Watching the Tide Roll Away – reply to Tibby et al. (2020)
Peter A. Gell
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations
School of Science, Psychology and Sport, Federation University Australia, Ballarat, Vic. 3350, Australia. Email: p.gell@federation.edu.au
Pacific Conservation Biology 26(4) 338-343 https://doi.org/10.1071/PC20057
Submitted: 9 July 2020 Accepted: 24 August 2020 Published: 18 September 2020
Abstract
The published findings on the diatom-inferred condition of a terminal lake in the Murray–Darling Basin were overlooked in favour of a revised unpublished interpretation, without the provision of new evidence or argument, posted on the website of the managing state government. Coauthors of the posted report have responded (Tibby et al. 2020) to the publication (Gell 2020) that outlined the changes made to this interpretation. This reply reaffirms that subtle changes were made to published interpretations and that these were critical in the development of a watering plan for the system. It also illustrates that anecdotal evidence was used selectively but would be a valuable contribution if aligned to known climatic variability. Further, this response corrects the widespread misunderstanding that signatory nations to the Ramsar Convention are obliged to retain listed wetlands in the condition observed at the time of listing. Finally, this response contests the favouring of certain evidence and seeks an approach that reconciles all available evidence, incorporates variability into planning and prepares for future management challenges.
Keywords: aquatic ecology, environmental change, estuarine biology, Lake Alexandrina, Murray River, palaeontology, wetlands.
References
Bayly, I. A. E., and Williams, W. D. (1966). Chemical and biological studies on some saline lakes of south-east Australia. Australian Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research 17, 177–228.| Chemical and biological studies on some saline lakes of south-east Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Chiew, F. H. S., Hale, J., Joehnk, K. D., Reid, M. A. and Webster, I. T. (2020). Independent review of Lower Lakes science informing water management. Report for the Murray–Darling Basin Authority.
Colloff, M. J., and Pittock, J. (2019). Why we disagree about the Murray–Darling Basin Plan: water reform, environmental knowledge and the science-policy decision context. Australasian Journal of Water Resources 23, 88–98.
| Why we disagree about the Murray–Darling Basin Plan: water reform, environmental knowledge and the science-policy decision context.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Davidson, N. C. (2016). Editorial: Understanding change in the ecological character of internationally important wetlands. Marine and Freshwater Research 67, 685–686.
| Editorial: Understanding change in the ecological character of internationally important wetlands.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Davis, J., Murray, S. and Burchell, F. N. (1902). Interstate Royal Commission on the River Murray, representing the states of New South Wales, Victoria, and South Australia: report of the Commissioners with Minutes of evidence, appendices, and plans. Parliament of Victoria, Melbourne.
Edwards, R. (1972). ‘Aboriginal Bark Canoes of the Murray Valley.’ (South Australian Museum: Adelaide.)
Finlayson, C. M., Clarke, S. J., Davidson, N. C., and Gell, P. (2016). Role of palaeoecology in describing the ecological character of wetlands. Marine & Freshwater Research 67, 687–694.
| Role of palaeoecology in describing the ecological character of wetlands.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Fluin, J. (2002). A diatom-based palaeolimnological investigation of the lower River Murray, south-eastern Australia. Ph.D. Thesis, Monash University, Melbourne.
Fluin, J., Gell, P., Haynes, D., and Tibby, J. (2007). Paleolimnological evidence for the independent evolution of neighbouring terminal lakes, the Murray Darling Basin, Australia. Hydrobiologia 591, 117–134.
| Paleolimnological evidence for the independent evolution of neighbouring terminal lakes, the Murray Darling Basin, Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Fluin, J., Haynes, D. and Tibby, J. (2009). An environmental history of the Lower Lakes and The Coorong. Unpublished report for the Department of Environment and Heritage, South Australia.
Fluin, J., Tibby, J., and Gell, P. (2010). Testing the efficacy of electrical conductivity (EC) reconstructions from the lower Murray River (SE Australia): a comparison between measured and inferred EC. Journal of Paleolimnology 43, 309–322.
| Testing the efficacy of electrical conductivity (EC) reconstructions from the lower Murray River (SE Australia): a comparison between measured and inferred EC.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Gasse, F., Juggins, S., and Khelifa, L. B. (1995). Diatom-based transfer functions for inferring past hydrochemical characteristics of African lakes. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 117, 31–54.
| Diatom-based transfer functions for inferring past hydrochemical characteristics of African lakes.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Gasse, F., Fontes, J.-C., Plaziat, J. C., Carbonel, P., Kaczmarska, I., De Deckker, P., Soulié-Marsche, I., Callot, Y., and Dupeuble, P. A. (1987). Biological remains, geochemistry and stable isotopes for the reconstruction of environmental and hydrological changes in the Holocene lakes from North Sahara. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 60, 1–46.
| Biological remains, geochemistry and stable isotopes for the reconstruction of environmental and hydrological changes in the Holocene lakes from North Sahara.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Gell, P. A. (1997). The development of a diatom data base for inferring lake salinity: towards a quantitative approach for reconstructing past climates. Australian Journal of Botany 45, 389–423.
| The development of a diatom data base for inferring lake salinity: towards a quantitative approach for reconstructing past climates.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Gell, P. A. (2020). Watching the tide roll away: contested interpretations of the nature of the Lower Lakes of the Murray Darling Basin. Pacific Conservation Biology 26, 130–141.
| Watching the tide roll away: contested interpretations of the nature of the Lower Lakes of the Murray Darling Basin.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Gell, P. A., Finlayson, C. M., and Davidson, N. C. (2016). Understanding change in the ecological character of Ramsar wetlands: perspectives from a deeper time – synthesis. Marine and Freshwater Research 67, 869–879.
| Understanding change in the ecological character of Ramsar wetlands: perspectives from a deeper time – synthesis.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Gell, P., Perga, M.-E. and Finlayson, C. M. (2018). Changes over time. In ‘Freshwater Ecology and Conservation: A Handbook of Techniques’. (Ed. J. M. R. Hughes.) (Oxford University Press: Oxford.)
Gell, P., Tibby, J., Fluin, J., Leahy, P, Reid, M., Adamson, K., Bulpin, S., MacGregor, A., Wallbrink, P., Hancock, G., and Walsh, B. (2005). Accessing limnological change and variability using fossil diatom assemblages, south-east Australia. River Research and Applications 21, 257–269.
| Accessing limnological change and variability using fossil diatom assemblages, south-east Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Gergis, J., Gallant, A. J. E., Braganza, K., Karoly, D. J., Allen, K., Cullen, L., D’Arrigo, R., Goodwin, I., Grierson, P., and McGregor, S. (2011). On the long-term context of the 1997–2009 ‘Big Dry’ in south-eastern Australia: insights from a 206-year multi-proxy rainfall reconstruction. Climatic Change 111, 923–944.
| On the long-term context of the 1997–2009 ‘Big Dry’ in south-eastern Australia: insights from a 206-year multi-proxy rainfall reconstruction.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Government of South Australia (2010). A freshwater future for the Lower Lakes. Murray Futures fact sheet. Climm-fact-freshwaterfuture-1.pdf [accessed 19 October 2018].
Hall, R. I., and Smol, J. P. (1992). A weighted-averaging regression and calibration model for inferring total phosphorus concentration from diatoms in British Columbia (Canada) lakes. Freshwater Biology 27, 417–434.
| A weighted-averaging regression and calibration model for inferring total phosphorus concentration from diatoms in British Columbia (Canada) lakes.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Helfensdorfer, A. M, Power, H. E., and Hubble, T. C. T. (2019). Modelling Holocene analogues of coastal plain estuaries reveals the magnitude of sea-level threat. Nature Scientific Reports 9, 2667.
| Modelling Holocene analogues of coastal plain estuaries reveals the magnitude of sea-level threat.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Helfensdorfer, A. M, Power, H. E., and Hubble, T. C. T. (2020). Atypical responses of a large catchment river to the Holocene sea-level highstand: the Murray River, Australia. Nature Scientific Reports 10, 7503.
| Atypical responses of a large catchment river to the Holocene sea-level highstand: the Murray River, Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Heneker, T. M. (2010). Development of flow regimes to manage water quality in the Lower Lakes, South Australia. DFW Technical report 2010/05. Government of South Australia, through Department of Water, Adelaide.
Herczeg, A. L., Smith, A. K., and Dighton, J. C. (2001). A 120 years record of changes in nitrogen and carbon cycling in Lake Alexandrina, South Australia: C:N, δ15N and δ13C in sediments. Applied Geochemistry 16, 73–84.
Hubble, T., Power, H., and Helfensdorfer, A. (2020). Response to ‘The predominantly fresh history of Lake Alexandrina, South Australia, and its implications for the Murray–Darling Basin Plan: a comment on Gell (2020)’. Pacific Conservation Biology 26, 215–217.
| Response to ‘The predominantly fresh history of Lake Alexandrina, South Australia, and its implications for the Murray–Darling Basin Plan: a comment on Gell (2020)’.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Kopf, R. K., Finlayson, C. M., Humphries, P., Sims, N. C., and Hladyz, S. (2015). Anthropocene baselines: human-induced changes to global freshwater biodiversity restoration potential. Bioscience 65, 798–811.
| Anthropocene baselines: human-induced changes to global freshwater biodiversity restoration potential.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Lester, R. E., Fairweather, P. G. and Higham, J. S. (2011a). Determining the environmental water requirements for the Coorong, Lower Lakes and Murray Mouth region. Methods and Findings to date. A report for the Department of Environment and Natural Resources, Adelaide.
Lester, R. E., Fairweather, P. G., Heneker, T. M., Higham, J. S. and Muller, K. L. (2011b). Specifying an environmental water requirement for The Coorong and Lakes Alexandrina and Albert: a first iteration. A report for the Department of Environment and Natural Resources, Adelaide.
Mallen-Cooper, M., and Zampatti, B. P. (2018). History, hydrology and hydraulics: rethinking the ecological management of large rivers. Ecohydrology 11, e1965.
| History, hydrology and hydraulics: rethinking the ecological management of large rivers.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Murray–Darling Basin Authority (2014). Basin-wide environmental watering strategy. Murray–Darling Basin Authority, Canberra.
Pittock, J. (2019). Are we there yet? The Murray–Darling Basin and sustainable water management. Thesis Eleven 150, 119–130
Pittock, J., Finlayson, M., Gardner, A., and McKay, C. (2010). Changing character: The Ramsar Convention on Wetlands and climate change in the Murray–Darling Basin, Australia. Environmental Planning and Law Journal 27, 401–425.
Powell, J. M. (1989). ‘Watering the Garden State: Water, Land and Community in Victoria, 1834–1988.’ (Allen and Unwin: Sydney.)
RM Consulting Group (2016). Basin Plan – GMID socio-economic impact assessment – final report. RM Consulting Group, Bendigo.
Sim, T. and Muller, K. (2004). ‘A Fresh History of the Lakes: Wellington to Murray Mouth, 1800s to 1935.’ (River Murray Catchment Water Management Board: Strathalbyn.)
Societas Internationalis Limnologiae (1959). Symposium sur la classification des eaux saumâtres. Archivio di Oceanografia e Limnologia, Venice (Supplement), pp. 1–248.
Thom, B., Rocheta, E., Steinfeld, C., Harvey, N., Pittock, J. and Cowell, P. (2020). The role of coastal processes in the management of the mouth of the River Murray, Australia: present and future challenges. River Research and Applications 36, 656–667.
Tibby, J., and Reid, M. A. (2004). A model for inferring past conductivity in low salinity waters derived from Murray River (Australia) diatom plankton. Marine and Freshwater Research 55, 597–607.
| A model for inferring past conductivity in low salinity waters derived from Murray River (Australia) diatom plankton.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Tibby, J., Lane, M., and Gell, P. A. (2008). Local knowledge as a basis for environmental management: a cautionary tale from Lake Ainsworth, northern New South Wales. Environmental Conservation 34, 334–341.
| Local knowledge as a basis for environmental management: a cautionary tale from Lake Ainsworth, northern New South Wales.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
Tibby, J., Muller, K., and Haynes, D. (2020). The predominantly fresh history of Lake Alexandrina, South Australia, and its implications for the Murray–Darling Basin Plan: a comment on Gell. Pacific Conservation Biology 26, 142–149.
| The predominantly fresh history of Lake Alexandrina, South Australia, and its implications for the Murray–Darling Basin Plan: a comment on Gell.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
