an organisation: a case study of the socialisation of newly hired engineers.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Korte, RF, and Lin, S (2013). Getting on board: organizational socialization and the contribution of social capital. Human Relations 66, 407–442.
| Getting on board: organizational socialization and the contribution of social capital.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Kreindler, SA, Dowd, DA, Dana Star, N, and Gottschalk, T (2012). Silos and social identity: the social identity approach as a framework for understanding and overcoming divisions in health care. The Milbank Quarterly 90, 347–374.
| Silos and social identity: the social identity approach as a framework for understanding and overcoming divisions in health care.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Lamont, M, and Molnár, V (2002). The study of boundaries in the social sciences. Annual review of sociology 28, 167–195.
| The study of boundaries in the social sciences.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Lee, J, Arnason, A, Nightingale, A, and Shucksmith, M (2005). Networking: social capital and identities in European rural development. Sociologia Ruralis 45, 269–283.
| Networking: social capital and identities in European rural development.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Leitch, S, and Palmer, I (2010). Analysing texts in context: current practices and new protocols for critical discourse analysis in organization studies. Journal of Management Studies 47, 1194–1212.
| Analysing texts in context: current practices and new protocols for critical discourse analysis in organization studies.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Lüders A, Eva J, Immo F, Dimitrij A (2016) Between the lines of us and them: identity threat, anxious uncertainty, and reactive in-group affirmation: how an antisocial outcomes be prevented? In ‘Understanding peace and conflict through social identity theory’. (Eds S McKeown, R Haji, N Ferguson) pp. 33–53. (Springer International Publishing: Switzerland)
McAdams, DP, and McLean, KC (2013). Narrative identity. Current Directions in Psychological Science 22, 233–238.
| Narrative identity.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
McHenry‐Sorber, E, and Schafft, K (2015). Make my day, shoot a teacher: Tactics of inclusion and exclusion and the contestation of community in a rural school‐community conflict. International Journal of Inclusive Education 19, 733–747.
| Make my day, shoot a teacher: Tactics of inclusion and exclusion and the contestation of community in a rural school‐community conflict.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Mieroop D (2015) Social Identity Theory and the Discursive Analysis of Collective Identities in Narratives. In ‘The Handbook of Narrative Analysis’. (Eds A De Fina, A Georgakopoulou) (John Wiley & Sons, Inc.) Available at https://doi.org/eu.wiley.com/WileyCDA/WileyTitle/productCd‐111845815X.html
Nieuwenhuis, M, Manstead, AS, and Easterbrook, MJ (2019). Accounting for unequal access to higher education: the role of social identity factors. Group Processes & Intergroup Relations 22, 371–389.
Ok, C, and Park, J (2018). Change in newcomers’ job satisfaction: Met‐expectations effect as a moderator. Social Behavior and Personality: an international journal 46, 1513–1521.
| Change in newcomers’ job satisfaction: Met‐expectations effect as a moderator.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Patten, E, O’Meara, P, and Dickson-Swift, V (2015). Scoping review of the exclusion and inclusion of rural newcomers in community participation. Australian Journal of Rural Health 23, 127–135.
| Scoping review of the exclusion and inclusion of rural newcomers in community participation.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Paull M (2009) Barriers to volunteering by newcomers in Wheatbelt towns in Western Australia. (Edith Cowan University: Volunteering, WA, Australia) Available at http://researchrepository.murdoch.edu.au/id/eprint/33969
Phelps, D, and Kelly, D (2019). Overcoming drought vulnerability in rangeland communities: lessons from central-western Queensland. The Rangeland Journal 41, 251–270.
| Overcoming drought vulnerability in rangeland communities: lessons from central-western Queensland.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Pickett, CL, Bonner, BL, and Coleman, JM (2002). Motivated self-stereotyping: heightened assimilation and differentiation needs result in increased levels of positive and negative self-stereotyping. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 82, 543–562.
| Motivated self-stereotyping: heightened assimilation and differentiation needs result in increased levels of positive and negative self-stereotyping.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Potter J (1996) Discourse analysis and constructionist approaches: theoretical background. In ‘Handbook of qualitative research methods for psychology and the social sciences’. (Ed. JTE Richardson) (BPS Books: Leicester, UK)
Reicher, S (2004). The context of social identity: domination, resistance, and change. Political Psychology 25, 921–945.
| The context of social identity: domination, resistance, and change.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Scheepers, D, and Ellemers, N (2005). When the pressure is up: the assessment of social identity threat in low and high status groups. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 41, 192–200.
| When the pressure is up: the assessment of social identity threat in low and high status groups.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Schegloff, EA (1997). Whose text? Whose context? Discourse & Society 8, 165–187.
| Whose text? Whose context?Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Smailes, PJ, Argent, N, and Griffin, TLC (2002). Rural population density: its impact on social and demographic aspects of rural communities. Journal of Rural Studies 18, 385–404.
| Rural population density: its impact on social and demographic aspects of rural communities.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Stollberg J, Immo F, Baerth M, Jugert P (2016) Extending control perceptions of the social self: Ingroups serve the restoration of control. In ‘Coping with a lack of control in a social world’. (Eds M Bukowski, I Fritsche, A Guinote, M Kofta) (Psychology Press)
Swann, R, and Hughes, G (2016). Exploring micro-sociality through the lens of ‘established outsider’ figurational dynamics in a South Wales community. The Sociological Review 64, 681–698.
| Exploring micro-sociality through the lens of ‘established outsider’ figurational dynamics in a South Wales community.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Tajfel H (1981) ‘Human groups and social categories.’ (Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK)
Tanis, M, and Postmes, T (2005). A social identity approach to trust: interpersonal perception, group membership and trusting behaviour. European Journal of Social Psychology 35, 413–424.
Tracy K, Naughton JM (2000) Institutional identity-work: a better lens. In ‘Small talk’. (Ed. J Coupland) (Routledge)
| Crossref |
Turner, JC (1975). Social comparison and social identity: some prospects for intergroup behaviour. European Journal of Social Psychology 5, 1–34.
| Social comparison and social identity: some prospects for intergroup behaviour.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Turner JC (1982) Towards a cognitive redefinition of the social group. In ‘Social identity and intergroup relations University Press’. (Ed. T Henri) pp. 15–40. (Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK)
van den Hoonaard, DK (2002). Life on the margins of a Florida retirement community: the experience of snowbirds, newcomers, and widowed persons. Research on Aging 24, 50–66.
| Life on the margins of a Florida retirement community: the experience of snowbirds, newcomers, and widowed persons.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Vignoles, VL, Regalia, C, Manzi, C, Golledge, J, and Scabini, E (2006). Beyond self-esteem: influence of multiple motives on identity construction. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 90, 308–333.
| Beyond self-esteem: influence of multiple motives on identity construction.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Wodak R, Meyer M (2009) ‘Methods for critical discourse analysis.’ (Sage: London, UK)
