Comparative lithogeochemistry of komatiites in the Norseman-Wiluna and Abitibi Greenstone Belts, and implications for nickel sulfide targeting

Abstract

This paper uses large sets of whole-rock geochemical data to make comparisons between the komatiitic rocks of Abitibi (AGB) and Norseman-Wiluna (NWGB) greenstone terranes. The NWGB komatiite suite has a much higher proportion of highly olivine-enriched cumulates than the AGB suite, as indicated by data-density distributions on plots of MgO vs FeO and MgO vs Cr, although average compositions of the komatiite magmas in the two belts were not significantly different. NWGB komatiites appear generally more contaminated, on the basis of various ratios of strongly to moderately incompatible low-mobility trace elements. Both factors which are likely contributors to the much higher Ni sulfide resource endowment of the NWGB. The combination of high degrees of contamination and presence of olivine adcumulates in the NWGB attests to the presence of exceptionally high-intensity, prolonged eruptions, capable of forming long-lived entrenched magma pathways, represented by highly olivine-enriched cumulates, and capable of melting substrates to form orebodies. This is in contrast with more episodic, lower volume eruptions in the AGB. The contrast is interpreted as the result of crustal structure and tectonic setting, rather then the size and intensity of mantle plume sources.