Issues for reregulation of private hospital insurance in Australia
Cale Dobrosak
A C and Paul Dugdale B
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations
A Canberra Hospital, Yamba Drive, Canberra, ACT, Australia.
B Australian National University Medical School, Canberra, ACT, Australia. Email: paul.dugdale@anu.edu.au
C Corresponding author. Email: cdobrosak@gmail.com
Australian Health Review 45(3) 290-296 https://doi.org/10.1071/AH20268
Submitted: 22 September 2020 Accepted: 16 November 2020 Published: 25 February 2021
Abstract
Objective The aim of this study is to explore policy paths towards private health insurance (PHI) reform that might reduce out-of-pocket costs, restore public confidence and allow insurers to finance value-based care.
Methods This study used thematic analysis of semi-structured interviews with informed opinion holders, including a politician, three former senior public servants and an industry lobbyist. Critical analysis of peer reviewed and grey literature was also conducted.
Results PHI regulation is contributing to unexpected out-of-pocket expenses and low-value care. Modification of existing tax incentives would be incapable of significantly increasing PHI coverage. Regulatory reform could restore confidence among policy holders by promoting value-based care, wherein health outcomes are measured and incentivised with remuneration.
Conclusions Targeted relaxation of out-of-hospital restrictions should be explored to promote value-based competition and facilitate bundled payments for chronic disease management and community services. To address out-of-pocket diagnostic and procedural costs, insurers should have more responsibility for private specialist’s fees, including by financing the entire provider’s bill through insurance and redirecting the Medicare Benefits Schedule fee to the insurer.
What is known about the topic? Healthcare expenditure and out-of-pocket costs have grown rapidly, while confidence and depth of coverage in private health insurance has declined, as has the fiscal appetite for expanding public financing for health care.
What does this paper add? This paper outlines the regulatory and policy factors that are contributing to low-value care and unmet expectations from insurance policy holders. It also maps the strategic terrain of the non-government health sector and considers feasible policy options for reforming the PHI industry that do not increase drawings on the public purse.
What are the implications for practitioners? An appreciation of the ongoing challenges to financing value-based care provision will inform key stakeholders, including policymakers and health service providers, as reforms are debated and implemented.
Keywords: chronic disease management, health funding and financing, health policy, health systems., health reform, value-based healthcare, value-based competition, out-of-pocket costs, private health insurance.
References
[1] Commonwealth Ombudsman. Annual Report 2016–17. Canberra: Commonwealth Ombudsman; 2017.[2] Australian Prudential Regulation Authority. Private Health Insurance Membership and Benefits - June 2020. Sydney: Australian Prudential Regulation Authority; 2020.
[3] Australian Competition and Consumer Commission. Report to the Australian Senate: on anti-competitive and other practices by health insurers and providers in relation to private health insurance. Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia; 2018.
[4] Australian Prudential Regulation Authority. Private Health Insurance Membership and Coverage - March 2020. Sydney: Australian Prudential Regulation Authority; 2020.
[5] Butler JR. Policy change and private health insurance: did the cheapest policy do the trick? Aust Health Rev 2002; 25 33–41.
| Policy change and private health insurance: did the cheapest policy do the trick?Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 12536860PubMed |
[6] Duckett S, Willcox S. The Australian health care system. Oxford University Press; 2015.
[7] McDonald F, Duckett S. Regulation, Private Health Insurance, and the Australian Health System. McGill J Law Health 2017; S31 11
[8] Commonwealth of Australia. 2015 Intergenerational Report: Australia in 2055. Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia; 2015.
[9] Department of the House of Representatives (Ed). Private Health Insurance Legislation Amendment Bill 2018 Explanatory Memorandum. Canberra: Commonwealth Government Printer; 2018.
[10] Stavrunova O, Yerokhin O. Tax incentives and the demand for private health insurance. J Health Econ 2014; 34 121–30.
| Tax incentives and the demand for private health insurance.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 24513860PubMed |
[11] Ellis RP, Savage E. Run for cover now or later? The impact of premiums, threats and deadlines on private health insurance in Australia. Int J Health Care Finance Econ 2008; 8 257–77.
| Run for cover now or later? The impact of premiums, threats and deadlines on private health insurance in Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 18568433PubMed |
[12] Cheng TC. Does reducing rebates for private health insurance generate cost savings. Melbourne Institute of Applied Economic and Social Research, The University of Melbourne; 2013.
[13] Department of the House of Representatives (Ed). Health Legislation (Private Health Insurance Reform Amendment Bill) 1994 Explanatory Memorandum. Canberra: Commonwealth Government Printer; 1994.
[14] Kay A. Tense layering and synthetic policy paradigms: the politics of health insurance in Australia. Aust J Polit Sci 2007; 42 579–91.
| Tense layering and synthetic policy paradigms: the politics of health insurance in Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[15] ALP National Policy Forum. ALP National Platform Consultation Draft. In Carroll N, ed. 48th ALP National Conference, 16–18 December. Adelaide; 2018.
[16] van de Ven WPMM, Beck K, Buchner F, Schokkaert E, Schut FTE, Shmueli A, Wasem J. Preconditions for efficiency and affordability in competitive healthcare markets: are they fulfilled in Belgium, Germany, Israel, the Netherlands and Switzerland? Health Policy 2013; 109 226–45.
| Preconditions for efficiency and affordability in competitive healthcare markets: are they fulfilled in Belgium, Germany, Israel, the Netherlands and Switzerland?Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[17] Buchmueller TC, Fiebig DG, Jones G, Savage E. Preference heterogeneity and selection in private health insurance: the case of Australia. J Health Econ 2013; 32 757–67.
| Preference heterogeneity and selection in private health insurance: the case of Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 23770762PubMed |
[18] Arrow KJ. Uncertainty and the welfare economics of medical care. Am Econ Rev 1963; 53 941–73.
[19] Nghiem S, Graves N. Selection bias and moral hazard in the Australian private health insurance market: evidence from the Queensland skin cancer database. Econ Anal Policy 2019; 64 259–65.
| Selection bias and moral hazard in the Australian private health insurance market: evidence from the Queensland skin cancer database.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[20] Connelly LB, Paolucci F, Butler JR, Collins P. Risk equalisation and voluntary health insurance markets: the case of Australia. Health Policy 2010; 98 3–14.
| Risk equalisation and voluntary health insurance markets: the case of Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 20638148PubMed |
[21] van de Ven WPMM, Beck K, Buchner F, Chernichovsky D, Gardiole L, Holly A, Lamers LM, Schokkaert E, Shmueli A, Spycher S, Van de Voorde C, Van Vliet RCJA, Wasem J, Zmoraj I. Risk adjustment and risk selection on the sickness fund insurance market in five European countries Health Policy 2003; 65 75–98.
| Risk adjustment and risk selection on the sickness fund insurance market in five European countriesCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[22] García-Goñi M, Fouda A, Calder RV, Paolucci F. A new funding model for a chronic-care focused healthcare system in Australia. Health Policy Technol 2018; 7 293–301.
| A new funding model for a chronic-care focused healthcare system in Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[23] Senate Community Affairs Committee. Value and affordability of private health insurance and out-of-pocket medical costs. Canberra: Senate Printing Unit; 2017.
[24] Goss J. Projection of Australian health care expenditure by disease, 2003 to 2033. Canberra: Australian Institute of Health and Welfare; 2008.
[25] Goss J, Twizeyemariya A. Submission to the ACT Legislative Assembly Standing Committee on Health, Ageing and Community services ‘Inquiry into the future sustainability of health funding in the ACT’. Canberra: University of Canberra; 2018.
[26] Productivity Commission. Impacts of Advances in Medical Technology in Australia. Melbourne: Productivity Commission; 2005.
[27] National Commission of Audit. Towards Responsible Government: The Report of the National Commission of Audit. Vol Appendix Volume 1. Canberra: National Commission of Audit; 2014.
[28] Australian Institute of Health and Welfare. Deaths in Australia. Canberra: Australian Institute of Health and Welfare; 2018.
[29] Craig K, Sivathas S, Stuart F, Rawstron E. Healthcare Reimagined: innovation trends, predictions and actions for healthcare leaders. KPMG; 2018.
[30] Australian Bureau of Statistics. Australian Health Survey: Health Service Usage and Health Related Actions 2011–12. ABS Canberra; 2013.
[31] The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. Health at a Glance 2017. OECD Publishing; 2017.
[32] Parliamentary Budget Office. Trends affecting the sustainability of Commonwealth taxes. Report no. 02. Canberra: Parliamentary Budget Office; 2018.
[33] Parliamentary Budget Office. Australia’s ageing population: understanding the fiscal impacts over the next decade. Canberra: Parliamentary Budget Office; 2019.
[34] Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Relief So Working Australians Keep More Of Their Money) Bill 2019.
[35] Grattan M. Anthony Albanese on Labor’s hard times. Politics with Michelle Grattan: 2019. Transcript. Available at: https://theconversation.com/politics-with-michelle-grattan-anthony-albanese-on-labors-hard-times-121184. [verified 11 August 2020].
[36] Commonwealth of Australia. Budget Strategy and Outlook: Budget Paper No: Statement 3 - Budget 2019–20. Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia; 2019.
[37] Murphy K, Karp P. Labor fumes at ‘dodgy Treasury costings’ as Coalition alleges ‘tax hit on the economy’. The Guardian 11 April 2019.
[38] Porter ME. The Strategy to Transform Health Care and the role of Outcomes. Paper presented at: Putting People at the Centre: The Future of Health; January 2017; Paris: OECD.
[39] Porter ME, Teisberg EO. Redefining health care: creating value-based competition on results: Harvard Business Press; 2006.
[40] Australian Healthcare & Hospitals Association. Strategies for outcomes-focused and value-based healthcare: a blueprint for a post-2020 national health agreement. Canberra: Australian Healthcare & Hospitals Association; 2019.
[41] The Council of Australian Governments (COAG). Heads of Agreement between the Commonwealth and the States and Territories on public hospital funding and health reform 2018: p. 2. The Council of Australian Governments; : 2018.
[42] Australian Institute of Health and Welfare. Health expenditure Australia 2015–16. AIHW; 2017.
[43] Braun V, Clarke V. Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology 2006; 3 77–101.
| Using thematic analysis in psychology.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[44] Braun V, Clarke V. Reflecting on reflexive thematic analysis. Qualitative Research in Sport, Exercise and Health 2019; 11 589–597.
| Reflecting on reflexive thematic analysis.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[45] Vivien B. An introduction to social constructionism. London: Routlegde; 1995.
[46] Furnival A, Cullen D, McGovern C, Ergas H. The Relative Efficiency of The Private Health Insurance Rebate v. Direct Public Health Expenditure. Sydney: Evaluate; 2017.
[47] Duckett S, Cowgill M, Nemet K. Saving Private Health 2: Making private health insurance viable. Grattan Institute; 2019.
[48] Stoelwinder J. The Operation of Private Health Insurance in Australia. Monash University: School of Public Health & Preventive Medicine; 2014.
[49] The Australian Consumers’ Association. Submission On Proposed Inquiry Into The Private Health Sector. Marrickville NSW: CHOICE; 2019.
[50] Commonwealth of Australia. Private health insurance reforms: Gold/Silver/Bronze/Basic product tiers. In Department of Health, ed. Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia; 2019.
[51] Fox H, Topp SM, Callander E, Lindsay D. A review of the impact of financing mechanisms on maternal health care in Australia. BMC Public Health 2019; 19 1540
| A review of the impact of financing mechanisms on maternal health care in Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 31752792PubMed |
[52] Sandall J, Soltani H, Gates S, Shennan A, Devane D. Midwife-led continuity models versus other models of care for childbearing women. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2016; 4 CD004667
| Midwife-led continuity models versus other models of care for childbearing women.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 27121907PubMed |
[53] Windle A, Fisher M, Freeman T, Baum F,, Javanparast S, Kay A, Kidd M. Increased private health fund involvement in Australia’s primary health care: implications for health equity. Aust J Soc Issues 2018; 53 338–54.
| Increased private health fund involvement in Australia’s primary health care: implications for health equity.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[54] Hall J. Australian health care—the challenge of reform in a fragmented system. N Engl J Med 2015; 373 493–7.
| Australian health care—the challenge of reform in a fragmented system.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 26244304PubMed |
[55] The Hospitals Contribution Fund of Australia. Media Release: HCF And Sydney Adventist Hospital Partner To Introduce Australia’s First No-Gap Pregnancy Package. 2020. Available at https://www.hcf.com.au/content/hcf/home/about-us/media-centre/media-releases/2020/no-gap-pregnancy-package
[56] Private Healthcare Australia. Pre-Budget Submission 2018–19. Private Healthcare Australia; 2017.
[57] Commonwealth of Australia. Budget Measures, Budget Paper No. 2 2019–20. Canberra: Commonwealth of Australia; 2019.
[58] Chalmers K, Elshaug AG, Larkin S. First steps towards price transparency: comparability of online out-of-pocket tools from Australian private health funds. Aust Health Rev 2020; 44 347–54.
| First steps towards price transparency: comparability of online out-of-pocket tools from Australian private health funds.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 31715123PubMed |
[59] Gath S. Private health insurance may be broken, but it can be fixed. The Australian 18 April 2016.
[60] Duckett S, Nemet K. Saving Private Health 1: Reining In Hospital Costs and Specialist Bills. Grattan Institute; 2019.
