In search of sustainable livestock management in the Dry Chaco: effect of different shrub-removal practices on vegetation
L. M. Guzmán A * , P. E. Villagra B C , R. E. Quiroga D , D. I. Pereyra A , M. E. Pelliza A , A. R. Ricarte A and L. J. Blanco A
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations
A Instituto Nacional de Tecnología Agropecuaria (INTA), Estación Experimental Agropecuaria La Rioja, Chamical, La Rioja 5380, Argentina.
B Instituto Argentino de Nivología, Glaciología y Ciencias Ambientales, CCT CONICET, Mendoza 5505, Argentina.
C Facultad de Ciencias Agrarias, UNCUYO, Chacras de Coria, Mendoza 5505, Argentina.
D Instituto Nacional de Tecnología Agropecuaria (INTA), Estación Experimental Agropecuaria Catamarca, Sumalao, Catamarca 4705, Argentina.
* Correspondence to: guzman.luism@inta.gob.ar
The Rangeland Journal 44(4) 193-202 https://doi.org/10.1071/RJ22040
Submitted: 27 June 2022 Accepted: 3 January 2023 Published: 23 February 2023
© 2022 The Author(s) (or their employer(s)). Published by CSIRO Publishing on behalf of the Australian Rangeland Society. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License (CC BY-NC-ND)
Abstract
Increasing shrub density hinders cattle raising in central Argentina rangelands. While roller-chopping and hand-cutting are used to remove shrubs and make land accessible for cattle grazing, studies on the effects of these practices on ecosystem composition, structure and functioning are scarce. We assessed the impact of shrub removal on (a) vegetation cover, composition, species richness and diversity and (b) green biomass and seasonal phenological dynamics. We used a randomised design with three treatments (degraded rangeland; roller-chopping and hand-cutting) with four replicates, and compared the treatments with the least disturbed woodland (conserved woodland). Cenchrus ciliaris L. was sown following removal treatments and grass cover increased significantly (45% roller-chopping and 84% hand-cutting vs 27% degraded rangeland, and 13% conserved woodland), and tree cover decreased (3% roller-chopping and 2% hand-cutting vs 16% degraded rangeland, and 23% conserved woodland). Shrub cover reached 45% under roller-chopping, similar to the degraded rangeland treatment (46% degraded rangeland, 60% conserved woodland), but in hand-cutting reached only 3% cover. Hand-cutting reduced species richness and vegetation diversity, whereas roller-chopping had no effect. Shrub-removal treatments decreased normalised difference vegetation index (NDVI; proxy of green biomass) and modified ecosystem phenology. Under both shrub treatments, the maximum, minimum and integral NDVI (area under the NDVI curve) were significantly lower than those of the degraded rangeland treatment. The results suggest that shrub-removal practices increase forage for livestock, but reduce functional diversity and compromise the return to less disturbed states (woodland), where tree populations are maintained.
Keywords: biomass production, disturbance, extensive grazing systems, grazing, rangeland management, shrublands, woodlands, woody-plant encroachment.
References
Allegretti, L, Sartor, C, Paez Lama, S, Egea, V, Fucili, M, and Passera, C (2012). Effect of the physiological state of Criollo goats on the botanical composition of their diet in NE Mendoza, Argentina. Small Ruminant Research 103, 152–157.| Effect of the physiological state of Criollo goats on the botanical composition of their diet in NE Mendoza, Argentina.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Anriquez, A, Albanesi, A, Kunst, C, Ledesma, R, López, C, Rodriguez Torresi, A, and Godoy, J (2005). Rolado de fachinales y calidad de suelos en el Chaco Occidental, Argentina. Ciencia del Suelo 23, 145–157.
Archer SR (2010) Rangeland conservation and shrub encroachment: new perspectives on an old problem. In ‘Wild rangelands: conserving wildlife while maintaining livestock in semi‐arid ecosystems’. (Eds JT du Toit, R Rock, JC Deutsch) pp. 53–97. (Wiley-Blackwell Publishing: Oxford, UK)
Barger, NN, Archer, SR, Campbell, JL, Huang, C, Morton, JA, and Knapp, AK (2011). Woody plant proliferation in North American drylands: a synthesis of impacts on ecosystem carbon balance. Journal of Geophysical Research 116, G00K07.
| Woody plant proliferation in North American drylands: a synthesis of impacts on ecosystem carbon balance.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Bestelmeyer, BT, Okin, GS, Duniway, MC, Archer, SR, Sayre, NF, Williamson, JC, and Herrick, JE (2015). Desertification, land use, and the transformation of global drylands. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 13, 28–36.
| Desertification, land use, and the transformation of global drylands.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Biurrun FN, Cabido M, Blanco LJ (2015) Consideraciones sobre la vegetación de La Rioja y su estado de conservación. In ‘El deterioro del suelo y del ambiente en la Argentina’. (Eds R Casas, G Albarracín) pp. 485–504. (FECIC-PROSA: CABA, Argentina) [In Spanish]
Blanco LJ (2017) Patrones espaciales y temporales de la productividad primaria neta aérea herbácea y leñosa en el Chaco Árido (Argentina). PhD Thesis, Universidad de Buenos Aires, Buenos Aires, Argentina. [In Spanish]
Blanco, LJ, Ferrando, CA, Biurrun, FN, Orionte, EL, Namur, P, Recalde, DJ, and Berone, GD (2005). Vegetation responses to roller chopping and buffelgrass seeding in Argentina. Rangeland Ecology and Management 58, 219–224.
| Vegetation responses to roller chopping and buffelgrass seeding in Argentina.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Boletta, PE, Ravelo, AC, Planchuelo, AM, and Grilli, M (2006). Assessing deforestation in the Argentine Chaco. Forest Ecology and Management 228, 108–114.
| Assessing deforestation in the Argentine Chaco.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Bravo S, Abdala R, del Corro F, Ibáñez-Moro V, Santacruz-García AC, Loto D, Ojeda F (2018) Regeneración en especies de leñosas nativas del Chaco de Argentina y su respuesta a disturbios. In ‘Los Bosques y el futuro consolidando un vinculo permanente en educacion forestal’. (Eds AM Gimenez, GI Bolzón de Muñiz) pp.127–150. (UNSE-UFPR: Santiago del Estero, Argentina) [In Spanish]
Calella HF, Corzo RR (2006) ‘El Chaco Árido de La Rioja: Vegetación y suelos. Pastizales naturales.’ (Ediciones INTA: Buenos Aires, Argentina) [In Spanish]
Chandregowda, MH, Murthy, K, and Bagchi, S (2018). Woody shrubs increase soil microbial functions and multifunctionality in a tropical semi-arid grazing ecosystem. Journal of Arid Environments 155, 65–72.
| Woody shrubs increase soil microbial functions and multifunctionality in a tropical semi-arid grazing ecosystem.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Di Bella, CM, Paruelo, JM, Becerra, JE, Bacour, C, and Baret, F (2004). Effect of senescent leaves on NDVI-based estimates of fAPAR: experimental and modelling evidences. International Journal of Remote Sensing 25, 5415–5427.
| Effect of senescent leaves on NDVI-based estimates of fAPAR: experimental and modelling evidences.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Di Rienzo JA, Casanoves F, Balzarini MG, González L, Tablada M, Robledo CW (2018) InfoStat version 2018. Centro de transferencia InfoStat, FCA, Universidad Nacional de Córdoba, Argentina. Available at https://www.infostat.com.ar/ [accessed 13 July 2022]
Díaz, S, and Cabido, M (2001). Vive la différence: plant functional diversity matters to ecosystem processes. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 16, 646–655.
| Vive la différence: plant functional diversity matters to ecosystem processes.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Egea, AV, Allegretti, L, Paez Lama, S, Grilli, D, Sartor, C, Fucili, M, Guevara, JC, and Passera, C (2014). Selective behavior of Creole goats in response to the functional heterogeneity of native forage species in the central Monte desert, Argentina. Small Ruminant Research 120, 90–99.
| Selective behavior of Creole goats in response to the functional heterogeneity of native forage species in the central Monte desert, Argentina.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Eldridge, DJ, Bowker, MA, Maestre, FT, Roger, E, Reynolds, JF, and Whitford, WG (2011). Impacts of shrub encroachment on ecosystem structure and functioning: towards a global synthesis. Ecology Letters 14, 709–722.
| Impacts of shrub encroachment on ecosystem structure and functioning: towards a global synthesis.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Flombaum, P, and Sala, OE (2008). Higher effect of plant species diversity on productivity in natural than artificial ecosystems. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 105, 6087–6090.
| Higher effect of plant species diversity on productivity in natural than artificial ecosystems.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Huxman, TE, Wilcox, BP, Breshears, DD, Scott, RL, Snyder, KA, Small, EE, Hultine, K, Pockman, WT, and Jackson, RB (2005). Ecohydrological implications of woody plant encroachment. Ecology 86, 308–319.
| Ecohydrological implications of woody plant encroachment.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Kunst, C, Ledesma, R, Basan Nickish, M, Angella, G, Prieto, D, and Godoy, J (2003). Rolado de fachinales e infiltración de agua en el suelo en el Chaco occidental argentino. Revista de investigaciones Agropecuarias 32, 105–122.
Kunst, C, Ledesma, R, Bravo, S, Albanesi, A, Anriquez, A, van Meer, H, and Godoy, J (2012). Disrupting woody steady states in the Chaco region (Argentina): responses to combined disturbance treatments. Ecological Engineering 42, 42–53.
| Disrupting woody steady states in the Chaco region (Argentina): responses to combined disturbance treatments.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Kunst C, Navall M, Ledesma R, Silberman J, Anríquez A, Coria D, Bravo S, Gomez A, Albanesi A, Grasso D, Dominguez Nuñez JA, Gonzalez A, Tomsic P, Godoy J (2016) Silvopastoral Systems in the Western Chaco Region, Argentina. In ‘Silvopastoral Systems in Southern South America’. (Eds PL Peri, F Dubé, A Varella) pp. 63–87. (Springer International Publishing: Switzerland)
Lizzi, JM, and Garbulsky, MF (2023). Precipitation controls the annual net primary productivity in sown pastures across a precipitation gradient in dry subtropical Chaco. Journal of Arid Environments 208, 104863.
| Precipitation controls the annual net primary productivity in sown pastures across a precipitation gradient in dry subtropical Chaco.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Magliano PN (2016) Dinámica superficial del agua en el Chaco Seco: el papel de las precipitaciones y de la cobertura vegetal. PhD Thesis, Universidad de Bueno Aires, Buenos Aires, Argentina. [In Spanish]
Magliano, PN, Fernández, RJ, Florio, EL, Murray, F, and Jobbágy, EG (2017). Soil physical changes after conversion of woodlands to pastures in dry chaco rangelands (Argentina). Rangeland Ecology & Management 70, 225–229.
| Soil physical changes after conversion of woodlands to pastures in dry chaco rangelands (Argentina).Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Marchesini VA (2011) Cambios en el uso de la tierra y el balance de agua en ecosistemas semiáridos: el desmonte selectivo en el Chaco árido analizado a diferentes escalas espaciales. PhD Thesis, Universidad de Buenos Aires, Buenos Aires, Argentina. [In Spanish]
Monegi, P, Mkhize, NR, Tjelele, TJ, Ward, D, and Tsvuura, Z (2022). The impact of tree removal on standing grass biomass, seedling establishment and growth of woody species. The Rangeland Journal 44, 25–32.
| The impact of tree removal on standing grass biomass, seedling establishment and growth of woody species.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Nai Bregaglio, M, Karlin, U, and Coirini, R (2001). Efecto del desmonte selectivo sobre la regeneración de la masa forestal y la producción de pasturas, en el Chaco Árido de la provincia de Córdoba, Argentina. Multequina 010, 17–24.
Natenzon, CE, and Olivera, G (1994). La tala del bosque en los Llanos de La Rioja (1900-1960). Desarrollo Económico 34, 263–284.
| La tala del bosque en los Llanos de La Rioja (1900-1960).Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Navall M (2008) Rolados y Manejo Forestal. In ‘Rolado selectivo de baja intensidad’. (Eds C Kunst, R Ledesma, M Navall) pp. 71–85. (Ediciones INTA: Santiago del Estero, Argentina) [In Spanish]
Nosetto, MD, Luna Toledo, E, Magliano, PN, Figuerola, P, Blanco, LJ, and Jobbágy, EG (2020). Contrasting CO2 and water vapour fluxes in dry forest and pasture sites of central Argentina. Ecohydrology 13, e2244.
| Contrasting CO2 and water vapour fluxes in dry forest and pasture sites of central Argentina.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Paruelo, JM, Epstein, HE, Lauenroth, WK, and Burke, IC (1997). ANPP Estimates from NDVI for the Central Grassland Region of the United States. Ecology 78, 953–958.
| ANPP Estimates from NDVI for the Central Grassland Region of the United States.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Passera CB, Dalmaso AD, Borsetto O (1983) Método del Point Quadrat Modificado. In ‘Taller de arbustos forrajeros. Actas del II taller de arbustos forrajeros’. (Eds RJ Candia, RH Braun) pp. 135–152 (FAO-IADIZA: Mendoza, Argentina) [In Spanish]
Pérez Harguindeguy, N, Cingolani, AM, Enrico, L, Vaieretti, MV, Giorgis, MA, Moreno, ML, Falczuk, V, Gurvich, DE, Bertone, GA, Díaz, SM, and Cabido, MR (2022). How human-induced transitions from forest to treeless ecosystems affect litter decomposition. Ecología Austral 32, 716–733.
| How human-induced transitions from forest to treeless ecosystems affect litter decomposition.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Piñeiro, G, Oesterheld, M, and Paruelo, JM (2006). Seasonal variation in aboveground production and radiation-use efficiency of temperate rangelands estimated through remote sensing. Ecosystems 9, 357–373.
| Seasonal variation in aboveground production and radiation-use efficiency of temperate rangelands estimated through remote sensing.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Ragonese, A, and Castiglioni, C (1968). La Vegetación del Parque Chaqueño. Boletín de La Sociedad Argentina de Botánica 11, 133–160.
Raunkiaer C (1934) ‘The life forms of plants and statistical plant geography.’ (Clarendon Press: Oxford, UK)
Rejžek, M, Coria, RD, Kunst, C, Svátek, M, Kvasnica, J, Navall, M, Ledesma, R, Gómez, A, and Matula, R (2017). To chop or not to chop? Tackling shrub encroachment by roller-chopping preserves woody plant diversity and composition in a dry subtropical forest. Forest Ecology and Management 402, 29–36.
| To chop or not to chop? Tackling shrub encroachment by roller-chopping preserves woody plant diversity and composition in a dry subtropical forest.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Rueda, CV, Baldi, G, Verón, SR, and Jobbágy, EG (2013). Apropiación humana de la producción primaria en el Chaco Seco. Ecología Austral 23, 44–54.
| Apropiación humana de la producción primaria en el Chaco Seco.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Schwinning, S, and Sala, OE (2004). Hierarchy of responses to resource pulses in arid and semi-arid ecosystems. Oecologia 141, 211–220.
| Hierarchy of responses to resource pulses in arid and semi-arid ecosystems.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Shannon CE, Weaver W (1949) ‘The mathematical theory of communication.’ (University of Illinois Press: Urbana, IL, USA)
Silberman, JE, Anriquez, AL, Dominguez Nuñez, JA, Kunst, CG, and Albanesi, AS (2015). La cobertura arbórea en un sistema silvopastoril del Chaco y su contribución diferencial al suelo. Ciencia del Suelo 33, 19–29.
Steinaker, DF, Jobbágy, EG, Martini, JP, Arroyo, DN, Pacheco, JL, and Marchesini, VA (2016). Vegetation composition and structure changes following roller-chopping deforestation in central Argentina woodlands. Journal of Arid Environments 133, 19–24.
| Vegetation composition and structure changes following roller-chopping deforestation in central Argentina woodlands.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Szymañski, CR, Tabeni, S, Alvarez, JA, and Campos, CM (2021). Diversity of plants and mammals as indicators of the effects of land management types in woodlands. Forest Ecosystems 8, 74.
| Diversity of plants and mammals as indicators of the effects of land management types in woodlands.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Van Auken, OW (2000). Shrub invasions of North American semiarid grasslands. Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 31, 197–215.
| Shrub invasions of North American semiarid grasslands.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Villagra, PE (2000). Aspectos ecológicos de los algarrobales Argentinos. Multequina 9, 35–51.
Villagra, PE, and Alvarez, JA (2019). Determinantes ambientales y desafíos para el ordenamiento forestal sustentable en los algarrobales del Monte, Argentina. Ecología Austral 29, 146–155.
| Determinantes ambientales y desafíos para el ordenamiento forestal sustentable en los algarrobales del Monte, Argentina.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Villagra, PE, Giordano, C, Alvarez, JA, Cavagnaro, JB, Guevara, A, Sartor, C, Passera, CB, and Greco, S (2011). Ser planta en el desierto: estrategias de uso de agua y resistencia al estrés hídrico en el Monte Central de Argentina. Ecología Austral 21, 29–42.
Villarino, SH, Studdert, GA, Baldassini, P, Cendoya, MG, Ciuffoli, L, Mastrángelo, M, and Piñeiro, G (2017). Deforestation impacts on soil organic carbon stocks in the Semiarid Chaco Region, Argentina. Science of the Total Environment 575, 1056–1065.
| Deforestation impacts on soil organic carbon stocks in the Semiarid Chaco Region, Argentina.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Volante, JN, Alcaraz-Segura, D, Mosciaro, MJ, Viglizzo, EF, and Paruelo, JM (2012). Ecosystem functional changes associated with land clearing in NW Argentina. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 154, 12–22.
| Ecosystem functional changes associated with land clearing in NW Argentina.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Willcox, EV, and Giuliano, WM (2010). Seasonal effects of prescribed burning and roller chopping on saw palmetto in flatwoods. Forest Ecology and Management 259, 1580–1585.
| Seasonal effects of prescribed burning and roller chopping on saw palmetto in flatwoods.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Zerda, HR, and Tiedemann, JL (2010). Dinámica temporal del NDVI del bosque y pastizal natural en el Chaco de la Provincia de Santiago del Estero, Argentina. Ambiência 6, 13–24.
