Comparing fixed and flexible stocking as adaptations to inter-annual rainfall variability in the extensive beef industry of northern Australia
Lester Pahl A D , Joe Scanlan A , Giselle Whish A , Robyn Cowley B and Neil MacLeod C
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations
A Queensland Department of Agriculture and Fisheries, Toowoomba, Qld 4350, Australia.
B Northern Territory Department of Primary Industry and Fisheries, Katherine, NT 0851, Australia.
C CSIRO Ecosystem Sciences, EcoSciences Precinct, Brisbane, Qld 4102, Australia.
D Corresponding author. Email: lester.pahl@daf.qld.gov.au
The Rangeland Journal 38(1) 85-102 https://doi.org/10.1071/RJ15045
Submitted: 29 May 2015 Accepted: 15 February 2016 Published: 11 March 2016
Abstract
Many beef producers within the extensive cattle industry of northern Australia attempt to maintain a constant herd size from year-to-year (fixed stocking), whereas others adjust stock numbers to varying degrees annually in response to changes in forage supply. The effects of these strategies on pasture condition and cattle productivity cannot easily be assessed by grazing trials. Simulation studies, which include feedbacks of changes to pasture condition on cattle liveweight gain, can extend the results of grazing trials both spatially and temporally. They can compare a large number of strategies, over long periods of time, for a range of climate periods, at locations which differ markedly in climate.
This simulation study compared the pasture condition and cattle productivity achieved by fixed stocking at the long-term carrying capacity with that of 55 flexible stocking strategies at 28 locations across Queensland and the Northern Territory. Flexible stocking strategies differed markedly in the degree they increased or decreased cattle stocking rates after good and poor pasture growing seasons, respectively. The 28 locations covered the full range in average annual rainfall and inter-annual rainfall variability experienced across northern Australia.
Constrained flexibility, which limited increases in stocking rates after good growing seasons to 10% but decreased them by up to 20% after poor growing seasons, provides sustainable productivity gains for cattle producers in northern Australia. This strategy can improve pasture condition and increase cattle productivity relative to fixed stocking at the long-term carrying capacity, and its capacity to do this was greatest in the semiarid rangeland regions that contain the majority of beef cattle in northern Australia. More flexible stocking strategies, which also increased stocking rates after good growing seasons by only half as much as they decreased them after poor growing seasons, were equally sustainable and more productive than constrained flexibility, but are often impractical at property and industry scales. Strategies with the highest limits (e.g. 70%) for both annual increases and decreases in stocking rates could achieve higher cattle productivity, but this was at the expense of pasture condition and was not sustainable. Constrained flexible stocking, with a 10% limit for increases and a 20% limit for decreases in stocking rates annually, is a risk-averse adaptation to high and unpredictable rainfall variability for the extensive beef industry of northern Australia.
Additional keywords: grazing management, pastoral industry, perennial grasses, rangeland management.
References
ABS (2006). 1301.0 – Year Book Australia, 2006. Livestock. Available at: www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs@.nsf/0/8345877D2FBA8C4DCA2570DE00167195?opendocument (accessed 7 December 2015).Ash, A., O’Reagain, P., McKeon, G., and Stafford Smith, M. (2000). Managing climate variability in grazing enterprises: a case study of Dalrymple Shire, north-eastern Australia. In: ‘Applications of Seasonal Climate Forecasting in Agriculture and Natural Ecosystems’. (Eds G. L. Hammer, N. Nicholls and C. Mitchell.) pp. 253–270. (Kluwer Academic Publishers: Dordrecht, The Netherlands.)
Bastin, G. (2008). ACRIS Livestock Density Update 2003–2008. Updated information to that provided in Rangelands 2008 – Taking the pulse. Australian Government of Sustainability, Environment, Water, Population and Communities. Available at: www.environment.gov.au/system/files/resources/20de2792-409d-44b9-a7d7-c65288b262cc/files/acris-livestock-update.pdf (accessed 7 December 2015).
Beutel, T., Tindall, D., Denham, R., Trevithick, R., Scarth, P., Abbott, B., and Holloway, C. (2014). Getting ground cover right: thresholds and baselines for a healthier reef. Report to the Reef Rescue Research and Development Program. Reef and Rainforest Research Centre Limited, Cairns, Qld.
BOM (2013a). Rainfall variability map. Australian Government Bureau of Meteorology. Available at: www.bom.gov.au/jsp/ncc/climate_averages/rainfall-variability/index.jsp (accessed 7 December 2015).
BOM (2013b). Average annual rainfall map. Australian Government Bureau of Meteorology. Available at: www.bom.gov.au/jsp/ncc/climate_averages/rainfall/index.jsp (accessed 7 December 2015).
Bortolussi, G., McIvor, J. G., Hodgkinson, J. J., Coffey, S. G., and Holmes, C. R. (2005). The northern Australian beef industry, a snapshot. 4. Condition and management of natural resources. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 45, 1109–1120.
| The northern Australian beef industry, a snapshot. 4. Condition and management of natural resources.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Buxton, R., and Stafford Smith, M. (1996). Managing drought in Australia’s rangeland: four weddings and a funeral. The Rangeland Journal 18, 292–308.
| Managing drought in Australia’s rangeland: four weddings and a funeral.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Campbell, B. M., Gordon, I. J., Luckert, M. K., Petheram, L., and Vetter, S. (2006). In search of optimal stocking regimes in semi-arid grazing lands: one size does not fit all. Ecological Economics 60, 75–85.
| In search of optimal stocking regimes in semi-arid grazing lands: one size does not fit all.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Cobon, D. H., and Toombs, N. R. (2013). Forecasting rainfall based on the Southern Oscillation Index phases at longer lead-times in Australia. The Rangeland Journal 35, 373–383.
| Forecasting rainfall based on the Southern Oscillation Index phases at longer lead-times in Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Cowley, R., Pettit, C., Cowley, T., Pahl, L., and Hearnden, M. (2012). Optimising fire management in grazed tropical savannas. In: ‘Proceedings of the 17th Australian Rangeland Society Biennial Conference’. Kununurra. (Australian Rangeland Society: Perth) Available at: www.austrangesoc.com.au/biennial-conference-pages/Paper%207-2%20Robyn%20Cowley.pdf (accessed 7 December 2015).
Day, K., McKeon, G., and Carter, J. (1997). ‘Evaluating the Risks of Pasture and Land Degradation in Native Pastures in Queensland.’ Project DAQ124A. (Rural Industries Research and Development Corporation: Canberra, ACT.)
Díaz-Solís, H., Grant, W., Kothmann, M., Teague, W., and Diaz-Garcia, J. (2009). Adaptive management of stocking rates to reduce effects of drought on cow-calf production systems in semi-arid rangelands. Agricultural Systems 100, 43–50.
| Adaptive management of stocking rates to reduce effects of drought on cow-calf production systems in semi-arid rangelands.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Fatichi, S., Ivanov, I., and Caporali, E. (2012). Investigating inter-annual variability of precipitation at the global scale: is there a connection with seasonality? Journal of Climate 25, 5512–5523.
| Investigating inter-annual variability of precipitation at the global scale: is there a connection with seasonality?Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
FirstMark Technologies (1990) KnowledgeSEEKER® Version 2.1. Ottawa, Ontario, Canada. Available from Angoss Software Corporation. Available at: www.angoss.com/predictive-analytics-software/products/data-analysis-software (accessed 7 December 2015).
Foran, B. D., and Stafford Smith, D. M. (1991). Risk, biology and drought management strategies for cattle stations in central Australia. Journal of Environmental Management 33, 17–33.
| Risk, biology and drought management strategies for cattle stations in central Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Genstat (2015). ‘Genstat for Windows, Release 16.1.’ (VSN International Ltd: Oxford, UK.)
Hall, W., McKeon, G., Carter, J., Day, K., Howden, S., Scanlan, J., Johnston, P., and Burrows, W. (1998). Climate change in Queensland’s grazing lands: II. An assessment of the impact on animal production from native pastures. The Rangeland Journal 20, 177–205.
| Climate change in Queensland’s grazing lands: II. An assessment of the impact on animal production from native pastures.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Hassett, R., Wood, H., Carter, J., and Danaher, T. (2000). A field method for statewide ground–truthing of a spatial pasture growth model. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 40, 1069–1079.
| A field method for statewide ground–truthing of a spatial pasture growth model.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Higgins, S., Kantelhardt, J., Scheiter, S., and Boerner, J. (2007). Sustainable management of extensively managed savanna rangeland. Ecological Economics 62, 102–114.
| Sustainable management of extensively managed savanna rangeland.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Hunt, L. (2008). Safe pasture utilisation rates as a grazing management tool in extensively grazed tropical savannas of northern Australia. The Rangeland Journal 30, 305–315.
| Safe pasture utilisation rates as a grazing management tool in extensively grazed tropical savannas of northern Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Hunt, L. P., McIvor, J. G., Grice, A. C., and Bray, S. G. (2014). Principles and guidelines for managing cattle grazing in the grazing lands of northern Australia: stocking rates, pasture resting, prescribed fire, paddock size and water points – a review. The Rangeland Journal 36, 105–119.
| Principles and guidelines for managing cattle grazing in the grazing lands of northern Australia: stocking rates, pasture resting, prescribed fire, paddock size and water points – a review.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Illius, A. W., Derry, J. F., and Gordon, I. J. (1998). Evaluation of strategies for tracking climatic variation in semi-arid grazing systems. Agricultural Systems 57, 381–398.
| Evaluation of strategies for tracking climatic variation in semi-arid grazing systems.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Johnston, P., McKeon, G., and Day, K. (1996). Objective ‘safe’ grazing capacities for south-west Queensland Australia: development of a model for individual properties. The Rangeland Journal 18, 244–258.
| Objective ‘safe’ grazing capacities for south-west Queensland Australia: development of a model for individual properties.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Johnston, P., McKeon, G., Buxton, R., Cobon, D., Day, K., Hall, W., and Scanlan, J. (2000). Managing climate variability in Queensland’s grazing lands – new approaches. In: ‘Applications of Seasonal Climate Forecasting in Agriculture and Natural Ecosystems’. (Eds G. L. Hammer, N. Nicholls and C. Mitchell.) pp. 197–226. (Kluwer Academic Publishers: Dordrecht, The Netherlands.)
Karfs, R., Abbott, B., Scarth, P., and Wallace, J. (2009). Land condition monitoring information for reef catchments: a new era. The Rangeland Journal 31, 69–86.
| Land condition monitoring information for reef catchments: a new era.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Littleboy, M., and McKeon, G. (1997). Subroutine GRASP; grass production model, Marcoola version of subroutine GRASP. In: ‘Final Report to the RIRDC, Project No. DAQ-124A Evaluating the Risk of Pasture and Land Degradation in Native Pastures in Queensland’. (Eds K. A. Day, G. M. McKeon and J. O. Carter.) pp. 2–35. (Queensland Department of Primary Industries: Brisbane, Qld.)
Lodge, G. M., and Johnson, I. R. (2008). Using modelling to explore the relationships between predicted long-term stocking rates and sheep intake of pasture and supplement for a native perennial grass-based pasture near Barraba, New South Wales. In: ‘Proceedings of the 23rd Annual Conference of the Grassland Society of NSW’. (Eds S. P. Boschma, L. M. Serafin and J. F. Ayres.) pp. 141–143. (NSW Grassland Society: Orange, NSW.)
Mayer, D., Tierney, M., and Thurbon, P. (1994). Statistical experiments with simulation models – a dairy genetics example. Agricultural Systems 45, 203–216.
| Statistical experiments with simulation models – a dairy genetics example.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
McKeon, G. M., Day, K. A., Howden, S. M., Mott, J. J., Orr, D. M., Sacttini, W. J., and Weston, E. J. (1990). Northern Australian Savannas: management for production. Journal of Biogeography 17, 355–372.
| Northern Australian Savannas: management for production.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
McKeon, G. M., Hall, W. B., Crimp, S. J., Howden, S. M., Stone, R. C., and Jones, D. A. (1998). Climate change in Queensland’s grazing lands. I. Approaches and climatic trends. The Rangeland Journal 20, 151–176.
| Climate change in Queensland’s grazing lands. I. Approaches and climatic trends.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
McKeon, G. M., Ash, A. J., Hall, W. B., and Stafford-Smith, M. (2000). Simulation of grazing strategies for beef production in north-east Queensland. In: ‘Applications of Seasonal Climate Forecasting in Agricultural and Natural Systems – The Australian Experience’. (Eds G. Hammer, N. Nichols and C. Mitchell.) pp. 227–252. (Kluwer Academic Press: Amsterdam, The Netherlands.)
McKeon, G., Hall, W., Henry, B., Stone, G., and Watson, I. (2004). ‘Pasture Degradation and Recovery in Australia’s Rangelands: Learning from History.’ (Queensland Dept. of Natural Resources, Mines and Energy: Brisbane, Qld.)
McKeon, G., Stone, G., Syktus, J., Carter, J., Flood, N., Ahrens, D., Bruget, D., Chilcott, C., Cobon, D., Cowley, R., Crimp, S., Fraser, G., Howden, M., Johnston, P., Ryan, J., Stokes, C., and Day, K. (2009). Climate change impacts on northern Australian rangeland livestock carrying capacity: a review of issues. The Rangeland Journal 31, 1–29.
| Climate change impacts on northern Australian rangeland livestock carrying capacity: a review of issues.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
MLA (2012). Cattle numbers – as at June 2011. Natural resource management region. Meat and Livestock Australia, Sydney. Available at: www.google.com.au/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=1&ved=0ahUKEwjDi9Lxn8vJAhWiF6YKHWmRClYQFggbMAA&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.mla.com.au%2Ffiles%2Fd0faf79a-7218-4f5a-85db-a1110102aaf8%2FCattle-Numbers-Map_as-at-June-2011.pdf&usg=AFQjCNGZpyaOQbmcTh2dwAV6kpjoMA28xA (accessed 7 December 2015).
Nicholls, N., Drosdowsky, W., and Lavery, B. (1997). Australian rainfall variability and change. Weather 52, 66–72.
| Australian rainfall variability and change.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
O’Reagain, P. J., and Bushell, J. J. (2011). ‘The Wambiana Grazing Trial: Key Learnings for Sustainable and Profitable Management in a Variable Environment.’ (The State of Queensland, Department of Employment, Economic Development and Innovation: Brisbane, Qld.)
O’Reagain, P. J., and Scanlan, J. C. (2013). Sustainable management for rangelands in a variable climate: evidence and insights from northern Australia. Animal 7, 68–78.
| Sustainable management for rangelands in a variable climate: evidence and insights from northern Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 23031187PubMed |
O’Reagain, P. J., Bushell, J. J., and Holmes, B. (2011). Managing for rainfall variability: long-term profitability of different grazing strategies in a northern Australian tropical savanna. Animal Production Science 51, 210–224.
| Managing for rainfall variability: long-term profitability of different grazing strategies in a northern Australian tropical savanna.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
O’Rourke, P., Winks, L., and Kelly, A. (1992). ‘North Australia Beef Producer Survey 1990.’ (Queensland Department of Primary Industries and The Meat Research Corporation: Brisbane, Qld.)
Orr, D., and Phelps, D. (2013). Impacts of level of utilisation by grazing on an Astrebla (Mitchell grass) grassland in north-western Queensland between 1984 and 2010. 1. Herbage mass and population dynamics of Astrebla spp. The Rangeland Journal 35, 1–5.
| Impacts of level of utilisation by grazing on an Astrebla (Mitchell grass) grassland in north-western Queensland between 1984 and 2010. 1. Herbage mass and population dynamics of Astrebla spp.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Pahl, L., Scanlan, J., Whish, G., Cowley, R., and MacLeod, N. (2013). Systematic management of stocking rates improves performance of northern Australian cattle properties in a variable climate. Tropical Grasslands – Forrajes Tropicales 1, 230–234.
| Systematic management of stocking rates improves performance of northern Australian cattle properties in a variable climate.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Rickert, K. G., Stuth, J. W., and McKeon, G. M. (2000). Modelling pasture and animal production. In: ‘Field and Laboratory Methods for Grassland and Animal Production Research’. (Eds L.’t Mannetje and R. M. Jones.) pp. 29–66. (CABI Publishing: New York.)
Sandford, S., and Scoones, I. (2006). Opportunistic and conservative pastoral strategies: some economic arguments. Ecological Economics 58, 1–6.
| Opportunistic and conservative pastoral strategies: some economic arguments.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Scanlan, J., and McIvor, J. (2010). ‘Enhancing Adoption of Best Practice Grazing Management in Northern Australia: Phase One – Integration and Scenario Testing. Caring for Our Country Final Project Report OG084273.’ (Meat and Livestock Australia: North Sydney, NSW.)
Scanlan, J., McKeon, G., Day, K., Mott, J., and Hinton, A. (1994). Estimating safe carrying capacities of extensive cattle-grazing properties within tropical, semi-arid woodlands of north-eastern Australia. The Rangeland Journal 16, 64–76.
| Estimating safe carrying capacities of extensive cattle-grazing properties within tropical, semi-arid woodlands of north-eastern Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Scanlan, J., Whish, G., Pahl, L., Cowley, R., and MacLeod, N. (2010). The Northern Grazing Systems project: estimating safe stocking rate. In: ‘Proceedings of the 16th Biennial Conference of the Australian Rangeland Society’. Bourke. (Eds D. J. Eldridge and C. Waters.) (Australian Rangeland Society: Perth, WA.) Available at: www.austrangesoc.com.au/biennial-conference-pages/Joe%20Scanlan%20new.pdf (accessed 28 January 2016)
Scanlan, J., Whish, G., Pahl, L., Cowley, R., and MacLeod, N. (2011). Assessing the impact of pasture resting on pasture condition in the extensive grazing lands of northern Australia. In: ‘MODSIM2011. 19th International Congress on Modelling and Simulation. December 2011. (Eds F. Chan, D. Marinova and R. Anderssen.) pp. 877–883. (Modelling and Simulation Society of Australia and New Zealand: Canberra, ACT.) Available at: www.mssanz.org.au/modsim2011/B1/scanlan2.pdf (accessed 25 March 2013)
Scanlan, J. C., MacLeod, N. D., and O’Reagain, P. J. (2013). Scaling results up from a plot and paddock scale to a property – a case study from a long-term grazing experiment in northern Australia. The Rangeland Journal 35, 193–200.
| Scaling results up from a plot and paddock scale to a property – a case study from a long-term grazing experiment in northern Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Scanlan, J., McIvor, J., Bray, S., Cowley, R., Hunt, L., Pahl, L., MacLeod, N., and Whish, G. (2014). Resting pastures to improve land condition in northern Australia: guidelines based on the literature and simulation modelling. The Rangeland Journal 36, 429–443.
| Resting pastures to improve land condition in northern Australia: guidelines based on the literature and simulation modelling.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
SILO (2013). SILO meteorology for the land; enhanced meteorological data. Department of Environment and Resource Management, Queensland. Available at: www.longpaddock.qld.gov.au/silo/ (accessed 7 December 2015).
Stafford Smith, D. M. (1992). Stocking rate strategies across Australia. Australian Rangeland Society Range Management Newsletter 92, 1–3.
Stafford Smith, D., and Foran, B. (1992). An approach to assessing the economic risk of different drought management tactics on a South Australian pastoral sheep station. Agricultural Systems 39, 83–105.
| An approach to assessing the economic risk of different drought management tactics on a South Australian pastoral sheep station.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Stocktake (2014). Stocktake: balancing supply and demand. Available at: http://futurebeef.com.au/resources/workshops/sustainable-grazing-workshops/stocktake-balancing-supply-and-demand/ (accessed 7 December 2015).
Torell, L. A., Murugan, S., and Ramirez, O. A. (2010). Economics of flexible versus conservative stocking strategies to manage climate variability risk. Rangeland Ecology and Management 63, 415–425.
| Economics of flexible versus conservative stocking strategies to manage climate variability risk.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Tothill, J. C., and Gillies, C. (1992). ‘The Pasture Lands of Northern Australia.’ Tropical Grassland Society of Australia Occasional Publication No. 5. (Tropical Grassland Society of Australia: St Lucia, Qld.)
Walsh, D., and Cowley, R. (2011). Looking back in time: can safe pasture utilisation rates be determined using commercial paddock data in the Northern Territory? The Rangeland Journal 33, 131–142.
| Looking back in time: can safe pasture utilisation rates be determined using commercial paddock data in the Northern Territory?Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Webb, N., and Stokes, K. (2012). Climate change scenarios to facilitate stakeholder engagement in agricultural adaptation. Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies for Global Change 17, 957–973.
| Climate change scenarios to facilitate stakeholder engagement in agricultural adaptation.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Whish, G., Cowley, R., Pahl, L., Scanlan, J., and Macleod, N. (2014). Impacts of projected climate change on pasture growth and safe carrying capacities for 3 extensive grazing land regions in northern Australia. Tropical Grasslands – Forrajes Tropicales 2, 151–153.
| Impacts of projected climate change on pasture growth and safe carrying capacities for 3 extensive grazing land regions in northern Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
