Evaluating management effectiveness of the Moulouya River Estuary Ramsar Site in Morocco: an application of the R-METT tool and implications for conservation
Toufik Ouagga
A * and Nargis Sahib A
A
Abstract
To ensure biodiversity outcomes in protected and conserved areas, it is essential that they are governed and managed effectively.
The study is an evaluation of the management effectiveness of Ramsar Sites in Morocco, with a particular focus on the Moulouya River Estuary, a wetland outside protected areas, to identify key challenges and propose strategies for improvement.
The Ramsar Management Effectiveness Tracking Tool (R-METT) was used to assess the Moulouya River Estuary across the following six elements: context, planning, input, process, output, and outcome. The R-METT score was converted to the global reporting standard for comparison.
The site performed a management effectiveness score of 26% (28% in global reporting), highlighting important shortcomings. Major challenges include the absence of legal protection, insufficient resources and minimal community involvement. Principal threats arise from tourism infrastructure, hydrological disruptions caused by upstream dams, and unsustainable agricultural practices.
The study identified critical management gaps, underscoring the urgent need for governmental and conservation-partner interventions to safeguard the ecological value of the estuary.
Integrating unprotected Ramsar Sites into national conservation strategies is essential. Establishing partnerships between provincial authorities and local communities, alongside implementing long-term conservation initiatives with sustainable funding, is recommended.
Keywords: biodiversity, conservation, ecological, hydrological, management, protected areas, tool, wetlands.
References
Al Ouazzane H (1525) Description de l’Afrique: tierce partie du monde. Livre/Volume 1. Ecrit par Hassan Al Ouazzane dit Jean Léon l’Africain. (Ernest Leroux: Paris, France) Available at https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/bpt6k65364704/f15.item# [In French]
Arrach S (2014) Etude hydrologique de l’embouchure de la Moulouya et proposition de schéma d’aménagement et de gestion. Projet FEM/Banque Mondiale. Gestion Intégrée des Zones Côtières/Côtes Méditerranéennes – région de l’Orientale. Rapport fait pour le Ministère délégué auprès du Ministre de l’Energie des Mines de l’Eau et de L’environnement chargé de l’Environnement au Maroc, Oujda, Morocco. [In French]
Bakar AN, Ali A, Jangga R, Yaakob AN, Salleh RM, Shukor MFA (2022) Community participation in Gunung Ledang protected area: supporting the Sustainable Development Goal (SDG). IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science 1019, 012010.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Basraoui Y, Chafi A, Zarhloule Y, Demnati S (2011) An integrated coastal zone management initiative for sensitive coastal wetland on either sides of The Moulouya Estuary in Morocco. Procedia – Social and Behavioral Sciences 19, 520-525.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Battisti C, Luiselli L, Pantano D, Teofili C (2008) On threats analysis approach applied to a Mediterranean remnant wetland: is the assessment of human-induced threats related to different level of expertise of respondents? Biodiversity and Conservation 17, 1529-1542.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Belle E, Stolton S, Dudley N, Hockings M, Burgess ND (2012) Cadre régional et module METT supplémentaire (Outil de suivi de l’efficacité de la gestion des AP) pour le suivi des impacts du changement climatique. UNEPWCMC technical report. (UNEP World Conservation Monitoring Centre: Cambridge, UK) Available at http://parcc.protectedplanet.net/system/comfy/cms/files/files/000/000/131/original/PARCC_framework_and_METT_tool_FINAL_FRN.pdf [In French]
Berrahou A, Chavanon G, Richoux P (2000) Etudes sur la Basse Moulouya (Maroc oriental) : 6. Les Coléoptères aquatiques de l’Oued Zegzel. Bulletin mensuel de la Société linnéenne de Lyon 69(3), 44-50 Available at http://www.persee.fr/doc/linly_0366-1326_2000_num_69_3_11320 [In French].
| Google Scholar |
Biotope Ingénierie Biodiversité (2016) Diagnostic écologique, socio-économique, cartographie des habitats et élaboration d’un programme de suivi écologique de la zone humide de l’embouchure de Moulouya : Rapport Final. Mission IV, Programme de suivi écologique du Projet GIZC (Gestion Intégrée des Zones Côtières). Rapport fait pour le Ministère délégué auprès du Ministre de l’Energie des Mines de l’Eau et de L’environnement chargé de l’Environnement au Maroc. Available at http://gizc.environnement.gov.ma/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Rapport_Final_Suivi_Ecologique__Moulouya_01122016.pdf [In French]
BirdLife International (2024) Embouchure Oued Moulouya, Morocco. DataZone by BirdLife, Important Bird Area factsheet. (BirdLife International) Available at https://datazone.birdlife.org/site/factsheet/embouchure-oued-moulouya-iba-morocco [Verified 3 July 2024]
Borrini-Feyerabend G, Dudley N, Jaeger T, Lassen B, Pathak Broome N, Phillips A, Sandwith T (2013) Governance of protected areas: from understanding to action. Best Practice Protected Area Guidelines Series Number 20. (International Union for Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources: Gland, Switzerland) Available at https://portals.iucn.org/library/node/29138
Boumeaza T, Sbai A, Salmon M, Benata M, Ozer A (2010) Impacts écologiques des aménagements touristiques sur le littoral de Saïdia. Maroc oriental. Rivages Méditerranéens 115, 94-102 [In French].
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Carbutt C, Goodman PS (2013) How objective are protected area management effectiveness assessments? A case study from the iSimangaliso Wetland Park. Koedoe 55(1), a1110.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Cherkaoui I, Boutaleb A, Faqihi Y, Saddik M (2006) Some observations of rare or common birds in winter 2005-2006 at the mouth of the Moulouya and in the plain of Triffa (north-eastern Morocco). Go-South Bulletin 3, 43-47.
| Google Scholar |
Dakki M, El Agbani MA (2003) Recensements hivernaux d’oiseaux d’eau au Maroc: Résultats du suivi de 1983–2000 et leur application à l’évaluation des sites inscrits ou proposés pour inscription sur la liste Ramsar. Rapport Inédit, Projet WWF International ‘Inscription de nouveaux sites marocains sur la liste Ramsar des zones humides d’importance internationale’. Haut Commissariat aux Eaux et Forêts et à la Lutte Contre la Désertification (HCEFLCD), Institut Scientifique, WWF International and BirdLife. [In French]
Dakki M, El Agbani MA, Qninba A, Benhoussa A, Hammada S, Hamidi S, Maamri A (2003) Fiche Descriptive sur les zones humides RAMSAR. (FDR). Catégories approuvées dans la Recommandation 4.7 modifiée par la résolution VIII.3 de la Conférence des Parties contractantes. Rapport de mission. (Ramsar Sites Information Service: Rabat, Morocco) Available at https://rsis.ramsar.org/RISapp/files/RISrep/MA1478RIS.pdf [In French]
Dakki M, El Agbani MA, Qninba A (2011) Zones humides du Maroc inscrites jusqu’en 2005 sur la Liste de la Convention de Ramsar. Sér. Générale nombre 7. (Travaux Institut Scientifique: Rabat, Morocco) Available at https://www.worldcat.org/title/zones-humides-du-maroc-inscrites-jusquen-2005-sur-la-liste-de-la-convention-de-ramsar/oclc/864513463 [In French]
Dakki M, Menioui M, Zouhair A (2015) Stratégie nationale des zones humides 2015–2024. Stratégie – Plan d’action. (Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit, GIZ: Rabat, Morocco) Available at https://medwet.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/03/strategie-nationale_-ZH_Maroc.pdf [In French]
Darif H, Hassouni T, Belghyti D, El Kharrim K, Chiahou B, El Madhi Y, El Halouani H (2015) Contribution à la connaissance de l’état actuel de la faune benthique de l’écosystème estuarien de l’embouchure de la Moulouya (Maroc). European Scientific Journal 11(3), 231-240 [In French].
| Google Scholar |
Davidson NC, Finlayson CM (2018) Extent, regional distribution and changes in area of different classes of wetland. Marine and Freshwater Research 69(10), 1525-1533.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Díaz S, Settele J, Brondízio ES, Ngo HT, Guèze M, Agard J, Arneth A, Balvanera P, Brauman KA, Butchart SHM, Chan KMA, Garibaldi LA, Ichii K, Liu J, Subramanian SM, Midgley GF, Miloslavich P, Molnár Z, Obura D, Pfaff A, Polasky S, Purvis A, Razzaque J, Reyers B, Roy Chowdhury R, Shin YJ, Visseren-Hamakers IJ, Willis KJ, Zayas CN (Eds) (2019) Summary for policymakers of the global assessment report on biodiversity and ecosystem services of the Intergovernmental Science–Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services. (IPBES Secretariat: Bonn, Germany) doi:10.5281/zenodo.6417333
Erwin KL (2009) Wetlands and global climate change: the role of wetland restoration in a changing world. Wetlands Ecology and Management 17, 71-84.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Finlayson CM, Capon SJ, Rissik D, Pittock J, Fisk G, Davidson NC, Bodmin KA, Papas P, Robertson HA, Schallenberg M, Saintilan N, Edyvane K, Bino G (2017) Policy considerations for managing wetlands under a changing climate. Marine and Freshwater Research 68, 1803-1815.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Gaget E, Galewski T, Jiguet F, Le Viol I (2018) Waterbird communities adjust to climate warming according to conservation policy and species protection status. Biological Conservation 227, 205-212.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Gardner RC, Barchiesi S, Beltrame C, Finlayson CM, Galewski T, Harrison I, Paganini M, Perennou C, Pritchard D, Rosenqvist A, Walpole M (2015) State of the world’s wetlands and their services to people: a compilation of recent analyses. Ramsar Briefing Note Number 7, Ramsar Convention Secretariat, Gland, Switzerland.
Gaussen H, Roux G, Bagnouls MF (1957) Carte des précipitations publiée par la Direction de l’agriculture et des forêts, la Direction de l’instruction publique, la Direction de la production industrielle et des mines, et la Direction des travaux publics du Maroc. Document cartographique, ark:/12148/cb407315227, Direction de l’instruction publique, Rabat, Morocco. [In French]
Giovacchini P, Battisti C, Marsili L (2022) Evaluating the effectiveness of a conservation project on two threatened birds: applying expert-based threat analysis and threat reduction assessment in a mediterranean wetland. Diversity 14, 94.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Green JMH, Larrosa C, Burgess ND, Balmford A, Johnston A, Mbilinyi BP, Platts PJ, Coad L (2013) Deforestation in an African biodiversity hotspot: extent, variation and the effectiveness of protected areas. Biological Conservation 164, 62-72.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Gross JE, Woodley S, Welling LA, Watson JM (Eds) (2016) Adapting to climate change: guidance for protected area managers and planners. Best Practice Protected Area Guidelines. Series Number 24. (International Union for Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources: Gland, Switzerland) Available at https://portals.iucn.org/library/sites/library/files/documents/PAG-024.pdf
Gurung B, Jnawali SR, Dhakal T, Bhattarai B, Thapa GJ, Wikramanayake E (2018) Participatory threat assessment of two major wildlife corridors in the Terai Arc Landscape. Parks 24, 97-106.
| Google Scholar |
Hashim Z, Abdullah SA, Nor SM (2017) Stakeholders analysis on criteria for protected areas management categories in Peninsular Malaysia. IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science 91, 012014.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Haut Commissariat Aux Eaux et Forêts et à la Lutte Contre La Désertification (2007) Plan d’action du Haut Commissariat Aux Eaux et Forêts et à la Lutte Contre La Désertification. (HCEFLCD: Rabat, Morocco) Available at https://faolex.fao.org/docs/pdf/mor164708.pdf [In French]
Hockings M, Stolton S, Leverington F (2006) Evaluating effectiveness: a framework for assessing management effectiveness of protected areas, 2nd edn. (International Union for Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources: Gland, Switzerland) Available at https://portals.iucn.org/library/efiles/documents/pag-014.pdf
Hoffmann S (2022) Challenges and opportunities of area-based conservation in reaching biodiversity and sustainability goals. Biodiversity and Conservation 31, 325-352.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Irzi Z (2002) Les environnements du littoral méditerranéen du Maroc compris entre l’oued Kiss et le Cap des Trois Fourches. Dynamique sédimentaire et évolution et écologie des foraminifères benthiques de la lagune de Nador. PhD thesis, Université Mohammed 1er, faculté des Sciences, Oujda, Morocco. [In French]
Key Biodiversity Areas Partnership (2024) Embouchure Oued Moulouya (6484), Morocco, Africa. Key biodiversity areas factsheet, extracted from the World Database of Key Biodiversity Areas. (keybiodiversityareas.org) Available at https://www.keybiodiversityareas.org/site/factsheet/6484 [Verified 28 February 2025]
Lambi CM, Kimengsi JN, Kometa CG, Tata ES (2012) The management and challenges of protected areas and the sustenance of local livelihoods in Cameroon. Environment and Natural Resources Research 2(3), 10-18.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Leverington F, Costa KL, Pavese H, Lisle A, Hockings M (2010) A global analysis of protected area management effectiveness. Environmental Management 46(5), 685-698.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
López-Rodríguez F, Rosado D (2017) Management effectiveness evaluation in protected areas of southern Ecuador. Journal of Environmental Management 190, 45-52.
| Crossref | Google Scholar | PubMed |
Lu D-J, Kao C-W, Chao C-L (2012) Evaluating the management effectiveness of five Protected Areas in Taiwan using WWF’s RAPPAM. Environmental Management 50, 272-282.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Mabrouki Y, Taybi AF, Chavanon G, Vinçon G, Berrahou A (2016) Contribution to the study of stoneflies in eastern Morocco and the catchment area of the Moulouya and their distribution depending on the bioclimatic zones. Journal of Materials and Environmental Sciences 7(6), 2178-2193.
| Google Scholar |
Mabrouki Y, Taybi AF, Skalli A, Sánchez-Vialas A (2019) Amphibians of the Oriental Region and the Moulouya River Basin of Morocco: distribution and conservation notes. Basic and Applied Herpetology 33, 19-32.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Maestro M, Pérez-Cayeiro ML, Reyes H, Chica-Ruiz JA (2024) Analysis of the management of protected areas in Galapagos: 60 years after its declaration as a National Park. Sustainability 16, 6532.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Médail F, Quézel P (1999) Biodiversity hotspots in the Mediterranean Basin: setting global conservation priorities. Conservation Biology 13(6), 1510-1513.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Melloul A, Boughriba M, Boufaida M (2009) Étude de la contamination des ressources en eaux souterraines et cartographie de la vulnérabilité d’un aquifère soumis au climat semi-aride méditerranéen : cas de la plaine côtière de Saïdia, Maroc. Science et changements planétaires/Sécheresse 20(2), 223-231 [In French].
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Munguía SM, Heinen JT (2021) Assessing protected area management effectiveness: the need for a wetland-specific evaluation tool. Environmental Management 68, 773-784.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Nations Unies (1992) La Convention sur la diversité biologique, traité international pour un avenir durable. (Secrétariat de la Convention sur la diversité biologique: Montréal, QC, Canada) Available at https://www.un.org/fr/observances/biological-diversity-day/convention#:~:text=La%20Convention%20sur%20la%20diversit%C3%A9%20biologique%20vise%20tous%20les%20niveaux,la%20pr%C3%A9vention%20des%20risques%20biotechnologiques [In French]
Naughton-Treves L, Holland MB, Brandon K (2005) The role of protected areas in conserving biodiversity and sustaining local livelihoods. Annual Review of Environment and Resources 30, 219-252.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Negru C, Gaibor ID, Halalisan A-F, Popa B (2020) Management effectiveness assessment for Ecuador’s national parks. Diversity 12, 487.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Novelli M, Scarth A (2007) Tourism in Protected areas: integrating conservation and community development in Liwonde National Park (Malawi). Tourism and Hospitality Planning & Development 4, 47-73.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Oldekop JA, Holmes G, Harris WE, Evans KL (2016) A global assessment of the social and conservation outcomes of protected areas. Conservation Biology 30, 133-141.
| Crossref | Google Scholar | PubMed |
Oukemeni D, Bourne JH (1993) Study of granitic rocks which are exposed in the Aouli Paleozoic window, Haute Moulouya area, Morocco. Journal of African Earth Sciences 17(4), 429-443.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Ramsar Convention (2023) The list of wetlands of international importance. (Ramsar Convention on Wetlands Secretariat: Gland, Switzerland) Available at https://www.ramsar.org/document/list-wetlands-international-importance-ramsar-list
Ramsar Convention (2024) The Ramsar Sites criteria: the nine criteria for identifying wetlands of international importance. (Ramsar Convention on Wetlands Secretariat: Gland, Switzerland) Available at https://www.ramsar.org/sites/default/files/documents/library/ramsarsites_criteria_eng.pdf [Verified 19 August 2024]
Rebelo L-M, McCartney MP, Finlayson CM (2010) Wetlands of Sub-Saharan Africa: distribution and contribution of agriculture to livelihoods. Wetlands Ecology and Management 18, 557-572.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Salafsky N, Wollenberg E (2000) Linking livelihoods and conservation: a conceptual framework and scale for assessing the integration of human needs and biodiversity. World Development 28, 1421-1438.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Salafsky N, Salzer D, Stattersfield AJ, Hilton-Taylor C, Neugarten R, Butchart SHM, Collen B, Cox N, Master LL, O’Connor S, Wilkie D (2008) A standard lexicon for biodiversity conservation: unified classifications of threats and actions. Conservation Biology 22(4), 897-911.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Sálvio GMM, Gomes CR (2018) Protected area systems in south American countries. Floresta e Ambiente 25(4), e20171134.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Stolton S, Dudley N, Belokurov A, Deguignet M, Burgess ND, Hockings M, Leverington F, MacKinnon K, Young L (2019) Lessons learned from 18 years of implementing the management effectiveness tracking tool (METT): a perspective from the METT developers and implementers. Parks 25, 79-92.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Stolton S, Hockings M, Dudley N (2020) Management Effectiveness Tracking Tool (METT-4) Guide (2020). (BIOPAMA). Available at https://rris.biopama.org/node/20639
Taybi AF, Mabrouki Y, Ghamizi M, Berrahou A (2017) The freshwater malacological composition of Moulouya’s watershed and Oriental Morocco. Journal of Materials and Environmental Sciences 8(4), 1401-1416.
| Google Scholar |
Thapa K, Lindner A (2023) Beyond protected areas: assessing management effectiveness of a Ramsar Site in Nepal. Diversity 15, 593.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Triplet P, Dakki M, Cherkaoui I, De Lopé M, Dufour A (2010) Mission consultative RAMSAR. Rapport nombre 71. (Convention on Wetlands Secretariat) Available at https://www.ramsar.org/document/ramsar-advisory-mission-report-71-morocco-2010 [In French]
Watson JEM, Darling ES, Venter O, Maron M, Walston J, Possingham HP, Dudley N, Hockings M, Barnes M, Brooks TM (2016) Bolder science needed now for protected areas. Conservation Biology 30, 243-248.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Watson JEM, Venegas-Li R, Grantham H, Dudley N, Stolton S, Rao M, Woodley S, Hockings M, Burkart K, Simmonds JS, Sonter LJ, Sreekar R, Possingham HP, Ward M (2023) Priorities for protected area expansion so nations can meet their Kunming–Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework commitments. Integrative Conservation 2, 140-155.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
West P, Igoe J, Brockington D (2006) Parks and peoples: the social impact of protected areas. Annual Review of Anthropology 35, 251-277.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
Woodley S, Locke H, Laffoley D, MacKinnon K, Sandwith T, Smart J (2019) A review of evidence for area-based conservation targets for the post-2020 global biodiversity framework. PARKS 25(2), 31-46.
| Crossref | Google Scholar |
