The future of community-centred health services in Australia: ‘When too many beds are not enough’
Alan Rosen A B C H , Roger Gurr D E , Paul Fanning F and Alan Owen GA School of Public Health, Faculty of Health & Behavioural Sciences, University of Wollongong, Wollongong, NSW 2522, Australia.
B Greater West Area Health Service, NSW, Australia.
C Brain and Mind Research Institute, School of Medicine, University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW, Australia.
D Blacktown Mt Druitt Mental Health Service, Blacktown Hospital, Blacktown Rd, Blacktown, NSW 2148, Australia. Email: rogurr@netspace.net.au
E Faculty of Medicine, University of Western Sydney, Sydney, NSW, Australia.
F Service Planning and Development, Centre for Rural and Remote Mental Health, School of Medicine and Public Health, University of Newcastle, Newcastle NSW, Australia. Email: Paul.fanning@gwahs.health.nsw.gov.au
G Australian Health Services Research Institute, University of Wollongong, Wollongong, NSW 2522, Australia. Email: aowen@uow.edu.au
H Corresponding author. Email: alanrosen@med.usyd.edu.au
Submitted: 16 July 2012 Accepted: 16 July 2012 Published: 24 August 2012
Abstract
The authors welcome a constructive debate on the future of community-centred health services. Therefore, we have written this piece in response to an article published by Cunningham in the previous edition of the Australian Health Review (Cunningham, Australian Health Review 2012; 36: 121–124), which was a very limited analysis and misleading critique of our previous contribution to this journal (Rosen et al. Australian Health Review 2010; 34: 106–115).
The focus here is necessarily brief and does not stand in for a detailed analysis of the evidence base. The aim instead, is to draw attention back to the broader political, economic and social dimensions of how the retreat from community health services has affected clinical care. We also outline a response to a longstanding assumption, or belief, that ‘too many hospital beds are not enough’ and may never be enough.
How we understand the problem of resource allocation in healthcare shapes the remedies that are considered realistic. We explain that the reasons for the systematic underdevelopment of community health services are complex, historical, and largely relate to political and economic factors, but they are still amenable to change.
What is known about the topic? There is a growing evidence base and consensus of expert opinion supporting the gradual shift in health service delivery away from hospital-based models of care to community-centred ones. Wherever possible, speciality community health services should be co-located with primary health care in communal shopping and transport hubs so that patients have access to ‘one-stop-shops’ providing both primary healthcare and community treatment, and support services. It is important that these speciality community health services retain their integrity and control of their budgets, but also that they maintain functional integration with their respective hospital-based services.
What does this paper add? In response to a recently published vigorous but narrowly targeted critique of community-based models of care, we explore the wider context of the debate about the appropriate balance between hospital and community health services. We pay particular attention to the current debate in mental health services.
What are the implications for practitioners? Clinicians need to understand the historical, political and economic factors that have influenced the underdevelopment of community-centred health services, so as to avoid unhelpful conflicts between specialists and those working in different care settings. Rear-guard attempts to restore the dominance of hospital-centric services are unsustainable in terms of ethics and economic reality. Policy-makers and health planners should instead aim to rebalance resources in the health sector so that people in all age groups and regions have equitable access to the full range of human health and support services across the continuum of care.
Additional keywords: Australia, beds, community health, community mental health, community sites, future, emergency departments, hospital sites.
References
[1] Fine M. When too many beds are not enough: the nursing homes paradox New Doctor 1984; 27 25–8.[2] Rittel H, Webber M. Dilemmas in a general theory of planning. Policy Sciences 1973; 4 155–169.
| Dilemmas in a general theory of planning. Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[3] Leutz W. Five laws for integrating medical and social services: lessons from the United States and the United Kingdom. Milbank Q 1999; 77 77–110.
| Five laws for integrating medical and social services: lessons from the United States and the United Kingdom.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[4] Leutz W. Reflections on Integrating Medical and Social Care: Five Laws Revisited. Journal of Integrated Care 2005; 13 3–12.
| Reflections on Integrating Medical and Social Care: Five Laws Revisited.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[5] Eagar K, Pirkis J, Owen A, Burgess P, Posner N, Perkins D. Lessons from the National Mental Health Integration Program. Aust Health Rev 2005; 28 189–200.
[6] Cunningham P. The future of community-centred health services in Australia-an alternative view Aust Health Rev 2012; 36 121–4.
| The future of community-centred health services in Australia-an alternative viewCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[7] Rosen A, Gurr R, Fanning P. The future of community-centred health services in Australia: lessons from the mental health sector. Aust Health Rev 2010; 34 106–15.
| The future of community-centred health services in Australia: lessons from the mental health sector.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[8] Owen A, Thompson C, Samsa P, Grootemaat P, Fildes D, Eager K. Community health: the evidence base. A report for the NSW Community Health Review. Wollongong: University of Wollongong. 2008. Available from http://www.health.nsw.gov.au/pubs/2008/chr_evidence.html
[9] Muir K, Powell A, Patulny RV, Flaxman S, McDermott SC, Gendera S, et al. Independent evaluation of headspace. Sydney: Social Policy Research Centre, University of NSW. 2009.
[10] Rosen A. Integration is as essential as balance: invited leading commentary on Thornicroft, G. and Tansella, M., Balancing Community-based and Hospital-based Mental Health Care World Psychiatry 2002; 1 91–3.
[11] Johnson S, Gilburt H, Lloyd-Evans B, Osborn DPJ, Boardman J, Reese M, et al In-patient and residential alternatives to standard acute psychiatric wards in England. Br J Psychiatry 2009; 194 456–63.
| In-patient and residential alternatives to standard acute psychiatric wards in England.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[12] McGorry PD, Jackson HJ, eds. The recognition and management of early intervention: A preventive approach . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 1999.
[13] Mihalopoulos C, Harris M, Henry L, Harrigan S, McGorry P. Is early intervention for psychosis cost-effective over the long term? Schizophr Bull 2009; 909–918. ]
| Is early intervention for psychosis cost-effective over the long term?Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[14] Hoult J, Rosen A, Reynolds I. Community orientated treatment compared to psychiatric hospital orientated treatment. Soc Sci Med 1984; 18 1005–10.
| Community orientated treatment compared to psychiatric hospital orientated treatment.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[15] Stein LI, Test MA. Alternatives to mental hospital treatment. New York: Plenum Press. 1978.
[16] Harvey C, Killaspy H, Martino S, White S, Priebe S, Wright C, Johnson S. A comparison of the implementation of assertive community treatment in Melbourne, Australia and London, England. Epidemiology and Psychiatric Sciences 2011; 20 151–61.
| A comparison of the implementation of assertive community treatment in Melbourne, Australia and London, England.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[17] Killaspy H, Rosen A. Case management and assertive community treatment. In Thorniocroft G, et al. (editors). Textbook of Community Psychiatry. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 2011.
[18] Housing & Accommodation Support Initiative (HASI). HASI Report 1: Summary, Social Policy Research Centre 2005.
[19] Housing & Accommodation Support Initiative (HASI). Section 9, HASI monitoring and evaluation. Sydney: NSW Health and NSW Department of Housing. 2006.
[20] Thornicroft G, Tansella M. Balancing Community-based and Hospital-based Mental Health Care World Psychiatry 2002; 1 84–90.
[21] Thornicroft G, Alem A, Antunes R, Dos Santos AR, Barley E, Drake RE, et al WPA guidance on steps, obstacles and mistakes to avoid in the implementation of community mental health care. World Psychiatry 2010; 9 67–77.
[22] Gurr R. Drugs and Australasian Government policies have created a crisis in public mental health services. Canberra: Senate Select Committee on Mental Health, Proceedings, 2005. http://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate_Committees?url=mentalhealth_ctte/index.htm
[23] Kalucy R, Thomas L, King D. Changing demand for mental health services in the emergency department of a public hospital Aust N Z J Psychiatry 2005; 39 74–80.
| Changing demand for mental health services in the emergency department of a public hospitalCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[24] Shepperd S, Doll H, Angus RM, Clarke MJ, Iliffe S, Kalra L, et al Admission avoidance hospital at home. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2008; CD007491
[25] Shepperd S, Doll H, Broad J, Gladman J, Iliffe S, Langhorne P, et al Early discharge hospital at home. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2009; CD000356
[26] Shepperd S, Doll H, Angus R, Clarke MJ, Illiffe S, Kaira L, et al. Hospital at home admission avoidance, Cochrane Effective Practice and Organisation of Care Group. The Cochrane Library. 2010 http://www.thecochranelibrary.com/view/0/index/html
[27] Baum F. The New Public Health 3rd edition. Melbourne: Oxford University Press. 2008.
[28] Masso M, Bezzina AJ, Siminiki P, Middleton R, Eagar K. Why patients attend emergency departments for conditions potentially appropriate for primary care – Reasons given by patients and clinicians differ. Emerg Med Australas 2007; 19 333–40.
| Why patients attend emergency departments for conditions potentially appropriate for primary care – Reasons given by patients and clinicians differ.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[29] Thompson C, Masso M, Westera A, Morris D, Eagar K. Ambulance Service of NSW: review of the capacity of the paramedic to identify the low risk patient. Final report. Wollongong: University of Wollongong. 2011
[30] Westera A, Stevermuer T, Samsa P, Quinsey K, Owen A, Marosszeky N. et al. The NSW SAFTE Care Program – evaluation of a pilot program to prevent unnecessary hospital attendances by older people. Wollongong: University of Wollongong. 2007. http://ahsripub.uow.edu.au/publication/2007_pubs/safte_final_report_%20apr07.pdf
[31] Shepperd S, Harwood D, Jenkinson C, Gray A, Vessey M, Morgan P. Randomised controlled trial comparing hospital at home care with inpatient hospital care I: Three month follow up of health outcomes. BMJ 1998; 316 1786–1791.
| Randomised controlled trial comparing hospital at home care with inpatient hospital care I: Three month follow up of health outcomes.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[32] Rosen A, McGorry P, Hill H, Rosenberg S. The independent hospital pricing authority and mental health services: it is not a case of one size fits all Med J Aust 2012; 196 675–7.
| The independent hospital pricing authority and mental health services: it is not a case of one size fits allCrossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[33] Eagar K, Burgess P, Whiteford H. ABF Information Series No. 8 Mental Health. Wollongong: University of Wollongong. 2011. http://ahsri.uow.edu.au/content/groups/public/@web/@chsd/documents/doc/uow097565.pdf
[34] Knapp M, McDaid D, Parsonage M (editors). Mental health promotion and mental illness prevention: The economic case. London: London School of Economics and Department of Health. 2011.
[35] Economics Australia. The economic impact of youth mental illness and the cost effectiveness of early intervention. Melbourne: Headspace Centre of Excellence Orygen Youth Health Research Centre. 2009.
[36] Maj M. Mistakes to avoid in the implementation of community mental health care World Psychiatry 2010; 9 65–6.
[37] Mahler H. Address to the 61st World Health Assembl. 20 May 2008,Available from: http://www.who.int/mediacentre/events/2008/wha61/hafdan_mahler_speech/en/index.html
[38] Rosen A, O’Halloran P, Mezzina R. International trends in community mental health services in Handbook of Community Psychiatry (McQuiston H, Feldman J, Sowers W, editors). New York: Springer; 2012.
[39] Rosen A, Goldbloom D, McGeorge P. Mental health commissions: making the critical difference to the development and reform of mental health services, clinical therapeutics. Current Opinion in Psychiatry 2010; 23 593–603.
| Mental health commissions: making the critical difference to the development and reform of mental health services, clinical therapeutics.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[40] Rosenberg S, Rosen A. It’s raining mental health commissions – prospects and pitfalls in driving mental health reform. Australasian Psychiatry 2012; 20 85–90.
| It’s raining mental health commissions – prospects and pitfalls in driving mental health reform.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
