Australia’s private health insurance industry: structure, competition, regulation and role in a less than ‘ideal world’
Ardel Shamsullah
+ Author Affiliations
- Author Affiliations
School of Social Sciences, La Trobe University, PO Box 199, Bendigo, VIC 3552, Australia. Email: a.shamsullah@latrobe.edu.au
Australian Health Review 35(1) 23-31 https://doi.org/10.1071/AH10879
Submitted: 4 February 2010 Accepted: 22 June 2010 Published: 25 February 2011
Journal Compilation © AHHA 2011
Abstract
Australia’s private health insurance funds have been prominent participants in the nation’s health system for 60 years. Yet there is relatively little public awareness of the distinctive origins of the health funds, the uncharacteristic organisational nature of these commercial enterprises and the peculiarly regulated nature of their industry. The conventional corporate responsibility to shareholders was, until recently, completely irrelevant, and remains marginal to the sector. However, their purported answerability to contributors, styled as ‘members’, was always doubtful for most health funds. After a long period of remarkable stability in the sector, despite significant shifts in health funding policy, recent years have brought notable changes, with mergers, acquisitions and exits from the industry. The research is based on the detailed study of the private health funds, covering their history, organisational character and industry structure. It argues that the funds have always been divorced from the disciplines of the competitive market and generally have operated complacently within a system of comprehensive regulation and generous subsidy. The prospect of the private health funds enjoying an expanded role under a form of ‘social insurance’, as suggested by the National Health and Hospitals Reform Commission, is not supported.
What is known about the topic? Government policies promoting private health insurance have long been the subject of public debate and have received considerable academic analysis. The health funds have a high profile in the media and with the public, reflecting the extent of private health insurance coverage.
What does this paper add? There is relatively little awareness of the unique nature of the private health insurance industry. This paper highlights the distinctive organisational origins of the health funds, the recent changes to the structure of the sector which have complicated their corporate identities and the complex role they play in an extraordinarily regulated private health insurance industry.
What are the implications for practitioners? Awareness of the nature of the sector should take us beyond perennial concerns about premium rises and the level of private health insurance coverage to better appreciate the diverse nature of the industry, the constraints under which the funds operate and the potential they may have to deliver ‘social insurance’.
References
[1] Turnbull M. Turnbull rejects Rudd’s claim that Coalition wants to kill Medicare. Transcript from PM, ABC Radio, 15 May 2009, 1814 hours. Available at http://www.abc.net.au/pm/content/2008/s2572063.htm [verified 31 January 2011].[2] Halley S. Operations of the Registered Health Benefits Organisations – Annual Report 1996–97. Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service; 1997: p. iii.
[3] Richardson JR, Scotton RB. The Viability of Private Health Insurance and the Options for Reform. Paper delivered to conference: Health Insurance – Deregulation and Devolution; Sydney; 20 March 1989: p. 6.
[4] Enthoven A. Theory and Practice of Managed Competition. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science; 1988.
[5] White House Domestic Policy Council. The President’s Health Security Plan. New York: Random House; 1993: pp. 64–8.
[6] Varkevisser M, van der Greest SA. Competition among health insurers. Research in Healthcare Financial Management 2002; 7 65–84.
[7] Scotton RB. Restructuring the Financing of Health Care. In: Investing in Health Care: A Challenging Future. Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service, Economic Planning Advisory Council; 1993: p. 124.
[8] Scotton RB. The Scotton Proposal. In: Managed Competition in Health Care. Workshop Proceedings; Canberra; 23 August 2002. Canberra: Productivity Commission; 2002: pp. 6–8. Available at http://www.pc.gov.au/research/confproc/mcihc [verified 10 May 2010].
[9] Hospital Services in Australia: Access and Financing. Issues Paper No. 2; Canberra: National Health Strategy; 1991: pp. 187–95.
[10] Keating M. Lessons from the market place for health and human services. Aust Econ Rev 2000; 33 198–204.
| Lessons from the market place for health and human services.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[11] Kay A. Tense layering and synthetic policy paradigms: the politics of health insurance in Australia. Aust J Polit Sci 2007; 42 579–91.
| Tense layering and synthetic policy paradigms: the politics of health insurance in Australia.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[12] Elliot A. ‘The best friend Medicare ever had’? Policy initiatives and changes in Coalition health policy. Health Sociol Rev 2006; 15 132–43.
| ‘The best friend Medicare ever had’? Policy initiatives and changes in Coalition health policy.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[13] Gray G. The Politics of Medicare: Who Gets What, When and How. Sydney: University of NSW; 2004.
[14] McAuley I. Private health insurance: still muddling through. Agenda 2005; 12 159–78. [verified 5 June 2009]. http://epress.anu.edu.au/agenda/012/02/12-2-A-5.pdf
[15] Duckett SJ, Jackson TJ. The new health insurance rebate: an inefficient way of assisting public hospitals. Med J Aust 2000; 172 439–42.
| 1:STN:280:DC%2BD3czivVKhtg%3D%3D&md5=d785eb658e732b50249417ab50b1a495CAS | 10870538PubMed |
[16] Johnson D. Economic issues in health policy. Aust Econ Rev 2001; 34 295–311.
| Economic issues in health policy.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar |
[17] Segal L. Health insurance: universal cover or a safety net? Economic Papers 2004; 23 xx–xx.
[18] Hindle D, McAuley I. The effects of increased private health insurance: a review of the evidence. Aust Health Rev 2004; 28 119–38.
| The effects of increased private health insurance: a review of the evidence.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 15525264PubMed |
[19] Scotton R. Voluntary health insurance in Australia. Aust Econ Rev 1968; 114–24.
[20] Deeble J, Scotton R. Compulsory health insurance for Australia. Aust Econ Rev 1968; 9–16.
[21] Whitlam EG. The alternative national health programme. Aust J Soc Issues 1968; 3 33–50.
[22] Senate Select Committee on Medical and Hospital Costs. Final Report, Submissions and Evidence. Commonwealth Parliamentary Papers. Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service; 1970: pp. 7, 529.
[23] Commonwealth Committee of Enquiry. Health Insurance: Report of the Commonwealth Committee of Enquiry. Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service; 1969.
[24] Commonwealth Department of Health, Private Health Insurance Administration Council. Operations of the Registered Medical and Hospital Benefits Organisations/Health Benefits Organisations/Private Health Insurers. Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service; 1972–2009.
[25] Senate Select Committee on Health Legislation and Health Insurance. What Price Care? Hospital Costs and Health Insurance. Canberra: Parliament of the Commonwealth of Australia; 1990.
[26] Evidence and Submissions to the Senate Select Committee on Health Legislation and Health Insurance. Senate Committee Hansard; Canberra: 3 November, 6 December 1989, 23 May 1990; Melbourne: 5–6 February 1990; Sydney: 12–13 February, 28 August 1990.
[27] Industry Commission. Private Health Insurance. Report 57. Canberra: Industry Commission; 1997: pp. 182–5.
[28] National Health and Hospitals Reform Commission. A Healthier Future for All Australians: Final Report. Canberra: Australian Government; 2009. Available at www.nhhrc.org.au/internet/nhhrc/publishing.nsf/Content/nhhrc-report
[29] Operations of the Private Health Insurers – Annual Report 2008–09. Canberra: Private Health Insurance Administration Council; 2009: pp. 2, 6, 13–14, 18, 25, 34.
[30] Commonwealth Department of Health. Submission to Senate Select Committee on Medical and Hospital Costs. Commonwealth Parliamentary Papers. Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service; 1970; pp. 7, 24, 244.
[31] Green D, Cromwell L. Mutual Aid or Welfare State?: Australia’s Friendly Societies. Sydney: Allen and Unwin; 1984.
[32] Ooi, T. MBF’s Dodd hopes for a super BUPA birthday. Australian 14 January 2008. Follow-up article: Ooi, T. A super BUPA campaign that won the war, 21 June 2008.
[33] NIB Holdings Limited. Proposal to Demutualise – Explanatory Statement. In: Listing Prospectus. 5 October 2007: pp. 25–47. Available at www.corpsites.nib.com.au/Shareholders/downloads/announcements/Listing_Prospectus.pdf [verified 4 December 2010].
[34] Fisher D. Evidence to Senate Select Committee on Medical and Hospital Costs. Final Report. Commonwealth Parliamentary Papers. Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service; 1970; pp. 7, 970.
[35] Simmons WF. The medical benefits fund of Australia. Med J Aust 1972; 1 880–2.
| 1:STN:280:DyaE387osVGhsg%3D%3D&md5=29257375872289f74d79e49ca1f19e14CAS | 4554600PubMed |
[36] Suich M. Those medical benefits funds. Bulletin. 15 July 1972.
[37] Annual Report and Accounts. BUPA (UK); 2008: p. 44. Available at www.bupa.com/financialinformation/corporate-governance [verified 28 January 2010].
[38] Governance Standards for Private Health Insurers – Discussion Paper. Canberra: Private Health Insurance Administration Council; 2009. Available at www.phiac.gov.au/resources/file/0909_discussion.pdf [verified 4 December 2009].
[39] Touche Ross. Cost structures of Medibank Private. Canberra: VHIAA, 1987.
[40] Medibank Private. Statement of Corporate Intent 2010–12. Available at www.medibank.com.au/client/documents/pdfs/Statement_of_Corporate_Intent.pdf [verified 9 December 2009].
[41] Medibank Private. Submission 221 and Attachments A and B. NHHRC Interim Report. 2009. Available at http://www.nhhrc.org.au/internet/nhhrc/publishing.nsf/Content/221-interim [verified 12 December 2009].
[42] Commonwealth Parliamentary Debates – Senate. 10 May 1995: pp. 125–30.
[43] Commonwealth Department of Health. Guide to National Health Benefits. Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service; 1966: pp. 5–10.
[44] Private Health Insurance Legislation and Rules. Available at www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/health-privatehealth-consumers-legislat.htm [verified 28 January 2010].
[45] Commonwealth Department of Health. Report of the Director-General, 1962–63. Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service; 1963: pp. 9, 12–13.
[46] Private Health Insurance Administration Council. Operations of the Registered Health Benefits Organisations, 1997–98. Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service; 1998: pp. 34–5.
[47] Abbott T. Health Legislation Amendment (Private Health Insurance) Bill 2006: explanatory Memorandum. 2006. Available at http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/download/legislation/ems/r2567_ems_d52f88f3-0b55-43ee-8e20-65809d679d05/upload_pdf/302700.pdf;fileType=application%2Fpdf#search=%22explanatory%20memorandum%20AND%20private%20health%20insurance%20bill%202006%20bills%20and%20legislation%20ems%22 [verified 31 January 2011].
[48] Private Health Insurance Circular. Private Health Insurance Branch, Department of Health and Ageing; 2007. Available at www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/health-phicirculars2007-46_07.htm [verified 16 December 2009].
[49] Biggs A. Private Health Insurance Premium Increases: An Overview. Parliamentary Library Background Note. 2009: pp. 1–3. Available at www.aph.gov.au/library/pubs/BN/index.htm [verified 17 November 2009].
[50] Reform of Private Health Insurance. Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service; 1993.
[51] Right Problem, Wrong Answer: AMA Issues Paper on Senator Richardson’s Health Plans. Canberra: Australian Medical Association; 1994.
[52] Willcox S. Buying best value health care: evolution of purchasing among Australian private health insurers. Aust New Zealand Health Policy 2005; 2 6
| Buying best value health care: evolution of purchasing among Australian private health insurers.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 15801982PubMed |
[53] Abbott T. Informed Financial Consent. Speech notes for Surgeons’ Conference, Sydney Convention Centre, Darling Harbour 16/5/06. 2006. Available at http://www.health.gov.au/internet/ministers/publishing.nsf/650f3eec0dfb990fca25692100069854/D8FF80932E060D25CA257170001014A3/$File/abbsp160506.pdf [verified 28 January 2010].
[54] Cormack M. Private health insurance: the problem child faces adulthood. Aust Health Rev 2002; 25 38–51.
| Private health insurance: the problem child faces adulthood.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 12046153PubMed |
[55] Beyond the Hospital Gate: a new province for private health insurance. Submission to the House of Representatives Standing Committee on Health – Inquiry into Hospital Funding. Australian Health Insurance Association; 2005: pp. 26–9. Available at http://www.ahia.org.au/documents/AHIA%20Submission,%20House%20of%20Representatives%20-%20Inquiry%20into%20Health%20Funding%202005.pdf [verified 31 January 2010].
[56] Evans RG. Tension, compression and shear: directions, stresses and outcomes of health care cost control. J Health Polit Policy Law 1990; 15 101–28.
| Tension, compression and shear: directions, stresses and outcomes of health care cost control.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:STN:280:DyaK3c3gtlGhtQ%3D%3D&md5=edd87b8457de4ec402bce31a6afb925eCAS | 2108199PubMed |
[57] Butler JRG. Estimating Elasticities of Demand for Private Health Insurance in Australia. Working Paper 43. Canberra: National Centre for Epidemiology and Population Health; 1999: pp. 23–24, 31–32. Available at www.nceph.anu.edu.au/Publications/Working_Papers/WP43.pdf [verified 13 May 2010].
[58] Private Health Insurance: a snapshot, 2004–05. Cat. 4815.0.55.001. Australian Bureau of Statistics; 2006. Available at www.abs.gov.au/AUSSTATS/abs@.nsf/Lookup/4815.0.55.001Main+Features12004-05?OpenDocument [verified 13 May 2010].
[59] Senate Community Affairs Legislation Committee. Report into Fairer Private Health Insurance Incentives Bill 2009 and two related bills. Canberra: Parliament of the Commonwealth of Australia; 2009; pp. 11–3, 73. Available at http://www.aph.gov.au/senate/committee/clac_ctte/fairer_private_health_09/report/index.htm [verified 20 May 2010].
