Can extension programs improve grazing management in rangelands: a case study in Australia’s Great Barrier Reef catchments
John Rolfe A C , Megan Star A and Adam Curcio B
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations
A School of Business and Law, CQUniversity, Qld, Australia.
B Resource Consulting Services, 44 Arthur St, Yeppoon, Qld, Australia.
C Corresponding author. Email: j.rolfe@cqu.edu.au
The Rangeland Journal 42(6) 447-459 https://doi.org/10.1071/RJ20098
Submitted: 9 October 2020 Accepted: 19 January 2021 Published: 11 February 2021
Journal Compilation © Australian Rangeland Society 2020 Open Access CC BY-NC-ND
Abstract
A key challenge in reducing sediment moving from grazing lands into the Great Barrier Reef in Australia is to encourage beef cattle producers to improve management practices. Excessive grazing pressures cause land degradation, leading to both increased sediment runoff and lower future profits. Although higher grazing rates may be possible (and profitable) in better seasons, slow rates of adjustment to poorer seasons can lead to overgrazing and negative impacts on land condition. For policymakers the challenge is to find mechanisms that encourage or signal producers to be more precise in their management and avoid overstocking. Some of the most common options include extension programs, grant programs that use financial incentives, and regulation.
In this paper we outline a conceptual framework that shows why extension may be a more powerful driver of management change than incentive programs, and then test this through an evaluation of a case study program conducted with beef cattle producers in catchments of the Great Barrier Reef, Australia. The pathway involving landholders to implement management change was through improved efficiency and productivity, as these are the issues that drive ongoing participation in broader environmental programs.
The results present multiple lines of evidence to infer positive outcomes of an extension program in terms of changed management practices, which may be expected to generate improved productivity and better water quality outcomes. These can be grouped into three key areas. First, outcomes show positive improvement relative to the Grazing Water Quality Risk framework for the Great Barrier Reef catchments, which is designed to assess the links between land management and water quality. This indicates that resource condition is likely to improve and sediment emissions should be reduced over time. A second outcome is increased landholder engagement and improved understanding of their business and engagement in future programs, which should underpin ongoing adoption. A third outcome is improved management of risk and developing the skills to do this through data collection and monitoring, which should improve management responses in drought years.
Keywords: economics, grazing, management, rangelands, land condition, extension program, water quality, Great Barrier Reef, sediment.
References
Ash, A., McIvor, J., Corfield, J., and Winter, W. (1995). How land condition alters plant-animal relationships in Australia’s tropical rangelands. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 56, 77–92.| How land condition alters plant-animal relationships in Australia’s tropical rangelands.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Ash, A., O’Reagain, P., McKeon, G., and Stafford Smith, D. (Eds) (2000). ‘Managing Climate Variability in Grazing Enterprises: A Case Study of Dalrymple Shire, Northeastern Australia.’ (Kluwer Academic Press: Dordrecht, Netherlands.)
Ash, A., Corfield, J., McIvor, J., and Ksiksi, T. (2011). Grazing management in tropical savannas: Utilisation and rest strategies to manipulate rangeland condition. Rangeland Ecology and Management 64, 223–239.
| Grazing management in tropical savannas: Utilisation and rest strategies to manipulate rangeland condition.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Australian Government and Queensland Government (2018). Results Great Barrier Reef Report Card 2016. Reef Water Quality Protection Plan Secretariat, Brisbane, Qld.
Barbi, E., Denham, R., and Star, M. (2015). Do improved grazing management practices lead to increased levels of ground cover? Rural Extension and Innovation Systems Journal 11, 114.
Bartley, R., Bainbridge, Z., Lewis, S., Kroon, F., Wilkinson, N., Brodie, J., and Silburn, D. (2014a). Relating sediment impacts on coral reefs to watershed sources, processes and management: a review. The Science of the Total Environment 468–469, 1138–1153.
| Relating sediment impacts on coral reefs to watershed sources, processes and management: a review.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 24121565PubMed |
Bartley, R., Corfield, J., Hawdon, A., Kinsey-Henderson, A., Abbott, B., Wilkinson, S., and Keen, R. (2014b). Can changes to pasture management reduce runoff and sediment loss to the Great Barrier Reef? The results of a 10-year study in the Burdekin catchment, Australia. The Rangeland Journal 36, 67–84.
| Can changes to pasture management reduce runoff and sediment loss to the Great Barrier Reef? The results of a 10-year study in the Burdekin catchment, Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Carroll, C., Waters, D., Vardy, S., Silburn, D., Attard, S., Thorburn, P., Davis, A., Halpin, N., Schmidt, M., Wilson, B., and Clark, A. (2012). A Paddock to reef monitoring and modelling framework for the Great Barrier Reef: Paddock and catchment component. Marine Pollution Bulletin 65, 136–149.
| A Paddock to reef monitoring and modelling framework for the Great Barrier Reef: Paddock and catchment component.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 22277580PubMed |
Chilcott, C., McCallum, B., Quirk, M., and Paton, C. (2003). Grazing Land Management Education Package Workshop Notes – Burdekin. Meat & Livestock Australia, Sydney, NSW.
Chilcott, C., Sandral, C., Aisthorpe, J., Paton, C., and McCallum, B. (2005). Grazing Land Management – Fitzroy Basin Version Workshop Notes. Meat & Livestock Australia, Sydney, NSW.
Druce, P. (1966). Rural extension and the agricultural economist. Australian Journal of Agricultural Economics 10, 97–111.
| Rural extension and the agricultural economist.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Dunn, B., Smart, A., Gates, R., Johnson, P., Beutler, M., Diersen, M., and Janssen, L. (2010). Long-term production and profitability from grazing cattle in the Northern Mixed Grass Prairie. Rangeland Ecology and Management 63, 233–242.
| Long-term production and profitability from grazing cattle in the Northern Mixed Grass Prairie.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Fernandez-Gimenez, M., Ruyle, G., and McClaran, S. (2005). An evaluation of Arizona Cooperative Extension’s Rangeland Monitoring Program. Rangeland Ecology and Management 58, 89–98.
| An evaluation of Arizona Cooperative Extension’s Rangeland Monitoring Program.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Fraser, G., and Stone, G. (2016). The effect of soil and pasture attributes on rangeland infiltration rates in northern Australia. The Rangeland Journal 38, 245–259.
| The effect of soil and pasture attributes on rangeland infiltration rates in northern Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Great Barrier Reef Water Science Taskforce (2016). Great Barrier Reef Water Science Taskforce Report – Final Report. Government of Queensland, Brisbane.
Gregg, D., and Rolfe, J. (2016). Using experiments to improve understanding of limits to decision making in Grazing Land Management. Land Use Policy 54, 508–521.
Gregg, D., and Rolfe, J. (2017). Risk behaviours and grazing land management: a framed field experiment and linkages to range land condition. Journal of Agricultural Economics 68, 682–709.
Gregg, D., and Rolfe, J. (2018). Myopia and saliency in renewable resource management. Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 62, 394–419.
Greiner, R., and Gregg, D. (2011). Farmers’ intrinsic motivations, barriers to the adoption of conservation practices and effectiveness of policy instruments: Empirical evidence from northern Australia. Land Use Policy 28, 257–265.
| Farmers’ intrinsic motivations, barriers to the adoption of conservation practices and effectiveness of policy instruments: Empirical evidence from northern Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Hunt, L., McIvor, J., Grice, A., and Bray, S. (2014). Principles and guidelines for managing cattle grazing in the grazing lands of northern Australia: stocking rates, pasture resting, prescribed fire, paddock size and water points – a review. The Rangeland Journal 36, 105–119.
| Principles and guidelines for managing cattle grazing in the grazing lands of northern Australia: stocking rates, pasture resting, prescribed fire, paddock size and water points – a review.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Jones, R. J., and Sandland, R. L. (1974). The relation between animal gain and stocking rate in grazing trials: derivation of a model from experimental results. The Journal of Agricultural Science 83, 335–342.
| The relation between animal gain and stocking rate in grazing trials: derivation of a model from experimental results.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Karfs, R., Abbott, B., Scarth, P., and Wallace, J. (2009). Land condition monitoring information for reef catchments: a new era. The Rangeland Journal 31, 69–86.
| Land condition monitoring information for reef catchments: a new era.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Koci, J., Sidlea, R., Kinsey-Henderson, A., Bartley, R., Wilkinson, S., Hawdon, A., Jarihania, B., Roth, C., and Hogarth, L. (2020). Effect of reduced grazing pressure on sediment and nutrient yields in savanna rangeland streams draining to the Great Barrier Reef. Journal of Hydrology 582, 124520.
| Effect of reduced grazing pressure on sediment and nutrient yields in savanna rangeland streams draining to the Great Barrier Reef.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Kroon, F., Thorburn, P., Schaffelke, B., and Whitten, S. (2016). Towards protecting the Great Barrier Reef from land-based pollution. Global Change Biology 22, 1985–2002.
| Towards protecting the Great Barrier Reef from land-based pollution.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 26922913PubMed |
Landsberg, J., James, C., Maconochie, J., Nicholls, A., Stol, J., and Tynan, R. (2002). Scale-related effects of grazing on native plant communities in an arid rangeland region of South Australia. Journal of Applied Ecology 39, 427–444.
| Scale-related effects of grazing on native plant communities in an arid rangeland region of South Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Larson, S., Smith, K., Lewis, D., Harper, J., and George, M. (2005). Evaluation of California’s rangeland water quality education program. Rangeland Ecology and Management 58, 514–522.
| Evaluation of California’s rangeland water quality education program.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
MacLeod, N., and McIvor, J. (2008). Quantifying production-environment tradeoffs for grazing land management - A case example from the Australian rangelands. Ecological Economics 65, 488–497.
| Quantifying production-environment tradeoffs for grazing land management - A case example from the Australian rangelands.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
MacLeod, N. D., Ash, A. J., and McIvor, J. G. (2004). An economic assessment of the impact of grazing land condition on livestock performance in tropical woodlands. The Rangeland Journal 26, 49–71.
| An economic assessment of the impact of grazing land condition on livestock performance in tropical woodlands.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Marsh, S., and Pannell, D. (2000). Agricultural extension policy in Australia: the good, the bad and the misguided. The Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 44, 605–627.
| Agricultural extension policy in Australia: the good, the bad and the misguided.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Marsh, S., Pannell, D., and Lindner, R. (2004). Does agricultural extension pay? Agricultural Economics 30, 17–30.
McIvor, J. (2012). ‘Sustainable management of the Burdekin grazing lands – a technical guide of options for stocking rate management, pasture spelling, infrastructure development and prescribed burning to optimise animal production, profitability, land condition and water quality outcomes.’ (State of Queensland: Brisbane, Qld.)
McKeon, G., Watson, I., Hall, W., Henry, S., Power, S., and Stone, G. (2004). ‘Pasture degradation and recovery in Australia's rangelands: learning from history.’ (Queensland Department of Natural Resources Mines and Energy: Brisbane, Qld.)
Moravek, T., and Hall, T. (2014). Impacts of rehabilitating degraded lands on soil health, pastures, runoff, erosion, nutrient and sediment movement. Project RRRD.024 Final Report Part III. The State of Queensland, Brisbane, Qld.
Mullen, J., Vernon, D., and Fishpool, K. (2002). Agricultural extension policy in Australia: public funding and market failure. The Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 44, 629–645.
| Agricultural extension policy in Australia: public funding and market failure.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
O’Reagain, P., Bushell, J., and Holmes, W. (2011). Managing for rainfall variability: long-term profitability of different grazing strategies in a northern Australian tropical savanna. Animal Production Science 51, 210–224.
| Managing for rainfall variability: long-term profitability of different grazing strategies in a northern Australian tropical savanna.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
O’Reagain, P., Scanlan, J., Hunt, L., Cowley, R., and Walsh, D. (2014). Sustainable grazing management for temporal and spatial variability in north Australian rangelands – a synthesis of the latest evidence and recommendations. The Rangeland Journal 36, 223–232.
| Sustainable grazing management for temporal and spatial variability in north Australian rangelands – a synthesis of the latest evidence and recommendations.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Orr, D., and O’Reagain, P. (2011). Managing for rainfall variability: impacts of grazing strategies on perennial grass dynamics in a dry tropical savanna. The Rangeland Journal 33, 209–220.
| Managing for rainfall variability: impacts of grazing strategies on perennial grass dynamics in a dry tropical savanna.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Orr, D., and Phelps, D. (2013). Impacts of level of utilisation by grazing on an Astrebla (Mitchell grass) grassland in north-western Queensland between 1984 and 2010. 1. Herbage mass and population dynamics of Astrebla spp. The Rangeland Journal 35, 1–15.
| Impacts of level of utilisation by grazing on an Astrebla (Mitchell grass) grassland in north-western Queensland between 1984 and 2010. 1. Herbage mass and population dynamics of Astrebla spp.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Orr, D., Yee, M., and Myles, D. (2006). Impact of short-term exclosure from grazing on pasture recovery from drought in six Queensland pasture communities. Tropical Grasslands 40, 202–212.
Orr, D., Yee, M., Rutherford, M., and Paton, C. (2010). Impacts of grazing management options on pasture and animal productivity in a Heteropogon contortus (black speargrass) pasture in central Queensland. 2. Population dynamics of Heteropogon contortus and Stylosanthes scabra cv. Seca. Crop & Pasture Science 61, 255–267.
| Impacts of grazing management options on pasture and animal productivity in a Heteropogon contortus (black speargrass) pasture in central Queensland. 2. Population dynamics of Heteropogon contortus and Stylosanthes scabra cv. Seca.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Pannell, D. (1999). Economics, extension and the adoption of land conservation innovation in agriculture. International Journal of Social Economics 26, 999–1012.
| Economics, extension and the adoption of land conservation innovation in agriculture.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Pannell, D. (2006). Flat Earth Economics: The Far-reaching Consequences of Flat Payoff Functions in Economic Decision Making. Applied Economic Perspectives and Policy 28, 553–566.
Rolfe, J., and Gregg, D. (2015). Factors affecting adoption of improved management practices in the pastoral industry in Great Barrier Reef catchments. Journal of Environmental Management 157, 182–193.
| Factors affecting adoption of improved management practices in the pastoral industry in Great Barrier Reef catchments.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 25909442PubMed |
Rolfe, J., Windle, J., McCosker, K., and Northey, A. (2018). Assessing cost-effectiveness when environmental benefits are bundled: agricultural water management in Great Barrier Reef catchments. The Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 62, 373–393.
| Assessing cost-effectiveness when environmental benefits are bundled: agricultural water management in Great Barrier Reef catchments.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Sangha, K., Midmore, D., Rolfe, J., and Jalota, R. (2005). Tradeoffs between pasture production and plant diversity and soil health attributes of pasture systems of central Queensland, Australia. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 111, 93–103.
| Tradeoffs between pasture production and plant diversity and soil health attributes of pasture systems of central Queensland, Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Scanlan, J., Mckeon, G., Day, K., Mott, J., and Hinton, A. (1994). Estimating safe carrying capacities of extensive cattle-grazing properties within tropical, semi-arid woodlands of North-Eastern Australia. The Rangeland Journal 16, 64–76.
| Estimating safe carrying capacities of extensive cattle-grazing properties within tropical, semi-arid woodlands of North-Eastern Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Scanlan, J., Pressland, A., and Myles, D. (1996). Run-off and soil movement on mid-slopes in North-East Queensland [Australia] grazed woodlands. The Rangeland Journal 18, 33–46.
| Run-off and soil movement on mid-slopes in North-East Queensland [Australia] grazed woodlands.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Scanlan, J., MacLeod, N., and O’Reagain, P. (2013). Scaling results up from a plot and paddock scale to a property – a case study from a long-term grazing experiment in northern Australia. The Rangeland Journal 35, 193–200.
| Scaling results up from a plot and paddock scale to a property – a case study from a long-term grazing experiment in northern Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Silburn, D. (2011). Hillslope runoff and erosion on duplex soils in grazing lands in semi-arid central Queensland. III. USLE erodibility (K factors) and cover-soil loss relationships. Soil Research 49, 127–134.
| Hillslope runoff and erosion on duplex soils in grazing lands in semi-arid central Queensland. III. USLE erodibility (K factors) and cover-soil loss relationships.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Silburn, D. M., Carroll, C., Ciesiolka, C., deVoil, R., and Burger, P. (2011). Hillslope runoff and erosion on duplex soils in grazing lands in semi-arid central Queensland. I. Influences of cover, slope, and soil. Soil Research 49, 105–117.
| Hillslope runoff and erosion on duplex soils in grazing lands in semi-arid central Queensland. I. Influences of cover, slope, and soil.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Star, M., Donaghy, P., and Rolfe, J. (2011). Economically viable land regeneration in Central Queensland and improved water quality outcomes for the Great Barrier Reef. The Rangeland Journal 33, 267–276.
| Economically viable land regeneration in Central Queensland and improved water quality outcomes for the Great Barrier Reef.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Star, M., Rolfe, J., Donaghy, P., Beutel, T., Whish, G., and Abbott, G. (2013). Targeting resource investments to achieve sediment reduction and improved Great Barrier Reef health. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 180, 148–156.
| Targeting resource investments to achieve sediment reduction and improved Great Barrier Reef health.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Star, M., Rolfe, J., Long, P., Whish, G., and Donaghy, P. (2015). Improved grazing management practices in the catchments of the Great Barrier Reef, Australia: does climate variability influence their adoption by landholders? The Rangeland Journal 37, 507–515.
| Improved grazing management practices in the catchments of the Great Barrier Reef, Australia: does climate variability influence their adoption by landholders?Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Star, M., Rolfe, J., East, M., Beutel, T., McCosker, K., Ellis, R., Darr, S., and Coughlin, T. (2017). Can paddock scale data integration achieve more cost effective outcomes in the Great Barrier Reef? A case study in the Fitzroy Basin. Journal of Environmental Management 202, 461–468.
| 28420556PubMed |
Star, M., Rolfe, J., and Barbi, M. (2019). Do outcome or input risks limit adoption of environmental projects: Rehabilitating gullies in Great Barrier Reef catchments. Ecological Economics 161, 73–82.
| Do outcome or input risks limit adoption of environmental projects: Rehabilitating gullies in Great Barrier Reef catchments.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
State of Queensland (2017a). Reef 2050 Water Quality Improvement Plan: 2017–2050. Queensland Reef Water Quality Protection Plan Secretariat, Brisbane, Qld.
State of Queensland (2017b). Reef Water Quality Protection Plan–2016 Report Card. Queensland Government, Brisbane, Qld.
State of Queensland (2018). Reef 2050 Water Quality Improvement Plan: 2017–2022. Reef Water Quality Protection Plan Secretariat, Brisbane, Qld.
Thorburn, P., Wilkinson, S., and Silburn, D. (2013). Water quality in agricultural lands draining into the Great Barrier Reef: a review of causes, management and priorities. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 180, 4–20.
| Water quality in agricultural lands draining into the Great Barrier Reef: a review of causes, management and priorities.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Waterhouse, J., Schaffelke, B., Bartley, R., Eberhard, R., Brodie, J., Star, M., Thorburn, P., Rolfe, J., Ronan, M., Taylor, B., and Kroon, F. (2017). ‘2017 Scientific consensus statement: a synthesis of the science of land-based water quality impacts on the Great Barrier Reef.’ (State of Queensland: Brisbane, Qld.)
Westoby, M., Walker, B., and Noy-Meir, I. (1989). Opportunistic management for rangelands not at equilibrium. Journal of Range Management 42, 266–274.
| Opportunistic management for rangelands not at equilibrium.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
