Medical managers in contemporary healthcare organisations: a consideration of the literature
Alison J. DwyerRoyal Melbourne Hospital, Grattan Street, Parkville, VIC 3050, Australia. Email: alison.dwyer@austin.org.au
Australian Health Review 34(4) 514-522 https://doi.org/10.1071/AH09736
Submitted: 9 January 2009 Accepted: 18 February 2010 Published: 25 November 2010
Abstract
Objectives. To consider the literature supporting the evolution of the roles of a Medical Manager within contemporary healthcare organisations.
Design. Consideration of available literature.
Results. Limited dedicated literature available. Consideration of available studies and expert opinion reveals benefit of doctors in management positions within healthcare organisations. The roles of Medical Managers arise from: organisational structure-theory of healthcare’s ‘professional bureaucracy’; clinical directorate models; clinical governance, legislative and public health requirements; and the duality of combining medical knowledge with business and healthcare management training. Roles identified are: (1) leadership and management of medical staff including appointments and credentialing, and mentoring of medical staff in Clinical Directorate roles; (2) strategy development including Medical Advisory Role to Executive; (3) clinical governance including quality and risk management and legislative requirements; and (4) operational areas that benefit from clinical and management skills.
Discussion. Strengths of this review include considering contexts of Medical Managers in medical and healthcare management literature. Weaknesses include drawing inferences from theory. Future recommendations include formal studies and systematic reviews of available literature of the subject.
Conclusions. In light of falling Medical Management trainee numbers, this study highlights the value to the health system of a dwindling Medical Management profession, the urgent need to encourage more medical practitioners into management and for organisations to further embrace Medical Managers in key leadership roles.
What is known about the topic? Although there is general acknowledgement about the benefits of medical leaders within health services, the exact nature and evidence for the Medical Manager role in current health services has not been comprehensively explored and articulated.
What does this paper add? The aim of this consideration of the literature is to explore the evidence-base supporting the roles for Medical Managers within contemporary healthcare organisations, and articulate the exact nature and scope of the role. A concordance of studies and expert opinion highlights the benefits of Medical Managers within contemporary healthcare organisations, illustrating a theoretical basis for the differing roles. The nature of the roles include: leadership and management of medical staff (from organisational structure theory); leadership of the organisation within the executive team; clinical governance oversight; and operational management of medical areas with a business focus.
What are the implications for practitioners? In light of falling Medical Management trainee numbers, this study highlights the value to the health system of a dwindling Medical Management profession, the urgent need to encourage more medical practitioners into management and for organisations to further embrace Medical Managers in key leadership roles.
References
[1] About Us. American College of Physician Executives. Available at http://www.acpe.org/Footer/AboutACPE.aspx [verified 26 October 2008].[2] BAMM Supporting and developing Medical Managers: About Us. British Association of Medical Managers. Available at http://www.bamm.co.uk/Information/FAQ/About_us_2007060122/ [verified 26 October 2008].
[3] About Us. RACMA profile. Royal Australasian College of Medical Administrators; 2008. Available at http://www.racma.edu.au/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=59&Itemid=111 [verified 26 October 2008].
[4] RACMA Core Competencies Framework. Royal Australasian College of Medical Administrators [Updated 8 October 2008, cited 26 October 2008] Available at http://www.racma.edu.au/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=99&Itemid=197
[5] Eligibility for attending the Tutorial for Board Certification in Medical Management. Certifying Commission in Medical Management; 2008. Available at http://www.ccmm.org/tutorialeligibility.aspx [verified 26 October 2008].
[6] Fit to Lead – How it works. British Association of Medical Managers; 2005. Available at http://www.fittolead.co.uk/How_It_Works/ [verified 26 October 2008].
[7] Australian Legal Information Institute databases, Victorian Resources. [Updated unknown; cited 20 October 2008] Available at http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/vic/
[8] The Duties of the Medical Director. UK: British Association of Medical Managers; 2001.
[9] Making Sense – a career structure for medical management. UK: British Association of Medical Managers; 2004.
[10] Mintzberg H. The Structuring of Organizations: a Synthesis of the Research. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall; 1979.
[11] Schneller ES, Greenwald HP, Richardson ML, Ott J. The Physician Executive: role in the adaptation of American medicine. Health Care Manage Rev 1997; 22 90–6.
| 1:STN:280:DyaK2s3ovV2rsA%3D%3D&md5=1f5cb1c792ccc6b9c3dc6a15138036b9CAS | 9143905PubMed |
[12] American College of Healthcare Executives Research notes. The role and function of the Physician Executive. Healthc Exec 2003; 18 38–9.
| 12632582PubMed |
[13] Simpson J, Smith R. Why healthcare systems need medical managers. BMJ 1997; 314 1636
| 1:STN:280:DyaK2szjs1Ggsg%3D%3D&md5=ff350dd563ddfd2d267341f79d7beaebCAS | 9193281PubMed |
[14] Day M. The rise of the doctor–manager. BMJ 2007; 335 230–1.
| The rise of the doctor–manager.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 17673763PubMed |
[15] Goler MR, Sorensen DE. Physician governance – the strength behind St John’s Clinic. Physician Exec 2006; 32 52–9.
| 16509402PubMed |
[16] Menaker R, Banh RS. How perceived physician leadership behaviour affects physician satisfaction. Mayo Clin Proc 2008; 83 983–8.
| How perceived physician leadership behaviour affects physician satisfaction.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 18775197PubMed |
[17] Edwards N, Marshall M, McLellan A, Abbasi K. Doctors and managers: a problem without a solution? BMJ 2003; 326 609
| Doctors and managers: a problem without a solution?Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 12649210PubMed |
[18] Smith R. All changed, changed utterly. BMJ 1998; 316 1917–8.
| 1:STN:280:DyaK1czgs1SrtA%3D%3D&md5=1d4f7955cff06ba0718c675c0d71a387CAS | 9641922PubMed |
[19] Health Q. Bundaberg Hospital Commission of Inquiry: Queensland Health Initial Submission, 16 May 2005. 2005. Available at www.health.qld.gov.au/inquiry/submissions/INQUIRY.pdf [verified 27 October 2010].
[20] Lessons from the Inquiry into Obstetrics and Gynaecological Services at King Edward memorial Hospital 1990–2000. Darlinghurst, NSW: Australian Council for Safety and Quality in Health Care; 2002.
[21] Harris MG. Managing Health Services Concepts and Practice. Marrickville, NSW: Elsevier Australia; 2002.
[22] Shortell SM, Kaluzny AD. Health Care Management: Organisational Design and Behaviour. 4th Edition. Albany, NY: Thomson Learning; 2000.
[23] Coile RC. Physician executives in the 21st century: new realities, roles and responsibilities. Physician Exec 1999; 25 8–13.
[24] Weber DO. Poll results: doctors’ disruptive behaviour disturbs physician leaders. Physician Exec 2004; 30 6–14.
[25] Credentialing and defining the scope of clinical practice for medical practitioners in Victorian health services – a policy handbook. Melbourne: Statewide Quality Branch, Rural and Regional Health and Aged Care Services, Victorian Government Department of Human Services; 2007.
[26] Guidance for Victorian Public Health Services to Establish Technology/Clinical Practice Committees. Melbourne: Metropolitan Health and Aged Care Services Division, Victorian Department of Human Services; 2007. Available at http://www.health.vic.gov.au/newtech/documents/guidance2006.doc [verified 27 October 2010].
[27] Firth-Cozens J. Doctors, their wellbeing and their stress. BMJ 2003; 326 670–1.
| Doctors, their wellbeing and their stress.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 12663377PubMed |
[28] Graham IS, Gleason AJ, Keogh GW, Paltridge D, Rogers IR, Walton M, De Paola C, Singh J, McGrath BP. Australian curriculum framework for junior doctors. MJA 2007; 186 S14–9.
| 17407415PubMed |
[29] Joyce CM, McNeil JJ, Stoelwinder JU. More doctors, but not enough: Australian medical workforce supply 2001–2012. MJA 2006; 184 441–6.
| 16646743PubMed |
[30] Clinton M, Scheiwe D. Management in the Australian Health Care Industry. Harper Educational Publishers; 1995.
[31] Fit-To-Lead. British Association of Medical Managers; 2005. Available at http://www.fittolead.co.uk/home.html [verified 20 October 2008].
[32] Kumpusalo E, Virjo I, Mattila K, Halila H. Managerial skills of principle physicians assessed by their colleagues: a lesson from Finland. J Health Organ Manag 2003; 17 457–62.
| Managerial skills of principle physicians assessed by their colleagues: a lesson from Finland.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 14730799PubMed |
[33] Guthrie MB. Challenges in developing physician leadership and management. Front Health Serv Manage 1999; 15 3–26.
| 1:STN:280:DyaK1M3psFKltw%3D%3D&md5=ca088d5713240eb9384dde00bacbc13cCAS | 10387764PubMed |
[34] Barraclough BH. Safety and quality in Australian healthcare: making progress. MJA 2001; 174 616–7.
| 1:STN:280:DC%2BD3MvjtlelsA%3D%3D&md5=1fc4281031807ffe646eef4b12ebd0a8CAS | 11480678PubMed |
[35] Leape LL. Reporting of adverse events. N Engl J Med 2002; 3347 1633–8.
[36] Gill SL, Kirschman DR. Working with Chief Medical Officers. Healthc Exec 2002; 17 66–7.
| 12233130PubMed |
[37] Huntington J, Gillam S, Rosen R. Clinical governance in primary care: organisational development for clinical governance. BMJ 2000; 321 679–82.
| Clinical governance in primary care: organisational development for clinical governance.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 1:STN:280:DC%2BD3M%2FhvFWqsQ%3D%3D&md5=4629c23db8c5842603f36c683ae28969CAS | 10987774PubMed |
[38] Semmens JB, Aitken RJ, Sanfilippo FM, Mukhtar SA, Haynes NS, Mountain JA. The Western Australian Audit of Surgical Mortality: advancing surgical accountability. MJA 2005; 183 504–8.
| 16296962PubMed |
[39] Faunce TA, Bolsin SNC. Three Australian whistleblowing sagas: lessons for internal and external regulation. MJA 2004; 181 44–7.
| 15233613PubMed |
[40] Victorian Quality Council. Better Quality, Better Health Care: A Safety and Quality Improvement Framework for Victorian Health Services. Victorian Department of Human Services; 2003.
[41] Human Tissue Act 1982 (Vic), S3, S25, S28.
[42] Health (Compulsory Testing) Act 2005 (Vic) S 120A–120D.
[43] Chief Health Officer. Victorian Department of Human Services; 2008. Available at http://www.health.vic.gov.au/chiefhealthofficer/ [verifed 20 October 2008].
[44] Robertson AG, Cooper DM. Disaster surge planning in Australia: measuring the immeasurable. MJA 2007; 186 388–9.
| 17437390PubMed |
[45] Poustie SJ, Taylor DMcD, Forbes AB, Skiba MA, Nelson MR, McNeil JJ. Implementing a research governance framework for clinical and public health research. MJA 2006; 185 623–6.
| 17181507PubMed |
[46] Hammett RJH, Harris RD. Halting the growth in diagnostic testing. MJA 2002; 177 124–5.
| 12149076PubMed |
[47] Hall WD, Ward R, Liauw WS, Brien JE, Lu CY. Tailoring access to high cost, genetically targeted drugs. MJA 2005; 182 607–8.
| 15963014PubMed |
[48] Peters J, Blasco T. Enhancing hospital performance through perioperative services. Physician Exec 2004; 30 26–30.
| 15597828PubMed |
[49] Mayor S. Conference recommends joint training for doctors and health service managers. BMJ 2003; 326 1418
| Conference recommends joint training for doctors and health service managers.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 12829551PubMed |
[50] Edwards N, Marshall M. Doctors and Managers: a constructive dialogue has to replace mutual suspicion. BMJ 2003; 326 116–7.
| Doctors and Managers: a constructive dialogue has to replace mutual suspicion.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 12531821PubMed |
[51] Degeling P, Maxwell S, Kennedy J, Coyle B. Medicine, management and modernization: a “danse macabre”. BMJ 2003; 326 649
| Medicine, management and modernization: a “danse macabre”.Crossref | GoogleScholarGoogle Scholar | 12649244PubMed |
[52] Schultz FC, Pal S, Swan DA. Who should lead a Healthcare organisation: MDs or MBAs? J Healthc Manag 2004; 49 103–16.
| 15074119PubMed |
[53] Quality Directors Australia and Boyd Health Management. Factors Affecting Recruitment and Retention of Medical Managers in Australian Hospitals. Melbourne: Royal Australasian College of Medical Administrators; 2006.
[54] Medical Training Review Panel: 12th Annual Report, February 2009. Barton, ACT: Department of Health and Ageing; 2009.
